Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Lost Colony #1

Breaking Ties

Rate this book
Rose Payne is heartbroken when her secret betrothal to a duke's son results in public scandal and her dismissal from her position as a clerk in his noble household. Desperate for work, she signs up for a risky colonial venture and sails for the New World, vowing never again to fall for a wealthy gentleman.

Sailing home after a diplomatic tour in London, Chief Manteo is bewitched by the intelligent, fiery-haired, working class girl and determined to overcome her distrust of men. A titled and powerful man on two continents, he is everything she thinks she isn't looking for. But a man in his position never backs down from a challenge. He contrives a daring plan to win her heart -- a plan he prays will protect her from a conspiracy involving murder, blood money, and a terrifying betrayal aboard their fleet of ships.

BREAKING TIES is based on the story of the Lost Colonists from Roanoke Island. Pure historical fiction with a delightful twist of romance!

482 pages, ebook

First published October 16, 2013

115 people are currently reading
165 people want to read

About the author

Jo Grafford

166 books664 followers
Jo is an Amazon bestselling author of heartwarming cowboy romantic suspense stories, with a few Texas-sized detours into humor.

Join Cuppa Jo Readers at https://www.facebook.com/groups/Cuppa.... Join her newsletter at https://www.JoGrafford.com.

Jo also writes clean western historical romance and cozy mysteries as Jovie Grace.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
114 (63%)
4 stars
48 (26%)
3 stars
15 (8%)
2 stars
2 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
Profile Image for Misty Dietz.
Author 11 books130 followers
December 13, 2013
Wow. I have to say that I've never read a book quite like this in terms of setting and context, but I'm so glad I did. Ms. Grafford certainly has a talent for description that carries you along and makes you feel like you're the one wearing the period clothing, tasting the food, and watching the ship slice through the water. I generally read fast-paced romantic suspense. This is a not that, but it is truly perfect at what it strives to be: an epic drama about a group of people who embody the timeless qualities of humanity: bravery and cowardice, kindness and treachery, hope and disappointment. And of course...romance. :)

There were times I was a bit lost as to who was who because the cast is quite large, but it wasn't a problem in the big picture. I loved Rose and totally rooted for her and the dreamboat Manteo. Oh, he's yummy.

At the end of the story I stayed up way past my bedtime because I couldn't put it down. Grafford tied the romance up neatly at the end with a HEA, which I so much appreciated. And I for one cannot WAIT to read Jane's story!
Profile Image for Sandi Layne.
Author 20 books155 followers
November 13, 2013
I was so excited to get this one on my Kindle! The Roanoke Colony Mystery has always fascinated me and when I saw there was an historical romance book involving it, I was very pleased to purchase it.

Breaking Ties, by Jo Grafford, is written in the first person. For a novel involving mystery and shipboard politics and an inscrutable hero, this is not a bad perspective - it just doesn’t happen to be my favorite.

Still, after a bit of a confusing start (Our Heroine has a bit of a backstory that remains a mystery for a while), I fell right into the ocean and was tense and seasick by turns (In a good way) as Rose, Our Heroine, took on her clerking duties aboard ship.

What? A woman is working in business in the 1580’s? Why yes, yes she is. As unlikely as it might seem to us, Grafford made it work through the good offices of Eleanor Dare (mother of the famous Virginia Dare, who was the first English baby born in the New World) and the bamboozlement of the colony leaders who hired R. Payne on as clerk. She has a head of flaming red hair, outstanding aim when throwing a knife, and a very weak stomach. She attracts attention from some of the men aboard ship.

Including the attention of the Native American (Indian) diplomat: Manteo. Our Hero.

Here is the biggest draw for me. Jo Grafford portrays Manteo as highly intelligent, crafty, and passionate. His regard for Rose is obvious from the start, his pursuit of her daring but not indecent, which was appropriate for the times. I wanted more Manteo pretty much from the get-go.

The book is more than just a romance, however. Grafford posits reasons for the disaster of the Roanoke Colony and brings up the Spanish issue, spies, and the desire for gain that many in England had in terms of New World ventures. Secrets come out about Rose’s brother, about the captain of their ship, and even about Manteo himself.

