2.5 stars; I promise I was trying to be nice
So, here's the thing. I'm conflicted about this one because on the one hand I did read this in its entirety and I was somewhat invested to see how this was going to play out. But on the other... Mama, it's like this man has never heard of an editor.
Nice things first because I'm always a b*tch when it comes to Mr Heart. The alphas were distinct. I could tell them all a part from each other and they had their own personalities. Even the twins. Sam, on the other hand, didn't have a quiver of a personality. I can't even call him a caricature or a cardboard cutout because we learned nothing about him outside of he's a omega and therefore completely ruled and controlled by his hormones and need to obey his alphas. He had no wants, no dreams, and no goals. He was a name on a page and nothing more. I'm supposed to be nice, oh my god!
What are some other nice things I can say? Um, the smut was hot for the most part. The chair one was weird but that's me my own issues. Some of it did feel rushed but I'm guessing that's because there was so much smut that if you gave all the scenes time to marinate, they would probably get pretty tedious. Plus there were some cases where it was obvious the kink was the focal point, not the smut.
I also like how this wasn't too long and the pacing was pretty good. Just wish at some point Sam could have been given a personality trait but whatever. Again, I swear this is me being nice!
I will say that while all the alphas are very distinct from each other, I think that had this just been Jack, Max, and David it would have been better. I get why they were all there and it did work and come together but I think three alphas is his sweet spot. He ends up doing it in later books and it works really well. See, I told you I could be nice.
Now for some not so nice things. I try really hard not to talk about things like spelling and grammar because it's indie. Even The most seasoned editors doing multiple passes are going to miss things, it's inevitable. That being said, this was literally hard to read. There were times where the names kept getting mixed up so I literally didn't know who was doing what or who was talking. I read this to turn my brain off, not to play Clue meets Guess Who. There were also factoids and character details that were completely dropped for seeming no reason. Like the fact that Jack no longer plays football and was sad about it. But then all of a sudden is going to practice, on a Saturday no less. Gurl, you're in high school, calm down. Or how David's entire personality changed in the end. Or whatever those last two chapters were. Seriously, what was that? Was that supposed to be something and then it just wasn't so it was labeled epilogue. Because an epilogue I promise you that was not.
Do you see why conflicted? Because I know this man gets better at writing. And I know he read reviews and took the things that people really liked and just ran with it and made it something really good. I know because I've read those books and I really enjoyed them. This is a stepping stone to him becoming a better writer so I can excuse a lot when it comes to the setting and descriptions or lack there of I should say. What's hard to overlook is how horrifically edited this is because it genuinely made the book hard to read. For that, it's 2.5 stars. But I was really mean so I round it up. It's the nicest thing I can do.