What do you think?
Rate this book
Sister Fidelma #27
Penance of the Damned: A Mystery of Ancient Ireland
Ireland, AD 671. King Colgú of Cashel is shocked to learn that his loyal Chief Bishop and advisor has been murdered in the old enemy fortress of the Uí Fidgente. When word reaches Cashel that the culprit will be executed under new law, a larger conflict looms.
Dispatched to investigate, Fidelma and her companion Eadulf discover that the man facing punishment is Gormán―commander of the King’s bodyguard. But Fidelma cannot believe Gormán would carry out such an act―and yet he was found locked in a chamber with the body, weapon in hand. The evidence is stacked against him.
If they are to exonerate Gormán and keep the peace between the kingdoms, Fidelma and Eadulf must find the true culprit. As the threat of war looms, the date of execution drawers ever closer...
Dispatched to investigate, Fidelma and her companion Eadulf discover that the man facing punishment is Gormán―commander of the King’s bodyguard. But Fidelma cannot believe Gormán would carry out such an act―and yet he was found locked in a chamber with the body, weapon in hand. The evidence is stacked against him.
If they are to exonerate Gormán and keep the peace between the kingdoms, Fidelma and Eadulf must find the true culprit. As the threat of war looms, the date of execution drawers ever closer...
352 pages, Hardcover
First published July 14, 2016
79 people are currently reading
387 people want to read
About the author
Peter Tremayne
206 books471 followersPeter Berresford Ellis (born 10 March 1943) is a historian, literary biographer, and novelist who has published over 90 books to date either under his own name or his pseudonyms Peter Tremayne and Peter MacAlan. He has also published 95 short stories. His non-fiction books, articles and academic papers have made him acknowledged as an authority on Celtic history and culture. As Peter Tremayne, he is the author of the international bestselling Sister Fidelma mystery series. His work has appeared in 25 languages.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
September 2, 2017
For a number of reasons I have reached the conclusion that I will part ways with this series. Perhaps 27 is stretching it> patterns, same old, officiousness, stiffness, etc. It was a great run and provided me with wonderful insights and experiences when I spent a month in Ireland visiting many of the sites described so well in the Sister Fidelma series.
December 29, 2018
This thrilling and adventurous "Sister Fidelma" mystery is already the 27th volume of this fascinating series.
As ever the story has been thoroughly researched historically and explained in a very clear fashion within the Author's Note at the beginning of the book, while the book also includes a beautiful map of Fidelma's world of Muman (Munster) in the 7th Century AD, as well as an interesting character list.
Story-telling is once more of a top-notch quality because the author keeps you spellbound right till the end, before coming to the final conclusion when the culprit(s) will be exposed and accused according to the Irish Brehon Law.
Within this marvellous mystery all the characters come vividly to life, the interactions between all these same characters are very lifelike and real so much so that it makes this book such a joy to read, and the book is set again in the year AD 671, during the month which is called Meithem (Old Irish) meaning "the middle month", being regarded as midsummer but today known as June.
The mystery is mainly set in the Ui Fidgente area of Muman where unrest is still brooding and where this murder investigation will be taking place by Sister Fidelma and Brother Eadulf.
This murder investigation involves the death of the Chief Bishop, Abbot Segdae, who's also King Colgu of Cashel loyal advisor, at the hand of the probable murderer Gorman, who's Commander of the King's Bodyguard, and so its up to Sister Fidelma and Brother Eadulf to prove his innocence.
What will follow besides the well defined background details and vivid pictured everyday life and surroundings of Irish history, is a mystery with quite a few twists and turns before coming to the exciting plot where all will be revealed, and the culprit(s) of the murder(s) exposed and accused by Sister Fidelma in accordance to the Brehon Law.
Very much recommended, because this book is a great mystery and because the author Peter Tremayne still shows us very much that he's still on top of his game, and making his main characters "Sister Fidelma & Brother Eadulf Excel Again"!
As ever the story has been thoroughly researched historically and explained in a very clear fashion within the Author's Note at the beginning of the book, while the book also includes a beautiful map of Fidelma's world of Muman (Munster) in the 7th Century AD, as well as an interesting character list.
Story-telling is once more of a top-notch quality because the author keeps you spellbound right till the end, before coming to the final conclusion when the culprit(s) will be exposed and accused according to the Irish Brehon Law.
Within this marvellous mystery all the characters come vividly to life, the interactions between all these same characters are very lifelike and real so much so that it makes this book such a joy to read, and the book is set again in the year AD 671, during the month which is called Meithem (Old Irish) meaning "the middle month", being regarded as midsummer but today known as June.
