-- 5 stars for the original Trask House Press edition, 2007.
-- 3.5 stars for the revised Tavern Books edition, 2017.
One of my very favorite books, in the original edition. A collection of one-line gems.
However, in the revised 2017 edition, the translator, in the interest of polishing the translations, appears to have polished away some of the intimacy and mystery of his originals -- at least to my ear.
I have no Greek, and cannot speak to the accuracy of these revisions. But I find many of the "re-translation" choices unfortunately flat. But then, maybe I'm biased from my first love of the original translations.
A few examples here below: decide for yourself. Still, there is plenty of magic in both editions, and you can't really go wrong with either.
2007 versions
(88) If you never close your eyes, you'll never grow.
(152) Tell me again, my friend -- so you start over.
(178) Grape harvesters and horses in the ocean. Bravo, comes the call from the balconies.
(195) All the words are not enough to get anything said.
(230) Night insects tangled in women’s hair, and voices in the corridors.
(329) Quiet night creatures, smelling the roses, patrolling the walls.
2017 versions
(88) If you never ever close your eyes, you won't grow.
(152) My friend, you tell me again, and start over.
(178) Grape harvesters and horses in the ocean. Bravo, they call from the balconies.
(195) All the words are too few for you to say anything.
(230) Nocturnal insects tangled in the women's hair and voices in the corridors.
(329) Quiet nocturnal creatures, smelling the roses, patrolling wall to wall.