Darkly refreshing...
Overall, I was pleasantly surprised with this second volume of Nightscript. I felt the content actually came in a step above the previous issue.
One of the biggest things that impressed me was the editor's choice in stories. This anthology, unlike many anthologies I've read, wasn't characterized by an overbearing presence of author favoritism--to the point of providing diminishing returns, in terms of story quality. Hence the word "refreshing," I applaud Mr. Muller's effort to present stories based entirely upon their merit. This seems to be the benchmark Nightscript has set for itself, and I hope it continues this way.
Of the stories, there was certainly a mixed bag, which I think holds to tradition for any good anthology, regardless of theme or genre. I appreciate an editor's choice to present a variety of literary styles within a volume, which Mr. Muller certainly did. Although I can't say I liked all of the stories in this anthology, I do like what the editor has done. Variety is the spice of life, after all.
The range in these stories ran from tenuously weird, to outright horror. In my opinion, I sometimes feel that the "weird" genre is often represented by stories that are either entirely plot-less and nonsensical; or meaningful to the said genre only at the very end. Nothing makes me want to spoon my eyeballs out more than when I read 29 pages of mindless, god-forsaken boredom, and then 1 page (the last page) of pure shock and awe. (So why do I keep doing it, you might ask?) Again, this is just my lousy opinion only, and please forgive my digression. But the point, is that Nightscript 2 contains this "mixed bag" of stories, a complete variety, which I find highly admirable--even if I don't like them all. (I am aware that just because I don't enjoy the urge to disengage my optical nerves, doesn't mean that others feel the same.) But for even the stories that I did not like--nay, HATED--they were admittedly very well written.
Ultimately, there were plenty of stories in this volume that I found highly entertaining, well worth the buy. And as an additional bonus, the presentation was truly satisfying--which seems to be another benchmark Mr. Muller has set for himself. The editing was borderline flawless, the book itself was aesthetically pleasing (it even smelled good), and the artwork was original. Combined, that's why I am forced (with gun to my head--someone please help me!) to give this anthology a 4 star review.