I've been requesting lots of Who HQ books for a friend of mine, who is 101 years and seeking books to read. They're a nice length and have nice print size and spacing, and they're numerous on a wide variety of interesting people and places. She's enjoying them and I'm enjoying picking out titles I hope she'll enjoy.
We were talking about middle names during one of my through-the-window screen visits recently, my friend's middle name is Lucille and we got to talking about I Love Lucy. I have never seen an episode! So anyway, we both read this. As usual, it's a compact biography containing facts, highlights, and interesting tidbits on the subject - the life of Lucille Ball. But this one left me with more questions than usual, which is why it doesn't rank as high for me as other Who books.
And to be fully fair via honesty here, I'm less impacted or impressed by Who subjects whose main accomplishment is rising to money and fame. I'm not a big fan of celebrity. I realize that Lucille Ball accomplished more than this by making millions of people laugh, and if I had been one of those people (rather than someone who has never seen her shows) I may have felt more sentimental.
I always ask myself when reading these books, why was this person chosen as a subject? Sometimes it's obvious without asking. Sometimes I wonder a little more. Usually there is a theme of perseverance, of work ethic, following dreams, trailblazing, try, try again! That is present here. Lucille Ball was not an instant success. She had to keep at her dreams for a long time before seeing them come to fruition. Go, Lucy! On the other hand, the book emphasizes the fact that she lacked talent as a singer and dancer, highlights her long legs as the reason she was hired as a Chesterfield girl, tells a story about her stuffing her bra to try to get an acting role (lined up posing in swimwear to be inspected by a male doing the hiring) and expresses her continued vanity over her legs. I didn't like the tone. While this is the truth of the way our world used to be and very much still is, it's not the message I want replayed for my daughter.
Of course, Lucy eventually finds her niche, breaks barriers, and becomes successful while being uniquely herself. This is good. Use your wit, kids. Not your body.