What do you think?
Rate this book
Rabbi Akiva: Sage of the Talmud
From the prizewinning Jewish Lives series, a compelling and lucid account of the life and teachings of Rabbi Akiva—a founder of rabbinic Judaism and one of the most beloved heroes of Jewish history
"Holtz expertly teases Akiva’s core character traits from a plethora of midrashic sources to fashion a complex, yet likeable, religious leader who is at once pragmatist and dreamer, punctilious intellectual and passionate lover."—Rabbi Dr. Harvey Belovski, Jewish Chronicle
"A book to be read again and again."—Burton L. Visotzky, The Forward
Born in the Land of Israel around the year 50 C.E., Rabbi Akiva was the greatest rabbi of his time and one of the most important influences on Judaism as we know it today. Traditional sources tell how he was raised in poverty and unschooled in religious tradition but began to learn the Torah as an adult. In the aftermath of the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans in 70 C.E., he helped shape a new direction for Judaism through his brilliance and his character. Mystic, legalist, theologian, and interpreter, he disputed with his colleagues in dramatic fashion yet was admired and beloved by his peers. Executed by Roman authorities for his insistence on teaching Torah in public, he became the exemplar of Jewish martyrdom.
Drawing on the latest historical and literary scholarship, this book goes beyond older biographies, untangling a complex assortment of ancient sources to present a clear and nuanced portrait of Talmudic hero Rabbi Akiva.
About Jewish
Jewish Lives is a prizewinning series of interpretative biography designed to explore the many facets of Jewish identity. Individual volumes illuminate the imprint of Jewish figures upon literature, religion, philosophy, politics, cultural and economic life, and the arts and sciences. Subjects are paired with authors to elicit lively, deeply informed books that explore the range and depth of the Jewish experience from antiquity to the present.
In 2014, the Jewish Book Council named Jewish Lives the winner of its Jewish Book of the Year Award, the first series ever to receive this award.
More praise for Jewish
"Excellent." –New York Times
"Exemplary." –Wall Street Journal
"Distinguished." –New Yorker
"Superb." –The Guardian
"Holtz expertly teases Akiva’s core character traits from a plethora of midrashic sources to fashion a complex, yet likeable, religious leader who is at once pragmatist and dreamer, punctilious intellectual and passionate lover."—Rabbi Dr. Harvey Belovski, Jewish Chronicle
"A book to be read again and again."—Burton L. Visotzky, The Forward
Born in the Land of Israel around the year 50 C.E., Rabbi Akiva was the greatest rabbi of his time and one of the most important influences on Judaism as we know it today. Traditional sources tell how he was raised in poverty and unschooled in religious tradition but began to learn the Torah as an adult. In the aftermath of the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans in 70 C.E., he helped shape a new direction for Judaism through his brilliance and his character. Mystic, legalist, theologian, and interpreter, he disputed with his colleagues in dramatic fashion yet was admired and beloved by his peers. Executed by Roman authorities for his insistence on teaching Torah in public, he became the exemplar of Jewish martyrdom.
Drawing on the latest historical and literary scholarship, this book goes beyond older biographies, untangling a complex assortment of ancient sources to present a clear and nuanced portrait of Talmudic hero Rabbi Akiva.
About Jewish
Jewish Lives is a prizewinning series of interpretative biography designed to explore the many facets of Jewish identity. Individual volumes illuminate the imprint of Jewish figures upon literature, religion, philosophy, politics, cultural and economic life, and the arts and sciences. Subjects are paired with authors to elicit lively, deeply informed books that explore the range and depth of the Jewish experience from antiquity to the present.
In 2014, the Jewish Book Council named Jewish Lives the winner of its Jewish Book of the Year Award, the first series ever to receive this award.
More praise for Jewish
"Excellent." –New York Times
"Exemplary." –Wall Street Journal
"Distinguished." –New Yorker
"Superb." –The Guardian
248 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2017
48 people are currently reading
176 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
November 15, 2025
This is a unique biography because it is the story of a person's life, a person who was only ever documented in tales passed down via oral tradition and eventually codified in text as part of the Mishna and Talmud. The author calls it an imagined biography.
What does that mean for us? It means that the stories about Akiva, while captivating, cannot truly be looked on as fact or as having happened at all. The main thing to glean from them is the character of Akiva.
In the story of his life (what's preserved) there are many contradictions, the most glaring being that in one story he arrives to Torah late in life (after having been married and having a son) and in another he is required by his wife to study Torah in order to marry her. Which one of these happened? Which is the truth? It doesn't matter. The elements that make each story distinctive and representative of Akiva’s character, these are what's most important. So you get broad strokes of who he was. Like looking at a scene through a kaleidoscope.
