In a land not so far away, there lives a place that lives in the past...
She is the governess... Agatha Blair has been with the Everards for nearly two years. She is plain and barely passes the category of pretty. And she is secretly in love with him.
He is the Lord of Devonshire... Benedict Everard is the eldest of all Everard children. He is a beast and he secretly believes the governess is a bore.
A past... Hers is dark, his is never talked about.
An unstoppable love that cannot be will test a fun and quirky family living in the affluent and wicked town of Wickhurst.
Janelle Ruiz works as a nurse in Bacolod City. She likes the rain, jazz, and freshly brewed coffee. When she's not writing, she spends her time reading inspirational, suspense, and psychological thriller books. She dreams of becoming a forensic psychologist, but as of now, being one of the most amazing criminal profilers in her dreamland is enough. Apart from dreaming, reading and watching too much suspense/thriller television series and a lot of documentaries, she is also known to most of her personal friends and family as a painter.
Greenwriter seriously took up the time to meticulously come up with a plot that connects all her stories that are held in the Town, and there are crossovers that help you cope with missing previous characters as well.
It's amazing how seemingly insignificant events are things she puts focus on in the next book, which will focus on the character involved in said event. I just... there are no words. This needs to be a worldwide hit, ASAP.
Words cannot describe how much I love this series.
This is one of my favourite stories in wattpad..It has everything for a historical Genre..Seriously I don't know which was my favourite part because the previous chapter made the next chapter better,more fun & exciting ..This deserves to be paid..& I am very glad that I've spent my coins on this one..
Benedict was one of my favourite characters..I just loved how he always respected & defended Agatha.Agatha also was a strong charcter always held herself high & proud, mainly stood for her self-respect(no matter what Benedict offered Agatha & how much she loved him)..This also helped Benedict to realize what matters most & how foolish he had been..They truly complemented each other❤️❤️Benedict's journey truly touched my heart..It was deep,heavy, full of love & reverence..Actually not only Benedict, I liked every single character in this book..They were just too fun,sweet,lovely😁😁..
Acutually mere words cannot describe this amazing book butI like to share two of my favourite quotes from this one.
"Rubies are the only stones the Everads cannot mine but always wanted and dreamed of.And you are the woman I cannot have but always wanted and dreamed of"-Benedict This scene literally tore my heart..Couldn't stop crying😭😭..The pain, the longing,the love was really evident in this part
" The beast has bewitched the beauty" -Benedict..It was one of their happy moments when they were happily looking back...It held a warmth & a promise for the future that they would make❤️❤️..
🚨 NOTE: This review is for the 2024 published paperback edition, which currently does not have an edition in Goodreads as of writing. It may or may not reflect past or future revisions of the novel.
Whatever happens, Blair, always remember that you are the ruby of one Everard.
Fun story--I actually found this at National Bookstore. It's pretty rare for me to grab a book off the shelf with absolutely zero prior knowledge purely based on first impressions, but this one (and its second installment, One Wicked Season) was a total attention-grabber. Plus, it's my first non-secondhand, local book purchase of the year, so that's already a huge milestone.
Before we dive in, context is super important that this series originally came out on Wattpad back in 2016. I literally didn't know this until I looked it up later, but keep that date in mind because I am going to be comparing this to Bridgerton even though J.D. Ruiz wrote this WAY before Bridgerton blew up on Netflix in 2020. That said... this is very much like Bridgerton LOL. They might as well have called them the Everardtons. KIDDING.
Anyway, to get to the meat.
Spoiler-free review: This novel's plot is basically if Sophie Beckett became Kate Sheffield, actually succeeded in becoming a governess to babysit the youngest siblings, and fell for Anthony Bridgerton while her past came back to haunt her.
Let's first talk about the parts that didn't quite work for me. The book attempts to add a pinch of uniqueness by putting the "Town" (yes, with a capital T) underground, but it honestly does not work because it's barely relevant to the plot. Even my first highlight in the book was: "WYM THIS IS ALL HAPPENING UNDERGROUND??? THIS IS AN UNDERGROUND CITY? WHAT THE HELL IS AN ABOVEGROUND?" It feels rather more like a backdrop than an integral part of the story, which is an odd choice to make--beyond establishing that everyone lives below the surface, it rarely affects the plot in meaningful ways. In fact, you could relocate much of the novel to a conventional Regency setting (actually, I don't even know if it's during the Regency era, there's no year explicitly mentioned?), keep the characters and romance exactly the same, and surprisingly little would change. I kept waiting for the worldbuilding to become inseparable from the narrative but it mostly stayed on the sidelines.
My biggest criticism overall is probably that the novel itself is enjoyable, yet never quite distinguishes itself enough from the many-thousands of historical romances that came before it and after. The setting, the class difference romance, the drama... they're all competently written, but I often found myself comparing it to other books in the genre. That isn't necessarily a bad thing if you're already a fan of this kind of romance. It's just that I personally wanted this book's strongest ideas (especially the underground setting) to play a much larger role.
I also found the book surprisingly dependent on the author's previous series. I swear, authors today want to make standalone series but don't want to exert the effort to make them actually stand alone! Certain cameos and references here clearly felt like they were meant to be exciting reveals, but because I was coming in as a new reader, I mostly sat there wondering who everyone was. Sorry for bringing up Bridgerton again but why did I have to wait nine chapters just to get an introduction to the nine siblings? Even Bridgerton clones usually manage that in chapter one!
Now, we have to talk about this novel's Everard sibling.
The short version: BENEDICT EVERARD, STAY AWAY FROM ME YE WALKING RED FLAG!!! 😭
The long version: Without getting into spoiler territory, Benedict made such an awful first impression that he single-handedly dragged my rating down. Throughout my read, I was ringing The Scumbag Bell at the back of my head the entire time! His early actions crossed lines that I simply couldn't overlook, and while I do appreciate that the novel attempts to give him growth afterward (I am, unfortunately, weak to pathetic men who cry), I never completely recovered from those initial scenes. 'Nuff said.
That said, it's not all bad. I still have to give our author credit.
On the bright side, I adored some of the Everard family dynamics. Ysabella and Emma absolutely stole every scene they appeared in, and my favorite scenes were the ones with the siblings i.e. Margaret and Maxwell. The romance is... decent, which sounds mean, but that's already a big compliment coming from me.
The dialogue also deserves a mention. It leans into that delightfully theatrical faux-19th century style that fits the tone well. Was it perfectly accurate? Probably not. Was it entertaining? Absolutely. For a story that originated on Wattpad in 2016, this is remarkably polished compared to much of what was circulating on the platform at the time. You can absolutely see the potential here, and I respect how ambitious the project is. I may have wanted more originality in execution, but I never felt like I was reading an amateur work.
Also... nobody warned me there was a brief smut. My prudish self was caught entirely off guard oops.
Ultimately, To Bewitch a Beast ended up as a 2.75-star read for me, plus one honorary cookie for sheer effort and ambition. I enjoyed it enough to stay curious about the series even if this first installment didn't completely win me over, although this may also likely be subject to change, since I'm saving my 3 to 5-star ratings for better reads in the future. And yes, I will probably continue the series, and that's not just because I already bought Book 2. Partly because I'm optimistic it'll improve.
Mostly because I'm patiently waiting for Maxwell Everard. (Have you seen that man's bookmark art? RAWR)
I recommend this for readers who love historical family romances, forced proximity, class differences, interconnected series with recurring casts, and anyone curious to see how a local author put her own spin on Regency-inspired romance long before the genre's recent boom! This is absolutely a delightfully nostalgic, trope-filled novel that brings a Filipina voice to the historical romance genre. :))
“Rubies are the only stones the Everards cannot mine but always wanted and dreamed for. Whatever happens, Blair, I want you to always be reminded that you are the ruby of one Everard.”
Bakit now ko lang siya binasa? Hahahaha ay naku.
Benedict, with his raging emerald eyes was bewitched by the fiery topaz brown eyes of Agatha. He was really enamoured, smitten and besotted doon sa tinawag niyang boring noong una ay. I really loved their kulitan and banters pati mga heated arguments. Kaso naging loving friends lang sila, may fiancee na kasi si Ben huhu. Tapos kinikiss niya pa si Agatha. Ang pangit kaya sa feels.
Naungkat pa ang past ni Agatha na dati siyang mangkukulam. May harboring ng secret feelings, may love for imperfect scars ng kanyang beast, may makukulit na matchmakers. Pero kaloka si Doc Johannes doon sa backhanded comment niya. Anyways, all is well naman.
Overall, this was a good one! Beast x witch ulit hahaha.
I actually had a fun time with this one, especially with the whole Agatha and Benedict situation.
On paper, their problem feels so simple, but considering the time period, the fact that Agatha has no title while Benedict is a Lord makes everything so much more complicated.
I also really enjoyed the dialogue because it had that very theatrical, old-fashioned feel that fit the setting. It wasn't always the most natural to me, but it definitely made the story entertaining. And the twins? Easily some of my favorite characters here. I loved whenever they were around.
That said, I think I wanted a little more from the story overall. There were parts I really enjoyed, but I also found myself not feeling as invested as I hoped I would, especially when it came to the romance and some of the plot.
Still, it was an entertaining read with characters I genuinely liked.
Just finished the book and hour ago and I can this was one the many amazing history Ton romances I have read over time. But one thing I couldn’t help but notice maybe it was just my perspective but it felt like the story was greatly inspired by Bridgerton, not sure which was published further so Im not sure. It felt like we took penelope featherington made her tall and slim, put her in the character of Kate Sharma as an irish woman who wants to be a governess as well and matched her with Benedict (very anthony like) their banter was amazing and I love the entire family especially the twins devious and charming in their own way.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
another story recommendation from my bff 🤩 and I LOVE HOW THE TOWN IS CONSTRUCTED PERFECTLY, WITH THE MAPS AND ALL. IT'S SO FUCKING BRILLIANT. also, you just can't help but to love agatha and benedict. broo their flirtation 🤌🏼