Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Clean and Wholesome American mail order bride historical western novel romance.

It’s 1869 and love is starting to blossom in the booming town of Bear River City.

This historically inspired Western romance much-loved series is about empowered women who turn around their hopeless circumstances in this mid-19th-century tale of the old West, with strong faith and discover genuine men and true love.

Meet Mary Anderson, a twelve-year-old girl who appreciates the beautiful ray of the sunshine, a bunch of wildflowers in the garden, or a singing bird in the tree. She arrived at the orphanage when she was a baby. The nuns were the only family that she knew. Her mother had died giving birth, and all she knew of her father was his name, Richard Anderson. Sometimes she would ask the nuns for more information, but they would tighten their lips and look away, telling Mary that a young girl should not ask too many questions. Mary was sure that they knew more than they were telling, but they were deaf to the pleas.

Mary knew that she was lucky to have been raised here, but sometimes she yearned to have a family of her own. She fears of becoming a spinster someday stuck up in the orphanage all her life, not having a family of her own. Afraid of the thought, Mary took a leap of faith and answered the ad she read on the newspaper, looking for a mail order bride.


What happened six years ago that made Mary hate guns and anything related to violence?

Thomas tries to outrun his past, but the sour truth keeps hunting him. What is the reason why he is hardly to forgive himself?

Who is Silver Heels, and why was he so important in their lives?


Come on now and hang out with the wonderful folks in Atlanta where Mary had known life in the orphanage. Get to know Sister Grace & Sister Rose, the Christian nuns who always look after them. Trixie Sheldon, the kind and friendly store owner who never fails to give Mary candies and goodies for the children. Thomas Smith, the sheriff who tries to run from the dark history of the past. And don’t forget to get to know the brave and fearless horse!

186 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 5, 2016

835 people are currently reading
208 people want to read

About the author

Katie Wyatt

698 books54 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
385 (55%)
4 stars
174 (25%)
3 stars
91 (13%)
2 stars
33 (4%)
1 star
11 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
Profile Image for Mary.
181 reviews
July 18, 2018
Orphan Finds Love

I saw the notations when I first started reading about this story being revised to correct errors. They may have been, but I still found several errors in the story. Misspellings, words in sentences twice, wrong pronouns.
The story was about a mail-order bride & a sheriff. The heroine wanted nothing to do with guns because of a tragedy when she was twelve years old. The hero was a sheriff who believed there was no need for guns in the city limits of the towns where he worked. Once they agree to marry & become husband & wife, Mary is finally feeling like she has a family & belongs. It is her faith in God that will be tested throughout the story. Is her faith strong enough to help Mary persevere?
542 reviews2 followers
September 5, 2016
Great read

I loved this mail order bride story a lot.The characters were so easy to get to know and love or hate.Oh was up quite late trying to finish this wonderful book
Profile Image for Dana Redding.
486 reviews1 follower
June 15, 2019
Would rate higher stars if allowed! 10 stars! Must Read!

Thomas Smith was a lawman of the finest caliber.
Born in New York City on June 12, 1840, Smith grew up to be a middle-weight professional boxer before joining the New York City Police force. However, after being involved in the accidental killing of a 14-year-old boy, Smith left the force in 1868 and took a job with the Union Pacific Railroad.

Smith’s first official acts was to ban all weapons in town without a permit. Within 48 hours, everyone had turned over their weapons to Smith.
I tell you to look up this mans history.

In this story you meet Mary, she travels to Bear River City, Wyoming to marry Thomas Smith who is a Sheriff.
They fall in love with each other and everything is going well until vigilantes destroy the town and shoot up the town up to 16 people parish and the town is left in charred out remains.

Thomas and Mary move to Texas and again he in forces the no gun law. Most people are alright with this law others are not so happy. I’ll leave it here and I’ll tell you this I cried during the last few chapters. Very touching story. I very much would have enjoyed hearing more about Mary. But this story isn’t about her ending it’s about Silver Heels and Thomas Smith.
Profile Image for Christy.
658 reviews8 followers
December 17, 2018
Great Read

I choose this not just because I like this genre, but also because of its interesting synopsis. I was a counselor for a children's home (age 11-18) many years ago. I felt a connection to Mary. She never knew her mother, as she had died during child birth, and Mary's father left her at the orphange when she was a few days old and disappeared. The nuns treated Mary and all the children with great kindness. However, Mary longed to have a life and family of her own. I wanted to see how Mary's future worked out. I think Mary is a courageous and strong woman. I look forward to reading more in this series. Nice work Ms Wyatt.
81 reviews1 follower
December 7, 2017
Mail Order Bride: Silver Heels: Clean Historical Western Romance ( Sweet Frontier Cowboys Series Book 1)

Great story easily deserving of the 5 star award. It has an unexpected plot which at times is sad. But the heroine is a strong young woman and can overcome any struggle which she has to face.
Profile Image for Linda Zaragoza-zrubek.
163 reviews1 follower
April 8, 2022
I found this book to be very interesting about a young girl living at an orphanage since birth. A horrible and terrifying death in front of her eyes leaves her disliking guns. She falls in love with a sheriff and so much happens in their quiet little town. I loved reading this book…one of my favorite genre’s.
235 reviews1 follower
April 4, 2025
Mary Anderson

Mary has been at the orphanage all her life. Now at 18 she is helping the nuns raise the younger children. But Mary wonders what may await her outside the orphanage.

While reading the back page of the newspaper Mary decides to answer an advertisement for a wife. Will she become a mail order bride?
454 reviews1 follower
January 31, 2018
She was left at the orphanage as a baby

It was a very interesting story about how she was raised and how she became a mail order bride. How her husband got his nick name and what he tried to enforce as laws in the two towns they lived in.
138 reviews1 follower
March 12, 2018
A little boring.