Who was he?
For one, he was a person with an innate depth of understanding when it came to the Torah. That's shown through his story by the well. He saw how the water had cut the stone, received an explanation of the natural phenomenon from nearby scholars based on the teachings of the Torah, and immediately saw how his heart would be worn down through Torah study.
Second, he was a master when it came to accepting criticism. His ability to receive feedback and be able to take it in with no resentment to the other party is to be admired. I liked the short comment a fellow rabbi made about Akiva: that to criticize him only leads to more admiration from him.
Third, that he was a highly sensitive man. That's best depicted in his approach to dealings with Rabbi Eliezer. Despite Eliezer’s contempt for Akiva, Akiva still showed profound respect. He made sure not to interrupt Eliezer's lessons if he arrived late to class, he respected Eliezer's boundaries when he chose to stop speaking to him, and he was most considerate when he delivered to Eliezer the news of his excommunication from the rabbinical community.
But beyond who Akiva was, the book also clearly outlines the legacy that he left behind.
The first is the model of the Jewish martyr and acceptance of the existence of evil alongside a deep belief and admiration in God. The story about Akiva's recitation of the Shema in the midst of torture was the unfortunate foundation for many similar scenes thereafter. To do so sincerely is a means of transcendence that shows a total faith and acceptance of God.
The second is of the Jewish tradition of close reading. It's not clear to me how the Torah was read and interpreted prior to Akiva but it's very clear that Akiva's approach of finding meaning in every sentence, word, and letter was instrumental in establishing the close reading practices of Judaism that then went on to influence Jewish professions and aspirations.
Although a short read (and ambiguous due to the nature of the material) I found this biography to be very engrossing and a good reflection of how Akiva lived and shaped his era.
What does that mean for us? It means that the stories about Akiva, while captivating, cannot truly be looked on as fact or as having happened at all. The main thing to glean from them is the character of Akiva.
In the story of his life (what's preserved) there are many contradictions, the most glaring being that in one story he arrives to Torah late in life (after having been married and having a son) and in another he is required by his wife to study Torah in order to marry her. Which one of these happened? Which is the truth? It doesn't matter. The elements that make each story distinctive and representative of Akiva’s character, these are what's most important. So you get broad strokes of who he was. Like looking at a scene through a kaleidoscope.
Who was he?
For one, he was a person with an innate depth of understanding when it came to the Torah. That's shown through his story by the well. He saw how the water had cut the stone, received an explanation of the natural phenomenon from nearby scholars based on the teachings of the Torah, and immediately saw how his heart would be worn down through Torah study.
Second, he was a master when it came to accepting criticism. His ability to receive feedback and be able to take it in with no resentment to the other party is to be admired. I liked the short comment a fellow rabbi made about Akiva: that to criticize him only leads to more admiration from him.
Third, that he was a highly sensitive man. That's best depicted in his approach to dealings with Rabbi Eliezer. Despite Eliezer’s contempt for Akiva, Akiva still showed profound respect. He made sure not to interrupt Eliezer's lessons if he arrived late to class, he respected Eliezer's boundaries when he chose to stop speaking to him, and he was most considerate when he delivered to Eliezer the news of his excommunication from the rabbinical community.
But beyond who Akiva was, the book also clearly outlines the legacy that he left behind.
The first is the model of the Jewish martyr and acceptance of the existence of evil alongside a deep belief and admiration in God. The story about Akiva's recitation of the Shema in the midst of torture was the unfortunate foundation for many similar scenes thereafter. To do so sincerely is a means of transcendence that shows a total faith and acceptance of God.
The second is of the Jewish tradition of close reading. It's not clear to me how the Torah was read and interpreted prior to Akiva but it's very clear that Akiva's approach of finding meaning in every sentence, word, and letter was instrumental in establishing the close reading practices of Judaism that then went on to influence Jewish professions and aspirations.
Although a short read (and ambiguous due to the nature of the material) I found this biography to be very engrossing and a good reflection of how Akiva lived and shaped his era.
December 13, 2021
This is an exceptional book regarding the founder of Rabbinic Judaism. It is a challenge since few sources are readily available but the author does a great job at trying to piece together what is available. As someone diving into Torah at a later age, it’s good to know there are those who started late but lived an exceptional life applying and acquiring Torah. The author does a good job at making the book accessible to all. Highly recommended!
October 11, 2019
A fascinating introduction to rabbinic Judaism's development through one of the men who helped form it.The author is pretty clear that the sources by which he brought together this text was traditional from classic biographical research. He wishes to understand more how the ancient stories of the man teach us about the culture rather than the man's actual life. Which of course would be near impossible to put together.