The mystery is mainly set in the Ui Fidgente area of Muman where unrest is still brooding and where this murder investigation will be taking place by Sister Fidelma and Brother Eadulf.
This murder investigation involves the death of the Chief Bishop, Abbot Segdae, who's also King Colgu of Cashel loyal advisor, at the hand of the probable murderer Gorman, who's Commander of the King's Bodyguard, and so its up to Sister Fidelma and Brother Eadulf to prove his innocence.
What will follow besides the well defined background details and vivid pictured everyday life and surroundings of Irish history, is a mystery with quite a few twists and turns before coming to the exciting plot where all will be revealed, and the culprit(s) of the murder(s) exposed and accused by Sister Fidelma in accordance to the Brehon Law.
Very much recommended, because this book is a great mystery and because the author Peter Tremayne still shows us very much that he's still on top of his game, and making his main characters "Sister Fidelma & Brother Eadulf Excel Again"!
August 2, 2017
I always wait with great expectation every new book in the Sister Fidelma series. Unfortunately, they come pretty far apart. Thankfully, Mr. Tremayne gives enough background in the telling of the story that we are reminded of who certain characters are and what their previous relationship was to Fidelma and Eadulf. This book was no exception.
The problem with the retelling in this story is that the previous adventure referred to was quite complex when reading originally. Getting bits and pieces in a refresher makes it all the more complicated. There were names that I recognized, but others that I had forgotten. I found myself struggling with the story line a times trying to make sense of the personalities.
Of course, it is no spoiler to report that Sister Fidelma is triumphant in the end. It didn't take me long to figure out the how of the first murder as was true for Fidelma. She didn't reveal that information to others until the end though which also left me wondering if I had the right answer. The why seemed pretty obvious. The question that remained in my mind the who. But there was plenty of action along the way to keep me turning the pages! I saw conspiracy where there was none, unjustly thinking ill of loyal people. There were enough clues that I hadn't picked up on that three were still some surprises for me.
The story was wonderful, as always. My Latin was challenged. I learned new words and customs. The reason for the 4 stars vs. 5 is simply that I had a difficult time placing characters from previous books. And that is my fault for not having a better memory, nothing that should be held against the author.
The problem with the retelling in this story is that the previous adventure referred to was quite complex when reading originally. Getting bits and pieces in a refresher makes it all the more complicated. There were names that I recognized, but others that I had forgotten. I found myself struggling with the story line a times trying to make sense of the personalities.
Of course, it is no spoiler to report that Sister Fidelma is triumphant in the end. It didn't take me long to figure out the how of the first murder as was true for Fidelma. She didn't reveal that information to others until the end though which also left me wondering if I had the right answer. The why seemed pretty obvious. The question that remained in my mind the who. But there was plenty of action along the way to keep me turning the pages! I saw conspiracy where there was none, unjustly thinking ill of loyal people. There were enough clues that I hadn't picked up on that three were still some surprises for me.
The story was wonderful, as always. My Latin was challenged. I learned new words and customs. The reason for the 4 stars vs. 5 is simply that I had a difficult time placing characters from previous books. And that is my fault for not having a better memory, nothing that should be held against the author.
September 1, 2016
Fidelma is once again in the land of the Ui Fidgente. This time Gorman, the commander of her brother's bodyguard, has been charged with killing his chief bishop. All of this happened in the dicey land of their former rivals. The bishop there is calling for use of the Penitentials and Gorman's death without delay. The Prince is in a jam with serious consequences on the one hand killing Colgu's guard will provoke retaliation, but seeming to excuse his behavior will antagonize his own people for bowing to Cashel - a thought certain to be stirred up by the nasty abbot from a few books ago. How it wasn't Gorman despite the locked room seemed obvious from the start and some of the players too. But the whole plot unraveled in typical Fidelma ways and the total package was unexpected. Lots of old friends despite not being in Cashel.
January 7, 2020
I should have given up on this series at least by 20, but it's never too late. There are two main problems with this book. First, the one that continues to be a major issue. While I'm sure there's a lot to the Irish culture and mysteries set in that culture could be very interesting, Tremayne remains set of focusing far too much of his writing on doctrinaire fights between early Christian fanatics. It's too much. Second, there are just too many characters who are idiots, who refuse to do the intelligent thing.
