You know those books that leave you feeling conflicted whilst reading? This was one of those books for me. I really enjoyed parts of it, was thrown off by other bits and bored more than once.
I'm going to do my best to give a balanced honest review.Firstly I really liked the way the book kicked off. I liked Rob and his assortment of dysfunctional housemates. I was interested in his saddened state of mind and could see glimpses of humour in there.
Then we get introduced to Rob's neighbour, Mrs Popov and there were some very cringeworthy moments. Her son has gone missing she shares and Rob is intrigued by the mystery of where Alexei has gone. He's a writer so his writer's brain is working away on what the truth could be.
Here's my first issue. Mrs Popov is obviously portrayed as foreign (Russian) but her speech is written nothing like someone even with English as their second language is spoken. She literally speaks like Yoda.
'Rob, help find my Alexei you must. Alone, I am alvays, and, missing him, I do, so much.'
and...
'Young man, very direct, you are. Blush at your inviting I vould, but I'm vorldly voman. Anyway, any sugar I have not, my dear.'
It's through every conversation and went from slightly amusing to really irritating rather quickly for me dear readers. You may be more tolerant. I get it's written to be funny.
The plot takes some unexpected turns as Rob begins sleuthing and then romance enters his life and the story. The romance is very lovely-dovey, very perfect and is written with a Christian message through it. That doesn't bother me (I'm a Christian myself) but it seemed a strange mash of genre directions within one book. It was unexpected. It started to lose me.
I liked some characters and really didn't connect with others. Some bits are great, others lack the oomph required. The build up and the ending again I really enjoyed. It was well-written, an interesting reveal and I sparked up heading towards the end of the book.
For me, the mix-up of genres was a bit messy, I would have loved the romantic element to have more faults, realism, imperfections like most new relationships do. It was a bit too nice if that's at all possible.
Oh I hate doing reviews like this. I wanted to love it, kicked off with high hopes but I read hundreds of books every year and either a book grabs me and stays with me or it doesn't.
This was an okay read. Reviewer friends of mine gave it 5 stars. If you like a bit of romance tossed in with some mystery served up with a side of human nature you will like No Idea. Oh! and if you can cope with the Yoda-speak from Mrs Popov. I can't say I've heard anybody from Russia or Eastern Europe speak in that way except at Star Wars conventions. I should be laughing but it just got too much.
I'm going to give a comedy book Si Page has written a go as I can see the potential with the humour in this novel. I suspect I'll lean towards feeling "funny" is what he does really well.
I read a copy of this book for the author, all review opinions are my own and totally unbiased.