Informative and clearly written, as well as somewhat gossipy (in an arch way that tries to pretend it's above that), and dated. I either met the author once or had a friend who knew him in oxford in the late 1980s, thus the curiosity when I saw this title appear many years ago in a used book shop. Finally decided to pick it up. Reminds me of many things I dislike about the RC church. But none of that should stop others from reading it.
Peter Hebblethwaite’s The Year of the Three Popes is one of those history books that pulls you in right away, even if you don’t think you’re all that interested in church history. 1978 was a remarkable year for the Catholic Church, with the deaths of two popes and the surprising election of a third—John Paul II. Hebblethwaite does a fantastic job of telling the story like it’s unfolding in real time, full of drama, uncertainty, and hope.
What I liked most is how readable it is. A lot of religious history books can feel heavy or overly academic, but this one flows almost like a political thriller. You get a real sense of the personalities involved—John Paul I with his warmth and humility, and John Paul II stepping onto the world stage with energy and vision. Hebblethwaite doesn’t just give you facts; he helps you understand why these moments mattered so much, not just for Catholics but for the world.
Even if you’re not particularly religious, the book gives fascinating insight into leadership, faith, and how quickly history can change. It’s both educational and surprisingly gripping—a rare combination. Definitely worth picking up if you enjoy modern history told with style.
Still an important read and look back into a tumultuous and really unbelievable period in the Catholic Church. Pope Paul's death was sad but expected, and the shock of his successor's quick election and unique name, John Paul I, was overwhelmed some thirty three days later just as we were becoming accustomed to the Pope with a smile. From that upset came the Pope from the East, the Polish Pope, and not an Italian name! Pope John Paul II. The Church, the world, and communism were never the same again.