What do you think?
Rate this book
Uncommon Magic #2
A Little Taste of Poison
Twelve-year-old Isaveth tries to take down the man who framed her father for murder in this lively follow-up to A Pocket Full of Murder, which Kirkus Reviews called thoroughly entertaining.
The city of Tarreton is powered by magic, from simple tablets that light lamps to advanced Sagery that can murder a man from afar. Isaveth has a talent for spell-making, but as a girl from a poor neighborhood she never dreamed she could study at the most exclusive magical school in the city. So when she s offered a chance to attend, she eagerly accepts.
The school is wonderful, but old and new enemies confront Isaveth at every turn, and she begins to suspect her scholarship might be more a trap than a gift. Even her secret meetings with Esmond, her best friend and partner in crime-solving, prove risky especially once he hatches a plan to sneak her into the biggest society event of the season. It s their last chance to catch the corrupt politician who once framed her father for murder. How can Isaveth refuse?"
The city of Tarreton is powered by magic, from simple tablets that light lamps to advanced Sagery that can murder a man from afar. Isaveth has a talent for spell-making, but as a girl from a poor neighborhood she never dreamed she could study at the most exclusive magical school in the city. So when she s offered a chance to attend, she eagerly accepts.
The school is wonderful, but old and new enemies confront Isaveth at every turn, and she begins to suspect her scholarship might be more a trap than a gift. Even her secret meetings with Esmond, her best friend and partner in crime-solving, prove risky especially once he hatches a plan to sneak her into the biggest society event of the season. It s their last chance to catch the corrupt politician who once framed her father for murder. How can Isaveth refuse?"
384 pages, Paperback
First published September 27, 2016
24 people are currently reading
1159 people want to read
About the author
R.J. Anderson
18 books1,475 followersR.J. (Rebecca) Anderson was born in Uganda, raised in Ontario, and has spent much of her life dreaming of other worlds entirely. She is the author of ten traditionally published fantasy/SF books for children and teens, including the UK-bestselling faery romance KNIFE. Her latest published book is TORCH (Book 3 of the Flight and Flame trilogy, which began with SWIFT and NOMAD).
* * * REVIEW POLICY * * *
I review books that I enjoyed reading and think other readers may enjoy as well, but that doesn't mean I agree with or endorse those books in every respect. If you're concerned about content, please check out other reviewers or sites that provide detailed warnings.
I'm no longer giving star ratings as I don't find them nuanced enough, but for books I've already rated, see below:
5 stars: I loved this book so much that I expect to read it again and again -- I reserve this rating for beloved classics and books that knocked my socks off.
4 stars: I really enjoyed the book and/or thought it was excellently done -- there is a good possibility that I'll re-read it.
3 stars: I enjoyed the book and thought it was well done. Should not be taken as belittling the book or its author -- it really does mean "I liked it".
2 stars: I didn't connect to this book as I'd hoped. This category includes books by authors whose other works I truly love, so it's not a dealbreaker. Just found this particular book wasn't for me.
1 star/DNF: Definitely not for me. But I won't be reviewing it because I choose to focus on books I enjoy.
* * * REVIEW POLICY * * *
I review books that I enjoyed reading and think other readers may enjoy as well, but that doesn't mean I agree with or endorse those books in every respect. If you're concerned about content, please check out other reviewers or sites that provide detailed warnings.
I'm no longer giving star ratings as I don't find them nuanced enough, but for books I've already rated, see below:
5 stars: I loved this book so much that I expect to read it again and again -- I reserve this rating for beloved classics and books that knocked my socks off.
4 stars: I really enjoyed the book and/or thought it was excellently done -- there is a good possibility that I'll re-read it.
3 stars: I enjoyed the book and thought it was well done. Should not be taken as belittling the book or its author -- it really does mean "I liked it".
2 stars: I didn't connect to this book as I'd hoped. This category includes books by authors whose other works I truly love, so it's not a dealbreaker. Just found this particular book wasn't for me.
1 star/DNF: Definitely not for me. But I won't be reviewing it because I choose to focus on books I enjoy.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews
July 9, 2017
Edit: 9th of July 2017 UPDATE!
I loved this book more so the second time reading it! Isaveth and Esmond's friendship was such a joy to read about. I still felt he thrill of discovering who did what, even though I knew what would happen - and to me, that is a sign of an excellent story. This book will always be special to me, and I hope R.J Anderson writes more books based on these two characters.
Eryx didn’t turn to watch her go. His gaze was on Esmond, dark with reproach. “This is unacceptable. Apologize to our guests at once.”
“Why?” asked Esmond. “I haven’t said a thing that isn’t true. And it would be a shame to stop before the exciting bit.” He straightened up to his full height. “There’s a kidnapper, an extortioner, and at least two murderers in this room, and I’m not leaving until everyone knows who they are.”
You go Esmond, show everyone who's boss.
R.j anderson's best book yet.
I can't gush over this book enough! All I'll say for now is: there better be another one! I don't want to leave Vettie and Quiz's (I still call him that instead of Esmond) world just yet!
Their relationship is adorable, and I ship them so hard, my ship will cause a tsunami.
I won't say too much because, spoilers! But I will express my happiness that this WONT BE THE LAST BOOK!!!! YESSSSSSS. I loved the epilogue!!!
Okay, no more gushing. Ahhhsmfdjvskdvsdjnvwkhdnkwjdnvou who am I kidding, I can barely form a coherent sentence right, so I'll try again later.
I loved this book more so the second time reading it! Isaveth and Esmond's friendship was such a joy to read about. I still felt he thrill of discovering who did what, even though I knew what would happen - and to me, that is a sign of an excellent story. This book will always be special to me, and I hope R.J Anderson writes more books based on these two characters.
Eryx didn’t turn to watch her go. His gaze was on Esmond, dark with reproach. “This is unacceptable. Apologize to our guests at once.”
“Why?” asked Esmond. “I haven’t said a thing that isn’t true. And it would be a shame to stop before the exciting bit.” He straightened up to his full height. “There’s a kidnapper, an extortioner, and at least two murderers in this room, and I’m not leaving until everyone knows who they are.”
You go Esmond, show everyone who's boss.
R.j anderson's best book yet.
I can't gush over this book enough! All I'll say for now is: there better be another one! I don't want to leave Vettie and Quiz's (I still call him that instead of Esmond) world just yet!
Their relationship is adorable, and I ship them so hard, my ship will cause a tsunami.
I won't say too much because, spoilers! But I will express my happiness that this WONT BE THE LAST BOOK!!!! YESSSSSSS. I loved the epilogue!!!
Okay, no more gushing. Ahhhsmfdjvskdvsdjnvwkhdnkwjdnvou who am I kidding, I can barely form a coherent sentence right, so I'll try again later.
November 30, 2025
3 stars ⭐️ Mainstream/Secular Fiction - Middle-Grade Historical Fantasy
**This review has spoilers for the first book and it’s ending**
Well, well, well. That ending was something else and while at first I was satisfied, I think I would have preferred a little more about that sudden epilogue.
Overall I have mixed feelings on this duology, so let’s listen out some pros and cons:
Con- It’s definitely not a light, fluffy middle-grade read. This could also be a positive in some ways, but it’s one I would hesitate to recommend to an actual middle-grade aged reader because the villains are true villains in this series and willing to harm and even threat to kill our main characters who are only 12-14.
Pro- I really like the setting of this world and different elements that make it unique. The magic system is like baking or science so it makes sense and is easy to follow.
Con- I didn’t love the bit of romance in a middle-grade book. They are 13/14 in this book which is on the borderline for me with a kiss (crushes I understand, but I don’t think they should be kissing that young. I’m old, I know.)
Pro- I was suspicious of a new character the entire book but it turned out okay! Yay! I was very relieved about that. 😅
Con- I found the stuff with Esmond's family to be sad. It added a heaviness to the story with the mistreatment, lack of caring, and verbal abuse he faces from them.
Pro- the ending with finally having justice! (Which was my biggest complaint with the first book)
So, it was a mixed bag in terms of my thoughts, haha. I would personally suggest this book for ages 10/11+ but only that young if the reader is *not* sensitive and magic is okay. As a note, this book was much more magic heavy than the first book in the series.
Main Content-
Magic-
In this world, there’s two different types of magic: Common magic (that commoners are able to do/afford to do) and Sage magic (which only nobles can do/afford to do). Isaveth makes magic on page often, but it’s similar to baking (called “spell-baking”) with using flour, eggs, and milk and also “binding powder” and “magewort”; They are called “spells” and Isaveth follows the recipe from “The Common Book of Magic”; When baked correctly, they become “spell-tablets” and can be broken to release heat, light, cool air, to wash someone’s hands without water, record a conversation, or find something/someone like an AirTag; We see many scenes of her making spells from Common magic (most like baking with common ingredients like flour and milk) and also learn Sage magic (which is more like jewelry making with precious metals and gemstones); Making charms through Sage magic shows off your status because they usually only work for their creator; When using a charm, Isaveth breaks it by stepping on it too hard and it launches her into the ceiling where she passes out; Others can “charm-swear” a promise which will alert the other person if the swearer has broken their promise (these usually only last six months or until someone’s death, whichever comes first).
