MURDEROUS MAYHEM AT HONEYCHURCH HALL, the fourth book in the Honeychurch Hall Mystery series, is delightful reading fun, striking a nice balance between silliness, mischief, and murder.
Kate Stanford, a former TV show antique appraiser, has opened her own business in the gatehouse of Honeychurch Estate and hopes the village’s upcoming “Skirmish” reenactment of the English Civil War will draw some badly needed traffic. The whole tiny village of Little Dipperton in Devon traditionally gets involved, and this event provides a nice backdrop that ties the whole story together. Kate’s mother Iris, who is secretly a wildly successful romance author, mailed her latest manuscript to her publisher but is beside herself when she discovers it never arrived; the only copy of the book is missing. Add to this drama the discovery of a centuries old murder victim, small items gone missing, money stolen, a car theft ring, a family feud that dates back to said Civil War, infidelity, the postmistress’s murder, and a ghost, and readers can indeed see how easy it is for the mayhem to ensue. Author Hannah Denison does a great job of weaving these numerous plot threads together. In less skilled hands, this whole book could have been a royal mess, but everything comes together in a dramatic climax, and all threads are neatly resolved to provide an exceptionally satisfying read.
Each of the various mysteries is compelling on its own, but the story surrounding the unearthed skeleton is my favorite. The rich local history and the plethora of records dating back hundreds of years are fascinating and awe inspiring to me in contrast to my own “young” American history. Everything to do with the Honeychurch lineage and the family’s far reaching responsibility to the village is intriguing. There are frequent laugh-out-loud moments, and some of the situations are frivolous, but I reveled in every moment. Of note is a scene involving buttoned up Lady Lavenia unencumbered by Vicodin.
I think Kate and I could be good friends. She is intelligent, inquisitive, and pragmatic, all of which make her a fine amateur sleuth. I do feel like she needs a sidekick, though, to help her in her investigations. I realize she has her mother and DI Shawn Cooper, but Iris is far too unreliable. The supporting cast of characters is charming, every one of them quirky, and even those who are unpleasant are still likable. I especially enjoy young Master Harry, Lord and Lady Honeychurch’s son. His enthusiasm and imagination, combined with his innate sense of aristocratic entitlement, makes him quite endearing. Muriel is the quintessential nosy gossip, and it is unfortunate that she is one of the victims. I confess that I do not care for Iris. Lying comes far too easy to her, and she makes poor choices.
Hannah Dennison has created an enchanting world in the Honeychurch Estate and adjacent tiny Devonshire village. The historically rich setting is a nice foil for the contemporary narrative, and the wacky characters are engaging. I look forward to reading many further adventures featuring Kate and company. I highly recommend this complexly plotted and well written lighthearted mystery to Anglophiles and any cozy fan.
I received and ARC of this title from the publisher and voluntarily shared my unbiased opinions here.