I finished I Dared the Duke, my first experience with Anna Bennett's work, and I will be honest, I had a hard time deciding upon a rating. I think there will be readers that will really enjoy this novel, and others that will not. My intention here is to outline my opinions about the book's strengths and weaknesses so you as a reader can determine if this book is a good fit for you.
I Dared the Duke is the second novel in Anna Bennett's debut Wayward Wallflowers series. I have not read the first book in the series, but was able to follow this novel just fine so it can stand alone (I appreciate this since I often read series out of order). In this story, the second sister of the Wilted Wallflowers, as they have been cruelly dubbed, meets her match in the Duke of Blackshire. Elizabeth, or Beth, is a woman who likes to be needed. After her older sister marries well and the once struggling family is saved, she is left in an odd position of comfort/idleness. As a result, she accepts the task of acting as a companion for the dowager duchess of Blackshire (the hero's grandmother) so that she has someone to care for. For a time, she is happy with the arrangement, until the Duke, Alexander (Alex) Savage returns and begins wreaking all sorts of havoc. Someone is out to hurt him and he needs his grandmother and her companion out of the house and out of harm's way. However, since he doesn't tell Beth the problem and he doesn't want to worry his grandmother, neither departs and thus, Beth and Alex begin spending a lot of time together.
The bulk of the story focuses entirely on interactions between Beth and Alex. They initially trade barbs with each other, but that soon dissolves into mutual attraction. Throughout the story, the duke struggles to avoid various attacks on his person, tries to keep all his secrets about his past hidden, and avoid Beth--all of which he fails at miserably. Beth, despite her initial misgivings, begins to fall for the duke, and also begins to understand that something is wrong and she wants to help him. This results in many late night meetings, some intimate times, a whodunit climax, and a HEA.
This book, despite the threat to the duke, remained very light and fluffy. To be honest, there was little substance at all. I had a hard time connecting to either character and had no sense of the time period. The writing flowed well and the dialogue had some spark, but the story also had a very contemporary feel, which kept me from feeling immersed in the time period. I am not a huge stickler for the historical detail since I cannot claim to be an expert, but one of the things that bothered me about this story was how the crux of the main couple's romance was built upon three assumptions I couldn't quite believe. First, someone was out to kill the duke but he didn't hire any investigator or body guard to help--he only told Beth and his one good friend. Second, Alex and Beth constantly interacted in the middle of the night--most of their relationship developed in relative privacy without a whiff of scandal or a meddlesome chaperone. Last, no servants or anyone outside of the house created any sort of scandal/found out about Alex and Beth's antics even with the risks they took and the longing glances they sent each other. With the hero in the position of a duke, constantly surrounded by people and with tons of resources at his disposal, it seemed odd that he wouldn't use help or that Beth and he ever had so much time to converse alone without anyone finding out or raising an eye brow.
I thought the duke was developed a little differently than he was first presented, which I liked. He doesn't end up being the libertine everyone assumes and I found it interesting and refreshing how Bennett handled his character. He made a poor first impression, but I found that the duke was a romantic man without all the darkness he thinks he had. Beth, on the other hand, was more difficult for me to connect to. I initially liked her character, with her 'needing to be needed' and her compassion for the duke's grandmother. However, this faded as she continuously discarded what she knew about the duke in order to flounder with indecision and to believe rumors.
Based on these perceptions of the book, I think there are a few recommendations I can make to guide people for whether to select this book:
1. If you are looking for a light story with a romantic, powerful hero who falls for the wallflower, but you do not care about a lot of historical accuracy, you will enjoy this. The writing is clean and easy to follow. The mystery kept me turning pages to find out what happens next and the hero has some very romantic lines.
2. If you are a veteran of the genre and read a ton of historical romance, bear these things in mind before picking up this book. First, the book felt modern and I thought the two leads had way more private time together without discovery than I would've thought possible. The duke, as powerful as he was, did not use any help on the threat which I thought was odd. The solution to the mystery, after I learned the person's identity, didn't fully make sense. I was not sure how they could've pulled off some of the threats on the duke as they did. While I found the duke's past was underwhelming in how it was handled, how Bennett developed the duke's character regarding the rumors of his sexual prowess was original and well-done. It was one of my favorite parts of this book.
3. The sex scenes were pretty tame in this book (yay!). They were still fully explicit, but I wasn't cringing or skimming. I usually like the sex scenes to further the romance or to have some impact on the plot. In this case, I thought they were well-done for revealing different facets of the duke's character. Not a lot of steam if you are into that sort of thing, but more emotional and like older books which was just fine with me!
Overall, I thought this book was good. I didn't love it, but I think there will be plenty of people that will enjoy it. In many cases, I think the average rating is more a result of my preferences than the writing style. I either must LOVE the characters and be swept up in their romance so completely that I don't care about the plot, or I must be immersed fully in the time period. In this case, I was able to settle in and easily read the story and I liked the duke, but I couldn't connect with the heroine and I was jarred out of the story by some points of historical inaccuracy and modern language.
If you love reading a lot of the new authors coming out recently and just want to read for an escape, this will be a good fit. If you read a ton of historical romance and are pickier like me, I'd suggest you try a sample of the writing to see if the feel will work for you.
A nice effort and a good way for me to spend a few hours, but I will not be continuing the series. 3.5 stars.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for a chance to read and and provide an honest review.