All about & many mentions of magic, spells, charms, making both, & magical items; A few mentions of luck; A couple mentions of a claim to make an antidote to curses (which Isaveth notes that nobody really believes in those anymore).
Spiritual-
A few prayers to the All-One (including Isaveth saying one out loud and Esmond commenting about not knowing it was that easy to pray like you’re “just talking” and that his family never went to temple much); Going to the Temple (where Isaveth and the others sing songs of praise to the All-One and gave thanks for the wisdom of Moshiel).
Isaveth’s family are “Moshite” (which is implied to be both an ethnic group and a religion) and they show their faith by praying to the “All-One”, going to the Temple (shown on-page), and wearing a prayer veil at different times; Thanks to events in the first book, Isaveth has learned that it can be worse to lie about her faith than to keep the truth, so she is honest when asked about being Moshite; Isaveth’s older sister always wears her prayer scarf, but Isaveth only wears it at the temple or when praying because that was “what the scarf was for” and “why should she make it easier for people to despise her?”.
When making a Sage charm, it’s expected to invoke the Sage that first made the charm, but because Isaveth is Moshite, it unsettles her to “call on a long-dead scholar of magic for magic, as though he or she were the All-One” because that is blasphemy for a Moshite to do; Because of this, she does not say the scholar’s name, but later Esmond does when using a charm; A friend tells Isaveth that it’s only an old superstition and shouldn’t matter for her to use it, which disappoints Isaveth that her friend doesn’t understand and says she can’t do that; Someone later says that it’s disrespectful to not invoke the Sages as it’s “an important part” of the magical heritage (Isaveth later argues that she does respect the Sages, but that doesn’t mean she has to worship them); Moshiel forbade his followers from swearing oaths or loyalty to anyone but the All-One.
Isaveth and other Moshites face prejudice for their religion & many others believe them to be “worthless troublemakers”; One politician wants to punish all Moshites, refuse them government assistance, & encourage others to shun them; A boy at school taunts Isaveth with calling her “Mishmosh” and “Mushpot”.
Mentions of prayers & praying (to the All-One); Mentions of churches/temples & going to the temple; A couple mentions of “Moshiel” who is the guide for the Moshites in the first book; A couple mentions of when Isaveth and her sister lied about being Moshite; A couple mentions of someone being a Moshite in “private” only; A couple mentions of the blessing candles; A mention of someone soon facing the All-One’s justice (in death); A mention of Esmond calling religious studies “dull”.
Esmond calls his brother a “silver-tongued demon”.
Language/Attitudes-
Language: nothing stronger than stupid and idiot; A few mentions of curses said, not written (including by Esmond); “Maggots” is used as an exclamation; Sages are mentioned in exclamations as well with phrases like “Great Sages!”, “What in the name of the Sages”, “Thank the Sages”, and “Sages”.
Eye rolling; Some lies & half-truths; A few lies for safety; A side character tells a half-truth to a teacher; A teacher also comes up with a story (lies) to protect Isaveth but also gives her a punishment when she did something wrong; Isaveth keeps a secret from her family so they do not worry about her, but tells guilt about it and eventually tells them about a hundred pages later (her father isn’t happy to hear what she’s been up to, but knows that she did it for the right reasons and “that’s the main thing”).
Negative/Violence-
Seeing someone beaten, Hearing a gunshot, Seeing the body pushed off a boat (murder), & Grief/guilt over being unable to help the person (technically on-page, up to a few sentences: pg.322-323).
Pain, Passing out, Being threatened with harm and death, Being kidnapped, Tied-up, Trapped in a crate, & Charmed to be still and silent (up to a few sentences); Borrowing something without permission (twice).
Esmond punches another student during a sport game (on purpose because the boy was messing with him).
Isaveth is bullied by other students & we see their their cruel words (name-calling and snide remarks) and actions (protests, writing on her desk and walls, & putting a dead rat in her book bag) on-page.
Isaveth gets tired of being the only student in her classes that knew what it felt like to go hungry, to freeze at night because there wasn’t enough coal, and to have to keep wearing too-small shoes.
Government overreach with a politician wanting to reform the relief/government assistance program by refusing to help those who won’t swear to the government leader (which Moshites will not do and this is a direct attack on them).
Esmond’s family life is rough with his evil brother that everyone admires, a harsh father, and a mother and sister that avoid conflict; This is evident by mentions of when Esmond’s older brother lashed at and damaged Esmond’s eye with his fencing sword after Esmond defied his orders (which the family believes to be a mistake and don’t believe Esmond’s words against his brother), the father lashing out verbally to his wife, threatening each other for the sake of their plans/wants, & the evil brother being a “murdering hypocrite”; *Spoilers* ; *Major Spoilers* .
Esmond’s father gets drunk & has a drinking problem (he is supposed to avoid drinking due to a liver problem, but still sneaks into the alcohol & gets drunk); Esmond hints in a fake letter that he snuck into his father’s alcohol cabinet (which would get him in major trouble if that was true).
Discussions of & Mentions of the murder in the first book (no mentions of how it happened, but about the murdered person, how Isaveth’s father was accused as murderer, and the actual murderer); Mentions of illnesses (including of the liver), a family member dying, deaths, & grief (including Isaveth and her family for her late mother);Mentions of crimes, criminals, prison, arrests, & possible hangings; Mentions of weapons/guns, a gunshot (used to kill someone), & bullets; Mentions of stealing & thieves; Mentions of blackmail & threats; Mentions of fights, fighting, injuries, Esmond causing fights, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of protests (including against Isaveth being at the school); Mentions of kidnappings & ransoms; Mentions of poisons & someone being poisoned; Mentions of adults drinking wine/alcohol & getting drunk; Mentions of adults and students smoking (including Isaveth seeing Esmond take a “puffer” from another student and looking at it like he was debating to smoke it himself, but he doesn’t); Mentions of bullies & their cruel words and actions;Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of eavesdropping; Mentions of hatred (which is what Esmond has for his brother); Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of cheating; A couple mentions of a suicide in the prior book; A couple mentions of throwing up; A couple mentions of jealousy.
Romance-
A check kiss in thanks/gratitude & a kiss on the lips (lasting a sentence).
Dancing, Warmth, Tingles, & Nearness (up to a few sentences); Blushes & Staring.
Esmond asked Isaveth if he could kiss her at the end of the first book and because she did not answer, he plays it off as a joke in this book a few times by asking her again and she responds in nonsensical ways (such as he has to grow a beard first or that she can’t because she’s going to go dogsledding).
Esmond alters his appearance in a hurry to make it look like he sneaked off for a smoke or stole a kiss in the coatroom (messing up his hair and loosening his shirt).
Isaveth is called Esmond's girlfriend & him her boyfriend (he doesn’t correct it, but she does); A bit of teasing about this.
Isaveth is heckled by a group of men to show a smile to them & they whistle and laugh at her.
Isaveth is taught different dances by a female friend (because there isn’t a boy to play that role).
A girl comments that she got “all curvy” and pats her hips.
A few mentions of kisses, kissing, & implying that an attempted kiss happened; A few mentions of girl being smitten with a guy & the guy drooling over her; A couple mentions of a girl having awful cramps that leave her sitting on the toilet for “ages”; A couple mentions of flirting; A mention of a girl blushing when an older guy smiles at her.
**This review has spoilers for the first book and it’s ending**
Well, well, well. That ending was something else and while at first I was satisfied, I think I would have preferred a little more about that sudden epilogue.
Overall I have mixed feelings on this duology, so let’s listen out some pros and cons:
Con- It’s definitely not a light, fluffy middle-grade read. This could also be a positive in some ways, but it’s one I would hesitate to recommend to an actual middle-grade aged reader because the villains are true villains in this series and willing to harm and even threat to kill our main characters who are only 12-14.
Pro- I really like the setting of this world and different elements that make it unique. The magic system is like baking or science so it makes sense and is easy to follow.
Con- I didn’t love the bit of romance in a middle-grade book. They are 13/14 in this book which is on the borderline for me with a kiss (crushes I understand, but I don’t think they should be kissing that young. I’m old, I know.)
Pro- I was suspicious of a new character the entire book but it turned out okay! Yay! I was very relieved about that. 😅
Con- I found the stuff with Esmond's family to be sad. It added a heaviness to the story with the mistreatment, lack of caring, and verbal abuse he faces from them.
Pro- the ending with finally having justice! (Which was my biggest complaint with the first book)
So, it was a mixed bag in terms of my thoughts, haha. I would personally suggest this book for ages 10/11+ but only that young if the reader is *not* sensitive and magic is okay. As a note, this book was much more magic heavy than the first book in the series.
Main Content-
Magic-
In this world, there’s two different types of magic: Common magic (that commoners are able to do/afford to do) and Sage magic (which only nobles can do/afford to do). Isaveth makes magic on page often, but it’s similar to baking (called “spell-baking”) with using flour, eggs, and milk and also “binding powder” and “magewort”; They are called “spells” and Isaveth follows the recipe from “The Common Book of Magic”; When baked correctly, they become “spell-tablets” and can be broken to release heat, light, cool air, to wash someone’s hands without water, record a conversation, or find something/someone like an AirTag; We see many scenes of her making spells from Common magic (most like baking with common ingredients like flour and milk) and also learn Sage magic (which is more like jewelry making with precious metals and gemstones); Making charms through Sage magic shows off your status because they usually only work for their creator; When using a charm, Isaveth breaks it by stepping on it too hard and it launches her into the ceiling where she passes out; Others can “charm-swear” a promise which will alert the other person if the swearer has broken their promise (these usually only last six months or until someone’s death, whichever comes first).
