While scholarship in lesbian/gay studies, queer studies, and studies of gender and sexuality has had an enormous impact on medieval studies, little attention has been paid thus far to women who chose to live according to same-sex affectivity and desire. General treatments of homosexuality in the Middle Ages have assumed that little can be said on the subject. The contributors explore the many ways that lesbian love and desire may have been articulated and represented in the medieval period.
Very strong, wide-ranging essay collection; excellent work by the editors. I was impressed with the way the essays covered different types of text (religious versus legal versus vernacular), women from different social locations (from abesses and ladies to everyday wives), and different cultures and regions (there are two excellent articles on the medieval Islamic world, and one on India). The introduction is excellent and theoretically strong.
A mixed bag. I found the articles Lesbian sex and the military: from the medieval Arabic tradition to French literature by Sahar Amer and "At all times near": love between women in two medieval Indian devotional texts by Ruth Vanita to be the most convincing and accessible. Several of the articles felt like a major stretch, especially Hildegard of Bingen and Richardis of Stade: the discourse of desire by Susan Schibanoff. It's clear that Richardis is important to Hildegard, but in my mind Hildegard comes off more like a parent than a lover, and at times her ardor at getting Richardis back seems to border on the controlling. But that's the inherent limitation of this kind of research: there are a very large number of ways for women to relate to one another and so it's difficult to do more than suggest that two women might have had sex. (Well, except that one excerpt in Amer's work that is explicit enough to be in a work by Califia. Damn.)