Hmm So, do I consider myself a Trekkie... That's a hard question as I find many aspects of the show and movies utterly fascinating...while other parts of the Trekkie
lore and idea's...more cringeworthy at times. Though the arguement that a show and storyline that has been continuing since the 1970's...that's a pretty good record.
I think we all know what makes the hallmarks of Star Trek shine. It's many different pieces, but the core really has to do with what I consider three main pieces. The characters
and their interactions and dealings with each other, the metaphorically charged stories, and of course...the cool ships,and technology. Again that's not to say every episode of
Star Trek is a deep contemplative and thought provoking entry into screen writing. Far from it. But from what I've seen, in general, there is usually a good amount of thought
and social awareness placed in episodes or atleast overall themes of seasons.
So what am I rambling on here for? Well one of the downsides that prevents me from going full pro Trekkie, is the problem that they made in decisions of stories.
There are just too many and too frequently used "super undo" buttons. Or Time travel fixes, alternate universes, space magic, and temporal displacement gotcha's.
To put it bluntly, many of the stories in order to I suppose, keep the interest and action and shock value high, is to toss in time travel and an alternate universe and
call it a day. Now to me, when I hear or see something like this I instantly think, "Okay...lazy story writing excuse time". It's just too easy to create a "it was all a dream" excuse
plus to me, it does harm down the road when you're a new fan or even someone just trying to catch up, which story goes with what time arc, etc.. For this reason, while I was
intrigued by the story of the the quantum fluxing planet idea... it was the alternate dimension/time travel story that prevented me from really digging my teeth into
wanting to read Headlong Flight. Now prior to this, I have only read one or two Star Trek novels in the past, and neither did much for me. (It was back when I was younger and probably
just wanted all space battles or something). So I wasn't expecting (and rightfully so...) a grand literary masterpiece with this.
But I will admit, I was very surprised at the very least of the effort put in by Dayton to bring the crew of the Enterprise D and E to life. Now I remind you...
I'm not at all a fan of these big cross over time shifting stories, where old crew meets young... Captains meet from different era's. All that stuff seems silly to me, I
would just rather have a normal "Realistic" story that's....parden the pun... more down to earth. Well despite all of that and despite the obviously large impact that time
travel would have on this particular story, it was done...gracefully. By that I mean while it still felt completely cheesy and a bit "forced" there is actually a very large
amount of depth to this story and characters.
The story still focuses heavily on the idea of time travel, but and this is what I really appreciated, each crew of the factions involved (except oddly enough the newly discovered alien race..)
is given time to really dig down into their characters. I was particularly surprised by the backstory and characterization of Sarnath, the Romulan commander, and the crew of the Enterprise that
seem to have been created for the novels. I think this approach to writing was a wise wise choice in that even as someone who just picked up a random Star Trek book. I could get a feel for those
characters. I was almost ready to assume that the characters presented here were just "red shirt" cannon fodder and only the main crew would survive. But alas no! And real emotions and feelings
were given to the crew members all around. Again I stress the importance of this doubly so on the Romulan ship. This let's use get a very high level view of what Romulan society is like. The book treads
a very careful line, not having to fill every reader in on past events, but yet, make the story engaging and so that you know where and what the overall feel is for the races, and characters. For that...
well done! What sticks out the most to me is the inner turmoil and self doubt that Commander Ryker displays. Feeling as though he's in the shadow of Picard he feels incompetent to carry on his mantle after his death
(again...that damn paralell time line stuff...) we're given a much softer view of what Ryker could have been. The classic character tropes of Data and Jordi Laforge all are written with a very
"classic" if not cliched style, but it's something that feels just right. As I stated earlier, the author has come up with some very good and well thought out characters to fill the ship with.
I'm not actually sure if these are characters created by Dayton, but he's given them something to cling onto.
As a side note, the narration with this book was a bit odd. Certain times I got the feeling that the narrator really went out of his way and nailed the characters
Worf...hmm not so much, but that's a hard order to fill I admit.
and accents of the cast and crew, but other times where he comes off just very flat, and monotone. Overall though I think he did a pretty good job especially with Picard and Data.
What I also liked about this was the very balanced writing. Despite the Romulans being the enemy here, they aren't given an unfair, cheesy upper hand. Things go just as wrong for them as things go wrong for Federation.
Good thing about the novel is that even though it doesn't just come out and hold your hands with the background of races and politics, it does a great job in letting
us know where each race stands, how they feel and best of all their natural temperments and racial characteristics.
My real only complaint about the book, and this is one that was actually handled much better than it could have been, is the *slight* confusion of storylines
Because there's 3 main stories taking place, and two of them involved different crews and times of the same ship, if you're not careful you may get a bit turned around
with who is who and on what ship. But this rarely happened, and like I said, it was handled surprisingly well. The new alien race we're presented with didn't get a whole lot of
actual time to establish why we should really care about them to be honest. The Sidrac goof'd went too far with their experimenting and screwed themselves over! No real development of any
of their characters, and looking back I sort of agree with this approach as it would have distracted too much from the main crew and the Romulan interactions.
Overall this book was really fun. I legitimately wanted to know what was going to happen to the two varying story lines, and I was really happy to see some the crews displaying
their on screen behaviours and even some of the new crew members who seem to be shaping into their own. I'm eager to see and read about Glen Deagan a prospective Cardassian Science officer. I think I'm
actually going to pick up the "next" book in this series "Hearts and Minds". It's not really a direct sequel, from what I hear but definitely set in the Post Nemesis time...