I really enjoyed this, and would give it a B+, so 4 1/2 stars here. While it took place in a small town, it was nothing like so many of the "small town filled with meddlers" romances I've read before. The heroine, Julia, is a quirky child genius raised by strict parents focused entirely on her success. To break free of the mold after he parents died unexpectedly, Julia -- a neurosurgeon -- signed up for the military and is now a medical doctor. She's moved to a small town to be near her only living relative, Aunt Freckles (I know, stupid name), who would definitely be annoying if she appeared more in the book.
Julia hires a contractor --Kane -- at her aunt's recommendation to fix up the ramshackle home she bought. Turns out Kane is actually a former star pitcher, but Julia has no idea. I like how these two loners come to be friends and eventually lovers. I also appreciate that the big misunderstanding (that we know is going to come all along) plays out very quickly and doesn't cause a big breakup.
About the only thing that kept this from being a DIK for me is I found the heroine's inability to use her smart phone (and pretty much any other technical device) overplayed. That being said, I'm definitely going to look for more of the author's backlist.