Hmmm, it wasn't terrible. It was pretty intensely unrealistic though, for a book about a kid fighting against real-life barriers of fulfilling his dream. Like, INCREDIBLY unrealistic. And I feel like a hypocrite complaining about that, because fiction is all about the unrealistic and the fantastical: that is why we love fiction! It was just so jarring in a book that is set up to present a real kid with real struggles. But maybe it would be okay if parents sit down with their kid after reading this book and explain how things don't actually work that way, despite what the book says to the contrary.
Another issue I had was the way this middle-school kid, over the course of the novel (which probably I think took a school year, but certainly didn't read that way) wrote 4 or 5 novels that EVERYONE (including grownups and random strangers) loved and bought enthusiastically. I get that this is fiction, but I feel that this is giving kids a really warped perspective of the writing process. The reality is, for most people (including the greatest authors of our time) writing novels is back-breaking, heartbreaking, incredibly difficult hard work that times time and energy and so many re-writes and edits. It takes time and experience to become a good author, lots of practice, lots of fails, and lots and lots of hard work. It doesn't happen (like this book suggest) with a first draft that just APPEARS fully amazing and captivating for all audiences. Also, in reality, not everyone likes the books, and a lot of people struggle to sell their books (regardless of age, so how much odder is it that this boy's novels, printed on an old printer in his garage, were selling like crazy?). While the other unrealistic aspects of the novel bothered me but could be excused as part of "fiction," this was not acceptable. This is giving children a really unrealistic example of what writing (and selling) books is like, and I fear it will only result in a lot of potential and aspirating young authors to be discouraged and disillusioned at the first sign of hard work or bad reviews.