"Now available for the first time in paperback, "Lincoln and the Indians" remains the only thorough treatment of a much-neglected aspect of Lincoln's presidency. Placing Indian affairs in the broad context of Civil War politics and the settling of the West, David A. Nichols covers the Sioux War of 1862 in Minnesota, the forced removal of the Navahos from their homeland to the deadly concentration camp at Bosque Redondo, and the massacre of Cheyennes by volunteer troops at Sand Creek. He also examines Lincoln's inept handling of the Five Civilized Tribes in Indian Territory and the corrupt "Indian System" of government aid that mainly benefitted ambitious whites."
This is a paperback reprint of a book published in 1978. The message today is as timely as it was then -- or, for that matter as it was during Civil War America. Professor Nichols' book is a good overview of Indian policy during the Civil War-- an often overlooked part of the Lincoln story. The book begins with an overview of the system of Indian administration as it had developed by 1860. It was dominated by the political spoils system and by corruption resulting from the power accorded to the Indian agents. As a master of the art of pragmatic politics, Lincoln used the system -- as he needed to do--to hold the Union together-resulting in tragedy for too many of our country's Indian wards.
The book discusses the Five Civilized Tribes of Oklahoma (then Indian territory) and their relationship to both the Union and the Confederacy. The story picks up focus, though, in the discussion of the Minnesota Sioux rebellion, the summary trials and capital sentences of over 300 Sioux Indians, and Lincoln's remission of the death sentence in all but 39 cases. Nichols tells this story well, perhaps giving Lincoln's actions less credit and less courage than they may deserve.
The book discusses Lincoln's attempts in 1862 to reform Indian policy, which were defeated by War exigencies and by Congressional inaction. Nichols discusses a famous meeting held between Lincoln and the Indian chiefs in 1863 in the White House, again perhaps undervaluing Lincoln's intentions and the difficulties he faced.
The book considers the policy resulting from the Sioux war of concentrating the Indians under the control of the military with unsuccessful and inhumane results in Arizona and New Mexico. The book also includes an account of the too little known Sand Hill Massacre in Colorado in 1864.
The treatment of the American Indians does not constitute one of our nation's or of President Lincoln's prouder accomplishments. Professor Nichols is correct that this story deserves to be known as part of our history. The book ties Lincoln's treatment of the Indians to prevailing ideologies at the time involving a disrespect of cultural differences, to westward expansion, industrialization, the political patronage system, and, first and foremost, the Civil War. Even Nichols appears to acknowledge that given the War, there was little that might have been done differently at the time in the way of systematic reform.
As is unfortunately the case with most histories of Indian affairs, it is easier, as Nichols does, to find a great deal of deserved fault than it is to develop answers, as he does not. This book is worth reading as a good history of Indian affairs during the Civil War era.
This is a book published in 1978 which I have long wanted to read. It covers the dark side of American history--the treatment of the Native Americans by the government ( and whites in general). Specifically, this is about Lincoln's dealings with the tribes, going into the politics and policymaking rather than the details of such events as the Sioux War in Minnesota and the Sand Creek Massacre. As I had expected, this book exposes a dismal record for the Lincoln administration concerning "Indian affairs." Nichols shows that the cause of the Sioux War in Minnesota can be found in the operation of the totally corrupt "Indian system" of government aid. It was a system in which the Indian agents and traders enriched themselves by stealing from the Indians. In Minnesota in 1862, the Sioux were starving, waiting for promised food supplies from the government which never arrived. It was one of the traders who made the infamous statement: "So far as I am concerned, if they are hungry let them eat grass or their own dung." After war broke out, the trader was found dead, with grass stuffed in his mouth... With the Sioux ( or Dakota) attacks on settlers, panic ensued and the governor of Minnesota asked Lincoln for help. Lincoln, of course, had other concerns. After all, he was in the midst of fighting a civil war. Troops needed to fight the Confederates were diverted to fight the Indians. The Sioux were defeated and the Union army held well over a thousand prisoners, mostly women and children. A military commission was set up to try Indians as war criminals. After the trials were over, Lincoln was presented with a list of 303 Sioux men condemned to death by hanging. The general in charge of the trials stated that the number of executions "will be sufficiently great to satisfy the longings of the most blood-thirsty." Lincoln and his lawyers studied the transcripts and were appalled by what they found. A denial of due process and counsel were characteristic of the trial proceedings. President Lincoln was put under great pressure to have the executions carried out. He moved cautiously to a decision...there would still be hangings but the president wanted to drastically limit the number of hangings. Finally, Lincoln forwarded a list of names of thirty-nine men from the original three hundred and three that were to be executed. On December 26, 1862, the condemned Indians were executed. At the very last moment, one man was pardoned. Arguments have raged since as to whether Lincoln acted humanely, as he had prevented all 303 men from being executed. On the other hand, Lincoln had ordered the execution of 38 men, the largest official mass execution in American history in which guilt of the executed cannot be positively determined. Other issues that Lincoln had to deal with concerned the Civil War in Indian Territory (in which some of the Indians of the "Civilized Tribes" joined the Confederate forces), the Union Army war against the Navajo, the Sand Creek Massacre in Colorado in 1864, and reform of "the Indian system." Lincoln talked about reform but all reform efforts died in Congress. Lincoln signed the Homestead Act into law, which supported the settling of the West and would put increasing pressure on the Indians to give up more and more of their land...By the end of the 19th Century, it looked like the Indians, just like the bison, would be exterminated. As I stated, we are looking at the dark side of American history. I'll give this book 4.5 stars. I think this book is a good complement to the classic "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee" by Dee Brown.
This is one of those books that will do two things: 1) it will make you ashamed of being white 2) it will show you the politics have been corrupt for a long time!! I have always felt that the Native Americans have every right to be bitter towards whites and reading this gives you a whole no insight as to why.
Lincoln's Indian problems during the American Civil War are examined to include the Confederacy's attempts to recruit the Native Americans of Indian Territory [Oklahoma] and the Sioux uprising in Minnesota. This work provides an interesting take on the Civil War.
An academic look at Indian policy during the Civil War.
Whereas Scott Berg (38 Nooses) gives us a character-driven narrative, Nichols provides an in-depth look specifically at the Indian system during the Civil War period. Lincoln and the Indians is an academic treatise, in fact, the book is derived from the author’s doctoral dissertation. While much drier than Berg, Nichols provides a more detailed look of our national treatment of Native Americans throughout history and the country.
Nichols begins in what is now Oklahoma, then “Indian Territory.” Lincoln, as did all his predecessors, relied on congressmen and local leaders in each area to fill out the patronage system of Indian agents and traders. With the Civil War raging around him, he took little interest in Native American affairs. While there was substantial anti-slavery activism, there was almost non-existent pressure to reform a system that had been in place since the beginning of our country. Codified when Andrew Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act of 1830, the Indian system routinely forced Native populations westward. Most notably was the “Trail of Tears,” in which 100,000 members of the “Five Civilized Tribes” were forced out of the land cotton plantation owners wanted in the South and into smaller and less desirable land in Oklahoma and beyond. Seeing little reform under Lincoln, Native leaders felt that the man they called “Our Great Father” had abandoned them.
Nichols does delve into the Dakota uprising, its causes and results, and Lincoln’s review of the cases. Unlike the Berg book, this book presents the points dispassionately and devoid of personal storylines; it’s an academic treatment of an intensely emotional event. On the other hand, while Lincoln in Berg’s book is largely absent, Nichols digs deeper into Lincoln’s actions throughout the war. We see a Lincoln who would like to organize Indian soldiers helping the Union (many had joined up with the Confederacy and held black slaves of their own); and yet, this idea is never carried out and eventually given up. We also see Lincoln more involved with decision-making in the southwest and in Minnesota. In particular, we see him making an effort at reform, although limited and doomed to failure without public support. We see a Lincoln more in tuned with Bishop Whipple, who pleads for the lives of the Dakota sentenced to death. We see both the good and the bad about Lincoln’s attitudes—Nichols seems to emphasize the former but does give credence to the latter—attitudes that were both in conformance with the overall national belief that Native populations were a dying race while also believing they should be treated with greater respect and fairness. Lincoln never got his chance to fulfill his promise to begin reforming the Indian system, which he would have found difficult, or impossible, given the long history and long continuing activity.
These two books almost by necessity should be read in tandem. One provides a detailed examination of policy and politics; the other, a more personal narrative of one specific event. Together they help flesh out an aspect of our history that has been largely overlooked, but perhaps more recently has awakened in the public mind.
Important and depressing stories of the treatment of Indians during the Civil Way. Essentially two distinct parts. The first was mess that was Indian Territory (later Oklahoma) during the Civil War, where both sides used the Indians there as pawns when it suited them, and ignored them when they were a nuisance. The second was up in Minnesota, where greed and corruption lead to starvation and ultimately the outbreak of war between bands of Lakotas and small farm communities along the frontier. This forced Lincoln was forced to draw Union forces away from the Civil War, and the brutal "justice" afterwards led to the largest mass military execution in US history.
The writing is straightforward and to the point, which makes it readable if not necessarily gripping.