Rating: 3.75
One could describe this as the definitive biography of the Beatle and solo artist George Harrison although, for me at least, it falls short of that goal. Still, this is a good read that had me looking forward to picking it back up throughout.
The narrative takes the reader through George’s childhood in Liverpool, through the Beatles era, through his solo career and forays into Indian spirituality, and much of his personal life and other business ventures up to his death in 2001. Having studied the Beatles for years, there was still a lot of new information to be had here, and it was great to focus in on George for once, especially reading about his life after the Beatles.
What bothered me about Behind the Locked Door is not that it exposes George Harrison’s flaws, but that it seems intent on reducing him to them. The book repeatedly minimizes his contributions to the Beatles and treats much of his solo career as insignificant, while devoting disproportionate attention to his personal shortcomings, complete with moral judgements continually. A biography can deepen your understanding of a person, often leaving you with a more nuanced respect for them, even when their shortcomings are fully explored. Here, the effect felt inverted. Even if many of these points are factually grounded, the cumulative effect feels less like a portrait and more like a case being built against its subject, as if the author actively dislikes the subject.
Also, there were some parts of the book where I was craving more of an “intimate biography” where I could know more of George Harrison’s inner thoughts, as much as can be known. For example, when the Beatles played their famous and historic Ed Sullivan Show appearance, the author mentions how Harrison was sick, but there’s no insight into how he was feeling mentally about the magnitude of the show or anything like that, which I was craving more of. Another example is when Paul McCartney went to visit George before he died, the author says “they held hands, laughed and wept, and parted in love.” But I’ve seen interviews where Paul goes into more detail about noting how rare and emotional the hand holding gesture was for them. McCartney mentioned it was not typical Liverpool behavior for male friends, but felt it was a loving, “lovely” moment despite the sadness, etc. I just thought certain events and situations were summarized as to not give us a bit more insight into the deeper thoughts and feelings.
All in all, I’d still recommend this to Beatles fans and George Harrison fans specifically even if it is not the perfect biography in this reader’s opinion. Although, at the same time, I’m interested in reading other biographies about him as I don’t feel like I got everything I wanted here.