The hardships of shipboard life are well presented without, pardon the expression, going overboard with them. The needs of the colony once they reach their new home are shared but, again, without too many grisly details. Still, the tension is constant.

About the romance, I have to be cautious. This is a story with a romance, but it really doesn’t feel like “an historical romance” since the love relationship is a side-issue to the story, not part of the main event. Not really. Though we do see how Manteo’s feelings for Rose might certainly influence some of his decisions, they are not necessarily the only reason for his assistance with the colony.

There are some lovely moments like this one:

He scowled. "I did not stop to ponder the matter when you fell overboard."

"And ye regret it now," I said bitterly.

The scowl deepened.

A wave of exhaustion shook me. Manteo muttered an oath and caught me when my knees buckled. He lowered me to the ground. Settling against a tree, he drew Tomas and me against his chest. I sank into the warmth and strength of him. The even cadence of his heartbeat performed instant sorcery on my tired limbs. I tried to keep my eyes open and failed. Perhaps I dreamt his next words.

"Nay. I do not regret it."

I very much wanted to continue the conversation, but already I was drifting into sleep. I turned my face against his chest. He whispered something into my hair, drawing me closer. 'Twas the last thing I remembered.


Now, I have said I like this book, and so I do. But, there were anachronisms within it that completely threw me out of the story. I found that highly distracting. One of the most glaring is this one:

“A nanny, an apothecary's assistant, and a clerk you may be, but Shakespeare himself could not write a script with any more layers of intrigue."

"Alas, there is no curtain and no stage," I murmured. "And we are the players."


Shakespeare, though alive in the 1580’s, did not start producing plays until the 1590’s, so he would hardly have been known as a playwright by all and sundry in the time this novel takes place. Grafford also mentions devices that weren’t invented until the next century, expressions that are not known to have been used in England until the next century or so, and so on.

Overall, though, a gripping read that I recommend to anyone who is interested in the intrigues involved in colony-planting in the New World.
6,156 reviews
December 14, 2013
I really liked this book! I love how the author used one of the greatest mysteries of the colonial times and made into her own story. Great clean romance too. I would recommend this book and I hope to read more by this author.
Profile Image for A. McCarty.
Author 16 books42 followers
November 13, 2014
Very wonderful piece of history brought to life through emotions and amazing characters. This is one book you will want to read!

Imaginative Dreams was given for an honest review
Profile Image for Eileen Dandashi.
542 reviews17 followers
May 5, 2014
About the Story: A cursed island, a chilling conspiracy, and an unforgettable love story. The 115 colonists on Roanoke Island couldn't GPS, Skype or Twitter their ultimate destination back to their families and friends in 16th Century England. But modern laser technology has finally uncovered a clue - hidden beneath a patch on an ancient map at the British museum - that leads us to their whereabouts. Considered "lost" for centuries, these brave pioneers finally reveal the rest of their story in Book One of the Lost Colony Series.

Rose Payne's world is left in tatters after a disastrous betrothal, making her an easy target for recruiters to the Colonies. Using every cent she has, Rose sails for the New World and a fresh start, vowing to never again fall for a wealthy man.

Returning from a diplomatic tour in London, Chief Manteo is bewitched by the fiery-haired ship's clerk and determined to overcome her distrust. He contrives a daring plan to win her heart - one that forces her, honor bound, to serve as a slave to his tribe - a plan he prays will protect her from a chilling conspiracy involving murder, blood money, and a betrayal of their fledgling colony so terrifying it can only be revealed in Breaking Ties.

About the Author: Jo Grafford is an award winning writer and researcher of Colonial American history. Multiple business degrees and a background in finance assisted her in unraveling the mystery of the Lost Colonists on Roanoke Island and the risky investment venture that set the wheels in motion for their disappearance. Jo travels the word with her husband the three children. Her office is located anywhere she opens her laptop.

Excerpt:
Our sails caught the wind. We slowly picked up speed. I tasted the bitter thrill of success as the coastline grew smaller. I was leaving with little more than my integrity and the clothes on my back. Donnen would give our parents my love, and they could continue working on the tenant farm – none the wise about my true reason for leaving. Da would be proud that his only daughter had ventured off to see the world, after of course, he got over his rage for my failure to travel home and bid them farewell in person. Alas, I’d not had the time to pay them one last visit.

I blinked back tears. I would begin a new chapter wherever we landed. It was almost too simple.

My interview had been a hasty event three days earlier. Lady Dare had not batted an eye when I declared my sudden interest in becoming a colonists. Nor had she asked for a letter of reference. The only emotion on her plain features was relief at my willingness to hire on as the ship’s clerk. Apparently the last one had abandoned his post, giving neither advance notice nor an explanation.

My Thoughts: I have just started looking for historical novels with settings during the colonial days of North America. I have not been disappointed in the caliber of writing, historical research that has gone into what I’ve read to date. This particular series I will delightedly follow. I wish we had something like this to read when we were in high school--to read either in English or American History class. If I had I believe I would have been more engaged and eager to learn about the history of the United States. I often hear that we don’t have history. We are too young of a nation. But I certainly disagree. Only now that I’m older I appreciate the events of our history.

Even though a fictitious story, names of colonists who were aboard that fateful ship were characterized by the author and came alive to the reader. Knowing now what I know about what really happened to the lost colonists I’m eager to sit through another reading.

The story and plot were extremely well-written, a page-turner if there ever was one. The pages were full of adventure, love and hate amongst the colonists, romance, suffering and intrigue. Even though the colonists survived crossing the Atlantic through raging storms and depravity, they encountered further grief, hardship and death once landed at Roanoke Island.

The story blended dialog and actual events based on Jo Grafford’s research in an appealing manner. It gave us a very good description of the hardship and terror the colonists dealt with when trying to settle North America. I would not hesitate to recommend this book as well as the series to those who want to understand the colonization of North America, history buffs and anyone else who just loves a good love story mixed with adventure, suspense and intrigue.

Profile Image for Christine Blackthorn.
Author 5 books45 followers
March 10, 2015
In many, many ways I loved this book. It is engaging, the hero fascinating and intelligent, the heroine less cringeworthy than most. Historically, some aspects are very well researched and the fact that it is not just a romance, and never simply sweet, lets the tension rise and keeps the readers attention focused. Definitely a worthwhile read.

The beginning of the story is a little slow, a little involved as we are left to discover the heroine’s backstory and the slowly developing story of the book. The intrigue and conspiracy on board, what it means and the danger it presents - as well as the hero’s attempts to protect our heroine as much as possible within his means. Initially, I was suspicious how a female ships clerk could work in 1580 but it is made to work, with a little literary license. There are some historical missteps which are harder to put aside but the story carries it over those.

What are the best parts of the story? Definitely Manteo, our hero. He is created as a fascinated personality, intelligent, passionate and real. From the moment he appears in the story every other character pales a little and the story acquires a sense of excitement. I loved the fact that there is enough substance to the story for the romance to be both the glue to hold it together and the tempting draw below the storyline.

What did I not like? Well, there is a personal preference to third person, rather than first person, but that consideration did not matter in my judgement of the book. On the other hand, I thought it would be better to have some more depth in the descriptions, a little more draw on the reader to step into the story rather than just read about it.

Altogether a read not to be missed - enjoyable, passionate and engaging. The historical detail is interesting, the events and historical markers exciting enough to keep the attention on the story without loosing the romantic element. The two main characters work well together, create a chemistry that is exciting. The female character pales a little against the strength of the male one but in light of the time and story that is not entirely a bad thing.
Profile Image for Kathy Martin.
4,160 reviews115 followers
February 22, 2014
BREAKING TIES was an interesting historical fiction story that included a bit of romance too. Rose Payne, daughter of a tenant farmer and trained clerk, finds herself on a colonizing voyage to the New World as a way to escape a broken heart. She had different expectations about her romance with a Duke's son than he did. When he offered to set her up as his mistress instead of his wife, she decided to flee the country.

Rose finds herself on her way to Chesapeake Bay with a bunch of Puritans. However, plots at home regarding the Letters of Patent authorizing the colony means that someone is out to sabotage the journey. The journey has problems enough for Rose. Besides dealing with heartbreak and seasickness, she is also accused of witchcraft. When she falls overboard and is rescued by Chief Manteo, her failure to drown confirms her witchcraft in many eyes.

Chief Manteo is traveling back to his home after serving as a diplomat for his people. He is looked upon by most as a savage of little intelligence but it doesn't take Rose long to realize that he is a handsome man who speaks and understands more English than he lets on. He begins to court her but she isn't ready to risk her heart again. And then, when she is, she learns that he already has a wife and wants to make her his second wife which breaks her heart again.

Rose is something of a guy magnet. She also attracts the attention of Christopher Cooper who is the younger son of a Baron and one of the ministers on the voyage. She likes him but is concerned about his place in the conspiracy that is raging.

The book is filled with plots and the harsh brutality of the times. It is also filled with the colonists efforts to survive despite long odds against them. It was an engaging story for those who like their history gritty. It also provides a possible explanation for the disappearance of the Roanoke colony.

Fans of historical romance will enjoy this story.
Profile Image for Rosieposie.
23 reviews
November 27, 2014
I have always loved historical fiction, both in books and film. It is an educational treat whenever I happen upon a book that engrosses me to the point of insomnia. Breaking Ties was such a book. One can appreciate the endless hours of research that the author put towards the writing of Breaking Ties. I myself was newly educated to the character of Manteo and with my own research I was excited that this true historical figures did actually exist. It makes the story so much more exciting to know that there is that connection between fiction and non-fiction and I absolutely loved how the author infused her own story and Rose Payne’s character into it.

I myself don’t care for non-fictional reads, I much prefer an intelligently written story line added to the historical background, complimented with strong characters who persevere and forge ahead despite overwhelming odds. This is such a book. The relationships of the many characters and how they interacted was engaging and the love story between the two main characters showed a sweetness and a bravery that was unheard of at that time. Although they were from two different worlds, they continued a dangerously close friendship that blossomed into a close intimacy, something that ostracized them from many of the passengers on board this dangerous venture.

A thrilling journey awaits them as they set sail to a completely new world and on their way they encounter conspiracies, betrayal, murderous plots, and high adventure.
Don’t miss out on this book if you are a lover of historical fiction, you won’t regret the read. I am now highly anticipating the next novel by Jo Grafford. A perfect novel for the Thanksgiving Holiday!
Profile Image for Candice Carpenter.
30 reviews
January 23, 2015
Breaking Ties is the first romance novel I have read in years and I have to say that I am very glad that I chose it!

Rose Payne, a tenant farmer’s daughter and clerk to a noble family, finds herself in need of a job, an escape and a fresh start when she finds herself fired for her relationship with the Duke’s son. It’s 1587 England so that escape/fresh start comes in form of sailing to the New World with a group of colonists. Before she boards the ship, she is warned by her brother of a potential plot to sabotage the City of Raleigh.

More desperate for the escape than she is falling prey to a conspiracy, she boards the ship anyway. In the months that follow (they are sailing, remember) Rose rides the waves of loneliness, friendship, accusation, trust, betrayal, love and even loss.

On top of various levels of attraction in this story, it is also full of humor, action and lots of suspense. If this is what a “high stakes romance” novel is, I greatly prefer it to anything I have ever read in the genre! With loads of likable (and not so likable) characters, I can see the potential for more stories (that I would be very excited to read)!

The backdrop of the historical setting made the external struggles faced just as interesting as the developing relationships.
Breaking Ties is a great and (in my experience) quick read and I highly recommend joining Rose on her journey across the sea.

I was privileged enough to have Jo Grafford gift me a copy of this novel. So, THANK YOU Jo! I can’t wait to read the next books in the Lost Colony series!

***reviewed for www.wegeekgirls.com
Profile Image for Ally Web.
489 reviews23 followers
February 12, 2015
Rose Payne had been dealt a rather nasty hand. The man she loved was marrying another, and He had planned on making her his mistress! He even went as far as to threaten the well being of her family if she didn't agree to be his courtesan. Rose didn't have much of a choice, Her decision to ship off to the new world goes un-judged. Rose quickly discovers that living on a ship with so many other people has it's own problems. Between Life threatening accusations, petty gossip, work, and a gorgeous Indian Chief, Rose has her hands FULL during her time on The Lyon. When they finally hit land, Rose comes to realize that her problems have only just begun. I feel that reading this book was like watching history come alive. I have read about the complications faced by the first settlers, but I never saw them like this. Jo Grafford made everything realistic. I felt that I could taste, hear, and smell what Rose was experiencing. Breaking Ties is unlike any historical romance I've read. It feels natural, and I have never used that to describe a book before. In my opinion this book has the perfect romance to story ratio. If you love Historical Fiction/Romance, Breaking Ties should be on your 'To-Read' list. 5/5

Favorite Quote:

"You asked if there was an antidote for a broken heart."

"Aye. Does one exist?"

"Yes indeed. Are you familiar with the theory of climbing back on a horse after a tumble?"
Author 31 books498 followers
October 26, 2013
A fantastically crafted tale of romance, intrigue, and adventure... BREAKING TIES captured my fascination from the very first paragraph in the preface. The first book of the Lost Colony Series follows Rose Payne, a clever and capable heroine who joins a group of colonists as the ship's clerk on one of their three ships sailing toward Roanoke Island in the 16th century. In order to survive, Rose must brave starvation, disease, hostile natives and a chilling conspiracy. Above all, she has to overcome her past and learn to place her trust in others once more. From the first moment Manteo, the future chief of a local Native tribe, meets Rose, he strives to be the one to show her how to let go. But in a world where betrayal seizes every opportunity, trust becomes the most precious commodity these colonists have.

All of the characters are based upon actual names taken from the ship's ledgers and they are vividly brought to life with Ms. Grafford's storytelling mastery. The events are depicted with such realism that it really feels like these people existed and didn't simply disappear as history claims. I absolutely adored this story and I can't wait for the other two in the series.
Profile Image for Courtney Tassin.
Author 1 book4 followers
August 31, 2014
The tale of Rose Payne leaving behind everything she knows for the unknown in America was phenomenal! From the first chapter I was hooked and couldn't bear to put the book down. Intrigue, betrayal, and mystery plague the colonists aboard the three ships traveling to their new home. Just when you think you've figured out who is behind the problems another twist in the tale leaves you guessing yet again.

The attraction between Rose and the mysterious Manteo is very captivating! Each interaction between them leaves you wanting to know what will happen next. More than once Manteo comes to help Rose out of the bind she's in and shows her through his action what's in his heart. Though Rose isn't looking for love, it finds her.

I absolutely cannot wait to see what Jo Grafford writes next! I'll be looking for the second book in this series actively! As soon as it's available I'm buying it! This is a fantastic clean romance that was well thought out and written expertly! Jo definitely did her research for this novel.
16 reviews
September 15, 2014
Loved this story, loved the writing! Breaking Ties is a beautiful story full of intrigue and action. It's a compelling plot of adventure and danger with plenty of rock solid romance. The story is told through the eyes of Rose Payne, a young Scottish woman escaping a past while she makes her way to the Americas to help colonise. I loved Rose as soon as I met her, she was drawn well with flesh and bone, a mind of her own, and a bloody strong backbone - my favourite kind of heroine. Her romance and adventure, along with a strong cast of supporting characters made for a real page-turner from start to finish.

I must admit I generally don't read historical novels, but Jo Grafford's beautiful prose and compelling story really opened my mind and thankfully expands my reading choices (I read that 'Trail of Crosses', the second novel in the Lost Colony series, is out now, so I will be reading this too.)
Highly recommended!
Profile Image for C.L. Moore.
Author 17 books11 followers
January 18, 2015
I received an ARC for an honest review of this book.

I was quickly drawn into the life of Rose, and I turned each page in anticipation in seeing the direction her life would take me.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way Jo Grafford writes. Truly an outstanding novel from the first page until the last.
This novel gives us an intimate view into the devastation of Roanoke Island and the possible scenario of what transpired there.
It also shows us the majesty of the Native tribes of that region, along with their struggles as the English settled in a land that they lived.

I can't wait to see where the next book in this series takes me.
A totally enthralling read.
Profile Image for Alyssa White.
529 reviews18 followers
January 24, 2016
This book has officially made it to a very precise list of my all time favorite books. I was thrilled to get this book and see what it was about, colonial times that you don't get much good reading selection. While reading this book I laughed, I cried, I want to fall in love, and I feel in love. By far, one of the best books I have ever read! I cannot wait to start the next one! Breathtaking read!
3 reviews
April 6, 2014
A page turner that fans of historic fiction coupled with romance should read for sure. I, for one, am eagerly awaiting a sequel.
Profile Image for Carol Hilbig.
23 reviews1 follower
November 30, 2014
I'm not usually into historical fiction, but I liked this one. Now I need to read up on Roanoke Island. Thanks Brad and Brent for recommending it!
Profile Image for Philip Newey.
Author 15 books323 followers
November 25, 2013
Breaking Ties is an historical romance set at the end of the sixteenth century. Based around an historical event, the story tells of a group of religious separatists on a voyage to the New World (Chesapeake Bay) to establish a colony. From the little research I did concerning these events it seems that the fate of these early colonists remains largely unknown. Their leader, John White, returned to England for additional supplies. Upon his return to the colony, the colonists had disappeared. The gaps in our historical knowledge of this event has left Grafford space in which to create a fictionalised version of events: a tale of intrigue, betrayal and romance.

At the centre of the story are two main elements. The first is the suspicion that some aboard the ships undertaking the voyage are in the pay of enemies of the separatists, with the mission to sabotage the colony. The second is a romance between one of the colonists, Rose Payne, and a native American travelling with them, Manteo, who serves as ambassador for his people. As far as I can tell, all of the characters in the story are based on real people, although the story itself is fictional. It follows the colonists on board one of the ships, from the moment of sailing, to the moment when the fate of the colony is decided. The story provides a plausible resolution to the mystery.

The story is related from the first person point of view by Rose, a red-haired Scottish lass fleeing England to escape a romance gone bad. She is hired as the ship’s clerk, and is not one of the religious separatists. Getting inside the head of a sixteenth century woman of relatively low socio-economic status is not an easy task. It is easy to slip into a perspective that is too modern. It seemed to me that Grafford pulled this off with a reasonable degree of success. Rose is sufficiently complex, with a chequered past, to be interesting and fairly believable. The other stand-out characters are Agnes Wood, the apothecary, and Jane Mannering, the ship’s teacher. Both are slightly unconventional. Jane is tall and beautiful, and as tough as any of the men. The image that refused to leave my head was that of Geena Davis in the movie Cutthroat Island. Agnes is intelligent, clearly more competent than the drunken doctor on board, and slightly modern in her views. All three represent women who, I think it is fair to say, are somewhat unconventional for the period, but not so much so that they become unbelievable. The men of the story do not fair so well. The governor, John White, appears weak and vacillating. Manteo, the native American, with whom Rose falls in love, is little more than a shirtless body roaming the decks, silent, strong, enigmatic and inscrutable. The only other male character of whom I took any notice was the pastor, Christopher Cooper. He, at least, is a little more complex and interesting. The main villain of the piece, Simon Fernandez the Navigator, who seems to do all he can to sabotage the mission, plays his role largely from the wings.

The author has worked hard to research this piece and, for the most part, has remained true to the period. I had a few historical quibbles: quoting Macbeth before it was written, for example. I detected a few modernisms in the characters’ speech patterns from time to time (eg., ‘Come again’; ‘back on topic’). I don’t believe many of the types of fruit they found on one of the islands belonged there. Experts on this historical period may have found many more discrepancies. All in all, though, I felt the author did a good job of placing the reader in the period, on board that vessel. The story worked reasonably well, particularly in terms of the gradual unfolding of the plot to sabotage the colony. The romance between Rose and Manteo was rather stereotypical, and smacked of nineteen fifties or sixties Hollywood. However, there were enough moments of excitement and adventure along the way to keep me reading and interested. I thought that the final moments of jeopardy were particular well-written and well-constructed. The ending, while predictably Hollywoodian to a large extent, was, nevertheless, reasonably satisfying. I suspect that my quibbles about this and with the character of Manteo are what would make this an enjoyable romance for others.

I cannot complete this review without commenting on one chapter in particular which, I felt, was a standout, but not in a good way. In Chapter 17, I felt that the author’s attention to detail abandoned her. In describing the colonists’ time on this island (I don’t want to give away too much of the plot here) she has them doing things that would not have been possible. For example, where did they suddenly acquire bricks for building a two storey house (in a matter of only a day or two)? Where did they acquire the material for thatching cottages? These and other glaring inconsistencies, as well as some weak plot points, really stood out for me. This chapter could use a major revision.

It is probably fair to say that this book was not exactly my cup of tea. The romance I found stereo-typical. On the other hand, the story of the colonists and the historical setting were interesting. The author had me interested enough to care for these people and their fate, so much so that I would like to know the fate of certain other characters, which remains unresolved at the end of the book. There are enough loose ends to indicate the sequel(s) in the offing; but not too many to leave the reader feeling unsatisfied. I think this is a good book, without quite being very good, and I therefore give it three stars.
Profile Image for John.
134 reviews24 followers
October 10, 2014
A cursed island, a chilling conspiracy, an unforgettable love story...

Rose Payne’s world is left in tatters after a disastrous betrothal, making her an easy target for recruiters to the Colonies. Using every cent she has, Rose sails for the New World and a fresh start, vowing to never again fall for a wealthy man.

Returning from a diplomatic tour in London, Chief Manteo is bewitched by the fiery-haired ship’s clerk and determined to overcome her distrust. He contrives a daring plan to win her heart – one that forces her, honor bound, to serve as a slave to his tribe – a plan he prays will protect her from a chilling conspiracy involving murder, blood money, and a betrayal of their fledgling colony so terrifying it can only be revealed in Breaking Ties.

A historical romance series based upon the Lost Colony of Roanoke, Breaking Ties has a lot to offer.

The heroine, Rose Payne, eager to start a new life, manages to secure a place as a colonist to Roanoke. From the outset she’s drawn to Chief Manteo, who’ serving as a diplomat for his people. During the journey he manages to save Rose from drowning and she pledges her life to him in gratitude (can ya see it coming?). Rose felt MarySue-ish and uneven to me, constantly shifting from naïve to sagacious, depending upon the situation. Manteo also felt more like a construct or a plot device than a character, but at least the author made him fully aware of what England was planning and strove to have him prevent it.

Characters were layered and diverse, which was a pleasant surprise. With the very real threat of sabotage looming over the colonists in addition to their struggle to survive, alliances and adversaries emerge, forcing everyone to choose a side as the conspiracy to destroy them slowly reveals itself.

It was slow to get going at first, filled with lots of digressions and inaccuracies- like how’d they get bricks to build stuff so fast?- but ended up keeping my attention. Some of the plot hooks were pretty obvious and could stand some paring down on a lot of the minutiae that pads the pages, but it’s an engaging, solid read, if a little melodramatic.
Profile Image for Amy.
849 reviews2 followers
December 11, 2013
Read my review over at Only Trick in the Book!
http://onlytrickinthebook.blogspot.co...
I really enjoyed this read covering the story of the voyage over to the New World. Rose is escaping the strict roles of a working woman in England who has few options. I liked her spirit and her unwillingness to settle for things just because she was a woman and that was the way it was supposed to be. She falls quickly for Maneto on the boat, especially after he saves her life. But other than a chaste kiss or two, most of their relationship is through glances and secret conversations. I would have liked to see more develop there.

I think the strength of this book is in the friendships Rose develops with fellow travelers Agnes and Jane, who are also pretty strong women for the time. Their adventures together were the best parts of the book. The mystery behind the conspiracy that seems to follow the boat was hard for me to keep track of and didn't really intrigue me as a reader. Once they got to the island of Roanoke, I really liked the story behind why their colony "disappears". Of course in the end Rose and Manteo end up together and I really liked the description of their wedding ceremony and why they loved each other.

I don't know if this is going to be a series but I would like to see where the story could take Agnes and Jane. If you are interested in historical fiction, with a side of Romance, this might be the book for you.
Profile Image for Theresa Needham fehse.
447 reviews16 followers
March 18, 2015
Free book for honest review. juliesbookreview.blogspot.com

This book provided a sweet escape on a very dull winter afternoon. The book begins with the introduction of Rose Payne, a clerk who is desperate to leave England after finding that a rich lord, with whom she'd fallen in love, had no interest in marrying her. Rose takes a job on a ship headed for America,

During the voyage across the ocean, Rose grows closer and closer with tall, handsome Manteo, who will one day become chief of the Croatoans. Both are shunned by the ship's Puritan passengers, who believe red-haired Rose is a witch and Manteo is an unintelligent savage.

I absolutely loved this book. For a romance novel that contains no sexual situations, the book was very passionate. I actually did not miss the blatant sex one finds in most romance novels, because reading about the growing feelings between the two main characters was much more entertaining than if they had just had sex multiple times throughout the book.

I'm a great lover of Masterpiece Theater, and this is just the type of novel that they would use to create a movie for their program. I recommend it to anyone who likes classy romance with a historical spin.

Five stars

Siobhan
Profile Image for Mary Myers-Huff Barscz .
201 reviews5 followers
February 17, 2015
I am so happy that I read this book. Being that it is not anywhere near my normal genres it can be tricky to read and really get into a book, but Jo Grafford writes in a way that drew me in and kept me hooked.
This story follows the colonists that are the first to settle in Roanoke, from boarding the ships to sailing and landing.
Rose Payne is the lead female in this book, and she is looking to escape after being hurt by a Duke's son, what better way to escape than to go to the New World? She is a smart and feisty female lead, I like that she was not a simpering fool! Chief Manteo, is a diplomat who was brought to England to learn about the people that want to move to his land with his people. He never thought that the spitfire with red hair would catch his eye, and he intends to catch her heart.
But what will happen when Rose learns of his status in his tribe? She has sworn to never fall in love with a man in power again.
The intrigue and lives of the colonists are well written and you feel like you are sailing to the New World with them.
Profile Image for J.M. Northup.
Author 28 books129 followers
September 11, 2018
Great Historical Fiction

I love history and the mystery of the Roanoke colony. This book did a wonderful job exploring what might've happened while bringing to life a rich tale of love, discovery, suspicion, and betrayal.
The author did an amazing job describing the era. She was very knowledgeable about the ships and sailing, as well as other historical elements. I love that she used the proper verbiage even in the narrative. It really drew you into that time.
Though I enjoyed the characters, my favorite was the spunky Jane. She is a woman ahead of her time. I, also, loved Manteo. His description honors Native American culture while keeping you guessing about what he really thinks and desires.
As a writer and publisher, my leisure reading is extremely limited these days, even though I love reading. BREAKING TIES was worth investing my time and money. Upon finishing, I immediately bought book 2.
I definitely recommend this book to those who love the genres of romance, intrigue, historical, colonial, or adventure.
Profile Image for Linda.
Author 58 books650 followers
December 8, 2021
Breaking Ties is the first book I’ve read by author Jo Grafford. The premise is an intriguing “what if” about the Lost Colony of Roanoke. Five hundred years later, and scholars still disagree about what happened to this small group of “separatists” from England, so I enjoyed seeing how this author handled the mystery. The book is long (510 pages) and could probably be cut by 75 pages or more. Listed as a romance, the story felt more like women’s fiction. The romance portion of the book is sweet, but few people on the ship seem bothered that feelings are developing between a white woman and a Native American man, and that seemed a bit unrealistic to me. The cadence of the dialogue effectively evokes the era, and I learned a lot about the time period. I liked Rose and especially enjoyed the friendship she develops with Agnes and Jane (two delightful secondary characters). There are moments of violence and some graphic descriptions throughout the story (sailors being flogged, medical procedures/situations, battle scenes, etc.).
455 reviews2 followers
April 14, 2020
This was an extremely interesting book by Jo Grafford. It's one of those books you don't want to put down. The characters are wonderful and even though friends, they are all totally different in abilities. But each is willing to help the other on the journey across the ocean to their new home. I have lived my whole life in Virginia and was taught all about the Lost Colony in school but this is a different story all together. There are 4 books in this collection and I am off to the second one to see what Jo Grafford has in store for the Lost Colony.
Profile Image for Mary.
942 reviews9 followers
November 26, 2021
Leaving England

Rose wanted to leave England because she felt hurt and humiliated by the rejection of her high born love. Her adventures on board the ship and after landing are very exciting, adventurous, frightening. Maneo was an Indian chief who had been to England learning their ways but most thought him dumb and slow only Rose saw the love and intelligence in his eyes. This historical romance pulls one in very quickly.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.