Everything was cliché: she has a rich family that doesn’t appreciate her, the grandma is tough and she automatically approves of the ‘boyfriend’ even though she never has before, the son is the spitting image of the father, they have to wrestle in the mud to be close to each other upon meeting, he’s instantly turned on by her to the point of being unbearable, she’s amazing at foreplay even though she’s never done anything before, THEIR BEDROOM WINDOWS ARE LITERALLY LESS THAN TWO FEET APART FROM EACH OTHER – how convenient, she has a confrontation with an old ex of his, he gets jealous about an old ex of hers, all the men who are not taken are deemed perverted assholes, all the girls but Haley are bitchy.
He’s forced to use her shower, even though he lives next door, because they are trapped by bees – really? They surrounded the ENTIRE house? – and so he is forced to interact with each other where they discover they are not as bad as they thought they were and they go on to have the best friendship in the world. All so terrible.
Haley was a total Mary-Sue. She’s a 29 year old virgin who has had, by what the book implies, literally hundreds of men trying to ask her out in her lifetime. I doubt not one of those men was good enough for Haley, the perfect prize. She’s apparently stunning, sexy, intelligent, sports-savvy, quirky, and humble. She’s every perfect characteristic packaged into one beautiful, lovely woman. Her only fault isn’t even about her, it’s the fact that she has a rich snobby family that doesn’t appreciate her. She’s made to seem like she was dealt with a hard life but she prospered despite her neglected childhood. She even refuses to receive help from people just because she needs to do things on her own. I mean, I understand wanting to do things on your own, but to literally pitch a fit because someone lied about how much a cabin they’re renting out for you cost? “Oh, no, she spent way over the $1000 limit I gave her! How dare she?”
I hate this idea that a girl will only have sex with her one true love and that the man-whore will only settle for the innocent girl. Men are wild you can’t blame them for having sex with every model-like girl they meet and since girls are whores if they sleep with more than one guy then she needs to preserve her innocence in order to satisfy that one man. If you want to save yourself for marriage, fine by me whatever, but when they portray Haley as this completely innocent, good-natured girl and then couple that with her being a virgin, what does that really say?
Jason is very immature, I find it hard to believe that he would ever be a good teacher, I’m surprised he hasn’t gotten fired. The food stuff was kind of entertaining in the beginning, but as soon as it was established that it was his thing it got annoying. He acts like a two year old yelling, “Mine!” and nearly crying whenever anyone goes near his precious brownies. Seriously?
Even more so with the innocence and Mary-Sue stuff, Haley apparently doesn’t know that she’s beautiful and she’s unaware of all the attention she gets from guys. She’s so innocent she doesn’t even notice when men flirt with her. For a 29 year old, she seems pretty naïve. Also, Jason claiming to be a playboy and asserting over and over again the fact that he doesn’t let women sleep in his bed or cuddle with him? It was obvious they only put all that in there just to let Haley defy all of it and show that she was special! They don’t even really know each other and after claiming that she hated him for five years, they just go ahead and do it anyway! What kind of development is this? For people who were so adamant in their beliefs that they let them define them, they sure do break their own rules pretty quickly.
I didn’t understand the whole ‘little grasshopper’ stuff. I get that he thinks it’s because he’s teaching her stuff, but what did he really do? All he did was invite her to a party where she branched out on her own. He left her alone for most of the time and it was only when he decided subconsciously that he wanted to sleep with her that he made himself her ‘coach’. She decided on her own to become less shy and he didn’t do anything regarding that.
This idea that they’re such special soul-mates and whatever that they can’t even sleep if they’re not together???? Are you kidding me?? She literally says she hasn’t slept in five days because she needs Jason there with her. Can anyone, in real life, tell me if this has ever happened to you? I understand a day or two of having difficulty falling asleep because you’re sad about them, but to go DAYS without sleep because of it is just ridiculous. Going along with that, can you imagine if you moved houses and changed your workplace every time you broke up with a guy who lives/works nearby? Ridiculous. The entire ending was pretty dumb. It was just a bunch of groveling, stubbornness, and playing cat and mouse. They just went back and forth with their feelings and it got very annoying very fast.
1/10 would not recommend.