The World of Bad Gillo The World of Bad Bell FIRST First Edition Thus, First Printing. Published by Bell Publishing, 1968. Octavo. Hardcover. Book is very good with a slight spine lean and light edgewear. Seller 334216 Literature
Born in Trieste to a Gorizian father and a Genoese mother, Dorfles graduated in medicine, specializing in psychiatry. He was a professor in aesthetics at the University of Trieste, Milan and Cagliari and, in 1948, established the MAC (Movimento per l'arte concreta) with artists Atanasio Soldati, Galliano Mazzon, Gianni Monnet, and Bruno Munari. His paintings were displayed in two personal exhibitions held in Milan in 1949 and 1950 and also in numerous collective MAC exhibitions in the 1950s. In 1956 Dorfles co-founded the ADI (Associazione per il disegno industriale).
Having stopped painting, he devoted himself to the study of aesthetics and art criticism, dealing with the problem of the vanguard, the relationship between art and industry, analizing artistic phenomena, and tastes in the contemporary society. According to Dorfles, aesthetics should focus on culture as a whole, which combine elements of fantasy, symbolic, metaphorical and even mythical suggestions. Among his major works, L'architettura moderna (1954), Kitsch (originally published in Italian in 1968 and translated in English the following year), La moda della moda (1984), Il feticcio quotidiano (1988), Horror pleni. La (in)civiltà del rumore (2008). In the same period, however, Dorfles continued to hold personal exhibitions: in 1986 his works were displayed in Milan, in 1988 in Aosta, and in 1996 in Rome.[3]
In 2010, for his 100th birthday celebrations, L'avanguardia tradita took place at the Royal Palace of Milan. Another exhibition was held in 2012 at the Milan Triennale, organized by Dorfles itself, entitled Dorfles. Kitsch - oggi il kitsch.[4]
At 103, Dorfles published a new book (Poesie, Campanotto Editore, 2013), containing previously unpublished poems written from 1941 to 1952.[5] In 2013 he was among the artists that designed the Tibetan pavilion at the 55th Venice Biennale.[6]
This is WAY more information than I required. I really wasn't looking for a textbook about kitsch. I just wanted lots of pictures of stuff to make my own collection of tacky shit seem less preposterous.
1.) An anachronistic Greco-Renaissance wooden chess set made in Italy, featuring Middle-Ages peons and Renaissance-styled depictions of classical mythological gods and goddesses (this was my idea of a "classy" chess set when I bought it 30 years ago); it somehow makes the game seem more "important." The chess set is housed in a wooden and glass shadowbox frame that I devised. 2.) A statue of an Indian goddess (sorry, I don't know which one) bought on clearance at a discount department store. She was holding a candle at one point, in those oddly snaky distended arms. I think this is supposed to be something to smoke drugs by. I should have stowed this along when I was dating that dope-fiend girl earlier this year. 3.) A Christmas-scene shadowbox I made two holidays ago when I was bored and living alone. It turned out OK, considering I rushed to get it done. I knew it was kitsch and was all right with that. The whole idea was to recapture the simple fantasies of childhood.
To my delight, some of the chess pieces in my classy chess set are shown as lawn gnomes in this pretentiously amusing look at the world of tasteless art and the commercial objects fashioned or derived from higher art to be art. In fact, on page 285 we have this, a caption of a photo of a chess set that looks suspiciously like my own: "A chess set representing figures from ancient Rome gives the kitsch-man the joy of rediscovering 'historical culture' as he plays.'"
Hear that? I'm the Kitsch-Mann, bitches! Better than being the Ass-to-Ass Man, from Requiem for a Dream, I guess.
So far, the book more or less states the obvious in something of a roundabout way: that there is a great divide in the world of high and pop art. Gillo Dorfles, in so many large words and clause-laden paragraphs of Jamesian proportions, basically says, in a nutshell, that most people are stupid philistines. But we know that.
