I’ve often thought that mainstream sociologists miss the boat by failing to recognize how much of what goes on in and around pro sports, from the perspective of participants, chroniclers and fans, can be seen, appreciated and studied as archetypes for life in general. Such issues are very much present, albeit not necessarily appreciated (possibly not even by the author) in “Gunslinger.”
Presumably, those who read this review (aside, perhaps, from Goodreads friends wondering what the heck I’m babbling about this time) knows Brett Favre is a famous Quarterback and although not necessarily the absolute greatest in any single category, was one of the most impressive and significant in the era in which he played (pretty much the 1990s-2000s). What’s most noteworthy about him was captured by the title; in the context of the way pro football is played in this generation, Favre was notorious (for better and/or worse) as just that, a gunslinger.
Modern football is an incredibly disciplined regimented endeavor with the greatest success in the game being achieved by New England Patriots head coach and grand high exalted mystic poobah Bill Belichick and his well-known manta “Do your job.” As admirable as it may be to understand and see the big picture, what really counts with him is a player’s willingness and ability to consistently do exactly what he is told to do. If a wide receiver is supposed to run at a 45 degree angle to the line of scrimmage until he’s traveled 12 yard from the scrimmage, stop, turn and face the Quarterback, then that’s what he is supposed to do. If he does it consistently and holds onto the ball if its thrown to him, he can have a good career. If he sometimes runs 40 degrees, sometimes turns at 11 yards instead of 12, he’s not likely to last long. Even the process of improvisation is regimented, how and under what circumstances the quarterback can change the play at the scrimmage and the parameters of potential changes. Compare all this with how football is played among kids: “Everybody go deep. I’ll throw to whoever I can find who’re open.”
Brett Favre excelled in the regimented world of pro football despite the fact that his in his heart, he always remained the kid who wanted to just tell team mates to go deep and that he’ll figure out how to get the ball to somebody. That he lasted at all at the pro level is somewhat amazing. So much, much, much, more so that he became a legend and a Hall of Famer, despite the fact that hos coaches often wanted to wring his neck for all the gunslinging he did.
Maybe it’s just a matter of me empathizing with a guy like that because of my own gunslinging tendencies, where, when I worked at a mega-size corporation (Reuters) I often irritated people I wanted to talk to by walking up to them and asking if they could spare a minute rather than having gone on Outlook to reserve a conference room and schedule a meeting, or when I was asked regarding a new product I was trying to develop what revenues would be after five years and I answered “Damned if I know. Can I get back to you in five years?” (Not my fault; I went to work for a tiny dot-com that had pizza eating and hot dog eating contests but we were acquired, and then the company that bought us was acquired by Reuters.)
There are Brett Favres everywhere in the world, some we love and some we hate, some who succeed and some who fail. Some are obscure. Others are famous and revered (Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos, Warren Buffett). Others are famous and reviled (Travis Kalanik, Donald Trump). Others make you scratch your head and go “WTF?” (see, e.g. baseball player Manuel Puig).
I love reading biographies and books that focus on people like this. In today’s world with more information and procedures than we’ve ever had (I’m sure many a medieval monk would look at us today and say “Hey, can you guys just Chill!”), it’s important that we not lost sight of our gunslingers, who they are, how they get to be the way they are and what makes them tick. Favre is not the only gunslinger who has been written about and I’ve read (and reviewed on Goodreads others from other areas of life), but in terms of sports generally and pro football particularly, this book is a must read.