All and all this is well done and I advocate this book as one of the intro books for understanding Judaism’s development during the era of the roman empire’s hegemony
All and all this is well done and I advocate this book as one of the intro books for understanding Judaism’s development during the era of the roman empire’s hegemony
July 19, 2021
Thoughtful, well-researched take on the most famous Rabbi in the Talmud. A pleasure to revisit some classic stories and learn some obscure ones. Felt it could have been even longer, and I'd like to read a similar volume on bitter Rabbi Eliezer.
September 11, 2022
I found this book, Rabbi Akiva: Sage of the Talmud, by Barry W. Holtz, in the series "Jewish Lives." Akiva's story here is developed through ongoing references to the Babylonian Talmud and the Jerusalem Talmud. He was born poor and became the foremost scholar of the Torah in his times, a leading contributor to the Mishnah, to the point that the Talmud calls him the "Chief of Sages".
This is not a book to rush through. It is one to savor. The author repeats "We do not know -- and cannot know -- the year-by-year history of Akiva's life, but it is clear that the classic sources present him as a person whom his fellow students admired, both as a scholar and as a human being, and his reputation continued to grow as he left his years of preparation and became a rabbinic figure in his own right." (p. 106). He is viewed by his contemporaries as "a model for all Jews" (p. 107).
It is inspiring to me that Rabbi Akiva lived his life studying and speaking of the Torah, and that when persecutions came, he continued to teach the Torah. In the end, he gave his live because he would not yield to a Roman edict that forbade teaching the Torah, and after terrible torture, he died reciting the Shema Israel. His last words were "The Lord your God is One."
As I said, the book is well written, scholarly in presenting the sources, and inspiring in presenting the life and journey of one who understood that the great principle of the Torah was confined in the words "You shall love your neighbor as yourself."
This is not a book to rush through. It is one to savor. The author repeats "We do not know -- and cannot know -- the year-by-year history of Akiva's life, but it is clear that the classic sources present him as a person whom his fellow students admired, both as a scholar and as a human being, and his reputation continued to grow as he left his years of preparation and became a rabbinic figure in his own right." (p. 106). He is viewed by his contemporaries as "a model for all Jews" (p. 107).
It is inspiring to me that Rabbi Akiva lived his life studying and speaking of the Torah, and that when persecutions came, he continued to teach the Torah. In the end, he gave his live because he would not yield to a Roman edict that forbade teaching the Torah, and after terrible torture, he died reciting the Shema Israel. His last words were "The Lord your God is One."
As I said, the book is well written, scholarly in presenting the sources, and inspiring in presenting the life and journey of one who understood that the great principle of the Torah was confined in the words "You shall love your neighbor as yourself."
December 17, 2017
If you don't know anything about Mishnah, Talmud, ancient judaism, or the development of rabbinic judaism after the destruction of the temple, this is a good primer. Holtz's interpretations of the anecdotes about Akiva are interesting, but not illuminating. And it reads more like an undergraduate library research paper in parts. To make it worse, it's written like a recent college graduate who thinks they need to signpost the reader to death with the most obvious of instructions on how to follow the relatively easy argument the author is making. I was expecting a lot more; this is the same series with Avivah Zornberg's "Moses," so perhaps my expectations were too high.
December 17, 2025
I'm reading two biographies of Rabbi Akiva at the same time and managed to complete this one first, but as such, I find myself getting somewhat confused between the two, since they share accounts of similar events and statements. The big difference between the two is that this one seems the more topical, the less biographical. That's because of the author's method in writing the work.
You see, the problem with Akiva is that our information about him comes largely from the Talmud. In fact, he's referenced more than one thousand times in the Bablyonian Talmud and more than four hundred times in the shorter Jerusalem Talmud (at least as I remember the count both books gave). But those references are contradictory. They don't present any sort of biographical portrait as we would think of it. As such, knowing just who and what Akiva did is difficult--perhaps even impossible--although he was clearly important to rabbinic Judaism's formation.
While the other biography takes a chance on trying to sort truth from error, Holtz doesn't bother. He's more interested, as he says, in what the various portraits of Akiva say about the writers than what they say about Akiva. As such, all the contradictions are presented, but they are less often weighed. More often, Holtz discusses what they mean to the particular audience they are aimed at.