As I read it, some things occurred to me: The taste in the arts is no longer divided merely by wealth, status and power, because, in fact, a great deal of new money is going into the coffers of people with worse than plebian tastes. Today's robber barons, it seems, do not have respect for education and culture and the traditional sense of nobless oblige, or the notion of elevating themselves and the masses who enriched them. In the new paradigm, the Rand-ian Darwinism of the neocons and their Born Again fellow travelers, the market is the only good, and pandering and instant gratification render quality irrelevant, thus is the reality.
Gilles forwards the idea that kitsch really did not exist in the past, before, perhaps the industrial age. He doesn't really go on to parse this idea out, but it did make me wonder why this might be. Art in the past would have been produced by craftsmen of demonstrable skill and would have fit into the tenor of the times, whereas today's diffusion allows for plunder and pandering, because the mass market that exists now did not exist in earlier times, and anyone who would have been interested in any form of art back then would have constituted an extreme elite; most people were too busy surviving to worry about it. Nonetheless, I cannot believe that some peasants in the vast span of time would not have crafted from, say, a whittled piece of wood, a crude figure of the Christ or of farm animals that might very well have been considered kitsch by the elites of those times, and which today would be classed with some respect as folk art. Kitsch might have to do more with its prevalence and its mass acceptance, which is something that did not exist among the isolated societies of the past.
The book expressly steers away from literary criticism, and had it tackled it in a new edition it would no doubt include the pastiches of Stephenie Meyer and Dan Brown.
Dorfles struggles mightily in the book to define absolutes of good taste and bad taste, and rather artfully eludes the notion that any modern mid-century art could exhibit any qualities of the latter. In the end, it all has to do with education, exposure, and "sophistication." The latter term cannot help but be inherently condescending, or at least fraught with peril for definition, and this book in many ways shows its datedness. It came out in the late '60s, too soon to ponder the Velvet Elvis phenomenon, or indeed, any of the objects fashioned to honor the King. But it *does* include plenty of familiar and funny examples of kitsch. Indeed, some of these have become so familiar that the thought of them as kitsch nowadays seems less obvious. The statue of Atlas at Rockefeller Center in New York, for instance, would seem to lend an artistic touch to the surrounding architecture and public space, but Dorfles sees it as something reimagined grotesquely out of its original context, something meant to depict the might of commerce, something apart from its original mythological meaning.
FINALE: The book wore me down. The dense academic style of the writing does not engender clarity. Some interesting pictures and concepts (oddly, there's nothing about Las Vegas in it) along the way, but desperately in need of updating and or a complete re-write in language that is understandable. I would recommend the book to researchers of kitsch. For everyone else, I'd say pass.
3.5 stars. The essay by Broch is suggestive and quite interesting, though not definitive in any way. The introductory study by Dorfles is also interesting, though inconclusive - and a bit dated and stiff in translation. After a while, the text of this book got a bit tedious - but a review of the wonderful photos, showing instances of kitsch in all spheres of life -- from politics to birth to funerary to advertising to pornokitsch - are illuminating, and make the point more clearly than the text itself. Worth an evening of deep browsing.