The series began with much promise, with Fidelma leaving the church to follow the law in an ancient and interesting culture. Somewhere along the way, Tremayne lost that focus.
I've been like those idiotic characters for too long. It's time to wake up.
The series began with much promise, with Fidelma leaving the church to follow the law in an ancient and interesting culture. Somewhere along the way, Tremayne lost that focus.
I've been like those idiotic characters for too long. It's time to wake up.
August 8, 2016
A enjoyable read.I have read Sr fidelma since the beginning and like reading about the history of early Ireland.The story is simple Fidelma has to save Gorman from being found guilty of murder.The story shows us how the early Roman Church wanted to change the legal system of Ireland.These penitentials want to introduce capital punishment.Sr Fidelma is opposed to the penitentials and supports the traditional law of Ireland.If there's is a fault in the novel it was the solution which I worked out early on.Despite this I do like the series which is good on historical fact and brings to life 7th century Ireland.
December 28, 2020
I do love these Sr. Fidelma mysteries. Another enjoyable story.
February 10, 2022
This author created a series of books where each book is a separate story. Usually a series has to be read in order, to keep up on the story line. Each book is it's own story and doesn't need the book prior to support it. I like the story line, it was rich in detail and historical significance. Looking forward to reading the whole series to see how everything turns out.
January 21, 2023
This is the 27th book in the series, if you include the two short story collections. By this time, Fidelma has gained a reputation for being a sleuth. She has married Eadulf and has a growing son named Alchu. Fidelma has left the religious order but not the faith - something that she has to make that distinction to those who challenge. As a high ranking dalaigh, the sister of the king, and member of the Golden Torc, gone are the days when she has to remind people of her social and political rank.
Fidelma has made a lot of enemies and some of them are still around. For to understand this book's backstory, you would have to read Atonement of Blood first. These enemies hold grudges and Fidelma knows it. For some, the feeling is mutual.
The other historical background is to understand how the Irish kingdoms were set up in the 7th century AD. There was an elected High Kingdom that sat at the top. Next were the five kingdoms. Sometimes those kingdoms were at war and sometimes at peace. If that wasn't complicated enough, each of those kingdoms had sub-kingdoms and chieftains below them. The Ui Fidgente and the Osraige paid tribute to the King of Muman, which could cause tension since some wanted to be independent or switch allegiance to another kingdom.
However, just as Fidelma has made enemies, she has also made powerful friends too. In the past, Conri, warlord of the Ui Fidgente, did not like her due to their ethnic rivalries, but now he is one of her most powerful allies. If Fidelma needed a band of warriors for protection in that region, Conri often would be there to help.
I like this book because it kept me guessing all the way to the end. About 80% through the book, I suddenly realized who the real murderer and the person at the heart of the conspiracy. I just didn't know why and what the evidence was. Tremayne likes to have women as the ultimate villain and often uses gender neutral language in his setup. Even in a male-dominated world, Irish civilization then was very progressive when it came to rights for women. They could inherit in their own right, go to school, lead religious communities, and even become queens. So if that was true, surely they could set in motion their own plots. I just hope I didn't reveal too much.
Fidelma has made a lot of enemies and some of them are still around. For to understand this book's backstory, you would have to read Atonement of Blood first. These enemies hold grudges and Fidelma knows it. For some, the feeling is mutual.
The other historical background is to understand how the Irish kingdoms were set up in the 7th century AD. There was an elected High Kingdom that sat at the top. Next were the five kingdoms. Sometimes those kingdoms were at war and sometimes at peace. If that wasn't complicated enough, each of those kingdoms had sub-kingdoms and chieftains below them. The Ui Fidgente and the Osraige paid tribute to the King of Muman, which could cause tension since some wanted to be independent or switch allegiance to another kingdom.
However, just as Fidelma has made enemies, she has also made powerful friends too. In the past, Conri, warlord of the Ui Fidgente, did not like her due to their ethnic rivalries, but now he is one of her most powerful allies. If Fidelma needed a band of warriors for protection in that region, Conri often would be there to help.
I like this book because it kept me guessing all the way to the end. About 80% through the book, I suddenly realized who the real murderer and the person at the heart of the conspiracy. I just didn't know why and what the evidence was. Tremayne likes to have women as the ultimate villain and often uses gender neutral language in his setup. Even in a male-dominated world, Irish civilization then was very progressive when it came to rights for women. They could inherit in their own right, go to school, lead religious communities, and even become queens. So if that was true, surely they could set in motion their own plots. I just hope I didn't reveal too much.