This book was written in child like paragraphs. It felt every sentence was rehursed before typed. Who kills off the main hero at the end of a book??? I felt my time was wasted reading this story.
Profile Image for Debra French.
99 reviews
August 23, 2018
Enjoyed the plot of the book but found the wrong tense of many words or words left out of a sentence or extra words in sentences to be somewhat distracting. Otherwise, the author is an excellent storyteller.
21 reviews
June 15, 2019
An easy to follow story.

Great read for teens to read, you can't always prepare for what life throws at you. Belief in God can help you get thru. With his love and love from family and friends you can.
Profile Image for Sherry Kovell.
2 reviews7 followers
January 2, 2026
Story of love and faith

Great read about enduring love and faith in spite of trials and tribulations of the frontier west. Characters come alive in this wonderful story. I think I have found a new favorite author.
8 reviews
March 24, 2018
Beautiful story of love and support.

Love this story, not really like the death part, but like the end full of future love. Pleasant reading 📚
Profile Image for Lisa Garrison.
16 reviews1 follower
March 28, 2018
Couldn't put it down

Wonderfully written, suspenseful. I loved how the book is clean and referenced the Bible a few times. Can't wait to read some more.
664 reviews
April 26, 2018
Good.

I must admit that this story, even though it was interesting, was not as good as many of the other books by Katie Wyatt that I have read.
47 reviews1 follower
July 24, 2018
Not great writing. It was a quick read. I thought about it for days afterward so there was something compelling about it.
Profile Image for Catherine.
215 reviews9 followers
December 27, 2018
It felt too summarized, and the characters were pretty thin. I wanted a lot more from the story. I'll probably check out another book by this author to see if she improves.
Profile Image for Laurel .
1,355 reviews5 followers
April 17, 2019
Good plot, choppy writing. Hugs gaps of nothing surrounded by a tiny bit of action. Written for very low level readers or readers who don't have much time.
304 reviews3 followers
July 10, 2019
A good clean book.

This is a heart warming and interesting book, filled with happiness, sorrow, love and pain it displays life in reality. It is a good clean read.
6 reviews
November 19, 2021
I loved the book because it is decent and because of Mary's faith in God.
Profile Image for Latifah Alfoudari.
1 review
December 17, 2025
A gentle, comforting read that understands its purpose.
Sometimes a story doesn’t need to challenge you — it just needs to hold you.
54 reviews
February 16, 2021
Silver heels

Very good book. Enjoyed the characters, setting and plot. Romantic and filled with surprises.recommend for anyone to read. Western are my favorite to read.
Profile Image for Patsy.
614 reviews9 followers
July 24, 2020
The author wrote that these stories are inspired by actual historical people and events this is an amazing story including an amazing horse, Silver Heels. At birth Mary Anderson was left on the steps of an Orphanage in Bear Creek, she was raised by the Nuns until age 18. The Nuns encouraged her to find a job and to live on her own.

Mary found a Mail Order Bride Agency and place an ad. Thomas Smith, the Sheriff in Georgia, Utah saw the ad and the correspondence began from Georgia, Utah to Mary Anderson in Bear Creek. After many letters back and forth, Mary and Thomas met in Utah at the train station and was married the next day.

This story has been rewritten and revised with an outstanding surprise ending. This author, Katie Wyatt is an amazing author she is known for her many box sets of books that she has written. I enjoy reading her books, they are interested and entertaining. These are short stories, stand-alone, fast paced and easy to read books.
Profile Image for Dana Redding.
486 reviews1 follower
August 25, 2019
Spoilers... silver heels

Mary was left as a baby on the steps of an orphanage. The sisters raised her and when she is 18 she writes to a lawman named Thomas.

Thomas is a wonderful lawman takes care of the town and everyone tells him he needs a wife.

I read the other story about Thomas being gunned down and his widow Mary commissions along with the town a monument of Thomas and his faithful horse Silver Heels.

This story has a better ending although it isn’t true.
After reading the first story I got to the point where he should have died and was a little stunned how the rest of the story went.

If you like happy endings read this story.
Profile Image for Anita.
304 reviews
September 1, 2016
This author has potential of being a good story teller. She just needs to embellish scenes better as well as add emotion. You do not get all bonded to the characters even though they are sweet and a great story line, it is just lacking..It is like it is an outline of the story and the feeling you need to get bonded will be filled in later...With these things lacking in her authormenship I am not anxious to read another of her stories. But again they hold great potential. I hope this is a constructive review and it is not to be critical. Just hope to see improvement, good luck.
48 reviews4 followers
September 6, 2019
I am so happy I bought the whole series when Nanette to buy it after reading this book !

Wow what a fantastic book! This is the first book that I had wrong I always guess what is going on ! Near the end the suspense starts and you don’t put the book down ! Now I can eat lol ! Never expected suspense but it made it better just like life ! I got one other thing wrong too dang it lol ! But I am happy I did ! You must read this book and series ! Except to not have any appts.
Darlene Lindstrom
Profile Image for Gina Degrenier.
5 reviews
November 4, 2020
Great Read. Enjoyed very much! Lots of great details and excellent story line with very believable characters. I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good historical, Christian romance. These have become my new top choice. I can just sit , relax and enjoy. You knobut getting there is half the fun.

Enjoyed this book very much. Lots of great detail and excellent characters and story line. I would recommend this book and author to anyone who enjoys historical, Christian romance. You can just sit back and enjoy the story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.