Great pictures. The essays tend to be a bit dull and outdated. The authors all have subtly differing schemas for identifying kitsch which gets a little confusing at times. First time I can say a book felt distinctly Pre-Baudrillard, as in it's clawing at a concept it can't quite grasp yet, which is yet to be officially inaugurated and articulated. So instead the authors tend to refer back to Benjamin and McLuhan when not simply treating their own aesthetic judgements as self-evident facts. This latter version was often amusing but basically evacuated my mind the moment I had finished reading it, whereas the analytical attempts to form a unified theory of kitsch were more interesting. Of these I thought that the most convincing was in the Kitsch and Art essay where the author contends that kitsch lies in the transformation of aesthetic experience into "information" with his clear example being the Mona Lisa. This seems to my mind to be the best working definition, containing a material critique of the new media systems which make kitsch possible per McLuhan, Benjamin and co.m and which would be borne out so terribly in todays un-aesthetic media landscape wholly colonised by the taste-insensitive robots of high finance and information systems. I found myself raising an eyebrow at some of the more naive seeming claims in this book, wondering whether the authors would simply self-combust if exposed to the modern world in which all art has been fully drained of meaning and all culture flattened by the Internet. Now that everything is always already information first and foremost, with meaning an arbitrary supplement (usually reducible to the most low-hanging moral didacticism if considered at all) I imagine many people would find this book incomprehensible. Many of the examples which the authors take to be self-evident examples of tasteless crap, like Batman comics, are today taken dead seriously by no small part of the population, with superhero shlock having fully absorbed the cinema and artistic landscape of mass-culture. The authors references to a Marxist imperative to overhaul culture feels in this way the most strikingly naive observation of all. Again this was pre-Baudrillard so they were working with what was at hand, before his famous formulation of the mass which "knows it knows nothing and doesn't want to know anything, knows it had no power and doesn't want power", but it is a bit hard to imagine how the authors expected their elitist tastes to ever be received en masse. I guess this was before Nietzsche became fashionable again because it seems more fitting to use his critique of democracy as flattening out society into a uniform mediocrity, bringing down the heights reached by a few elites to the level of the self-satisfied herd. After all the free market which replaced elite state institutions of art was vaunted as the democratization of art (they termed it neo-liberalism for a reason) and look where it's got us. Today there is no difference between folk art, kitsch, ironic art, pop culture merchandise, outsider art, fine art, the avant-garde etc., the boundaries have all been dissolved by the new information systems of liquid modernity and there's no going back - AI art just represents a more overtly disgusting form of this change that had already taken place at the level of culture and the imagination.
too bored to finish it and also have a sneaking suspicion that just anything the authors found personally objectionable was labeled kitsch in an effort to feel self important.
Published in1969, the essays are a combination of pretentious nonsense and a demonstration of pointing out the obvious. Please...is it really fair to call out advertising and so much of film as kitsch? Their examples were absurd ... People in no way would confuse them for art. The authors crouch smugly behind their "expertise".
Take-home revelation for me was esteemed film historian Lotte Eisner seems to be forming entire film-critique opinions based solely on STUDIO STILL PHOTOGRAPHS, as to whether a production was "kitsch" or not. Pre-VCR (or presumably, even pre-TV reruns) apparently limited her to only that medium. First Eisner I've ever read; rather disillusioning there.
If you ever wanted to find out what's the difference between art and kitsch this is the right book for you: examples of bad taste and a definition of kitsch, elements of falseness, myth and kitsch, art with a message, transpositions, politics, birth & family, death, religious trappings, tourism, advertising, pornokitsch and morals, styling and architecture, traditional kitsch. This book might be regarded as a guideline. Many good photos and descriptions to form your own opinion. Highly recommended!
What a slog to get through! Despite the credibility of all the authors in this book, the arguments were weak when the definition of kitsch was far too loose.
I did find the essay Clement Greenberg wrote on politics and kitsch interesting and worth unpacking further. Reading this from the 21st century, there is definitely a resurgence of kitsch in propaganda, especially under the MAGA Crowd/Trump through AI "art," which is always in bad taste. Other than that, the rest of the book was too wordy and needed more of a direct line of argument in order to be more compelling.
Gillo Dorfles spends the whole of Kitsch: The World of Bad Taste arguing that most of what we call common sense is just habit in a nice outfit, and I mostly bought it. A couple of examples feel cherry-picked, but the core point stuck with me for days. Good for anyone who likes having their assumptions poked, bad for people who want the other side given equal time.
The classic work on the subject, where most of us got started beginning in the 1970s, although the term has a longer history (and Dorfles includes two significant earlier essays, by Hermann Broch and Clement Greenberg). It's mainly a philosophical and aesthetic approach, but keeps the analysis fairly light while providing numerous illustrations. This may be more of an historical relic at this point, but still interesting.
Of course I liked it! In the 70's I lived with an artist, and this book was on the shelf, so I just had to read it. It truly is an encyclopedic survey of bad taste through the ages, and the reasons for its popularity.