I was pleased to be offered this boxed set, as it contains two books I have already read and enjoyed very much, and more in the same vein seemed likely to be a good thing. So far, it is. The books are by no means all the same (how could they be?) so I will offer comments on them individually below. The project as a whole is a pleasing one: books that address the problems of flawed people trying to do right in difficult circumstances. (One might argue that even some 'grimdark' fantasy tries to do that, albeit in more extreme cases, but there is only so much negativity one should imbibe at any one time, and I just finished the superb Broken Empire sequence, so I was due some sweetness and light!) (Also, I am pleased to be able to recommend most of these to my 11 and 14 year olds!)
The premise of "The King's Sword" is common enough: a disinherited prince, trying to regain his throne. The twist is that it is told from the point of view of the soldier who comes across him face down in the snow, who must decide if said prince is worth helping or not. The situations that follow allow for serious consideration of what is needed in a good ruler. Just for a change, it turns out that excellence as a warrior is not on the list. Good manners apparently is, though; a judgement with which any modern monarch would surely agree.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and heartily recommend it. The writing is good, the characters engaging, and the plotting is exciting overall (though for myself I thought the resolution a bit sudden). There are two more books in the series, which flesh out the characters further, and are equally enjoyable.
"The Emporer's Edge" is a really fun read, both for the characters and the situations. The world is steampunk but not Victorian (just for a change). The characters are highly entertaining: slightly OCD ex-enforcer (female, probably attractive but not about to admit it, creatively competent in a pinch), a scarily good assassin (called Sicarius; but there doesn't appear to be a religious reason for his profession, unlike the original sicarii); a male escort of noble origin; a librarian; and a thief. Oh, and an idealistic, in-over-his head Emperor. Bandinage ensues. And escapades. All good, reasonably well-written fun. I will investigate the rest of this series.
"The Last Mage Guardian" is another steampunk world, plus magic. The situation is quasi-1920's -- one war recently finished, another potentially brewing amid racial tensions and economic crises. Mores are firmly Victorian; women are to be supported and not, under any circumstances, to do magic. Our main character, of course, is, it gradually appears, a very powerful mage indeed. This scenario did not play out quite as I expected it to, much to the author's credit. The mage neither pretends to be male, nor hides behind a male assistant (at least, not as a rule). I really enjoyed the story; the plot was twisty and inventive, the characters were engaging and believable (mostly), and the writing was good. The game of "guess which European country this is" was entertaining; I got Bretagne wrong for about 2/3 of the book. Again, I will look out for other books by this author.
"Lhind the Thief": I really, really enjoyed this book. The main two characters are well-developed; perhaps the others are less so, but they are still engaging. Still, Lhind herself is worth the price of admission. The adventures (or perhaps escapades is a better word) are exhilarating, the world is intriguing and original, and the writing is sure and accomplished. I particularly liked that Lhind is tempted by rather attractive evil (actions and characters), and sometimes succombs and has to find her way back.
"Six Celestial Swords", in contrast with the above books, is a terrific book that seriously needs a good editor. The plot is great, the world is intriguing, the pace of revelations is good, the characters are appealing (though frankly, the length of the main character's hair is a little beyond a joke. I had long hair for years, and the trouble loose hair that long would cause on an extended wilderness trip doesn't bear thinking about.). But, and it is a strong but, the writing is frustratingly erratic. Some of it is beautiful. Some of it sounds like it's been translated from a different language (I did occasionally wonder if this was deliberate). Idioms are misused, the wrong form of words is often chosen (one can "stand in amazement", or "stand amazed", but to "stand in amaze" conjures up hedges ...). There is also a tendency to repeat information, and several times characters come to the same personal realisation more than once. All of these things should be caught and corrected by a good editor.
I am not myself opposed to creative use of language; I revelled in Howard Pyle as a child, I adore Tolkein, and I view the vocabulary of the Thomas Covenant series as a blessing rather than a curse. But creativity must be tempered with clarity, and too often I had to go back and puzzle out what was meant from what had been said, or mentally substitute the word that seemed better to fit the context. (So many words in English are only nearly synonyms!) So, a qualified recommendation, though I want to know what happens badly enough that I will read the rest of the series.
"Hope and the Patient Man" seemed a quirky inclusion for this series. It is definitely more of a romance than any other sort of story. But it is an endearing romance, entertainingly told, and the obstacles the lovers must overcome (curses and psychological blocks) are original. And the world is enchanting. I probably will look out other books from this author. This one was just fun.
"The Keeper and the Rulership" is the first of the books in this set that has not appealed to me. That is not to say it will not appeal to others; it just wasn't a world I wanted to spend time in, myself.
Another book that is not so much to my taste was "Into the Storm". It is well written, and the world and it's magic are novel (wizards are required to work entirely through familiars), but the story felt a bit manipulative to me. Too much of a tear-jerker. Mind, I don't like Romeo and Juliet either. This is a prequel to a series; perhaps it is as it is to give a backstory of sufficient depth to later developments.
So, of eight books read so far, I really enjoyed six. Four to go, but six good books for the price is still good going, and I've been introduced to at least 4 new authors I will look for in the future.