The Interrogation of Joan of Arc

Medieval Cultures #20

by Karen Sullivan

The transcripts of Joan of Arc's trial for heresy at Rouen in 1431 and the minutes of her interrogation have long been recognized as our best source of information about the Maid of Orleans. Historians generally view these legal texts as a precise account of Joan's words and, by extension, her beliefs. Focusing on the minutes recorded by clerics, however, Karen Sullivan challenges the accuracy of the transcript. In The Interrogation of Joan of Arc, she re-reads the record not as a perfect reflection of a historical personality's words, but as a literary text resulting from the collaboration between Joan and her interrogators. Sullivan provides an illuminating and innovative account of Joan's trial and interrogation, placing them in historical, social, and religious context. In the fifteenth century, interrogation was a method of truth-gathering identified not with people like Joan, who was uneducated, but with clerics, like those who tried her. When these clerics questioned Joan, they did so as scholastics educated at the University of Paris, as judges and assistants to judges, and as pastors trained in hearing confessions. The Interrogation of Joan of Arc traces Joan's conflicts with her interrogators not to differing political allegiances, but to fundamental differences between clerical and lay cultures. Sullivan demonstrates that the figure depicted in the transcripts as Joan of Arc is a complex, multifaceted persona that results largely from these cultural differences. Discerning and innovative, this study suggests a powerful new interpretive model and redefines our sense of Joan and her time.

Genres: History, Nonfiction, Medieval

232 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1999

Reviews

[Jessica · Rating 2 out of 5]

There were some pretty interesting facts in this book, but it wasn't exactly a page-turner.

[Crystal · Rating 4 out of 5]

At times a little difficult to follow but this is a fantastic read! This associate professor of literature follows the minutes of the trial as recorded by clerics to reveal "that it was pleasing to God to have the adversaries of the king repelled by a simple maid" - Joan of Arc's reply when asked why God would choose her to perform the tasks she had undertaken in seeing the rightful king gain the throne of France and to defeat invading England.