So this is why a lot of people can’t stand the YA genre anymore?! Finally I understand.
But let’s start at the beginning. What is it all about?
In the near future pollution has gotten so bad that most people in the big cities don’t get much older than forty. But that’s only true for the meis, the have-nots. Though in this case that includes the middle class as well. Because only the very rich, the yous, are capable of buying themselves high-tech suits that protect them from the consequences of pollution.
Those suits are manufactured and sold all over the world by Jin Corp, a company based in Taipei. This is where the story takes place and it is one of the very few positives, as I really liked that setting.
Naturally the meis are not content with their situation and some try to change the status quo. Dr. Nataraj, a prominent ecology professor is trying to push through a legislative to bring down pollution. But she doesn’t make any headway. Because there are some people that are very happy with the way things are. I guess you know already who that might be.
Zhou, our MC, is a 18 yo mei who is friends with Dr. Nataraj’s son. When something spoilery happens they, along with three of their friends, decide to take matters into their own hands and infiltrate the ranks of the yous and Jin Corp, to bring down the enemy from within.
So Zhou has to pose as a you boy and try to become friends with Jin’s daughter Daiyu to obtain access to the headquarters of the company.
Naturally Zhou’s friends all have very special talents, so the five teenagers are well equipped to make this revolution happen.
We have the ingenius scientist Arun, the ninjalike Iris, the very well connected and charming Victor and Lingyi, the girl with the tremendous leadership qualities, who's actually called Boss by the others.
Jin's daughter Daiyu, of course, turns out to be a nice girl and Zhou therefore develops some conflicted feelings about his mission. And … well, I’ve read this story several times already. There’s really nothing surprising I could add here.
The characters are totally superficial and clichéd and most chapters seem to be there only to let them show off their skills rather than actually move the plot forward.
Everything that happens here I've already seen somewhere else (and better). There are zero surprises and also absolutely no tension, because everything just goes very smoothly down these well-trodden paths.
Reading this book, for me, was like playing a video game at too low a difficulty level. There will be some obstacles, sure. But you know they won't stop you. It might be enough to escape reality for some time, but completing the task doesn't give you a feeling of achievement or satisfaction.
I think I'm just not in the target audience here. Which, of course, isn't the fault of the book. Teenagers might possibly enjoy this, I suppose. Because at least Pon's prose has a nice flow and there are some scenes that some might consider fun, in a Michael Bay sort of way. But even then, there are better options out there.
1.5 stars rounded up. Even though it was way too shallow for my liking, it wasn't a total disaster, future Taipei as a setting was cool, it was fairly easy to read and mildly entertaining in a few chapters.
I was pretty surprised to learn, though, that Cindy Pon is one of the cofounders of Diversity in YA and is on the advisory board of We Need Diverse Books.
Because there's very little diversity in this book. And the constant ogling of female characters by the main protagonist was just gross.