All about & many mentions of magic, spells, charms, making both, & magical items; A few mentions of luck; A couple mentions of a claim to make an antidote to curses (which Isaveth notes that nobody really believes in those anymore).
Spiritual-
A few prayers to the All-One (including Isaveth saying one out loud and Esmond commenting about not knowing it was that easy to pray like you’re “just talking” and that his family never went to temple much); Going to the Temple (where Isaveth and the others sing songs of praise to the All-One and gave thanks for the wisdom of Moshiel).
Isaveth’s family are “Moshite” (which is implied to be both an ethnic group and a religion) and they show their faith by praying to the “All-One”, going to the Temple (shown on-page), and wearing a prayer veil at different times; Thanks to events in the first book, Isaveth has learned that it can be worse to lie about her faith than to keep the truth, so she is honest when asked about being Moshite; Isaveth’s older sister always wears her prayer scarf, but Isaveth only wears it at the temple or when praying because that was “what the scarf was for” and “why should she make it easier for people to despise her?”.
When making a Sage charm, it’s expected to invoke the Sage that first made the charm, but because Isaveth is Moshite, it unsettles her to “call on a long-dead scholar of magic for magic, as though he or she were the All-One” because that is blasphemy for a Moshite to do; Because of this, she does not say the scholar’s name, but later Esmond does when using a charm; A friend tells Isaveth that it’s only an old superstition and shouldn’t matter for her to use it, which disappoints Isaveth that her friend doesn’t understand and says she can’t do that; Someone later says that it’s disrespectful to not invoke the Sages as it’s “an important part” of the magical heritage (Isaveth later argues that she does respect the Sages, but that doesn’t mean she has to worship them); Moshiel forbade his followers from swearing oaths or loyalty to anyone but the All-One.
Isaveth and other Moshites face prejudice for their religion & many others believe them to be “worthless troublemakers”; One politician wants to punish all Moshites, refuse them government assistance, & encourage others to shun them; A boy at school taunts Isaveth with calling her “Mishmosh” and “Mushpot”.
Mentions of prayers & praying (to the All-One); Mentions of churches/temples & going to the temple; A couple mentions of “Moshiel” who is the guide for the Moshites in the first book; A couple mentions of when Isaveth and her sister lied about being Moshite; A couple mentions of someone being a Moshite in “private” only; A couple mentions of the blessing candles; A mention of someone soon facing the All-One’s justice (in death); A mention of Esmond calling religious studies “dull”.
Esmond calls his brother a “silver-tongued demon”.
Language/Attitudes-
Language: nothing stronger than stupid and idiot; A few mentions of curses said, not written (including by Esmond); “Maggots” is used as an exclamation; Sages are mentioned in exclamations as well with phrases like “Great Sages!”, “What in the name of the Sages”, “Thank the Sages”, and “Sages”.
Eye rolling; Some lies & half-truths; A few lies for safety; A side character tells a half-truth to a teacher; A teacher also comes up with a story (lies) to protect Isaveth but also gives her a punishment when she did something wrong; Isaveth keeps a secret from her family so they do not worry about her, but tells guilt about it and eventually tells them about a hundred pages later (her father isn’t happy to hear what she’s been up to, but knows that she did it for the right reasons and “that’s the main thing”).
Negative/Violence-
Seeing someone beaten, Hearing a gunshot, Seeing the body pushed off a boat (murder), & Grief/guilt over being unable to help the person (technically on-page, up to a few sentences: pg.322-323).
Pain, Passing out, Being threatened with harm and death, Being kidnapped, Tied-up, Trapped in a crate, & Charmed to be still and silent (up to a few sentences); Borrowing something without permission (twice).
Esmond punches another student during a sport game (on purpose because the boy was messing with him).
Isaveth is bullied by other students & we see their their cruel words (name-calling and snide remarks) and actions (protests, writing on her desk and walls, & putting a dead rat in her book bag) on-page.
Isaveth gets tired of being the only student in her classes that knew what it felt like to go hungry, to freeze at night because there wasn’t enough coal, and to have to keep wearing too-small shoes.
Government overreach with a politician wanting to reform the relief/government assistance program by refusing to help those who won’t swear to the government leader (which Moshites will not do and this is a direct attack on them).
Esmond’s family life is rough with his evil brother that everyone admires, a harsh father, and a mother and sister that avoid conflict; This is evident by mentions of when Esmond’s older brother lashed at and damaged Esmond’s eye with his fencing sword after Esmond defied his orders (which the family believes to be a mistake and don’t believe Esmond’s words against his brother), the father lashing out verbally to his wife, threatening each other for the sake of their plans/wants, & the evil brother being a “murdering hypocrite”; *Spoilers* ; *Major Spoilers* .
Esmond’s father gets drunk & has a drinking problem (he is supposed to avoid drinking due to a liver problem, but still sneaks into the alcohol & gets drunk); Esmond hints in a fake letter that he snuck into his father’s alcohol cabinet (which would get him in major trouble if that was true).
Discussions of & Mentions of the murder in the first book (no mentions of how it happened, but about the murdered person, how Isaveth’s father was accused as murderer, and the actual murderer); Mentions of illnesses (including of the liver), a family member dying, deaths, & grief (including Isaveth and her family for her late mother);Mentions of crimes, criminals, prison, arrests, & possible hangings; Mentions of weapons/guns, a gunshot (used to kill someone), & bullets; Mentions of stealing & thieves; Mentions of blackmail & threats; Mentions of fights, fighting, injuries, Esmond causing fights, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of protests (including against Isaveth being at the school); Mentions of kidnappings & ransoms; Mentions of poisons & someone being poisoned; Mentions of adults drinking wine/alcohol & getting drunk; Mentions of adults and students smoking (including Isaveth seeing Esmond take a “puffer” from another student and looking at it like he was debating to smoke it himself, but he doesn’t); Mentions of bullies & their cruel words and actions;Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of eavesdropping; Mentions of hatred (which is what Esmond has for his brother); Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of cheating; A couple mentions of a suicide in the prior book; A couple mentions of throwing up; A couple mentions of jealousy.
Romance-
A check kiss in thanks/gratitude & a kiss on the lips (lasting a sentence).
Dancing, Warmth, Tingles, & Nearness (up to a few sentences); Blushes & Staring.
Esmond asked Isaveth if he could kiss her at the end of the first book and because she did not answer, he plays it off as a joke in this book a few times by asking her again and she responds in nonsensical ways (such as he has to grow a beard first or that she can’t because she’s going to go dogsledding).
Esmond alters his appearance in a hurry to make it look like he sneaked off for a smoke or stole a kiss in the coatroom (messing up his hair and loosening his shirt).
Isaveth is called Esmond's girlfriend & him her boyfriend (he doesn’t correct it, but she does); A bit of teasing about this.
Isaveth is heckled by a group of men to show a smile to them & they whistle and laugh at her.
Isaveth is taught different dances by a female friend (because there isn’t a boy to play that role).
A girl comments that she got “all curvy” and pats her hips.
A few mentions of kisses, kissing, & implying that an attempted kiss happened; A few mentions of girl being smitten with a guy & the guy drooling over her; A couple mentions of a girl having awful cramps that leave her sitting on the toilet for “ages”; A couple mentions of flirting; A mention of a girl blushing when an older guy smiles at her.
June 8, 2022
Oh. My. Gosh.
That ending? What?
And the twists and turns this took?
And the character development?
And exploration of the world?
Absolutely stunning. This book holds my heart. I need to think about it because AGH was this ever good.
That ending? What?
And the twists and turns this took?
And the character development?
And exploration of the world?
Absolutely stunning. This book holds my heart. I need to think about it because AGH was this ever good.
June 17, 2023
Oh my goodness, what an insanely cool climax! I adored doing it as a read-aloud: it was so epic! 😭😍😍
But okay, now for a more serious review. I would say that if you loved the first book (for which I still have not written a review *cries in shame*), you should 100% also read this one. We get to see more of Isaveth, Quiz, and the whole slew of R.J. Anderson's other amazing characters from this duology (I love Isaveth's family! ❤️). We even get chapters from Quiz's point of view! I also love how Eryx is still playing a role all throughout (mwahahaha) but that he doesn't end up as the only antagonist. 😏
However, I do wish that Isaveth and Quiz could've had a more meaningful time together in this one. Not gonna lie, their meetings were kinda boring at times compared to their adventures from the first book. I think part of the reason for this is that the plot in general was moving too slowly.
The first half of the book could be compared to the middle volume of a trilogy (a.k.a. boring and dry, just kidding!). However. The story speeds up much more in the last half, and we end with lots of drama, intrigue, plot twists, etc! In the end, I was not disappointed at all. I just wish the first half could've been a little better.
Also, this is completely random, but is it just me, or does anyone else just adore Eryx in this weird sort of way? I would never actually side with him, but he's the villain, and imo, he carried the show, you guys. 💔 He really did. (Don't judge. 😆 I'm just being honest.)