So some of the contractions (again, I may be mixing up books at this point, as both cover similar ground): Akiva was born poor but he ended up rich. He was anti-intellectual but ended up the most intellectual of all rabbis. His wife would only marry him if he went to a Jewish academy, or he went to a Jewish academy and abandoned his wife. He grew rich when his father-in-law, who disapproved of him early on, accepted him as a great rabbi and then gave him lots of money. Or he was poor until he remarried--the ex-wife of a Roman governor of Judea, the same one who would put him to death.
I mostly turned to Akiva because I wanted to know a bit more about the Bar Kochba revolt, which he supposedly supported. But Holtz only quotes one passage in that regard, and he's less certain--in fact, he seems rather tepid toward the idea--that Akiva actually contributed to the Jewish rebel cause. Maybe he leaned toward Bar Kochba because of his early experiences, but it doesn't seem like he actually encouraged uprising. When he is put to death, it is unclear whether that is after or before the war or during the war. He is put to death for not giving up the law, for preaching publically, which seems more likely after the war, but there are not any sources outside the Talmud that confirm that this was ever against the law. Was Akiva even put to death? Such are the many mysteries of this man both authors think one of the greatest Jewish thinkers/sages ever.
You see, the problem with Akiva is that our information about him comes largely from the Talmud. In fact, he's referenced more than one thousand times in the Bablyonian Talmud and more than four hundred times in the shorter Jerusalem Talmud (at least as I remember the count both books gave). But those references are contradictory. They don't present any sort of biographical portrait as we would think of it. As such, knowing just who and what Akiva did is difficult--perhaps even impossible--although he was clearly important to rabbinic Judaism's formation.
While the other biography takes a chance on trying to sort truth from error, Holtz doesn't bother. He's more interested, as he says, in what the various portraits of Akiva say about the writers than what they say about Akiva. As such, all the contradictions are presented, but they are less often weighed. More often, Holtz discusses what they mean to the particular audience they are aimed at.
So some of the contractions (again, I may be mixing up books at this point, as both cover similar ground): Akiva was born poor but he ended up rich. He was anti-intellectual but ended up the most intellectual of all rabbis. His wife would only marry him if he went to a Jewish academy, or he went to a Jewish academy and abandoned his wife. He grew rich when his father-in-law, who disapproved of him early on, accepted him as a great rabbi and then gave him lots of money. Or he was poor until he remarried--the ex-wife of a Roman governor of Judea, the same one who would put him to death.
I mostly turned to Akiva because I wanted to know a bit more about the Bar Kochba revolt, which he supposedly supported. But Holtz only quotes one passage in that regard, and he's less certain--in fact, he seems rather tepid toward the idea--that Akiva actually contributed to the Jewish rebel cause. Maybe he leaned toward Bar Kochba because of his early experiences, but it doesn't seem like he actually encouraged uprising. When he is put to death, it is unclear whether that is after or before the war or during the war. He is put to death for not giving up the law, for preaching publically, which seems more likely after the war, but there are not any sources outside the Talmud that confirm that this was ever against the law. Was Akiva even put to death? Such are the many mysteries of this man both authors think one of the greatest Jewish thinkers/sages ever.
August 17, 2023
A truly fabulous book -- history meets biography meets folklore studies meets literary criticism. Barry Holtz is adept at weaving these different threads into a fascinating tapestry about one of the most important people in ancient Jewish history.
It's also a really engaging, readable book, which does not go without saying when you're reading a book of such academic merit. My Talmud study group read this book together this summer, and all of us -- a wide-ranging group with very different reading backgrounds -- absolutely loved it.
Highly recommended!
It's also a really engaging, readable book, which does not go without saying when you're reading a book of such academic merit. My Talmud study group read this book together this summer, and all of us -- a wide-ranging group with very different reading backgrounds -- absolutely loved it.
Highly recommended!
February 18, 2025
Holtz deals with the contradictory tales of Akiva in rabbinic literature not by trying to reconcile them, but by asking, “What are the rabbis trying to communicate by telling this story about Akiva?” Sometimes, they’re trying to prove a point in a particular argument, other times, crafting a portrait of Akiva as a revolutionary (and therefore self-taught) thinker who profoundly shaped Rabbinic Judaism with his methodology.
June 4, 2022
Somewhat unsatisfactory at the outset as it relates Rabbi Akiva immediately to the mythological and mystical rabbinical superstar. However, the book continues and makes a convincing argument that, much like many historical figures, the fact and the embellishment are intentionally interwoven to create a character “worth” remembering in Talmudic discussion.
October 11, 2017
Very informative and interesting. I learned as much as I could from our limited information we have on him. Important figure in modern rabbinic Judaism.
March 11, 2018
A lovely look at the life of the great Rabbi Akiva from the perspective of answering: what did the rabbis of our texts intend to teach us with the model of Akiva?
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews