Set in 1447 Milan, The Bones You Have Cast Down is the story of seventeen year old Taria, removed from an orphanage by the Duchess of Milan to become part of her retinue. While in the duchess’s home, Taria comes in possession of a small painting of Guglielma, who appears to be a female pope. When Taria holds the painting, she is transported back 150 years to the time when Guglielma was revered. The duchess wants to discover whether the woman in the painting should be recognized as a saint and why her notoriety and adoration died, and assigns Taria the task.
The Bones You Have Cast Down had an interesting premise but it was lost in subplots, such as love interests, political conflicts, the attention of the duchess’s husband, and tarot cards, which did very little to support the main plot. They actually worked against the main plot by lengthening the time from when Taria originally went back in time and then is given permission by the duchess to learn about Guglielma. Some scenes were also under developed. I sometimes found myself wondering what their meaning was and hoped they would be made clear as I continued reading.
The Bones You Have Cast Down immersed me in the religious fervor of the medieval town and the duchess’s court but could have either been tightened considerably or the subplots developed to support the main plot.
Reviewed for the Historical Novels Society