I would recommend this series to readers ages 10+ (or 12+ if you lean on the conservative side when it comes to books). The entire series is clean and fit for middle-grade readers, although it does include a unique magic system and some content that (I would seriously guess) was inspired by Harry Potter (e.g. the magic classes, the school Isaveth attended, and some of the characters). the author is a Christian, and the main character is the fantasy equivalent of Jewish.
4.5 stars
But okay, now for a more serious review. I would say that if you loved the first book (for which I still have not written a review *cries in shame*), you should 100% also read this one. We get to see more of Isaveth, Quiz, and the whole slew of R.J. Anderson's other amazing characters from this duology (I love Isaveth's family! ❤️). We even get chapters from Quiz's point of view! I also love how Eryx is still playing a role all throughout (mwahahaha) but that he doesn't end up as the only antagonist. 😏
However, I do wish that Isaveth and Quiz could've had a more meaningful time together in this one. Not gonna lie, their meetings were kinda boring at times compared to their adventures from the first book. I think part of the reason for this is that the plot in general was moving too slowly.
The first half of the book could be compared to the middle volume of a trilogy (a.k.a. boring and dry, just kidding!). However. The story speeds up much more in the last half, and we end with lots of drama, intrigue, plot twists, etc! In the end, I was not disappointed at all. I just wish the first half could've been a little better.
Also, this is completely random, but is it just me, or does anyone else just adore Eryx in this weird sort of way? I would never actually side with him, but he's the villain, and imo, he carried the show, you guys. 💔 He really did. (Don't judge. 😆 I'm just being honest.)
I would recommend this series to readers ages 10+ (or 12+ if you lean on the conservative side when it comes to books). The entire series is clean and fit for middle-grade readers, although it does include a unique magic system and some content that (I would seriously guess) was inspired by Harry Potter (e.g. the magic classes, the school Isaveth attended, and some of the characters). the author is a Christian, and the main character is the fantasy equivalent of Jewish.
4.5 stars
October 2, 2016
What a delightfully compelling series this is shaping up to be. This is, above all else, incredibly well-plotted - which means it's exciting and smart and fast-paced. I really like the characters, though they're almost secondary to how amazing the world is. This is meticulously constructed, detailed, thoughtful writing: that it's thrilling, too, is icing on the cake.
September 27, 2016
This MG fantasy novel includes fantastic world-building, a great heroine, complex family dynamics, an intriguing mystery, fascinating magic and a ridiculously fun masked ball. In other words, it is utterly delicious and EXACTLY my kind of book!
Highly recommended, whether or not you've read Book 1 in the series (which is also excellent).
Highly recommended, whether or not you've read Book 1 in the series (which is also excellent).
August 19, 2025
this was awesome
(reread and annotated)
(reread and annotated)
February 10, 2024
Uhhh, does that epilogue mean what I think it means??
I love R.J. Anderson's writing. I just love it. It's smooth, it's confident, it's succinct and yet so evocative. Everything, from the pacing to the dialogue to the descriptions, is just right for me. My only complaint is when it's over.
I already enjoyed A POCKET FULL OF MURDER, but in my opinion, this sequel is even better. Maybe that's because of the school setting, which, yes, does have hints of Harry Potter about it (at this point, how can any school set in a magical world not remind the reader of Harry Potter?), but was to me more reminiscent of Robin Stevens' MURDER MOST UNLADYLIKE series (which I liked at first but ultimately stopped reading due to the content). But I think my liking also has to do with the fact that we get to see Esmond and Isaveth's friendship grow, and to see into both their heads as they work to bring down Eryx Lording. I enjoyed every minute of their quest to find the evidence against him; the pacing, and the skill with which Anderson neatly kept whisking the rug out from under her protagonists, is really marvelous. And then, again, there's that cryptic epilogue, making us question what we've just been told...
I love R.J. Anderson's writing. I just love it. It's smooth, it's confident, it's succinct and yet so evocative. Everything, from the pacing to the dialogue to the descriptions, is just right for me. My only complaint is when it's over.
I already enjoyed A POCKET FULL OF MURDER, but in my opinion, this sequel is even better. Maybe that's because of the school setting, which, yes, does have hints of Harry Potter about it (at this point, how can any school set in a magical world not remind the reader of Harry Potter?), but was to me more reminiscent of Robin Stevens' MURDER MOST UNLADYLIKE series (which I liked at first but ultimately stopped reading due to the content). But I think my liking also has to do with the fact that we get to see Esmond and Isaveth's friendship grow, and to see into both their heads as they work to bring down Eryx Lording. I enjoyed every minute of their quest to find the evidence against him; the pacing, and the skill with which Anderson neatly kept whisking the rug out from under her protagonists, is really marvelous. And then, again, there's that cryptic epilogue, making us question what we've just been told...
August 29, 2016
Wonderful sequel to A Pocket Full of Murder!
Isaveth Breck is still longing to clear her father's name for murder. She has made a profit for the sale of her invention of magic-resistant paper. She is doubly rewarded when she not only profits for her family but is offered a chance at a scholarship to a prestigious school. As luck would have it, Esmond "Quiz" attends this school. They must secretly meet to scheme how to find the proof needed to clear her father.
Beautifully written with a lavish ball, much intrigue and a daring heroine!! Loved it!! Made my top 100 books!!
Isaveth Breck is still longing to clear her father's name for murder. She has made a profit for the sale of her invention of magic-resistant paper. She is doubly rewarded when she not only profits for her family but is offered a chance at a scholarship to a prestigious school. As luck would have it, Esmond "Quiz" attends this school. They must secretly meet to scheme how to find the proof needed to clear her father.
Beautifully written with a lavish ball, much intrigue and a daring heroine!! Loved it!! Made my top 100 books!!
September 21, 2016
So good!
August 11, 2017
Thanks so much to Simon and Schuster Canada for sending me a copy of this book for an honest review. As always, all opinions are my own.
After reading the first book in this series last year, A Pocket Full of Magic, I was excited to pick up the sequel. Luckily, it didn't disappoint!
The story picks up pretty much where it left off in the first book, Isaveth has sold her tablet wrappers and has now been offered a scholarship to the elite college by the company. After clearing her father's name, she decides she can't turn down such a prestigous offer and begins her schooling.
While her one saviour is Esmond, she doesn't end up seeing him much, because he is a year older than she. However, she finds a fast friend in a girl, Eulalie, who helps her navigate the new world of the college. I don't really want to say too much about the plot itself, because it is a sequel, and it might end up spoiling the first book.
One thing that I really enjoyed was the girl power that was going on in this book. Isaveth is her usual energetic self, but there are many other female characters that also find there voice and ruffle some feathers. Esmond's sister Civilla shows that she is more than just a petty gossip, having formulated a plan from the very beginning. Isaveth's little sister Mirriam is sticking up for her family, albeit not in the best way, but her intentions are pure. And that epilogue, power to Lady Nessa. She showed she is not some delicate little flower that can be pushed around. There is some hinting at issues between her and the Sagelord, hopefully they will be addressed more in book three (I think there will be more to this series, not 100% sure though). Overall, they were all clever and intelligent, I'll even forgive the author for using the cliché of poison because they were just so powerful.
I think this is a great book, and series, for kids. It deals with a lot of issues that kids these days deal with (man that makes me sound old...), like bullying, following their family's ill-advised beliefs, and just standing up for yourself. I think any of the main characters would be excellent role models for kids to look up to, they support one another and fight for what is right.
The setting of the book helps too, set in an adventure in a magical world, this story enchant all who read it. I also loved the fact that this book is set in winter, so you get that cozy, snowy vibe that everyone starts to crave by the end of September.
I also loved the inclusion of the Moshite religion. While both the religions in this book are fictitious, one where the followers worship the Sages, and the other Moshites, with their own beliefs, often deemed radical, the inclusion helps relate the message that no one religion or group is better than the other, and that you cannot generalize all members of the religion just based on the actions of a select few. This message of tolerance and acceptance is especially vital today in a world where there are so many opinions and thoughts. It is great for kids to see that people can peacefully work together and thrive, one is not better than the other.
Even though this series is technically a middle grade read, I still enjoyed it as a mature YA to NA reader. There is something so fun about going back and reading a book that deals with simpler issues than relationships and high school and college prep. After reading so many heavy books, it is nice to lighten everything with such a fun read.
I'm not too sure if there are only going to be two books in this series, I haven't been able to find anything. The ending itself is fairly well contained, I suppose there isn't a ton to be added to the story, but this is such a fun series, I would love to see more of Esmond and Isaveth's adventures!
Overall, I very much enjoyed this book and series overall and I look forward to book three (if there is one).
After reading the first book in this series last year, A Pocket Full of Magic, I was excited to pick up the sequel. Luckily, it didn't disappoint!
The story picks up pretty much where it left off in the first book, Isaveth has sold her tablet wrappers and has now been offered a scholarship to the elite college by the company. After clearing her father's name, she decides she can't turn down such a prestigous offer and begins her schooling.
While her one saviour is Esmond, she doesn't end up seeing him much, because he is a year older than she. However, she finds a fast friend in a girl, Eulalie, who helps her navigate the new world of the college. I don't really want to say too much about the plot itself, because it is a sequel, and it might end up spoiling the first book.
One thing that I really enjoyed was the girl power that was going on in this book. Isaveth is her usual energetic self, but there are many other female characters that also find there voice and ruffle some feathers. Esmond's sister Civilla shows that she is more than just a petty gossip, having formulated a plan from the very beginning. Isaveth's little sister Mirriam is sticking up for her family, albeit not in the best way, but her intentions are pure. And that epilogue, power to Lady Nessa. She showed she is not some delicate little flower that can be pushed around. There is some hinting at issues between her and the Sagelord, hopefully they will be addressed more in book three (I think there will be more to this series, not 100% sure though). Overall, they were all clever and intelligent, I'll even forgive the author for using the cliché of poison because they were just so powerful.
I think this is a great book, and series, for kids. It deals with a lot of issues that kids these days deal with (man that makes me sound old...), like bullying, following their family's ill-advised beliefs, and just standing up for yourself. I think any of the main characters would be excellent role models for kids to look up to, they support one another and fight for what is right.
The setting of the book helps too, set in an adventure in a magical world, this story enchant all who read it. I also loved the fact that this book is set in winter, so you get that cozy, snowy vibe that everyone starts to crave by the end of September.
I also loved the inclusion of the Moshite religion. While both the religions in this book are fictitious, one where the followers worship the Sages, and the other Moshites, with their own beliefs, often deemed radical, the inclusion helps relate the message that no one religion or group is better than the other, and that you cannot generalize all members of the religion just based on the actions of a select few. This message of tolerance and acceptance is especially vital today in a world where there are so many opinions and thoughts. It is great for kids to see that people can peacefully work together and thrive, one is not better than the other.
Even though this series is technically a middle grade read, I still enjoyed it as a mature YA to NA reader. There is something so fun about going back and reading a book that deals with simpler issues than relationships and high school and college prep. After reading so many heavy books, it is nice to lighten everything with such a fun read.
I'm not too sure if there are only going to be two books in this series, I haven't been able to find anything. The ending itself is fairly well contained, I suppose there isn't a ton to be added to the story, but this is such a fun series, I would love to see more of Esmond and Isaveth's adventures!
Overall, I very much enjoyed this book and series overall and I look forward to book three (if there is one).
September 30, 2016
The city of Tarreton is powered by magic, from simple tablets that light lamps to advanced Sagery that can murder a man from afar. Isaveth has a talent for spell-making, but as a girl from a poor neighborhood she never dreamed she could study at the most exclusive magical school in the city. So when she's offered a chance to attend, she eagerly accepts. The school is wonderful, but old and new enemies confront Isaveth at every turn, and she begins to suspect her scholarship might be more a trap than a gift. Even her secret meetings with Esmond, her best friend and partner in crime-solving, prove risky—especially once he hatches a plan to sneak her into the biggest society event of the season. It's their last chance to catch the corrupt politician who once framed her father for murder. How can Isaveth refuse?
A Little Taste of Poison is utterly magical and mysterious, captivating and charming. It's a story of intrigue, of family and faith, of struggle. A story of righting wrongs and helping friends. Of revealing the truth, no matter how dangerous it is.
Isaveth is a wonderful heroine. Ingenious and compassionate. Loyal and trusting. Curious and inquisitive. Her and her family have struggled for years and she's learned to be cautious when it comes to gifts. Especially when it comes to the upper class of Tarreton. But this scholarship, this chance to learn more about magic, to learn about Sagery along with what she already knows about Common Magic? It's hard for her to resist. It also means she can continue her investigating with Esmond, the one-eyed boy formerly known as Quiz. Isaveth can't not ask questions, she can't let things go by when it comes to people in charge abusing their power, treating families like Isaveth's, poor families, Moshite families, like they're less than them. But when those in charge are willing to do anything to get their way? It's hard for Isaveth to keep pushing.
And Esmond! We get more glimpses of his family life, the life he was running from when he first met Isaveth in the first book. It's not a happy life. It's privileged, it's fancy, but it's cold and unforgiving. It's a strict set of rules that Esmond doesn't necessarily agree with. It's a father who would rather drink and a brother with dangerous plans and powerful accomplices. He has to be careful if he wants to reveal the truth of his brother to the city, because Eryx isn't stupid when it comes to hiding his tracks.
In the first book, we only saw so much of Tarreton, of the city that Isaveth and Esmond race through before time runs out. Now we see more, like Tarreton College and its students, some of whom aren't completely stuck up and pretentious. We see more of Esmond's house and the figures that inhabit it. But the familiar things are still there, like Isaveth's house on Cabbage Street, like her father and her sisters. Like the supportive Moshite community.
As with the first book, this covers all manner of important and current ideas and topics. The class divide. Wealth and poverty. Privilege. Religion. Politics. It's so layered, from family disagreements to classroom bullies to political intrigue, all in a story about a young girl learning magic and solving mysteries with her best friend. I found this book and its heroine to be charming and honest, insightful and powerful. A must-read.
(I received an advance copy of this title to review from Simon & Schuster Canada.)
A Little Taste of Poison is utterly magical and mysterious, captivating and charming. It's a story of intrigue, of family and faith, of struggle. A story of righting wrongs and helping friends. Of revealing the truth, no matter how dangerous it is.
Isaveth is a wonderful heroine. Ingenious and compassionate. Loyal and trusting. Curious and inquisitive. Her and her family have struggled for years and she's learned to be cautious when it comes to gifts. Especially when it comes to the upper class of Tarreton. But this scholarship, this chance to learn more about magic, to learn about Sagery along with what she already knows about Common Magic? It's hard for her to resist. It also means she can continue her investigating with Esmond, the one-eyed boy formerly known as Quiz. Isaveth can't not ask questions, she can't let things go by when it comes to people in charge abusing their power, treating families like Isaveth's, poor families, Moshite families, like they're less than them. But when those in charge are willing to do anything to get their way? It's hard for Isaveth to keep pushing.
And Esmond! We get more glimpses of his family life, the life he was running from when he first met Isaveth in the first book. It's not a happy life. It's privileged, it's fancy, but it's cold and unforgiving. It's a strict set of rules that Esmond doesn't necessarily agree with. It's a father who would rather drink and a brother with dangerous plans and powerful accomplices. He has to be careful if he wants to reveal the truth of his brother to the city, because Eryx isn't stupid when it comes to hiding his tracks.
In the first book, we only saw so much of Tarreton, of the city that Isaveth and Esmond race through before time runs out. Now we see more, like Tarreton College and its students, some of whom aren't completely stuck up and pretentious. We see more of Esmond's house and the figures that inhabit it. But the familiar things are still there, like Isaveth's house on Cabbage Street, like her father and her sisters. Like the supportive Moshite community.
As with the first book, this covers all manner of important and current ideas and topics. The class divide. Wealth and poverty. Privilege. Religion. Politics. It's so layered, from family disagreements to classroom bullies to political intrigue, all in a story about a young girl learning magic and solving mysteries with her best friend. I found this book and its heroine to be charming and honest, insightful and powerful. A must-read.
(I received an advance copy of this title to review from Simon & Schuster Canada.)
October 10, 2016
Originally posted here at Random Musings of a Bibliophile.
R.J. Anderson is an auto-buy author for me (and also a friend), but her Uncommon Magic books may be absolute favorite. A Little Taste of Poison is the follow-up to last year's A Pocket Full of Murder. It is the perfect follow-up and surpassed all the expectations I had.
Isaveth has an amazing opportunity to attend Tarreton College on a scholarship and be trained in Sage Magic. This is not something any commoner, never mind a Moshite, has ever done. Isaveth grasps the opportunity though she know it will be difficult. Yet it would also give Isaveth a chance to see Esmond again. They have not seen each other since freeing her father from the false murder charges against him. Both Isaveth and Esmond are eager to have the true mastermind of the crime brought to justice, but he is always two steps ahead of them.
It's always hard to write reviews to sequels without any spoilers of the first book. I attempt it as much as possible but can never avoid it altogether. If you haven't read A Pocket Full of Murder, read that first and then come back here.
Isaveth and Esmond are such an incredible team and magnificent characters. Both of them are developed more in this story. In A Pocket Full of Murder Esmond was in Isaveth's world for the most part, and this time that is switched around. We also see Esmond's family more. This switch works incredibly well and, taken with the first book, it rounds both of their characters out incredibly well. As a result of the revelations of book one, Isaveth and Esmond also have to renegotiate how they react to and deal with each other. They still can not spend time together openly which makes things challenging. Isaveth feels awkward as the Esmond she sees in public is so very different from the boy she came to know and care for in his disguise as Quiz. Another change in this book is that we see Esmond's family interactions and theses are fascinating and insightful as well as a minefield of intrigue and smart people trying to outsmart each other. It's brilliant.
There are several familiar secondary characters who return and it feels like seeing old friends. I particularly enjoyed seeing Isaveth's sisters again. Several new characters are introduced as well. Isaveth has new enemies waiting for her when she arrives at school, but she makes new friends too including Eulalie, the vivacious daughter of an important law enforcement official. Isaveth and Esmond had to do so much alone in the first book, it is wonderful to see them have more people they can rely on. It enriches both of their characters so much. Seeing what this brings out in Esmond, who is not used to being able to rely on anyone else, is great. I can't tell you who my favorite secondary character is because of spoilers but know you're in for a treat!
The mystery in this book is even better than the first one. (And that's saying a lot.) The book is impossible to put down and fast paced. There are so many twists and turns and surprises, each one of them more delightful than the last. And it continues that way to the very last page. I was squealing with delight and happiness at the end of the story and then nearly fell off the couch after reading the Epilogue.
Read the book. Read both the books. You'll thank me.
R.J. Anderson is an auto-buy author for me (and also a friend), but her Uncommon Magic books may be absolute favorite. A Little Taste of Poison is the follow-up to last year's A Pocket Full of Murder. It is the perfect follow-up and surpassed all the expectations I had.
Isaveth has an amazing opportunity to attend Tarreton College on a scholarship and be trained in Sage Magic. This is not something any commoner, never mind a Moshite, has ever done. Isaveth grasps the opportunity though she know it will be difficult. Yet it would also give Isaveth a chance to see Esmond again. They have not seen each other since freeing her father from the false murder charges against him. Both Isaveth and Esmond are eager to have the true mastermind of the crime brought to justice, but he is always two steps ahead of them.
It's always hard to write reviews to sequels without any spoilers of the first book. I attempt it as much as possible but can never avoid it altogether. If you haven't read A Pocket Full of Murder, read that first and then come back here.
Isaveth and Esmond are such an incredible team and magnificent characters. Both of them are developed more in this story. In A Pocket Full of Murder Esmond was in Isaveth's world for the most part, and this time that is switched around. We also see Esmond's family more. This switch works incredibly well and, taken with the first book, it rounds both of their characters out incredibly well. As a result of the revelations of book one, Isaveth and Esmond also have to renegotiate how they react to and deal with each other. They still can not spend time together openly which makes things challenging. Isaveth feels awkward as the Esmond she sees in public is so very different from the boy she came to know and care for in his disguise as Quiz. Another change in this book is that we see Esmond's family interactions and theses are fascinating and insightful as well as a minefield of intrigue and smart people trying to outsmart each other. It's brilliant.
There are several familiar secondary characters who return and it feels like seeing old friends. I particularly enjoyed seeing Isaveth's sisters again. Several new characters are introduced as well. Isaveth has new enemies waiting for her when she arrives at school, but she makes new friends too including Eulalie, the vivacious daughter of an important law enforcement official. Isaveth and Esmond had to do so much alone in the first book, it is wonderful to see them have more people they can rely on. It enriches both of their characters so much. Seeing what this brings out in Esmond, who is not used to being able to rely on anyone else, is great. I can't tell you who my favorite secondary character is because of spoilers but know you're in for a treat!
The mystery in this book is even better than the first one. (And that's saying a lot.) The book is impossible to put down and fast paced. There are so many twists and turns and surprises, each one of them more delightful than the last. And it continues that way to the very last page. I was squealing with delight and happiness at the end of the story and then nearly fell off the couch after reading the Epilogue.
Read the book. Read both the books. You'll thank me.
September 22, 2019
I enjoyed this book just as much as its predecessor. The pacing was phenomenal--this was the first story in a while that kept me reading an hour after I told myself "Just one more chapter"
The story elaborated on the concept of sagery, which was intriguing in itself. The storyline was quite unpredictable. I could see the general idea of what would happen, but I didn't know who or what would be involved.
I'm sad that this book is done, and I don't think there will be a third one. The epilogue left me with a lot of questions, though.
The story elaborated on the concept of sagery, which was intriguing in itself. The storyline was quite unpredictable. I could see the general idea of what would happen, but I didn't know who or what would be involved.
I'm sad that this book is done, and I don't think there will be a third one. The epilogue left me with a lot of questions, though.
June 26, 2017
It super cute.
May 27, 2023
The only problem I have with this series is that there are only two books in it
March 4, 2024
I loved the ending of this sequel. I enjoyed when they gathered all the people involved and told the whole story. I also liked learning about the higher level of magic in their world. I think it's actullaly more of a 4.5, the only reason it's not 5 was their were a few times things were not entirely clear.
October 4, 2016
I recently had the privilege of attending a book launch in Waterloo region that had four local authors. I had already read and reviewed two of the books and had read other books by those authors. But this event was my introduction to R.J. Anderson and her wonderful writing. And even though this is book two in a series after hearing the author read the opening chapter I read this book through and have only now gone back to read book one. This book continues a few months after book one, but not having read it this story does have the strength to stand alone.
This is a very interesting read, it is a story about friendship, and standing up for what is right. Isaveth is still trying to get evidence on the man responsible for framing her father. She is doing so with that man's brother, Esmond, one of the few people who seem to recognize the true nature of their foe. Isaveth has been given a scholarship to learn Sagery at the academy. But she has a lot stacked against her, first she is a commoner, second she belongs to a religious minority the Moshites. And third her father was recently accused of murder and organizing unions. So even though being at the school is a wonderful opportunity, Isaveth soon finds out it is also full of prejudice and enemies both old and new. And no matter how good she does in her classes things keep getting worse and worse for her.
There is a lot of adventure in this book, for a 12 years old girl who is a little head strong and determined to do all she can for her family. And for the second son of the sage lord who seems to be in conflict with everyone but Isaveth.
In this book we have a world powered by magic, but there are two types of magic, common magic that is baked and can be used by almost anyone and sagery which works with charms and often only works for those who make it. This magic is used for heat, light, transportation and more. The book is written with a brisk pace of action. With a number of small side plots that eventually all come together. It some ways it reads like a magical Agatha Christie book.
And though this book was my introduction to R.J. Anderson's writings it will defiantly not be my last. It was an excellent little read and I look forward to reading Isaveth and Esmond's earlier adventure and also other books from Anderson.
Read the review on my blog Book Reviews and More.
This is a very interesting read, it is a story about friendship, and standing up for what is right. Isaveth is still trying to get evidence on the man responsible for framing her father. She is doing so with that man's brother, Esmond, one of the few people who seem to recognize the true nature of their foe. Isaveth has been given a scholarship to learn Sagery at the academy. But she has a lot stacked against her, first she is a commoner, second she belongs to a religious minority the Moshites. And third her father was recently accused of murder and organizing unions. So even though being at the school is a wonderful opportunity, Isaveth soon finds out it is also full of prejudice and enemies both old and new. And no matter how good she does in her classes things keep getting worse and worse for her.
There is a lot of adventure in this book, for a 12 years old girl who is a little head strong and determined to do all she can for her family. And for the second son of the sage lord who seems to be in conflict with everyone but Isaveth.
In this book we have a world powered by magic, but there are two types of magic, common magic that is baked and can be used by almost anyone and sagery which works with charms and often only works for those who make it. This magic is used for heat, light, transportation and more. The book is written with a brisk pace of action. With a number of small side plots that eventually all come together. It some ways it reads like a magical Agatha Christie book.
And though this book was my introduction to R.J. Anderson's writings it will defiantly not be my last. It was an excellent little read and I look forward to reading Isaveth and Esmond's earlier adventure and also other books from Anderson.
Read the review on my blog Book Reviews and More.
September 28, 2016
Oh my god this book was so good! It was even better than 'A pocket full of murder' was. Considering this book is aimed at 'middle grade' which I assume to mean 9-12 year olds, it's just as enjoyable for adults in my opinion. It covers so many issues that are present in our society in such an honest way. The plot was gripping and fast paced. I found myself not wanting to put it down but at the same time wanting to savour it knowing there wouldn't be any more once I had finished. The ending was so exciting and then sweet. And then the epilogue happened which literally made this book perfect! I have so many feelings about this book right now so I think I'll be spending the next few days with a book hangover
September 1, 2017
its a really good book that i think every kid should read, but don't forget to read the first one before!
June 6, 2022
Thanks to her inventive spellwork, Isaveth gets an invitation to study at an elite magical school on a scholarship, but you know what they say about things that feel too good to be true...As she and her friend Esmond desperately try to unravel murderous plots and political intrigue behind the scenes, now Isaveth has to deal with bitter and envious classmates, bullying, and double-crossing on top of everything else. It's a race against the clock as Esmond's father's health deteriorates every day. Will they make it?
I inadvertently picked up this book without realizing it's a sequel, and in full transparency...I haven't read a Pocket Full of Murder. That said, it didn't take too long to catch hold of the gist of the intrigue already in progress. I will say there are good twists and turns--some genuine surprises, and incredibly high stakes for a middle grade book. We're talking real murders here. The magic is interesting but this magical school is no Hogwarts...or maybe it would be if nearly every single student were a Slytherin. Isaveth's family dynamics are also interesting. I like the evolving dynamics between the sisters. It's interesting.
This may be a bit of a nitpick, and maybe it makes much more sense if you read the first book, but my only real issue with this book was the relationship with Esmond and Isaveth. Most of the foundation was apparently laid in the first book, and the reader is clearly meant to rely on that context for the second. There's so much going on that the two characters don't get a lot of time together that isn't solely spent in plotting, and I couldn't get a read on their real relationship. In book two we really only get a glimpse at Esmond's feelings on this than Isaveth's. Because of that, some running joke(?) with Esmond asking for a kiss felt really off-putting to me, especially with the power dynamic. This disconnect could be partly because (apparently) Isaveth knew him almost as an entirely different person in the first book, and with him having to be himself as a noble, she feels like she has to reacquaint herself with him. Still though--it felt...not great.
I could see this being a possible read-alike to the Tasters Guild series by Susannah Appelbaum, or The Troubled Girls of Dragomir Academy.
I inadvertently picked up this book without realizing it's a sequel, and in full transparency...I haven't read a Pocket Full of Murder. That said, it didn't take too long to catch hold of the gist of the intrigue already in progress. I will say there are good twists and turns--some genuine surprises, and incredibly high stakes for a middle grade book. We're talking real murders here. The magic is interesting but this magical school is no Hogwarts...or maybe it would be if nearly every single student were a Slytherin. Isaveth's family dynamics are also interesting. I like the evolving dynamics between the sisters. It's interesting.
This may be a bit of a nitpick, and maybe it makes much more sense if you read the first book, but my only real issue with this book was the relationship with Esmond and Isaveth. Most of the foundation was apparently laid in the first book, and the reader is clearly meant to rely on that context for the second. There's so much going on that the two characters don't get a lot of time together that isn't solely spent in plotting, and I couldn't get a read on their real relationship. In book two we really only get a glimpse at Esmond's feelings on this than Isaveth's. Because of that, some running joke(?) with Esmond asking for a kiss felt really off-putting to me, especially with the power dynamic. This disconnect could be partly because (apparently) Isaveth knew him almost as an entirely different person in the first book, and with him having to be himself as a noble, she feels like she has to reacquaint herself with him. Still though--it felt...not great.
I could see this being a possible read-alike to the Tasters Guild series by Susannah Appelbaum, or The Troubled Girls of Dragomir Academy.
January 2, 2023
this was more of a 3.5 leaning very hard to a solid 4//AAHHHH this actually had such a stellar ending sequence of events! Honestly I took a long break between this book which was a huge disadvantage but I was able to get back into it with a lot more ease than I thought. It’s taken me about a YEAR to finish entirely. anyway, I wasn’t toooo excited until the last part of the book. all I can really rave about is the (wink wink) dinner party scene. That had my whole heart. AND ESMOND AND ISAVETH?? I LOVE THEM SO MUCH. they are so wholesome. They made me feel like a giddy little child again—which is just a great feeling. I cannot wait to see if there are more of them because the politics of this book series’ works is NO JOKE. I loved the politics and the world the most, it’s like a character of its own. And civilla? I’m always in her corner. I’ve met her for like idk a total of 20 pages and she stole me. Great read!
Read
December 30, 2020Cross-posted from my blog where there's more information on where I got my copy and everything.
(Rounded down from three and a half.)
This was pretty much just what I wanted it be. It's really cute, a great mystery, and the setting continues to work great for the story. It's nice to read a book that's just good and that's what this was. I love the idea of combining magic with good old fashioned mysteries. I think kids would love this. Eleven year old me seriously would have devoured this and wanted like eight more books. I still wish there would be like eight more books, because I genuinely enjoyed this one.
Plot Talk: This one continues one of the larger plot threads from the last book and many of the smaller ones. The continuity is wonderful, honestly. I won't go into too much details because I don't want to end up spoiler territory, but this one wraps up everything from the first book without being too neat and tidy. Everything is exciting and fresh, and this is my least favourite part of the review process so let's move on.
Characters: A new thing happens in this book! We get to switch POVs from strictly Isaveth's to Esmond's POV as well, and that allows us to see things that Isaveth isn't present for. I like that despite that, the book kept only to Isaveth or Esmond, not anyone else. It pretty much would have been impossible to have Esmond's POV in the last book, or it would have ruined one of the surprises at the end, and the tension of that surprise. But it's nice that there wasn't random headhopping, and just our two main characters. The POV choices worked for me.
I still adore the relationships in this, especially the relationship between Isaveth and her sisters. There is a good amount of female characters in this, including several new ones, and the book does take some time to give us a new female friendship for Isaveth, and I love that that was included, because it's so important. And while you get a touch of romance in this one, it's handled well, and it's not so over the top that I think it's too much. While a tiny bit predictable, romance being built on trust, friendship, and mutual respect is always a good thing to show.
PG-13 stuff: Dude straight up gets shot in this and dies, and it's not really "off-screen". Plus the usual mystery stuff like kidnapping and the poisoning mentioned in the title. Sensitive readers may be upset by that, but it's not graphic.
Cons, complaints, bad stuff, etc.: I wish some of the people had been described a little better at certain times. Specifically, I think sometimes it's hard to tell if some characters are meant to be characters of colour or not. I choose to error on the "absolutely they are" side, but I don't think it's quite clear enough in context especially considering the inherant subconscious bias that we white people have while reading (and the autho is white as well).
I think that kind of ties into one of the bigger things I feel conflicted about, and that's if Isaveth being Moshite, which is clearly meant to be Jewish, but isn't actually called Jewish, is problematic or okay. Because, like, there are elements in this that are reminscent of Harry Potter in the magic school and such, and who wouldn't want to read Harry Potter if Harry was a Jewish girl??? Since I'm totally not the one who should be deciding this stuff, I'm looking for reviews from Jewish reviewers, and I'm just not finding anything, so shouting out to you guys - what do you think of this one? Does ths make you uncomfortable, or are you cool with it?
As such, I'm raising that element specifically as a concern, but neither taking points off my review of it nor giving points for it.
Oh, and there wasn't any fatphobia in this one. Very few fat characters as far as I can remember that were around for any significant time, if any, though.
Cover comments: This cover is very cute, and props for it actually showing a scene that happens in the book, and I really enjoy the colour scheme, but it is slightly inaccurate. One character is wearing something they wouldn't be wearing in the book, which is fine. That makes sense, to make the character more recognizable (although it would have annoyed the crud out of me as a kid). But the other thing is... Isaveth is described as "olive skinned" in the middle of a harsh probably based on Canada winter by Esmond's narration. That aspect is, ah. Not happening so much on the cover, or the cover of the last book.
They're gorgeous covers, don't get me wrong. I'm just looking a little sideways at that particular aspect.
Conclusion: While I have some concerns that I'm missing glaring microaggressions or maybe worse, I really enjoyed this. I know eleven year old me would have loved it, and it is a really fun read. The mystery is great, the magic setting is really fun, and there's a whole lot I enjoyed about it. I also think that this series has incredibly realistic depictions of poverty, and there are no easy fixes for that in it. I appreciate that. Some things I mentioned could definitely do with being a little more explicit, but overall, I find these very enjoyable. Strong three and a half roses, and I'll probably round it up on goodreads to four comfortably when I get around to posting this review over there.
Other notes:
- Is the city meant to be Toronto? Because that'd be cool.
- The epilogue of this is amazing. Seriously, I can't say anything because spoilers but wow.
- This title puts two songs in my head. "A Little Taste" by Skyler Stonestreet and "Familiar Taste of Poison" by Halestorm. They get mashed up together in my head and make this, I guess.
(Rounded down from three and a half.)
This was pretty much just what I wanted it be. It's really cute, a great mystery, and the setting continues to work great for the story. It's nice to read a book that's just good and that's what this was. I love the idea of combining magic with good old fashioned mysteries. I think kids would love this. Eleven year old me seriously would have devoured this and wanted like eight more books. I still wish there would be like eight more books, because I genuinely enjoyed this one.
Plot Talk: This one continues one of the larger plot threads from the last book and many of the smaller ones. The continuity is wonderful, honestly. I won't go into too much details because I don't want to end up spoiler territory, but this one wraps up everything from the first book without being too neat and tidy. Everything is exciting and fresh, and this is my least favourite part of the review process so let's move on.
Characters: A new thing happens in this book! We get to switch POVs from strictly Isaveth's to Esmond's POV as well, and that allows us to see things that Isaveth isn't present for. I like that despite that, the book kept only to Isaveth or Esmond, not anyone else. It pretty much would have been impossible to have Esmond's POV in the last book, or it would have ruined one of the surprises at the end, and the tension of that surprise. But it's nice that there wasn't random headhopping, and just our two main characters. The POV choices worked for me.
I still adore the relationships in this, especially the relationship between Isaveth and her sisters. There is a good amount of female characters in this, including several new ones, and the book does take some time to give us a new female friendship for Isaveth, and I love that that was included, because it's so important. And while you get a touch of romance in this one, it's handled well, and it's not so over the top that I think it's too much. While a tiny bit predictable, romance being built on trust, friendship, and mutual respect is always a good thing to show.
PG-13 stuff: Dude straight up gets shot in this and dies, and it's not really "off-screen". Plus the usual mystery stuff like kidnapping and the poisoning mentioned in the title. Sensitive readers may be upset by that, but it's not graphic.
Cons, complaints, bad stuff, etc.: I wish some of the people had been described a little better at certain times. Specifically, I think sometimes it's hard to tell if some characters are meant to be characters of colour or not. I choose to error on the "absolutely they are" side, but I don't think it's quite clear enough in context especially considering the inherant subconscious bias that we white people have while reading (and the autho is white as well).
I think that kind of ties into one of the bigger things I feel conflicted about, and that's if Isaveth being Moshite, which is clearly meant to be Jewish, but isn't actually called Jewish, is problematic or okay. Because, like, there are elements in this that are reminscent of Harry Potter in the magic school and such, and who wouldn't want to read Harry Potter if Harry was a Jewish girl??? Since I'm totally not the one who should be deciding this stuff, I'm looking for reviews from Jewish reviewers, and I'm just not finding anything, so shouting out to you guys - what do you think of this one? Does ths make you uncomfortable, or are you cool with it?
As such, I'm raising that element specifically as a concern, but neither taking points off my review of it nor giving points for it.
Oh, and there wasn't any fatphobia in this one. Very few fat characters as far as I can remember that were around for any significant time, if any, though.
Cover comments: This cover is very cute, and props for it actually showing a scene that happens in the book, and I really enjoy the colour scheme, but it is slightly inaccurate. One character is wearing something they wouldn't be wearing in the book, which is fine. That makes sense, to make the character more recognizable (although it would have annoyed the crud out of me as a kid). But the other thing is... Isaveth is described as "olive skinned" in the middle of a harsh probably based on Canada winter by Esmond's narration. That aspect is, ah. Not happening so much on the cover, or the cover of the last book.
They're gorgeous covers, don't get me wrong. I'm just looking a little sideways at that particular aspect.
Conclusion: While I have some concerns that I'm missing glaring microaggressions or maybe worse, I really enjoyed this. I know eleven year old me would have loved it, and it is a really fun read. The mystery is great, the magic setting is really fun, and there's a whole lot I enjoyed about it. I also think that this series has incredibly realistic depictions of poverty, and there are no easy fixes for that in it. I appreciate that. Some things I mentioned could definitely do with being a little more explicit, but overall, I find these very enjoyable. Strong three and a half roses, and I'll probably round it up on goodreads to four comfortably when I get around to posting this review over there.
Other notes:
- Is the city meant to be Toronto? Because that'd be cool.
- The epilogue of this is amazing. Seriously, I can't say anything because spoilers but wow.
- This title puts two songs in my head. "A Little Taste" by Skyler Stonestreet and "Familiar Taste of Poison" by Halestorm. They get mashed up together in my head and make this, I guess.
May 2, 2020
Uncommon Magic is an amazing series! I loved it. Definitely one of my faves😍🙈.
September 28, 2016
Review to come
February 21, 2017
This is such a good Middle Grade series.
Excellent, complete characters? Check.
Familiar yet interesting worldbuilding? Check.
Discussions about the impact of corrupt governments, the ways in which injustice perpetuates itself, religious prejudice, social ostracism, the power of rumour and assumption, income inequality and privilege? Check.
Title that is applicable to actionable plot and ALSO the characters' journeys? Check.
Kick-ass mystery? Check.
A very deep desire on my part for book three? Check AND check.
Excellent, complete characters? Check.
Familiar yet interesting worldbuilding? Check.
Discussions about the impact of corrupt governments, the ways in which injustice perpetuates itself, religious prejudice, social ostracism, the power of rumour and assumption, income inequality and privilege? Check.
Title that is applicable to actionable plot and ALSO the characters' journeys? Check.
Kick-ass mystery? Check.
A very deep desire on my part for book three? Check AND check.
August 17, 2021
***This review does contain spoilers for book 1, A Pocket Full of Murder***
I loved A Pocket Full of Murder, and A Little Taste of Poison did not disappoint as a sequel.
Honestly, I am so sad that this series is over. I love everything about it--the characters, the plot, the unique magic systems--all of it. I want more adventures of Isaveth and Esmond in my life.
A Little Taste of Poison picks up a little bit after A Pocket Full of Murder. Isaveth and Esmond are still trying to find the evidence they need to convict of Eryx of his crimes, and Isaveth has been granted a scholarship to the college so that she can learn sagery.
In A Pocket Full of Murder, we get to learn a lot about Common Magic, which is done essentailly through baking. In A Little Taste of Poison, we get to learn more about Sagery, which is kind of like jewelry making. I love the magic systems R. J. created for this series. They are so unqiue and so fun. It was super neat to get to learn more about Sagery in A Little Taste of Poison.
The characters were amazing, of course. I love them so much. They are fantastic. Also, Isaveth and Esmond are an adorable ship. I love them.
The plot was super fun. While certain elements of the mystery were essentially already known (such as who the poisoner was), other elements still had to be figured out (such as how the person was poisoned).
My own "issue" with A Little Taste of Poison would be the epilogue. I feel like it can be read two different ways: one way concludes the series, and the other way makes it feel like the series should continue. At first when I read it, I thought that there was going to be another book. But that might have been because I want the series to be longer. :)
Overall, A Little Taste of Poison is a fantastic book. I love this duology, and R. J. is one of my favorite authors. Also, if she were to ever write anything set in this world, or start a new series about Isaveth and Esmond, I'd read it in a heartbeat.
Cautions: light romance; one kiss; brief, non-graphic moderate violence
I loved A Pocket Full of Murder, and A Little Taste of Poison did not disappoint as a sequel.
Honestly, I am so sad that this series is over. I love everything about it--the characters, the plot, the unique magic systems--all of it. I want more adventures of Isaveth and Esmond in my life.
A Little Taste of Poison picks up a little bit after A Pocket Full of Murder. Isaveth and Esmond are still trying to find the evidence they need to convict of Eryx of his crimes, and Isaveth has been granted a scholarship to the college so that she can learn sagery.
In A Pocket Full of Murder, we get to learn a lot about Common Magic, which is done essentailly through baking. In A Little Taste of Poison, we get to learn more about Sagery, which is kind of like jewelry making. I love the magic systems R. J. created for this series. They are so unqiue and so fun. It was super neat to get to learn more about Sagery in A Little Taste of Poison.
The characters were amazing, of course. I love them so much. They are fantastic. Also, Isaveth and Esmond are an adorable ship. I love them.
The plot was super fun. While certain elements of the mystery were essentially already known (such as who the poisoner was), other elements still had to be figured out (such as how the person was poisoned).
My own "issue" with A Little Taste of Poison would be the epilogue. I feel like it can be read two different ways: one way concludes the series, and the other way makes it feel like the series should continue. At first when I read it, I thought that there was going to be another book. But that might have been because I want the series to be longer. :)
Overall, A Little Taste of Poison is a fantastic book. I love this duology, and R. J. is one of my favorite authors. Also, if she were to ever write anything set in this world, or start a new series about Isaveth and Esmond, I'd read it in a heartbeat.
Cautions: light romance; one kiss; brief, non-graphic moderate violence
March 27, 2024
I really enjoyed this sequel to A Pocket Full of Murder, but I’m so disappointed that there are only two books in this series (if you could call it that). I think there’s so much potential with the many characters, the magical school that Isaveth has really just started, and the politics of the city. I wonder if it was meant to be a trilogy or longer. Even though the author neatly solved many things (especially with an A+ epilogue) there are still some loose ends. I really enjoyed the dual narratives of what Isaveth was doing and what Esmond was doing as they each separately investigated but continued to communicate with and support each other. I only wish there were more stories about them to look forward to.
BC #26: hybrid genre (murder mystery + gaslamp fantasy)
BC #26: hybrid genre (murder mystery + gaslamp fantasy)
August 10, 2016
I entered a contest on Goodreads to win "A Little Taste of Poison" as I thought my grandchildren might like the book.
I was fortunate enough to win a copy and it looked so intriguing I read it first before giving it to them.
It would have been better had I read the first book “A Pocket Full of Murder” so I had the complete background. Nevertheless, there is enough reference to the first book that I think you can read “A Little Taste of Poison” on it’s own.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book as Isaveth and Esmond, her partner in crime work together to solve another mystery. I think kids of any age will enjoy this book filled with spell making and intrigued.
I was fortunate enough to win a copy and it looked so intriguing I read it first before giving it to them.
It would have been better had I read the first book “A Pocket Full of Murder” so I had the complete background. Nevertheless, there is enough reference to the first book that I think you can read “A Little Taste of Poison” on it’s own.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book as Isaveth and Esmond, her partner in crime work together to solve another mystery. I think kids of any age will enjoy this book filled with spell making and intrigued.
October 1, 2016
I LOVED this book and the first one "A Pocket Full of Murder." I've always loved books with murder and twisted plots, but this one is by far one of my favorites. Isaveth and Esmond are the perfect crime solving team!
So, in this sequel to "A Pocket Full of Murder" Isaveth has started with a scholarship at the Tarreton college. But soon her secret that she's Moshite has leaked and the public is furious. And Esmond is still struggling to prove Eryx is guilty of murdering Master Orien when his father falls into a fatal illness. Can he and Isaveth get proof against Eryx before the Sagelord dies and Eryx becomes ruler?
So, in this sequel to "A Pocket Full of Murder" Isaveth has started with a scholarship at the Tarreton college. But soon her secret that she's Moshite has leaked and the public is furious. And Esmond is still struggling to prove Eryx is guilty of murdering Master Orien when his father falls into a fatal illness. Can he and Isaveth get proof against Eryx before the Sagelord dies and Eryx becomes ruler?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews