I was surprised to find that the show Heartland is actually based on books. I've seen episodes in the past, and during quarantine, I watched the first season, and I'm around halfway through the second season now. So I thought I'd finally try the books out.
I couldn't believe how thin this book is. It's like a children's book, not the thicker YA I was expecting.
It was immediately clear that this was very different from the show.
I thought this must take place in Canada because the show does, but it actually takes place in Virginia.
There were bigger differences to come. Ty had been there three years, so he knew their mom before she passed, unlike the show. Something the show doesn't really do is tell people's ages and more of their history. Ty dropped out of HS at 16, and is 17. Ty doesn't live at the ranch like he does on the show, which I don't like.
I also knew beforehand after watching season one's bonus material that the show chose to make Ty a 'bad boy' and that in the books Ty isn't like that. So that was another big thing they changed.
In the end, at least after book one, the show made things more interesting with Ty being 'bad' because in here he didn't have much of a presence. I hope the author builds his character more.
Their dad, Tim Flemming, was a British show jumper, who was hurt at a championship, and ended up paralyzed. A very big difference from the show.
Amy has brown hair and gray eyes. She's turning 15, so she's two years younger than Ty.
Lou is blue-eyed and dark-haired like the show, but she lived in England, where their dad's from, and has a British accent. She hoped their dad would come back, so she stayed in England, but moved to New York.
Scott is 29, and has a younger brother. I wish the show did it that way, too. Unlike the show, they don't appear to be Native American. At least it wasn't mentioned if they were.
I liked the information on training horses, how they get a horse to join up with them by having them run around the corral. She used a long line and flicked the end of it on his hindquarters to get him running in either direction. She keeps the horse moving by clicking her tongue and raising the longline to keep him moving.
In order for the horse to trust her, she has to show him she listens to him and understands him, and wants to join up with him.
She kept her eyes on his, and her shoulders square with his. She moved her shoulder to get him going in the other direction, and watched the inside ear. If it's fixed on them that's a good sign, that the horse respects you. And if they start making chewing motions and licking their mouths. Then they stretch their necks out, near the ground. It's them saying they want to team up with you. She then dropped her eyes, coiled the rope and turned angled away from them and wait for them to come up to them. When they come up to you, it means they wanna join up with you, that they trust you. To prove it, she walked away and the horse followed her, and also followed as she circled in each direction. When she stopped, the horse did. It's really amazing how that works.
In here, they rub a horses ears to calm them.
Amy turned fifteen, but she seemed even younger. Her dialogue just made her sound childish, not like a teenager.
Amy sometimes irritates me on the show, but she really irritated me in here. So much so that I actually didn't like her. This was right after her mom's death, and with Lou wanting to change things at the ranch, I know she's going through a lot, but she annoyed me. She took too long to come around, to actually get out of the house and help run the farm.
Although I get how she couldn't understand how her sister and grandpa acted as if nothing had happened, and expected her to move on, she eventually realizes she needs to help the horses.
I was so irritated when she childishly jumps on Star, an expensive jumper, and an expensive jumper who isn't hers, and goes running away from Lou,& gets lost. She realizes she could have hurt Star, but thankfully didn't.
In the end Lou is the one to cure Sugarfoot, Mrs. Bell's Shetland pony, after the woman passes away. Lou unknowingly sings like Mrs. Bell did. I do like that the show didn't kill her off like this book did, at least so far on the show. I liked that someone else healed a horse, that it wasn't just Amy, because in the show, it's all Amy, all the time. Very exhausting.
Like the show, it's one thing after another. A lot of drama. Too much drama for my tastes. The back and forth, the fighting, one minute they're having a nice moment, the next they're back to fighting.
Also like the show, there's at least one horse case to solve in every. single. episode. In here, there were actually two, Star, Nick's horse, and Sugarfoot. So that's two in one book. Also, like the show, they cure the horses remarkably fast, within days.
I couldn't believe how simple this was. The scenes were short, with hardly a long conversation, just short dialogue. I wish it was more YA, but this was leaning towards children's, with the length and the writing. If they're all this short and simple, it's no wonder there's like 29 books in this series.
I didn't like the sudden ending at all. It cut off with no warning, right in the middle of the scene with Amy, Lou and Sugarfoot.
This was short enough to read in one day. Some things I like better in here, & others I like how it is on the show. I'm disappointed by how simple and juvenile this was. There was also an abundance of exclamation points. I hope there's more to Ty in the next books, and more to the characters in general, cause there wasn't much in here.
If they're all like this, I'm in for a long ride.