(what follows are some general thoughts (from my first read-through in 2016, though after a second reading, I think my points are still valid) on what I liked and what frustrated me about this book, some is mildly spoilerish, but I don't really bother with a plot synopsis; after all this is book 11 in the series, a plot synopsis would take forever!)
100ish pages in when I realized that he was really going to do it, I swore I'd give this book 3 stars out of rage, but here we are, and I gave it 4 stars. Why? I didn't want to at first, Mr. Anderson pulled a really cheap (and predictable) melodramatic plot device that he'd actually already used once, many books ago. I actually begged him not to do it in my review of the previous book because I saw it coming a mile away and didn't like the idea. He did it anyway, and it was awful. In fact, a lot of awful things happen in this book, the allies are clearly on the defensive in the West. The U.S.S. Walker is out of the fight (and Captain Reddy is almost non-involved in the story, weird as that seems considering his main character status in basically every book in the series to date), too damaged to do more than putter around the harbor in Madagascar to avoid damage during the nightly Grik air raids. The Japanese and Grik have excellent intelligence (thanks to the perfidious League of Tripoli, playing its Machiavellian games from the shadows) on what the Allies are up to, and have laid some nasty traps to upend the entire campaign in the west, and the Allies suffer some brutal losses as a result. Yet, while all of this is really harsh; apart from the one thing, it doesn't feel unreasonable, it feels like war, brutal unpredictable and tragic, and it all underscores the sad tragedy of the Allies impromptu seizure of Madagascar two books ago, an action taken for emotional rather than practical strategic reasons which has tied the Allies into a campaign that they really REALLY weren't ready to mount. Still, bad as things might seem in this book, the fact that the Allies continue to adapt to this situation and are moving forward towards what feels like a final confrontation with the Grik and Japanese (and with the Dominion, too) means that it isn't as bleak as you might fear. Likewise, there's some good things to balance out all the doom and gloom: Halik has finally had it with the Grik way and is doing something about it, we get some info on the "Other Americans" (a plot thread that seems to have been dangling forever), and Silva and Chack go on a safari and make interesting new friends: good stuff! The eastern front is basically a non-element in this book (even more so than in the previous book), mostly because I think Anderson has already decided that the Dominion is finished and is just moving pieces around for the final showdown. Apart from some chapters dealing with the search for the "Other Americans," I think there might've been two chapters total about the eastern front, and that's probably too generous on my part. I was really beginning to fear that this series was starting to falter after the rather frustrating previous book, but while I may have disagreed sharply with Mr. Anderson on the one plot point (it's SO cheap!) and am mildly annoyed by how the Grik and Japanese don't seem to have any limit to their resource base (especially compared to the much more technically sophisticated Allies, Kurokawa's small group of Japanese churns out insane amounts of war materiel every book, most of it supposedly hand-crafted), on the whole I actually enjoyed this volume more than its predecessor, and I'm really hopeful some good things are in store in the next volume. I mean, they almost HAVE to get better at this point or I don't see how the allies can hope to win. Sadly, it'll be another year before I get to find out...