I bought this book because I did like the author's first book about the four personalities, and thought it would be fun for my husband and I to read this couples version of the book together. I write this negative review with the acknowledgement, first and foremost, that I really like the four personalities and have learned a lot by understanding that I am a choleric/melancholy! I am not critiquing the four personalities, but rather the author's HUGE bias in the book towards women, as well as the author's inconsistency. I honestly don't even want to give this book one star - it deserves zero stars. We did not even finish this book, it was so bad (but we did read over half of it).
I was increasingly upset while reading this book over the fact that MANY of her stories (if not all of them) were heavily sexist. I was also upset at the lack of female representations for cholerics - like she expect all natural leaders to be male. In the same vein, most of the phlegmatics in her stories were female, and my husband is a phlegmatic, so he did not feel represented at all.
That wasn't the worst of it though. I was really disturbed that in her numerous stories about couples having fights where the men and women both acted ridiculous almost EXCLUSIVELY ended with the woman needing to make some change or overlook some personality trait of her husband's. I kept reading hoping that it would even out, and sometimes the author would call on the husband to change or make an adjustment or overlook his wife's personality trait, but no! 99% of the stories in this book went like this: the husband acts like a complete fool, the wife reacts negatively, the wife learns about the four personalities, the wife changes and accepts her husband's personality, he never changes, everything is peaceful and perfect the end. That was the pattern for almost EVERY story, regardless of the personality she was writing about.
Now this was written from a Christian perspective, and that made it even more disturbing for me. There is a subtle and evil message in the conservative church that if a marriage is not thriving, the woman is at fault, and must be more obliging, more submissive, more affirming of her husband's leadership etc etc and the list goes on. Women are overtly at fault if a marriage isn't working, is the subtle message put forth in many sermons, Bible studies, and teachings in the church. Sadly, this book also fit the bill. My husband and I were both honestly SHOCKED how often in the stories a husband would act SINFUL, and his behavior get labeled by the author as "part of his personality," with the wife saving the day by "accepting her husband's unique personality" and basically allowing his sinful behavior to continue.
Now I get that we all have certain sins we're prone to because of our personality and the way God made us, but I 100% reject the notion that any sin is acceptable just because it's a personality thing, and what angered me the most was the heavily gendered bias making men the ones women must accept, and not the other way around. Women reading this book who are struggling with their husbands' sinful or even abusive behavior are going to be misled into thinking they can save their relationship by overlooking his flaws, being sweeter, and fitting themselves into their (usually phlegmatic or sanguine, according to the book) personality boxes. Honestly disgusted me, and I would never recommend this author to anyone, even though I really do like the idea of the four personalities. Ms. Littauer should be ashamed of herself for being so sexist and not giving equal representation to all the genders within all the personalities.