In The South's Best Butts, food writer and Southern gentleman, Matt Moore, waves away clouds of smoke to give barbecue-lovers a sneak peek into the kitchens and smokehouses of a handful of the Barbecue Belt's most revered pitmasters. He uncovers their tried-and-true techniques gleaned over hours, days, and years toiling by fire and spit, coaxing meltingly tender perfection from the humble pig-the foundation of Southern BBQ. More than a book of recipes, Matt explores how the marriage of meat, cooking method, and sauce varies from place to place based on history and culture, climate, available ingredients and wood, and always the closely-guarded, passed-down secrets followed like scripture. Because no meat plate is complete in the South without "all the fixin's" to round out the meal, Matt cues up patron-sanctioned recipes from every establishment he visits. One thing is for certain...this book will change the way you cook, smoke, grill, and eat, but be warned: Your own butt may suffer in the process.
I received this book as a digital advance reader copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Introduction clarifies that this book is all about the pork butt because “[i]t is humble, affordable, and forgiving….The pork butt is ubiquitous, a veritable cornerstone of BBQ.” The author’s goal with this book is to provide the reader with a peek into the kitchens, smokehouses, and personalities of the BBQ Belt’s most enduring pitmasters, along with some of their tried and true recipes for pork butt and trimmings. After the Introduction, there is an entertaining two-page history of the pig in American barbecue, which begins with the domestication of the pig by the ancient Chinese and ends by discussing the impact of the automobile on barbecue establishments.
After the introductory material, the book is divided into three parts: Fuel Equals Flavor, Smokehouse Stories and Recipes, and All the Trimmings. The first part contained a basic tutorial on the different equipment used to barbecue – open pit, closed pit, smokers – on how to tame the temperature while barbecuing, and on how to use hardwoods to impart flavor. That part ended with recipes with five “mother” sauces: Sweet BBQ Sauce, Vinegar BBQ Sauce, Black BBQ Sauce, White BBQ Sauce, and Mustard BBQ Sauce. The second part contained a dozen different profiles of barbecue joints from across the South, each followed by several recipes. The recipes ranged from their specialty house smoked pork butt and other smoked delicacies to desserts, such as fried banana pudding and sweet potato soufflé. This chapter is truly the heart and soul of the book, which accomplishes the author’s stated objective. The final chapter is purely a recipe chapter, which is further subdivided into Snacks and Starters, Sidekicks, Meaty Mains, Sweet Things, and Condiments. It was difficult to find a connection between the last chapter and the author’s stated goal, as these recipes did not appear to have any connection to any of the profiled Southern smokehouses. Some of them went so far as to lack any connection to Southern barbecue, such as Rosemary Salt & Vinegar Chips, Loaded Baked Potato Dip, and Red Beans and Rice. This last section was so different that I set the book aside for two weeks because I completely lost interest in reading it. Its imminent expiration was the only thing that motivated me to pick the book back up again.
Almost every recipe in the book had a headnote; those that didn’t were the subsidiary recipes that supported a main recipe. In the part of the book about the smokehouse stories, the headnotes were excellent: they tied in nicely with the smokehouse story, giving additional details about how the recipe is prepared by the pitmaster at that particular smokehouse. In the final part of the book that was just recipes, the headnotes were usually bland praise about the recipe. Aside from the subsidiary recipes, each recipe clearly indicates how many servings it makes, the hands-on time, and the total time required for the recipe. The recipe ingredients are provided in American measurements only, in order of use in the recipe. The recipe steps are clearly numbered and clearly written, with temperatures and times. Because the recipes in the smokehouse stories section are from the pitmasters themselves, there is a little more description about the look and feel of things in the recipe steps.
The full color photography in the first and second parts was predominantly of people and places, rather than of the finished recipes. Although the photography was lovely, the selection of photographs gave those parts more of a feel of a travel book than a cookbook. The photographs and accompanying artwork did an excellent job of conveying a sense of the South, and the Southern BBQ joints that the author profiled. However, the photographs of what the finished recipes should look like seemed to be few and far between. The full color photography in the third part was more in line with what I expected from a traditional cookbook. The majority of the styled photographs were clearly labeled as to which recipes were depicted so that it was easy to identify what the finished recipe should look like.
Overall, this book felt awkward. The second part was the clear bright star in the constellation. The first part was a good overview, but it was basically a recap of what I had already read in Steven Raichlen’s Project Smoke last summer. The third part felt extremely out of place. The author’s stated goal had been satisfied by the end of the second part, so the presence of the third part really confused me. It was odd to have such a chatty and opinionated author begin the third part without an introduction. At least have some commentary as to how the recipes that follow tie into the theme of the South’s Best Butts or relates to the goal that the author stated in the Introduction. Not many – if any – of the recipes in the third part seemed to have origin stories in the South or any clear ties to Southern barbecue written into their headnotes. For example, the first four main dishes were two stews, ramen, and pho. Those were followed by four mains featuring BBQ pulled pork: pizza, quesadilla, tortilla pie, and tostadas. And then there was the recipe for BBQ Spaghetti…. It just felt like someone else’s work was appended to a great Southern food travelogue in order to add another 100 pages of bulk to what was already a great book. If I had just stopped reading at the end of Smokehouse Stories and Recipes, I would have been much more satisfied with this book.
I have not prepared any recipes from this cookbook. When I do, I will update this review.
I gave this book a three, but it's really more of a 3.5 rating. The stories of all the pitmasters that Matt Moore interviews are a 4. They really bring to bear the diverse people who work the pits to make BBQ throughout the south. The recipes are a 3 as compared to the recipes Steve Raichlen, America's Test Kitchen, or Meathead provide.
I did at quite a few to my to-make list and so I'm excited to try some new ways of cooking pork shoulder (it is called South's Best Butts) and also a few other recipes.
Through great research, storytelling and photography, the essence of great southern barbecue is captured in the pages of this entertaining and interesting book. I intentionally didn't call it a "cookbook", because it is so much more. To me, a good cookbook is all about the photography, and, of course the recipes. But this one improves upon that structure with interesting stories of the Pitmasters of the South.
Restaurants are featured from each of these states: Alabama, Louisiana, Missouri, Oklahoma, Georgia, Mississippi, Tennessee, Kentucky, Arkansas, Texas, North Carolina, and South Carolina.
Each chapter tells the story of a renowned and successful southern barbecue joint, from humble shacks with limited seating to big emporiums that smoke tons of meat. There are infinite variations of temperature, fuels, rubs, and smoking techniques. Regional variances in recipes and techniques have lead to an astonishing number of ways to smoke a butt! Side dishes are given equal treatment, and are included in each chapter. In addition, the final section, labelled "All The Trimmings" includes snacks and starters, salad, breads, sauces, and various recipes that allow you to use the meat from the smoked butt - such as pizza, tostadas, casseroles and tacos. And finally, a chapter on sweet things - desserts. You could plan an authentic southern BBQ party from the pages of this excellent and inspiring cookbook.
The recipes are well written and easy to follow, and I can't wait to roll up my sleeves and try even more of them!
This book goes beyond your typical BBQ book and takes you inside select restaurants to hear stories and tips from experienced pitmasters. Matt Moore showcases one restaurant and pitmaster in each southern state. The restaurants he chose are not necessarily the most popular or well known in each state, but the key element found in each restaurant is pork.
The intro gives a short but interesting history of the pig in American BBQ. Then the book is divided into three parts: Part 1 - Fuel=Flavor - Discusses different cooking techniques, tips, and fuel types, as well as the different types of meat and sauces from each region. Part 2 - Smokehouse Stories and Recipes - Moore visits one restaurant in each southern state and sits down with each pitmaster to discuss their BBQ secrets. This section also provides many signature recipes from each restaurant. Part 3 - All the Trimmings - This last section is more like a traditional cookbook with southern inspired recipes to complement any meal, including 1) Snacks and Starters, 2) Sidekicks, 3) Meaty Mains, and 4) Sweet Things.
This book is filled with mouthwatering full color photos of food and lots of stories, tips, and recipes. I highly recommend it to any BBQ enthusiast. I received this as a free ARC from Time Inc. Books, Oxmoor House, on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This is an excellent book about barbeque and especially pork butts. The author gives you a little history about pork from china, to Rome, then Cuba and finally the South and how it became staple before the civil war and has just increased over the years. There is of course the different methods and types of wood, and of course slow cooking. Everyone has their one way but for the most part the beginning is just going over some of the same, but focus is on the pork butt. He then moves on to some different places in the country that have been around for a while and all of those stories are great. The recipes that the people shared from their places of business really added to this book. The different type of restaurant also gave it a different type of feel. Some of the pit masters are women, and they own or have taken over the family business in order to keep it going. I thought that was great. There also was a Korean Bar B Q that was interesting. When you get past though stories you get into different recipes from the author and some were very interesting and looked very good that I am going to try. Some other not so much, it is just a matter of choice. There are different rubs, and sauces, also salads, desserts, and sides. There was also an interesting bar b q tamale recipe that looked worthy of me giving it a try. The pictures were of good quality, the recipes were written in a way that were easy to follow. Overall a very good book. I got this book from Netgalley.com I gave it 5 stars. Follow us at www.1rad-readerreviews.com
Took a quick peek at this book when it rolled through my library. Looks like it's loaded with some pretty tasty recipes for bbq! I might have to take it out sometime to get a few recipes from it. Worth a look!
Matt Moore wrote a great book. I loved reading about the different pitmasters and what makes their BBQ unique. My family has already enjoyed many of the dishes highlighted.
I ended up using this one as more of a travel guide than a cookbook - but boy was it mouthwatering all the same. Especially the desserts, of all things.
Impressive!! The stories of the restaurants partnered with amazing recipes make this a must-have for any fan smoked barbecue. The pictures make you salivate. The sides and sauces are just as amazing as the meat. The recipes are all work even if you're not a pitmaster. This review is for the physical book. I plan to give this book as gifts.