Let's start with what I like:
- I liked having chapters from both mom and dad, seeing their different perspectives.
- I liked the staff of the hospital who were so nice and brilliant and amazing.
- I liked that little Juniper lived.
Reviewing nonfiction is so hard for me. When it comes to fiction reviews, it's fairly easy for me to rant and rave in favor of or against a character or plot, because none of it is real. You're not going to hurt anyone's feelings except for the unlikely event of the author seeing your review. With nonfiction, everyone in the book is real. How on earth do you review real people?
Well, I'll try. I found the parents in this book to be absolutely insufferable. I am very sorry that they went through this horrific experience, and I'm very glad their daughter lived. But I did not like them and that made it hard to like this book.
This includes, but is not limited to, instances like:
- Their relationship started with Tom going behind his girlfriend's back for TWO AND A HALF YEARS to be with Kelley secretly. This is recounted in a completely unapologetic way because they were meant to be or something. Not a great way to start when you're trying to build sympathy.
- I can't begin to imagine that toxic and awkward work environment when they were broken up or when Kelley starts creeping on the wife of one of her subordinates for an egg donation. (They happily agreed, but goodness, the way it was told just had a weirdness to it.)
- Rampant gender stereotyping when Kelley thinks for a split second she's going to have a boy or when Tom tells a baby Juniper that she can only like "princess bullshit" for a while. Jeez, not even out of the hospital or BORN and you're already deciding what your child can and can't be. I wonder what it would have been like if Juniper HAD been a boy, since they were so obsessed with having a girl. I'm not a parent, and I'm sure every parent has aspirations for what they want their child to be like. But it really seemed like they'd already made up their minds on what kind of person Juniper was going to be before she was even born, and, in Kelley's case, before she had even met Tom. Your child is his/her own person, not just an extension of you.
- Tom throwing in a casual NOT LIKE THE OTHER GUYS OBJECTIFYING WOMEN IS BAD comment when they're doing IVF and he has to, y'know, get some sperm. Calm down, dude, we're not here to judge on how feminist you are.
- Extreme judgement of other parents in the hospital. For example, Kelley identifying a tattooed woman in "stripper heels" as a bad mom because she dares to be on her cell phone sometimes when she's sitting near her baby daughter.
Those are some things that stood out to me. The writing certainly isn't bad. (Not surprising when it's coming from a pair of journalists. ) But it's really, REALLY hard to get invested in a story when you're so irritated with the people telling it.