May 26, 2018
In "Penance of the Damned", Peter Tremayne employs one of my least favorite plot devices, a recurring character (Gorman) is unjustly accused of a crime and imprisoned. So, right off the bat, losing myself in the story was a struggle. And way too much arguing with Abbott Nannid about the Old Faith versus the New Faith. The topic is growing old and stale in this particular series.
The story took a while to jumpstart, encumbered by the usually clunky dialogue. The pace did not pick up to any degree until Fidelma finally started asking questions. It was also rather obvious that false messages were relayed and I'm a little surprised it took Fidelma so long to figure out such an obvious clue.
The action is too slow-moving for most of the book (the one exception being the rescue of Gorman from the abbey) and there is far too much repetition (in the form of Abbott Nannid). As Fidelma said, Abbott Nannid was also far too obvious to be the guilty party. I guessed very early on who the real culprits were and why. Airmid was obviously being written as a direct contrast to Fidelma and the relationships each shares with their brothers.
A few good points did stand out, saving this book from a two-star rating. Fidelma was thorough, concise and exhibited an unusual amount of patience during her investigation. I was also glad to see Conri playing an integral part in this book. He is one of my favorite recurring characters and I enjoy the rapport between him and Fidelma. (There are actually times I wish Fidelma had married Conri instead of Eaudulf. Imagine the interesting storyline possibilities if a princess of the Eoghanacht married a warrior of the Ui Fidgente. And I probably butchered the spelling.)
Overall, however, the story suffered from a lack of pace, poor dialogue and a mystery which was too easily solved. Better luck next time.
The story took a while to jumpstart, encumbered by the usually clunky dialogue. The pace did not pick up to any degree until Fidelma finally started asking questions. It was also rather obvious that false messages were relayed and I'm a little surprised it took Fidelma so long to figure out such an obvious clue.
The action is too slow-moving for most of the book (the one exception being the rescue of Gorman from the abbey) and there is far too much repetition (in the form of Abbott Nannid). As Fidelma said, Abbott Nannid was also far too obvious to be the guilty party. I guessed very early on who the real culprits were and why. Airmid was obviously being written as a direct contrast to Fidelma and the relationships each shares with their brothers.
A few good points did stand out, saving this book from a two-star rating. Fidelma was thorough, concise and exhibited an unusual amount of patience during her investigation. I was also glad to see Conri playing an integral part in this book. He is one of my favorite recurring characters and I enjoy the rapport between him and Fidelma. (There are actually times I wish Fidelma had married Conri instead of Eaudulf. Imagine the interesting storyline possibilities if a princess of the Eoghanacht married a warrior of the Ui Fidgente. And I probably butchered the spelling.)
Overall, however, the story suffered from a lack of pace, poor dialogue and a mystery which was too easily solved. Better luck next time.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 14, 2017
I've only read one other Sister Fidelma mystery and feel much the same way about Penance of the Damned as I did about the earlier book--good mystery, excellent history.
Set in Ireland in 671 AD, Fidelma is sent to find out more about the murder of a bishop. What she finds is a friend accused, religious disagreements, disquisitions on Irish law vs the laws of the New Faith, and a locked room mystery.
The first of the novel is a little slow and deals with the recent history between Irish principalities that will effect Fidelma's mission to discover the truth about the bishop's murder. When Fidelma and Eadulf arrive in Prince Donnenach's fortress, however, the story begin to get interesting.
These books are as much (or more) for those interested in ancient Irish history as they are for lovers of historical mysteries. I find the historical elements fascinating, especially conflicts between the New and the Old Faith and the information concerning ancient Irish law.
"Peter Berresford Ellis (born 10 March 1943) is a historian, literary biographer, and novelist who has published over 90 books to date either under his own name or his pseudonyms Peter Tremayne and Peter MacAlan. He has also published 95 short stories. His non-fiction books, articles and academic papers have made him acknowledged as an authority on Celtic history and culture. As Peter Tremayne, he is the author of the international bestselling Sister Fidelma mystery series. His work has appeared in 25 languages."
NetGalley/St. Martin's Press
Historical Mystery. July 25, 2017. Print length: 352 pages.
Set in Ireland in 671 AD, Fidelma is sent to find out more about the murder of a bishop. What she finds is a friend accused, religious disagreements, disquisitions on Irish law vs the laws of the New Faith, and a locked room mystery.
The first of the novel is a little slow and deals with the recent history between Irish principalities that will effect Fidelma's mission to discover the truth about the bishop's murder. When Fidelma and Eadulf arrive in Prince Donnenach's fortress, however, the story begin to get interesting.
These books are as much (or more) for those interested in ancient Irish history as they are for lovers of historical mysteries. I find the historical elements fascinating, especially conflicts between the New and the Old Faith and the information concerning ancient Irish law.
"Peter Berresford Ellis (born 10 March 1943) is a historian, literary biographer, and novelist who has published over 90 books to date either under his own name or his pseudonyms Peter Tremayne and Peter MacAlan. He has also published 95 short stories. His non-fiction books, articles and academic papers have made him acknowledged as an authority on Celtic history and culture. As Peter Tremayne, he is the author of the international bestselling Sister Fidelma mystery series. His work has appeared in 25 languages."
NetGalley/St. Martin's Press
Historical Mystery. July 25, 2017. Print length: 352 pages.
July 21, 2017
This was a first time to read this author. Fidelma and her husband, Eadulf were sent by her brother, King Colgu, to check out the story that Gorman, the commander of his bodyguard, killed the Abbott but all this happened in a neighboring kingdom. Needless to say, thru a lot of twists and turns, they eventually get to the bottom of everything. I enjoyed the book and the story was marvelous, but I had some trouble with names that I could in no way pronounce. Fidelma, was intelligent and had a mind like a steel trap. Eadulf was her soft side and was a sort of physician. It was interesting to see the different characters, they seemed so real. You could imagine traveling thru the countryside with them. The plot was so complex, it was amazing that Fidelma was able to see her way around all the obstacles. I enjoy the book but I need more concentration because of the different language used in places. I think the author has a quick mind to just figure out this stuff. by the way, I never realized they had such sophisticated laws, way back then, interesting. But I think anyone who likes an excellent mystery with a twist would love this tale. I highly recommend it and hope you give it a try.
November 14, 2024
⛪ Cette saga se passe au VIIe siècle, en Irlande. Fidelma est une belle et intelligente jeune femme, qui est à la fois la soeur du Roi de Cashel, une éminente juriste, et soeur en religion. A l'époque, les monastères irlandais sont plus ouverts que de nos jours. Ils accueillent des couples et enfants. Au fil de la saga, Fidelma rencontre Eadulf, moine et médecin, qui l'épouse et vit mille aventures avec elle, l'aidant à résoudre de nombreuses enquêtes, souvent liés aux conflits entre royaumes irlandais ou entre différentes courants de pensée de la religion catholique.Dans cet opus, Fidelma va se débattre pour innocenter le commandant de la Garde royale de son frère, accusé de meurtre. Et sa sagacité l'amènera à divulguer un sombre complot.
⛪ Je suis une grande adepte des policiers historiques qui, sous prétexte d'une enquête plus ou moins complexe, nous amène en douceur à découvrir l'histoire d'un pays. Les enquêtes de Fidelma, outre qu'elles se passent dans un pays somptueux et décrivent souvent des paysages magiques, sont une fenêtre sur une période mal connue : celle où la religion catholique qui s'était installée en Irlande en épousant les contours des rites et traditions de ce pays se heurte aux nouvelles réformes dictées depuis Rome ; celle aussi où l'Irlande était découpée en plusieurs provinces sous le patronage du Haut-Roi de Tara.
A découvrir donc, pour voyager, apprendre, rêver, et tout simplement essayer de démêler de bien belles enquêtes !
⛪ Je suis une grande adepte des policiers historiques qui, sous prétexte d'une enquête plus ou moins complexe, nous amène en douceur à découvrir l'histoire d'un pays. Les enquêtes de Fidelma, outre qu'elles se passent dans un pays somptueux et décrivent souvent des paysages magiques, sont une fenêtre sur une période mal connue : celle où la religion catholique qui s'était installée en Irlande en épousant les contours des rites et traditions de ce pays se heurte aux nouvelles réformes dictées depuis Rome ; celle aussi où l'Irlande était découpée en plusieurs provinces sous le patronage du Haut-Roi de Tara.
A découvrir donc, pour voyager, apprendre, rêver, et tout simplement essayer de démêler de bien belles enquêtes !
December 4, 2023
Der vorliegende Roman ist wieder äußerst spannend, zudem haben die Story und einige Figuren Bezug zu vorangegangenen Büchern der Reihe. Wer also schon länger Fan von Schwester Fidelma ist, kommt hier voll auf seine Kosten.
Wie immer gibt es ein Personenverzeichnis und eine kurze Übersicht, eine Karte der Gegend zu jener Zeit, und auch die lateinischen wie gälischen Begriffe werden beim Lesen übersetzt und erläutert.
Spannend ist es, mit Fidelma und Eadulf zu ermitteln, mit den Gegebenheiten und Gesetzen des 7. JH. Im vorliegenden Roman ist zudem noch nicht einmal wirklich klar - zumindest anfangs nicht - nach welchen Gesetzen gehandelt werden soll, den geltenden Gesetzen der 5 Königreiche oder den neuen Gesetzen aus dem Alten Testament.
Unklar ist, wer den Abt ermordet hat, wenn auch eine vorgefertigte Meinung besteht. Uns Lesern sowie Fidelma und Eadulf ist natürlich klar, dass es Gorman nicht gewesen sein wird. Nur wie kann man seine Unschuld beweisen?
Dass Fidelma am Ende natürlich nicht nur den Mörder präsentiert, sondern auch das Motiv und eine komplette Verschwörung enttarnt, ist einfach wunderbar. - Ich gebe 94/100 bwz. 09/10 Punkte.
https://sunsys-blog.blogspot.com/2023...
Wie immer gibt es ein Personenverzeichnis und eine kurze Übersicht, eine Karte der Gegend zu jener Zeit, und auch die lateinischen wie gälischen Begriffe werden beim Lesen übersetzt und erläutert.
Spannend ist es, mit Fidelma und Eadulf zu ermitteln, mit den Gegebenheiten und Gesetzen des 7. JH. Im vorliegenden Roman ist zudem noch nicht einmal wirklich klar - zumindest anfangs nicht - nach welchen Gesetzen gehandelt werden soll, den geltenden Gesetzen der 5 Königreiche oder den neuen Gesetzen aus dem Alten Testament.
Unklar ist, wer den Abt ermordet hat, wenn auch eine vorgefertigte Meinung besteht. Uns Lesern sowie Fidelma und Eadulf ist natürlich klar, dass es Gorman nicht gewesen sein wird. Nur wie kann man seine Unschuld beweisen?
Dass Fidelma am Ende natürlich nicht nur den Mörder präsentiert, sondern auch das Motiv und eine komplette Verschwörung enttarnt, ist einfach wunderbar. - Ich gebe 94/100 bwz. 09/10 Punkte.
https://sunsys-blog.blogspot.com/2023...
December 18, 2017
A repeat of the plot where someone is murdered inside a locked room. I figured out how it happened early on. Apparently, Fidelma figured it out too but she also needed to know who and why. Unfortunately, half dozen more people died before she figured it all out.
This plot was another convoluted one. The bishop of Imleach is murdered in his room at the castle of Donennach. Gormán is found unconscious in the room with the bishop and accused by a religious. The head of the local abbey wanted to punish Gormán using Penitential rules - by hanging Gormán.
Fidelma goes to try to save Gormán but he escaped with his wife Aibell. Everyone (except Fidelma and Eadulf) assumes that the escape is a sign of guilt. During the investigation, Aibell’s friend Ciarnat is found hanged. Brother Máel Anfaid is found drowned. Fidelma and Eadulf find Aibell but her uncle has been murdered.
The crazy cleric captures Gormán and plans to hang him at. On the next day. Of course, Gormán is saved. The real murderer is finally revealed - surprise
This plot was another convoluted one. The bishop of Imleach is murdered in his room at the castle of Donennach. Gormán is found unconscious in the room with the bishop and accused by a religious. The head of the local abbey wanted to punish Gormán using Penitential rules - by hanging Gormán.
Fidelma goes to try to save Gormán but he escaped with his wife Aibell. Everyone (except Fidelma and Eadulf) assumes that the escape is a sign of guilt. During the investigation, Aibell’s friend Ciarnat is found hanged. Brother Máel Anfaid is found drowned. Fidelma and Eadulf find Aibell but her uncle has been murdered.
The crazy cleric captures Gormán and plans to hang him at. On the next day. Of course, Gormán is saved. The real murderer is finally revealed - surprise
July 20, 2017
In this book Fidelma and Eadulf head back to the land of the Ui Fedgente to investigate because their loyal Chief Bishop from Cashel has been murdered and a soldier from Cashel has been charged with his murder. Ui Fidgente is a land that has no love lost with the subjects of King Colgu, who is Fidelma's brother. So there is lots of danger and intrigue and plenty of murders like any Sister Fidleman mystery. Tremayne's books are set in 1st Century Ireland, and his knowledge of this ancient era comes through on every page of his books. But that was where this book fell short for me. I thought there was entirely too much relgious debate and discourse so it took away from the usual suspense and thrills of a Fidelma book. Also, unlike previous books, I had figured out the perpetrators about halfway through on this one. I was disappointed, but I will read the next one because Fidelma is one of my favourite characters.
October 16, 2022
I award three stars only because of this author's other great work. Any other author, writing of any other nation and age would have received two stars at best.
What a disappointing obfuscation. Sadly, the weak plot in this book is surrounded by irritatingly copious conversation on a pointedly minute moment of Irish church lore - not law.
Hate reading that last sentence? That's the way I felt as our author went over, and over, and over again talking about the Irish Christian beliefs versus those of the Roman Church. I got it. I got it the first time. I didn't need page upon page of bickering to understand.
Oh well, all the best authors have a clinker or two in their closets. So does Tremayne...and this is one of them. Sorry, Peter.
What a disappointing obfuscation. Sadly, the weak plot in this book is surrounded by irritatingly copious conversation on a pointedly minute moment of Irish church lore - not law.
Hate reading that last sentence? That's the way I felt as our author went over, and over, and over again talking about the Irish Christian beliefs versus those of the Roman Church. I got it. I got it the first time. I didn't need page upon page of bickering to understand.
Oh well, all the best authors have a clinker or two in their closets. So does Tremayne...and this is one of them. Sorry, Peter.
March 25, 2024
I love this series and have been reading them in order throughout the last 12 months. I enjoy the historical context, the interpretation fo gaelic phrases and the insights into a culture in flux. I enjoy encountering familiar characters from earlier tales, as well as the main two individuals - even though these stories are set so long ago in the distant past, it feels modern in many ways.
I found this plot a little more convoluted then some of the previous adventures and found it difficult to keep up with all the names, loyalties and red herrings. In fairness, I'm reading the stories on a phone so that adds to the challenge of reading as it's so difficult to flip back for clarification, if needed.
Looking forward to the next in the series.
I found this plot a little more convoluted then some of the previous adventures and found it difficult to keep up with all the names, loyalties and red herrings. In fairness, I'm reading the stories on a phone so that adds to the challenge of reading as it's so difficult to flip back for clarification, if needed.
Looking forward to the next in the series.
July 31, 2017
In this 27th of the series, King Colgu of Cashel receives word that the local bishop Segdae has been murdered in the fortress of the Ui Fidgente - former enemies with whom Colgu has only recently achieved a peace - and that the murderer will be executed under their abbey's new penitential laws.
Fidelma and her husband Eadulf are sent to investigate, and discover that the man being held is Gorman, the commander of Colgu's bodyguard, who was found locked in a chamber with Segdae's body, who says he was hit from behind and knocked unconscious. Fidelma believes him innocent, and in setting out to prove it, discovers a larger, more sinister plot at work.
Fidelma and her husband Eadulf are sent to investigate, and discover that the man being held is Gorman, the commander of Colgu's bodyguard, who was found locked in a chamber with Segdae's body, who says he was hit from behind and knocked unconscious. Fidelma believes him innocent, and in setting out to prove it, discovers a larger, more sinister plot at work.
October 1, 2017
Another very fine mystery in this series in which the crime is committed in a "locked room". I am very pleased that Eadulf is playing a more major role in uncovering the crime. The one character that puzzles me is Donennach, prince of the Ui Fidget, who seems very indecisive as a king. Yet he was the chosen one of his clan. True, his position is a sticky one: the accused is the leader of King Clog's bodyguard and the accuser is a bishop rising to acclaim and aiming to become the religious leader. He is one of the most repulsive of Tremayne's "bad guys", a truly joyless person. Rather than take a risk of spoilers I will cease.
August 16, 2017
I have read and enjoyed earlier Sister Fidelma books, and this is "locked room" mystery is just as enjoyable. I did figure out the "how" part before the big reveal, but not the "who" or "why". I like her steady insistence on the law, and the setting of medieval Ireland with it's conflicts between the New Faith of Christianity and the old, and the politics between the various kingdoms. The disadvantage to coming in without having read this series in a while is that it slows down the beginning of the actual story to cover some of the cases she as solved in the past.
May 15, 2018
It's always fun to pay a visit to Ancient Ireland and our friends Fidelma and Eadulf. This was another well-written book, though I knew who had "done it" from the beginning; because, if you assumed the recurring character Gorman was innocent, there was really only one person who could have committed the crime. There was also a pretty good hint as to who the accomplice was, however, there was enough misdirection and subplots to make it interesting. I only wish I had remembered the details of the previous novel that was referred to often.
June 20, 2019
As usual, Fidelma sticks tenaciously to the discovery of truth when investigating the death of her friend Abbot Se’gdae, advisor to her brother the King. However, an obnoxious Abbot attempts to twist everything to his view of faith and cause divisions over the ‘religious laws’ against the traditional Laws of the 5 Kingdoms. Further deaths, accusations, and confusing events contrive to endanger the fragile peace agreed between Cashel and Ui Fidgente. The death of the accused Gorma’n, warrior of Cashel seems a given if the truth is not uncovered.
April 18, 2021
I've always found reading books by Peter Tremayne to be an intellectual challenge. Others have been four stars , but this one also presented a particularly complicated plot that kept me reading way too late at night. HIs characters are an interesting mix, and Tremayne's grasp of the history of the Irish and English in the seventh century is a joy to read. These novels are also enlightening concerning the emergence and practices of Christianity at this time. I encourage you to try these Sister Fidelma mysteries; it is best to start with the first one and read them in order.
February 9, 2017
This story has much discussion about the 'Penitentials' which were a very strict set of laws relating to Christian communities and the history behind them, which I found quite interesting. Indeed, I love the historical background in all of the Fidelma books and that is partly what keeps me reading them. It is a tale of conspiracy, murder and red herrings which Fidelma sorts in her usual thoughtful way. An enjoyable read.
August 15, 2017
Sister Fidelma, Eadulf and Enda are dispatched to Donnacht of the Ui Figente. Gorman has been accused of killing Abbot Segdae and is on trial. Unfortunately the abbot of the Ui Figente want to punish Gorman under the penancetenials instead of the law of the Behons. But it seems clear Gorman is guilty. He was found with Segdae in a room locked from within. Fidelma must figure out how the crime was committed and of course she does in Peter Tremayne's Penance of the Damned.
February 19, 2018
Interesting story
Reading books by Peter Tremayne is always something of an intellectual exercise. This one also presented a particularly complicated plot. I enjoy the characters and the history of the Irish and English in the seventh century. These novels are also enlightening concerning the emergence and practices of Christianity at this time. If you want to read the Sister Fidelma mysteries, it is best to start with the first one and read them in order.
Reading books by Peter Tremayne is always something of an intellectual exercise. This one also presented a particularly complicated plot. I enjoy the characters and the history of the Irish and English in the seventh century. These novels are also enlightening concerning the emergence and practices of Christianity at this time. If you want to read the Sister Fidelma mysteries, it is best to start with the first one and read them in order.
March 29, 2018
What would you get if Agatha Christie's Poirot suddenly found himself in 7th century Ireland? This. The book is really a slavish imitation of Christie. And, while I don't read a whole lot of mysteries, and I acknowledge Christie as one of the masters, I have read enough to know that there's more than one way to write one.
However, if you're going to do a series with 30 or so books, I suppose it makes sense to borrow a framework that's known to work and keep that crank turning.
However, if you're going to do a series with 30 or so books, I suppose it makes sense to borrow a framework that's known to work and keep that crank turning.
March 8, 2019
Soy fan incondicional de esta saga, pero reconozco que en esta novela me he aburrido mucho con las disertaciones legales y religiosas en las que se enzarzan los personajes.
Es una tendencia habitual en Tremayne, enzarzarse en discusiones de índole religioso enfrentando las creencias antiguas con la Nueva Fe; no obstante en esta novela llega a ser muy tedioso y se prolonga en exceso, no aportando nada a la trama.
Es una tendencia habitual en Tremayne, enzarzarse en discusiones de índole religioso enfrentando las creencias antiguas con la Nueva Fe; no obstante en esta novela llega a ser muy tedioso y se prolonga en exceso, no aportando nada a la trama.
July 15, 2017
In 671, Ireland when King Colgú learns that his Chief Bishop has been killed in the fortress of the Uí Fidgente, held by his enemy, he sends his sister Fidelma to investigate in what seems to be a locked room mystery.
Took too long for Fidelma and her team to arrive at the fortress that I was already bored, too much extraneous detail, too much Irish history and religion.
A NetGalley Book
Took too long for Fidelma and her team to arrive at the fortress that I was already bored, too much extraneous detail, too much Irish history and religion.
A NetGalley Book
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews