What do you think?
Rate this book
Amish Beginnings #3
The Return
Beautiful and winsome, Betsy Zook never questioned her family's rigid expectations, nor those of devoted Hans, but then she never had to. Not until the night when she's taken captive in a surprise Indian raid. During her captivity, Betsy faces brutality and hardship, but also unexpected kindness. She draws strength from native Caleb, who encourages her to find God in all circumstances. She finds herself torn between her pious upbringing and the intense new feelings this compelling man awakens within her.
Handsome and complex, Hans is greatly anguished by Betsy's captivity and turns to Tessa Bauer for comfort. Eagerly, Tessa responds, overlooking troubling signs of Hans's hunger for revenge. When Betsy is finally restored to the Amish, have things gone too far between Hans and Tessa?
Inspired by true events, this deeply layered novel gives a glimpse into the tumultuous days of prerevolutionary Pennsylvania through the eyes of two young, determined, and faith-filled women.
Handsome and complex, Hans is greatly anguished by Betsy's captivity and turns to Tessa Bauer for comfort. Eagerly, Tessa responds, overlooking troubling signs of Hans's hunger for revenge. When Betsy is finally restored to the Amish, have things gone too far between Hans and Tessa?
Inspired by true events, this deeply layered novel gives a glimpse into the tumultuous days of prerevolutionary Pennsylvania through the eyes of two young, determined, and faith-filled women.
332 pages, Paperback
Published August 1, 2017
192 people are currently reading
897 people want to read
About the author
Suzanne Woods Fisher
73 books3,967 followersSuzanne Woods Fisher is the bestselling, award winning author of fiction and non-fiction books about the Old Order Amish for Revell Books, host of the radio-show-turned-blog Amish Wisdom, a columnist for Christian Post and Cooking & Such magazine.
Her interest in the Amish began with her grandfather, who was raised Plain. A theme in her books (her life!) is that you don’t have to “go Amish” to incorporate the principles of simple living.
Suzanne lives in California with her family and raises puppies for Guide Dogs for the Blind. To her way of thinking, you just can't life too seriously when a puppy is tearing through your house with someone's underwear in its mouth.
Suzanne can be found on-line at: www.suzannewoodsfisher.com
Her interest in the Amish began with her grandfather, who was raised Plain. A theme in her books (her life!) is that you don’t have to “go Amish” to incorporate the principles of simple living.
Suzanne lives in California with her family and raises puppies for Guide Dogs for the Blind. To her way of thinking, you just can't life too seriously when a puppy is tearing through your house with someone's underwear in its mouth.
Suzanne can be found on-line at: www.suzannewoodsfisher.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews
August 12, 2017
The Return is book 3 in the Amish Beginnings series. This book is not a stand alone and the series must be read in order to fully understand the story. It starts with Anna's Crossing,continues with The Newcomer and continues with this book. I read the author said she may continue the series if there is enough interest. I sure hope she does. I have a lot of unanswered questions about the characters. Suzanne's books I have read many of them over the years and enjoyed them all. She is one of those authors that can seamlessly add historical fiction to her Amish books without it seeming like it's any effort at all. This book was inspired by true events and a very emotional book unlike any I have read by her and I look forward to reading her next book when it releases.
Pub Date 01 Aug 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Pub Date 01 Aug 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
October 24, 2017
Overall
I found the book incredibly insightful into a time that isn’t often written about. I rarely see pre-revolutionary war stories these days. And with the Amish and Mennonite hints interwoven, it made this story quite interesting.
Characters
The people in this book are well crafted, interesting, and make the reader sympathetic to them. I found myself rooting for some of the characters; Betsy, Caleb, and Tessa mostly. There was one particular character I wanted to hit over the head, but such is the life of a reader. Uncle Felix was probably my favorite. The cast is rather large and considering that the story point of view switches between upwards of 4 or more characters over the course of the book, Fisher did an amazing job of keeping each of them distinct and easily relatable. The characters also have a very satisfying arc throughout the story. None of them felt unfinished at the end of the book, which I greatly appreciated.
Plot
I very rarely felt bored while reading this book. It was quite intriguing without being incredibly suspenseful. And while there was suspense, I didn’t find it overdone. With the heaviness of the subject matter, I found that the author balanced the feel of the story by keeping the humor alive and making parts of the narrative entertaining and even sad at times.
Setting
The story setting is richly depicted. With a pre-revolutionary war frontier, and the issues of land ownership, the settlers against the Indians, I found it very fascinating and educating, all while still being entertaining. I learned a lot about that time period and the struggles that were ever-present.
Message
Multiple messages abound throughout the tale; the message of trusting the Lord even when bad things happen being the most prevalent. All things work for good to those that love Him. Forgiveness, jealousy, anger, revenge, and bigotry are also major themes. I found that the author did an impressive job of weaving messages of hope and truth into the tumultuous lives of her characters.
Quibbles & Content
The content was a little violent at times and some of the story I found quite depressing. The number of people who died and the massacres that took place were so shocking and overwhelming. I can’t really blame the author, however, as it was real life and truly did happen. I just want the reader to be aware, especially if a family or children are going to be reading it. I would recommend this book for ages 14+ due to some violence and descriptions thereof, as well as some other somewhat mature, though not graphic, themes.
Final Thoughts
This book would be a lovely and enjoyable addition to anyone’s Historical Fiction shelf. The story and messages within are enjoyable, entertaining and educational. I even think The Return could make a great family read aloud and could prompt some discussions. I found that some of the character's struggles transcended time and could be issues that people of today will find relatable.
I found the book incredibly insightful into a time that isn’t often written about. I rarely see pre-revolutionary war stories these days. And with the Amish and Mennonite hints interwoven, it made this story quite interesting.
Characters
The people in this book are well crafted, interesting, and make the reader sympathetic to them. I found myself rooting for some of the characters; Betsy, Caleb, and Tessa mostly. There was one particular character I wanted to hit over the head, but such is the life of a reader. Uncle Felix was probably my favorite. The cast is rather large and considering that the story point of view switches between upwards of 4 or more characters over the course of the book, Fisher did an amazing job of keeping each of them distinct and easily relatable. The characters also have a very satisfying arc throughout the story. None of them felt unfinished at the end of the book, which I greatly appreciated.
Plot
I very rarely felt bored while reading this book. It was quite intriguing without being incredibly suspenseful. And while there was suspense, I didn’t find it overdone. With the heaviness of the subject matter, I found that the author balanced the feel of the story by keeping the humor alive and making parts of the narrative entertaining and even sad at times.
Setting
The story setting is richly depicted. With a pre-revolutionary war frontier, and the issues of land ownership, the settlers against the Indians, I found it very fascinating and educating, all while still being entertaining. I learned a lot about that time period and the struggles that were ever-present.
Message
Multiple messages abound throughout the tale; the message of trusting the Lord even when bad things happen being the most prevalent. All things work for good to those that love Him. Forgiveness, jealousy, anger, revenge, and bigotry are also major themes. I found that the author did an impressive job of weaving messages of hope and truth into the tumultuous lives of her characters.
Quibbles & Content
The content was a little violent at times and some of the story I found quite depressing. The number of people who died and the massacres that took place were so shocking and overwhelming. I can’t really blame the author, however, as it was real life and truly did happen. I just want the reader to be aware, especially if a family or children are going to be reading it. I would recommend this book for ages 14+ due to some violence and descriptions thereof, as well as some other somewhat mature, though not graphic, themes.
Final Thoughts
This book would be a lovely and enjoyable addition to anyone’s Historical Fiction shelf. The story and messages within are enjoyable, entertaining and educational. I even think The Return could make a great family read aloud and could prompt some discussions. I found that some of the character's struggles transcended time and could be issues that people of today will find relatable.
August 23, 2017
The complex dynamics of the characters in this book were so compelling amidst the trials they faced. There are multiple perspectives the story is told from which made it so interesting and the pace moved swiftly forward. Anna and Bairn from the first two books were influential as Tessa's parents and Bairn as the spiritual leader of the group, and I *loved* how their personalities shone through without the author retelling what happened in the previous books. Because of that, this book can definitely stand on its own and I think it will only make readers want to read the first book as well to discover how Anna and Bairn's romance began (The first book is my favorite- it's SO. GOOD.) Felix also plays an important role and I loved his rambunctious little family and the surprises that come out of his story.
I felt like we got to know Tessa the most, it showed her strong personality and also how vulnerable her unrequited love for Hans made her. Her fascination with a wild stallion she regularly seeks out shows her compassion and patience as she befriends it but never captures it. She stubbornly rebuffs "Rumpled Martin" over a grudge from long ago, and I admired his perseverance in earning her friendship and respect over time. Her not-so-secret habit of eavesdropping on her parents made me chuckle ;)
Betsy's story is heartbreaking and the realistic historical details of the raid and her captivity made me so sad for the real-life settlers who endured such traumatic experiences. I felt like the author did an excellent job representing both sides of the grievances the Indians and settlers had against each other and the humanity of the choices they made- good and bad. Because of the kindness and respect of her new Indian family, Betsy is able to differentiate between individuals and the choices they make. It was interesting and sad to see how fear and anger led many of the settlements to instead group all Indians together in their minds as the villains, leading to tragic results.
Overall I was completely satisfied with this book on its own and as an addition to the Amish Beginnings series. The rich history and the journey of the characters was forefront, and the romance sprinkled throughout created the perfect balance. Highly recommend!
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
I felt like we got to know Tessa the most, it showed her strong personality and also how vulnerable her unrequited love for Hans made her. Her fascination with a wild stallion she regularly seeks out shows her compassion and patience as she befriends it but never captures it. She stubbornly rebuffs "Rumpled Martin" over a grudge from long ago, and I admired his perseverance in earning her friendship and respect over time. Her not-so-secret habit of eavesdropping on her parents made me chuckle ;)
Betsy's story is heartbreaking and the realistic historical details of the raid and her captivity made me so sad for the real-life settlers who endured such traumatic experiences. I felt like the author did an excellent job representing both sides of the grievances the Indians and settlers had against each other and the humanity of the choices they made- good and bad. Because of the kindness and respect of her new Indian family, Betsy is able to differentiate between individuals and the choices they make. It was interesting and sad to see how fear and anger led many of the settlements to instead group all Indians together in their minds as the villains, leading to tragic results.
Overall I was completely satisfied with this book on its own and as an addition to the Amish Beginnings series. The rich history and the journey of the characters was forefront, and the romance sprinkled throughout created the perfect balance. Highly recommend!
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
July 23, 2017
Suzanne Woods Fisher has shown her versatility and expertise as an author as never before in her enthralling new saga, The Return. The readers' emotions are immediately swept away on a violent incursion by savage Indians against the first Amish settlers in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Beautifully kind-hearted, Betsy Zook, is brutally captured by Indians and her devout Amish faith is put to the ultimate test. My heart was broken for this lovely, courageous young woman just on the threshold of new love...so not deserving the cruel injustices inflicted upon her. Enter two handsome, brave heroes—Indian native, Caleb, brave, strong, and tender-hearted...and passionate, loving Hans, the man Betsy unwillingly left behind. In my initial estimation both are worthy of her love, but which man will capture her heart?
In my opinion this is Suzanne Woods Fisher's best novel to date and I have been a fan of hers forever! Impeccably researched and inspired by true historical events, this novel may be enjoyed by both men and women alike. Not your cushy, cookie-cutter Amish fiction novel, Ms. Fisher tells it like it was and the picture she paints isn't always pretty. Certain secondary characters add humor and warmth to the story, and I was so intrigued by the huge, wild black stallion! Although The Return reads well as a stand-alone, I hope readers will be sure to order Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer (Books 1 and 2) to get better acquainted with these unique individuals!
In my opinion this is Suzanne Woods Fisher's best novel to date and I have been a fan of hers forever! Impeccably researched and inspired by true historical events, this novel may be enjoyed by both men and women alike. Not your cushy, cookie-cutter Amish fiction novel, Ms. Fisher tells it like it was and the picture she paints isn't always pretty. Certain secondary characters add humor and warmth to the story, and I was so intrigued by the huge, wild black stallion! Although The Return reads well as a stand-alone, I hope readers will be sure to order Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer (Books 1 and 2) to get better acquainted with these unique individuals!
August 11, 2017
Reviewed at The Power of Words: http://bit.ly/2vWseUM
As with all that Suzanne Woods Fisher writes, The Return is incredible. I won’t go so far as to say that it’s the best book she has written because each story is unique and never fails to touch me, but there is something special about this one.
From a descriptive standpoint, the narrative flows smoothly and every word has a purpose. Careful attention is paid to historical detail, characters are multifaceted – and in the midst of danger and discord for colonists of the New World, Fisher injects a subtle and delightful humor. We even get to see the meaning behind some common sayings heard today … such as hitting the nail on the head and I’ll be there with bells on. This story stands alone, but reading the Amish Beginnings series in order makes for a more fulfilling experience.
Precious and endearing characters abound … Bairn and Anna, whose story began in book one, Anna’s Crossing; Bairn’s now-grown-up brother, Felix, who was a handful as a child and hasn’t yet outgrown some childish tendencies; Caleb, who knows what it’s like to not be fully accepted in any culture; Betsy and Tessa, two pioneer women with strength and determination; and even Rumpled Martin, son of a Mennonite minister. Bairn and Anna, equally strong in faith and love for each other, have been favorites of mine throughout the series. I have to confess a little humanness here, but there’s just something about a Scotsman that gets to me, and when Bairn speaks in his Scotish brogue …
What sets this novel apart is the way readers will connect with the setting and characters, literally being pulled into the scenes. They may have lived 250 years ago, but their wisdom, faith and courage are timeless. Spiritual themes are especially relevant … the need for grace, reflected in Bairn’s ministry style at Stoney Ridge … how thoughtless words can incite an unquenchable anger and vengeance … prejudice, how easy and tempting it is to paint all people of a certain nationality or belief system with the same brush … and that God is sovereign in all circumstances.
The Return is a wonderfully entertaining and touching story – heartbreaking at times, but filled with the inspiration of grace and hope. I hope to see more from these characters, especially Betsy and Tessa. “Best of the best” for me.
Highly recommended.
I was provided a free copy of this book through Celebrate Lit and Revell. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
As with all that Suzanne Woods Fisher writes, The Return is incredible. I won’t go so far as to say that it’s the best book she has written because each story is unique and never fails to touch me, but there is something special about this one.
From a descriptive standpoint, the narrative flows smoothly and every word has a purpose. Careful attention is paid to historical detail, characters are multifaceted – and in the midst of danger and discord for colonists of the New World, Fisher injects a subtle and delightful humor. We even get to see the meaning behind some common sayings heard today … such as hitting the nail on the head and I’ll be there with bells on. This story stands alone, but reading the Amish Beginnings series in order makes for a more fulfilling experience.
Precious and endearing characters abound … Bairn and Anna, whose story began in book one, Anna’s Crossing; Bairn’s now-grown-up brother, Felix, who was a handful as a child and hasn’t yet outgrown some childish tendencies; Caleb, who knows what it’s like to not be fully accepted in any culture; Betsy and Tessa, two pioneer women with strength and determination; and even Rumpled Martin, son of a Mennonite minister. Bairn and Anna, equally strong in faith and love for each other, have been favorites of mine throughout the series. I have to confess a little humanness here, but there’s just something about a Scotsman that gets to me, and when Bairn speaks in his Scotish brogue …
What sets this novel apart is the way readers will connect with the setting and characters, literally being pulled into the scenes. They may have lived 250 years ago, but their wisdom, faith and courage are timeless. Spiritual themes are especially relevant … the need for grace, reflected in Bairn’s ministry style at Stoney Ridge … how thoughtless words can incite an unquenchable anger and vengeance … prejudice, how easy and tempting it is to paint all people of a certain nationality or belief system with the same brush … and that God is sovereign in all circumstances.
The Return is a wonderfully entertaining and touching story – heartbreaking at times, but filled with the inspiration of grace and hope. I hope to see more from these characters, especially Betsy and Tessa. “Best of the best” for me.
Highly recommended.
I was provided a free copy of this book through Celebrate Lit and Revell. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
July 30, 2017
The Return is part thee from Suzanne Woods Fisher's Amish Beginnings series. When historical fiction and Amish fiction collide, it makes a perfect read for me. The story is based on real events, making it an even more fascinating read. I loved the first two books of the series, Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer, and The Return is a perfect addition to the series. It is written so well, that I felt like I was transported back in time and living among the Amish settlers in Pennsylvania. I felt like I was right there experiencing the fear, struggles, and turmoil the community and kidnapped Betsy must have had gone through. There are several elements of the story I liked. Some mystery and suspense, lessons of forgiveness, redemption, faith, love, following your heart, and learning to turn to God to overcome tragedy.
I highly recommend this book, especially for those who love Amish stories and those set during Colonial America. I, also, recommend to the reader to begin with Anna's Crossing, book one of the series.
I received this book from Celebrate Lit. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
I highly recommend this book, especially for those who love Amish stories and those set during Colonial America. I, also, recommend to the reader to begin with Anna's Crossing, book one of the series.
I received this book from Celebrate Lit. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
August 1, 2017
THE RETURN is the third book in Ms. Fisher's Amish Beginning's series, and readers will want to read them in order starting with Anna's Crossing, then The Newcomer, followed by THE RETURN. This collection doesn't stand alone. I did read Anna's Crossing, but missed The Newcomer. I was glad Ms. Fisher included a list of characters and who they are or I probably would've been lost.
The story (series) is based on real life events that happened in the days of the early settling of our country. The Indians and English didn't always get along and there were some brutal attacks, and of course, the Amish wouldn't defend themselves against them so it's plausible parents might be killed and children kidnapped as slaves.
Fans of historical Amish will devour this series by Ms. Fisher. The fact that quite a lot of it is real is a total draw for fans of the Amish lifestyle. Don't miss this book or this series. This is a series worth collecting by those who collect facts and replicas of Amish lifestyles and goes beyond the totally fictionalized accounts.
I've long been a fan of Ms. Fisher's contemporary Amish series and hope she'll write more of them. I'm not sure if there are any more historical novels planned but she definitely stands tall among the few that write historical Amish well.
I was given a free copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
The story (series) is based on real life events that happened in the days of the early settling of our country. The Indians and English didn't always get along and there were some brutal attacks, and of course, the Amish wouldn't defend themselves against them so it's plausible parents might be killed and children kidnapped as slaves.
Fans of historical Amish will devour this series by Ms. Fisher. The fact that quite a lot of it is real is a total draw for fans of the Amish lifestyle. Don't miss this book or this series. This is a series worth collecting by those who collect facts and replicas of Amish lifestyles and goes beyond the totally fictionalized accounts.
I've long been a fan of Ms. Fisher's contemporary Amish series and hope she'll write more of them. I'm not sure if there are any more historical novels planned but she definitely stands tall among the few that write historical Amish well.
I was given a free copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
July 31, 2017
As I turned the final page of this three-book sage, I reflected on how things had changed and how the people we have come to know and love have matured and some have died, and others are just beginning their lives.
What a journey the author has brought us on, and one that will linger for a long time, but alas it is saying goodbye, but with love at new lives starting and hope for the future. As sad as some of the things that happen in this story, and the fact that they are based on truth, if we could only change history, but we hope we learn from events, but somehow some things keep getting repeated.
There are a few chuckles here, and some past perceptions are no longer viable, and we sure get to see some of the changes that have happened in the people that we have come to know.
These books are not the ordinary Amish stories, of romance and mystery, but a look into how they arrived in American, and where they settled, and how they were able to cling to their beliefs and survive here.
I will miss this family, as I feel I have become a part of, and can see the future in where we left off. I thank the author for the wonderful journey and a glimpse into the past.
I received this book through Revell Publishing Book Bloggers tour, and was not required to give a positive review.
What a journey the author has brought us on, and one that will linger for a long time, but alas it is saying goodbye, but with love at new lives starting and hope for the future. As sad as some of the things that happen in this story, and the fact that they are based on truth, if we could only change history, but we hope we learn from events, but somehow some things keep getting repeated.
There are a few chuckles here, and some past perceptions are no longer viable, and we sure get to see some of the changes that have happened in the people that we have come to know.
These books are not the ordinary Amish stories, of romance and mystery, but a look into how they arrived in American, and where they settled, and how they were able to cling to their beliefs and survive here.
I will miss this family, as I feel I have become a part of, and can see the future in where we left off. I thank the author for the wonderful journey and a glimpse into the past.
I received this book through Revell Publishing Book Bloggers tour, and was not required to give a positive review.
August 6, 2017
This is one stinkin’ awesome book. I knew it would be, and I’ve gotta tell you why I say that.
Characters:
One thing I just love about Suzanne Fisher is that she creates non-stereotypical characters. Amish men bent on driving out the “savages”? Yes. She went there. How about a dad who lets his boys run wild? Maybe a Mennonite attending Amish services? WHAT?
And in portraying the natives, she did something that is too often unbalanced. She shows us that there are ugly, bitter people in all societies. Yes, natives butchered and scalped “white folks.” White folks massacred natives. And the ugliness happened among the natives long before settlers arrived… and brought the ugliness they hoped to leave behind with them in their hearts.
Fisher shows this and shows it well.
As for specific characters, I loved that I was annoyed with Tessa… and knew she’d become my favorite... girl. Betsy… I really thought I’d learn to dislike her rather than be ambivalent. I didn’t. However, I was a bit irked by the sudden revelation at the end of who she envied and why. It was a bit predictable, cliched, and… much. Perhaps toned down a bit. I don’t know. It’s probably just me.
But of all the characters Clumsy Marty was my favorite. Yes, I love Barin’s occasional lapses into his brogue, and I REALLY didn’t appreciate the denigration of my beloved bagpipes, but aside from little quirks and delights, I really feel like this was Tessa’s tale.
History/Setting:
Set in Pennsylvania during the years before the War for Independence, we’re treated to more than the rolling hills of Lancaster County of modern expectations. Fisher takes us up the Monongahela, the Allegheny, into the villages of peaceable tribes. We’re introduced to the “inventor” of the Conestoga wagon and the enormous project such a design would have been.
Best of all, I think only once did a turn of phrase make me pause and wonder if they’d have said that then. Once. And the story distracted me so quickly that frankly, I don’t remember what it was. I looked for things that might be anachronistic. Didn’t find any. I even looked up things I was sure would be correct just in case I was wrong. Fisher has done her research well. I thank her. It’s so easy not to know TO look up something. So, well done. Very well done.
Story:
The one thing that stood out to me is that this is supposed to be “historical romance.” But Suzanne Fisher didn’t just write boy meets girl, falls in love, fights, makes up, marries. She wrote about the deep, rich, pain and joy-filled lives of “real” people and then introduced natural elements of those lives. Birth, death, family, tragedy, pride, grief, and love. The romance in this book is a natural response to a life well-lived. It’s the kind of romance I enjoy.
Memorable lines:
Okay, I had to mark a couple while I was reading. I had to pull half of them out because I can't load this up with them, but these really stood out to me:
Fear and greed can inspire tyranny in all men.
How true is that? I just LOVED it. Then there was this one:
'You remind me of Catrina's third husband.'
'Third husband? How many has she had?'
She narrowed her beady eyes at him. 'Two.'"
And finally, this gem. Oh, man this is one amazing gem right here:
What virtue does obedience have if it is not examined and then made to be a choice?
Recommended:
If you enjoy historical fiction, you’ll likely love this well-researched book.Amish fiction enthusiast? You’ll appreciate your favorite genre over two hundred fifty years ago. If you love rich characters and engaging story lines regardless of the genre, this book is for you.
And even better, if you haven't read the others--it doesn't matter. While the previous books will make reading this a richer experience, you do NOT need to.
One of the easiest five-stars I’ve ever given. I hope we get more in the series and I'm so glad I asked for a review copy.
And yeah, thanks a lot, Ms. Fisher. First, you drag me away from work to read your awesome book, and then you make me not want to go back to work. Well played... very well played. And I'll get bck to my overdue books now. Ahem. All your fault. Just sayin'.
Characters:
One thing I just love about Suzanne Fisher is that she creates non-stereotypical characters. Amish men bent on driving out the “savages”? Yes. She went there. How about a dad who lets his boys run wild? Maybe a Mennonite attending Amish services? WHAT?
And in portraying the natives, she did something that is too often unbalanced. She shows us that there are ugly, bitter people in all societies. Yes, natives butchered and scalped “white folks.” White folks massacred natives. And the ugliness happened among the natives long before settlers arrived… and brought the ugliness they hoped to leave behind with them in their hearts.
Fisher shows this and shows it well.
As for specific characters, I loved that I was annoyed with Tessa… and knew she’d become my favorite... girl. Betsy… I really thought I’d learn to dislike her rather than be ambivalent. I didn’t. However, I was a bit irked by the sudden revelation at the end of who she envied and why. It was a bit predictable, cliched, and… much. Perhaps toned down a bit. I don’t know. It’s probably just me.
But of all the characters Clumsy Marty was my favorite. Yes, I love Barin’s occasional lapses into his brogue, and I REALLY didn’t appreciate the denigration of my beloved bagpipes, but aside from little quirks and delights, I really feel like this was Tessa’s tale.
History/Setting:
Set in Pennsylvania during the years before the War for Independence, we’re treated to more than the rolling hills of Lancaster County of modern expectations. Fisher takes us up the Monongahela, the Allegheny, into the villages of peaceable tribes. We’re introduced to the “inventor” of the Conestoga wagon and the enormous project such a design would have been.
Best of all, I think only once did a turn of phrase make me pause and wonder if they’d have said that then. Once. And the story distracted me so quickly that frankly, I don’t remember what it was. I looked for things that might be anachronistic. Didn’t find any. I even looked up things I was sure would be correct just in case I was wrong. Fisher has done her research well. I thank her. It’s so easy not to know TO look up something. So, well done. Very well done.
Story:
The one thing that stood out to me is that this is supposed to be “historical romance.” But Suzanne Fisher didn’t just write boy meets girl, falls in love, fights, makes up, marries. She wrote about the deep, rich, pain and joy-filled lives of “real” people and then introduced natural elements of those lives. Birth, death, family, tragedy, pride, grief, and love. The romance in this book is a natural response to a life well-lived. It’s the kind of romance I enjoy.
Memorable lines:
Okay, I had to mark a couple while I was reading. I had to pull half of them out because I can't load this up with them, but these really stood out to me:
Fear and greed can inspire tyranny in all men.
How true is that? I just LOVED it. Then there was this one:
'You remind me of Catrina's third husband.'
'Third husband? How many has she had?'
She narrowed her beady eyes at him. 'Two.'"
And finally, this gem. Oh, man this is one amazing gem right here:
What virtue does obedience have if it is not examined and then made to be a choice?
Recommended:
If you enjoy historical fiction, you’ll likely love this well-researched book.Amish fiction enthusiast? You’ll appreciate your favorite genre over two hundred fifty years ago. If you love rich characters and engaging story lines regardless of the genre, this book is for you.
And even better, if you haven't read the others--it doesn't matter. While the previous books will make reading this a richer experience, you do NOT need to.
One of the easiest five-stars I’ve ever given. I hope we get more in the series and I'm so glad I asked for a review copy.
And yeah, thanks a lot, Ms. Fisher. First, you drag me away from work to read your awesome book, and then you make me not want to go back to work. Well played... very well played. And I'll get bck to my overdue books now. Ahem. All your fault. Just sayin'.
July 31, 2017
Before I start talking about Suzanne Woods Fisher's book The Return, book three in her Amish Beginnings Series, I have to say this: of all the books I enjoy reading I absolutely love books based on history. It doesn't matter if the history is here in the States, or the Holy Land, Britain (where my parent's families descend from), or elsewhere. I simply love history. With that said let me tell you about this book, The Return, by Suzanne Woods Fisher.
Now, when I say this I say it with the utmost respect I have ever seen in a writer. Not only is Suzanne a wonderful and thoughtful writer, attentive to detail, descriptive when it comes to setting a scene, and the way she writes how the people interact with one another, I felt transported back to the time when our ancestors were first settling America. I could feel the thunderous hoof beats of the wild stallion she writes of. I could feel the fear the children have when the Indian massacre on an innocent family takes place. I could even feel the jealousy of a girl who was slowly becoming a woman throughout the pages of this book.
I am actually so dumbfounded by how Suzanne Fisher has written this book that actual words escape me at this point. I have never seen a book so lovingly prepared for a reader such as myself and eventually scores more like myself. I may not be the biggest fan of romance novels, but this hardly fits the bill of a romance novel. I would say this book is more historical fiction than anything else. She has, I feel, put herself fully into this novel. Like she says in the back of her book, I can say as well, "Not now! I'm reading about an Indian attack!"
I admit that when I read something new and it excites me, gets my pulse up and running, and just gets me where I think the wheels are going to fly off the wagon as it speeds towards a cliff, it's worth a read to me. I actually could not put this book down at all. I read it in one night, actually one day, because I just didn't want to put it down! That's how wonderfully well Suzanne Fisher crafted this book. I have never known much of anything about the Amish, but this book shows me how sensitive, how thoughtful, and willing to sacrifice themselves when it comes to danger they actually are. What little we know of them makes it hard on us for them to trust outsiders. If we only knew how much they are just like the rest of the Christian community as we are can we ever truly relate to them.
Suzanne Woods Fisher is an award-winning, bestselling author of more and two dozen novels, including Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer in the Amish Beginning Series. Neither of these books have I read as of yet, but I plan on it as I simply loved this third book. She has also written nonfiction books about the Amish as well. You can learn more about her at Suzanne Woods Fisher and follow her on Twitter @suzannewfisher.
Note: I received this book compliments of Revell. The thoughts in this review are mine alone aside from the author's bio on the back side of The Return.
Now, when I say this I say it with the utmost respect I have ever seen in a writer. Not only is Suzanne a wonderful and thoughtful writer, attentive to detail, descriptive when it comes to setting a scene, and the way she writes how the people interact with one another, I felt transported back to the time when our ancestors were first settling America. I could feel the thunderous hoof beats of the wild stallion she writes of. I could feel the fear the children have when the Indian massacre on an innocent family takes place. I could even feel the jealousy of a girl who was slowly becoming a woman throughout the pages of this book.
I am actually so dumbfounded by how Suzanne Fisher has written this book that actual words escape me at this point. I have never seen a book so lovingly prepared for a reader such as myself and eventually scores more like myself. I may not be the biggest fan of romance novels, but this hardly fits the bill of a romance novel. I would say this book is more historical fiction than anything else. She has, I feel, put herself fully into this novel. Like she says in the back of her book, I can say as well, "Not now! I'm reading about an Indian attack!"
I admit that when I read something new and it excites me, gets my pulse up and running, and just gets me where I think the wheels are going to fly off the wagon as it speeds towards a cliff, it's worth a read to me. I actually could not put this book down at all. I read it in one night, actually one day, because I just didn't want to put it down! That's how wonderfully well Suzanne Fisher crafted this book. I have never known much of anything about the Amish, but this book shows me how sensitive, how thoughtful, and willing to sacrifice themselves when it comes to danger they actually are. What little we know of them makes it hard on us for them to trust outsiders. If we only knew how much they are just like the rest of the Christian community as we are can we ever truly relate to them.
Suzanne Woods Fisher is an award-winning, bestselling author of more and two dozen novels, including Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer in the Amish Beginning Series. Neither of these books have I read as of yet, but I plan on it as I simply loved this third book. She has also written nonfiction books about the Amish as well. You can learn more about her at Suzanne Woods Fisher and follow her on Twitter @suzannewfisher.
Note: I received this book compliments of Revell. The thoughts in this review are mine alone aside from the author's bio on the back side of The Return.
October 13, 2017
Not my favorite book in the series. I guess my expectations were too high after the first two books.
August 8, 2017
Betsy Zook is a beautiful, young Amish woman engaged to be married to her beloved Hans. Tessa, one year Betsy's junior is infatuated with Hans and can't help but wish Betsy would disappear. Then Betsy does. The Zook family farm is attacked by Native Americans; the parents are brutally murdered and the two older children, Betsy and her younger brother, are carried off into the wild to be sold or traded. The remaining Zook boy, who hid in the trees, comes to live with Tessa's family while plans are made to find his siblings. Tessa is horrified. She never wished something so horrible on Betsy. And yet, this could be her chance to win over the distraught Hans, assuming Betsy never returns.
The Return is a complicated historical fiction set in an Amish community a decade before the Revolutionary War. By complicated, I mean, there are multiple points of view and subplots stacking on top of each other. Betsy, Hans, Tessa, Tessa's mother Anna, and Tessa's uncle all take up primary focal points of the story. Their goals and actions bleed into one another. Two plot points take focus: romance and Native Americans.
First, the romance. There is the love triangle between Betsy, Hans, and Tessa that takes primary focus. But there is another young man who loves Betsy and yet another who loves Tessa. I guess it's a love pentagon with Hans right in the middle? Talk about complicated and jealousy. Still, it was done well. Also, there is another romance going on in the sidelines. It is between Tessa's widower uncle and a widowed woman who is hired to tutor his wild twin boys. They have their own issues to overcome, and it was lovely watching them come together ... with a lot of kicking and screaming at the beginning.
Second is the complex relationship between the Native American peoples and the European settlers. Most of the main characters in this book are German Amish settlers. They are pacifists and most would not wish any harm upon their Native American neighbors. Some of the other settlers have different views, however. As for the Native Americans, it is almost as equally divided. There are the peoples who wish only to live their lives in peace and contentedness, and there are others who plunder and destroy the settlers. Both sides are represented. Betsy sees it first-hand, between the bloody massacre of her kidnapping and her subsequent adoption into a Native American family. The first are cruel and murderous, the second, kind and peaceful. Her fiance, Hans can't see them the way she does, though. He determines that they are all evil, and he will do nearly anything to put a stop to their murderous ways. In the end, there are massacres of the settlers by the Native Americans, massacres of the Native Americans by the settlers, and peaceful people on both sides wanting to coexist. Complicated, but true to life. I appreciated how well it was addressed.
I really enjoyed this novel. The plot was all over the place, but it was fascinating and intriguing on many levels. I highly recommend it.
I did receive a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, but it in now way influenced by review, positively or negatively.
The Return is a complicated historical fiction set in an Amish community a decade before the Revolutionary War. By complicated, I mean, there are multiple points of view and subplots stacking on top of each other. Betsy, Hans, Tessa, Tessa's mother Anna, and Tessa's uncle all take up primary focal points of the story. Their goals and actions bleed into one another. Two plot points take focus: romance and Native Americans.
First, the romance. There is the love triangle between Betsy, Hans, and Tessa that takes primary focus. But there is another young man who loves Betsy and yet another who loves Tessa. I guess it's a love pentagon with Hans right in the middle? Talk about complicated and jealousy. Still, it was done well. Also, there is another romance going on in the sidelines. It is between Tessa's widower uncle and a widowed woman who is hired to tutor his wild twin boys. They have their own issues to overcome, and it was lovely watching them come together ... with a lot of kicking and screaming at the beginning.
Second is the complex relationship between the Native American peoples and the European settlers. Most of the main characters in this book are German Amish settlers. They are pacifists and most would not wish any harm upon their Native American neighbors. Some of the other settlers have different views, however. As for the Native Americans, it is almost as equally divided. There are the peoples who wish only to live their lives in peace and contentedness, and there are others who plunder and destroy the settlers. Both sides are represented. Betsy sees it first-hand, between the bloody massacre of her kidnapping and her subsequent adoption into a Native American family. The first are cruel and murderous, the second, kind and peaceful. Her fiance, Hans can't see them the way she does, though. He determines that they are all evil, and he will do nearly anything to put a stop to their murderous ways. In the end, there are massacres of the settlers by the Native Americans, massacres of the Native Americans by the settlers, and peaceful people on both sides wanting to coexist. Complicated, but true to life. I appreciated how well it was addressed.
I really enjoyed this novel. The plot was all over the place, but it was fascinating and intriguing on many levels. I highly recommend it.
I did receive a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, but it in now way influenced by review, positively or negatively.
August 16, 2017
Um, wow. Review to come as soon as my heart rate calms and these happy feelings diminish enough for me to function properly. <33
// UPDATED
A beautifully and intricately woven tale of love and loss, faith and freedom. Once The Return tugged me into the storyline, I was hard-pressed to leave. Originally, I'd worried that I wouldn't like this book as much as the first two since it skipped 25 years, but I need not have worried. I had only read 70 or so pages when I sat down with the book this morning, and I finished it today. Charming, heartwarming, and faith-filled. It was amazing. <3
This book truly is, as the back cover synopsis suggests, a 'deeply layered' novel. Besides the main plot (which is quite complicated in itself) there are several little subplots to add to the enjoyment. There are quite a few characters to keep straight (the list of brief bios in the front of the book helped with that though *wink*), oodles of different things going on, and yet it was never confusing.
The characters... *happy sigh* Oh my goodness, don't even get me started. I already loved Anna, Bairn, and Felix from the first two books. And I really loved getting to know Tessa, Hans, Betsy, Caleb, and all the others. The family love, the humor and joshing, the warmth and whimsicalness of it all... I'm seriously wanting to move to Stoney Ridge right now. <3
I honestly can't think of any complaints concerning the book. There was a fair amount of violence when there's talk of Indian massacres and the atrocities surrounding such brutal incidents. I was okay with it, but I would be careful recommending the book to someone younger than 13/14.
I believe this is my favorite book of the series, and I will definitely be keeping an eye out for other books by Suzanne Woods Fisher. A hearty 5 stars!
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell Publishing in exchange for my honest review.**
// UPDATED
A beautifully and intricately woven tale of love and loss, faith and freedom. Once The Return tugged me into the storyline, I was hard-pressed to leave. Originally, I'd worried that I wouldn't like this book as much as the first two since it skipped 25 years, but I need not have worried. I had only read 70 or so pages when I sat down with the book this morning, and I finished it today. Charming, heartwarming, and faith-filled. It was amazing. <3
This book truly is, as the back cover synopsis suggests, a 'deeply layered' novel. Besides the main plot (which is quite complicated in itself) there are several little subplots to add to the enjoyment. There are quite a few characters to keep straight (the list of brief bios in the front of the book helped with that though *wink*), oodles of different things going on, and yet it was never confusing.
The characters... *happy sigh* Oh my goodness, don't even get me started. I already loved Anna, Bairn, and Felix from the first two books. And I really loved getting to know Tessa, Hans, Betsy, Caleb, and all the others. The family love, the humor and joshing, the warmth and whimsicalness of it all... I'm seriously wanting to move to Stoney Ridge right now. <3
I honestly can't think of any complaints concerning the book. There was a fair amount of violence when there's talk of Indian massacres and the atrocities surrounding such brutal incidents. I was okay with it, but I would be careful recommending the book to someone younger than 13/14.
I believe this is my favorite book of the series, and I will definitely be keeping an eye out for other books by Suzanne Woods Fisher. A hearty 5 stars!
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell Publishing in exchange for my honest review.**
August 28, 2017
The Return is Book Three in the Amish Beginnings series and though it reads perfectly fine as a standalone, readers who have been following this series will be thrilled to recognize some beloved faces among the characters in Stoney Ridge circa 1762. In particular Felix, that mischievous bundle of energy that exasperated all the adults and provided so much entertainment for readers in previous books, is now a grown man with sons of his own. He's even a deacon! But there are still glimpses of the rascally boy in thought and deed. I think I loved those bits the best.
Anna and Bairn are in their forties, parents of a teen-aged daughter. Their happily ever after hasn't gone as smoothly as I imagined at the end of The Newcomer, but they are just as in love as ever -- more really, as their love has deepened through shared experiences -- hardship and pain, joy and sorrow. I loved being a party to their mature love.
Despite the blurb on the back of the book, I really feel that this is largely Tessa's story. (Anna and Bairn's daughter.) We get a lot of her point of view, as well as Betsy's and several others. Fisher has interwoven layers of individual stories that ultimately come together in an astounding way.
"What life does to you depends on what life finds in you." (p. 109) plays out brilliantly in the lives of these early settlers as they face challenges, danger and ultimately truth in a tumultuous period of America's history. A wonderful mix of laughter and tears and tons of fascinating history make for a riveting read.
Book provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications Inc.
Anna and Bairn are in their forties, parents of a teen-aged daughter. Their happily ever after hasn't gone as smoothly as I imagined at the end of The Newcomer, but they are just as in love as ever -- more really, as their love has deepened through shared experiences -- hardship and pain, joy and sorrow. I loved being a party to their mature love.
Despite the blurb on the back of the book, I really feel that this is largely Tessa's story. (Anna and Bairn's daughter.) We get a lot of her point of view, as well as Betsy's and several others. Fisher has interwoven layers of individual stories that ultimately come together in an astounding way.
"What life does to you depends on what life finds in you." (p. 109) plays out brilliantly in the lives of these early settlers as they face challenges, danger and ultimately truth in a tumultuous period of America's history. A wonderful mix of laughter and tears and tons of fascinating history make for a riveting read.
Book provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications Inc.
August 24, 2017
I have completely enjoyed this series! I've been reading Suzanne's books for quite some time so I am familiar with the Stoney Ridge community. It has been interesting to go back to the beginning and see how the community was established and meet the people who through faith and endurance brought it about.
The Return is the third and final book in this series. I think it can be read as a stand alone novel but of course you'll miss out on all the tidbits of what has gone on before to bring them to this point. Of the three books I felt like this one was the most dramatic and compelling. I hope that Ms. Fisher writes a follow-up series that continues on from here. While the story itself is complete there are still threads that I would like to follow and see where they lead.
One of the most interesting aspects of this novel was that it was based on factual happenings. The author's note at the end explains what parts of the story were true. In my opinion that is what gave this story and series such an intriguing sense of authenticity.
If you are a fan of historical fiction then I think you will like this book. The triumphs and pitfalls of our forefathers are presented in a compelling way and should make for a very compelling read.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
The Return is the third and final book in this series. I think it can be read as a stand alone novel but of course you'll miss out on all the tidbits of what has gone on before to bring them to this point. Of the three books I felt like this one was the most dramatic and compelling. I hope that Ms. Fisher writes a follow-up series that continues on from here. While the story itself is complete there are still threads that I would like to follow and see where they lead.
One of the most interesting aspects of this novel was that it was based on factual happenings. The author's note at the end explains what parts of the story were true. In my opinion that is what gave this story and series such an intriguing sense of authenticity.
If you are a fan of historical fiction then I think you will like this book. The triumphs and pitfalls of our forefathers are presented in a compelling way and should make for a very compelling read.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
August 9, 2017
A touching story including history, family devotion, cultural divides, and so much more. The author tells a powerful story of families, friends and their differences. Danger and worry flow throughout the story due to circumstances Trusting God for His guidance and provision helps the characters deal with emotional situations. This is a story I will read again. I enjoyed this one very much. I received a copy of this story from the author and Net Galley and this is my honest personal opinion.
June 9, 2017
This stunning book definitely desrves 5 stars!!
When u first open this book it's like everyone's emotions just slap you in the face and before you know it you're on the ride of a lifetime!
I love this author's style because that's exactly what she does! Sends you spiraling into time warp.
I think I enjoyed it too because it's not your typical Amish book.
I love reading books that involves Indians! I could actually hear their war cries and it made the hairs stand up on the back of my neck!
My husband had to tell me to put the book down 3 times since I had to work the next day. My but it was hard to!!
Felix good ol Felix! He made me crack up and I didn't really see the need to grow up at all! Shoot! I'm an adult but I will never grow up lol!! It's no fun to grow up!
He's my delightful Felix! Sometimes tho I wanted to choke him and make him see what is right in front of his face! That man has been blessed twice over!
Poor Tessa! I've been in her spot before. I felt like people or certain person looking right through me like I wasn't there! Yes, I've had my heart broken and I've never forgotten my first love because he had left a deep impact on me for life and not all good either!!
Jealousy hits us like a thunderbolt. Many times I've felt that way. Why must certain ppl always get things handed to them on a silver platter? and others have to work for it?
I think Tessa has learned her lessons in life the hard way like I have to and still do.
I really enjoyed this story! Definitely burned the midnight oil!
Love just smacks you in the face or it can sneak up on you where you least expect it and friendships form whether you want to or not.
God has a way of working these things out in His own timing
When u first open this book it's like everyone's emotions just slap you in the face and before you know it you're on the ride of a lifetime!
I love this author's style because that's exactly what she does! Sends you spiraling into time warp.
I think I enjoyed it too because it's not your typical Amish book.
I love reading books that involves Indians! I could actually hear their war cries and it made the hairs stand up on the back of my neck!
My husband had to tell me to put the book down 3 times since I had to work the next day. My but it was hard to!!
Felix good ol Felix! He made me crack up and I didn't really see the need to grow up at all! Shoot! I'm an adult but I will never grow up lol!! It's no fun to grow up!
He's my delightful Felix! Sometimes tho I wanted to choke him and make him see what is right in front of his face! That man has been blessed twice over!
Poor Tessa! I've been in her spot before. I felt like people or certain person looking right through me like I wasn't there! Yes, I've had my heart broken and I've never forgotten my first love because he had left a deep impact on me for life and not all good either!!
Jealousy hits us like a thunderbolt. Many times I've felt that way. Why must certain ppl always get things handed to them on a silver platter? and others have to work for it?
I think Tessa has learned her lessons in life the hard way like I have to and still do.
I really enjoyed this story! Definitely burned the midnight oil!
Love just smacks you in the face or it can sneak up on you where you least expect it and friendships form whether you want to or not.
God has a way of working these things out in His own timing
August 21, 2017
The Return is a magnificent, enthralling, powerful, insightful and historical researched to the fullest to captivate readers into the early years of the Amish settlers in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. I’ve never been disappointed in any of Suzanne Woods Fisher’s books with this one definitely being the best one and a lovely conclusion to her Amish Beginnings series.
The characters are strong, filled with faith and determination as they are settling and moving forward in their communities, despite all the setbacks and attacks by Indians and others in 1763 – 64. My senses were on alert whether I was reading about an Indian attack or other attackers due to their strong feelings of revenge toward the Indians, traveling through the woods, the preparation of food and clothes, hunting, church services and reunion of lost loved ones. I was weeping at times in pain and sorrow and then the tears were happy ones due to the reunion of family members that had been separated during an attack. My heart broke for young Betsy and other secondary characters but their connection to individuals with faith, their own faith and beliefs kept them going during the dark hours of their lives. The design and finished product of the Conestoga Wagon added depth to this outstanding historical romance fiction. The Return shows the strong character of individuals with their faith, spirit and never failing love of God shining through. The scriptures interwoven throughout the story added to the characters’ lives and how they faced each valley or mountain top they were given.
I’m sorry to see Amish Beginnings come to an end. I would appreciate seeing a new series with an update on Betsy, Willie, and Johnny Zook, Anna, Bairn, and Tessa Bauer, Caleb, and other major characters. Even if it’s another 25 years like The Return was from Anna’s Crossing. Suzanne Woods Fisher research is superb in the history of this era and the settling of the little church of Ixheim in the New World. Thank you to Suzanne Woods Fisher for all her dedication to historical research to make this one of the best Amish genre Christian historical/romance fiction series.
I encourage Amish genre or historical genre readers to pick up a copy of the entire series to read. You'll appreciate the depth of this series filled with strong characters, action, history and the never ending sovereignty of God.
The characters are strong, filled with faith and determination as they are settling and moving forward in their communities, despite all the setbacks and attacks by Indians and others in 1763 – 64. My senses were on alert whether I was reading about an Indian attack or other attackers due to their strong feelings of revenge toward the Indians, traveling through the woods, the preparation of food and clothes, hunting, church services and reunion of lost loved ones. I was weeping at times in pain and sorrow and then the tears were happy ones due to the reunion of family members that had been separated during an attack. My heart broke for young Betsy and other secondary characters but their connection to individuals with faith, their own faith and beliefs kept them going during the dark hours of their lives. The design and finished product of the Conestoga Wagon added depth to this outstanding historical romance fiction. The Return shows the strong character of individuals with their faith, spirit and never failing love of God shining through. The scriptures interwoven throughout the story added to the characters’ lives and how they faced each valley or mountain top they were given.
I’m sorry to see Amish Beginnings come to an end. I would appreciate seeing a new series with an update on Betsy, Willie, and Johnny Zook, Anna, Bairn, and Tessa Bauer, Caleb, and other major characters. Even if it’s another 25 years like The Return was from Anna’s Crossing. Suzanne Woods Fisher research is superb in the history of this era and the settling of the little church of Ixheim in the New World. Thank you to Suzanne Woods Fisher for all her dedication to historical research to make this one of the best Amish genre Christian historical/romance fiction series.
I encourage Amish genre or historical genre readers to pick up a copy of the entire series to read. You'll appreciate the depth of this series filled with strong characters, action, history and the never ending sovereignty of God.
July 30, 2024
I truthfully did not think I would like this book in the beginning and I considered a DNF. We are following some of the same characters, but when they are older and have had their own children. It took me a little while to care about the new characters. But, then it started getting really interesting and I ended up really enjoying it!
Also, I actually loved the ending! Usually I want things to be all cut and dry but I enjoyed not knowing EXACTLY what happened in the end.
This was a good read for me and I enjoyed this series a lot!
Also, I actually loved the ending! Usually I want things to be all cut and dry but I enjoyed not knowing EXACTLY what happened in the end.
This was a good read for me and I enjoyed this series a lot!
August 1, 2017
I have loved every installment of the Amish Beginnings series and have been impatiently waiting for The Return to release. I’ll say it before, and I’ll say it again, how wonderful that Suzanne Woods Fisher has combined my love for Amish fiction and historical fiction. Not only combined them, but wove the genres together like a perfectly sewn blanket. I wonder if perhaps more Amish fiction writers may decide to go in this direction because it appears to be gaining in popularity.
Here’s the thing about this book. It has parts that will make you weep; parts that will make you laugh; parts that will make you gasp; and even parts that will make you mad. It is quite clear that the author took her time in researching this time period, and way the Indians and English interacted with each other, and even some of the legends from this time period. I really felt as if I had climbed aboard a time machine and woke up in the 1700’s. It was certainly scary, and I found myself thankful to be living here and now.
Although the book blurb points to Betsy’s story, I really felt it was a story about Tessa. She had a lot of growing up to do, and her love for Hans seemed to affect her more than I would have liked. However, I can certainly understand how a young woman can be overcome with emotion for a boy that does not return the feelings. I would have liked to see more discussion about her friendship with Martin. Perhaps that is for another installment.
Betsy’s story however, really captured my heart. Although facing a scary situation, and not knowing if she would live or die, Betsy seemed so brave and determined to make it. There is one scene in particular that gave me goosebumps. I won’t give away any spoilers, except to say that she was being mocked by an Indian who was holding something quite grotesque in his hand. I’m glad there wasn’t great detail provided about it, but at that very moment I didn’t just see Betsy’s pain. I saw something change in her character and it was so intriguing that I kept turning the pages to see how she’d make out.
There is an underlying love story here that doesn’t get confirmation until near the end. But if you look for clues you will probably discover it about half way through. I am glad that Suzanne chose to include this in the story. It was something different, something a little unexpected, and something that left possibilities for the future. I do hope to see something happen for this couple in the next installment!
Overall this is a wonderful read that will appease historic and amish fiction fans. I felt right at home reading about these characters and their surroundings. Now if only there wasn’t so much time in between book releases 😉 I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Here’s the thing about this book. It has parts that will make you weep; parts that will make you laugh; parts that will make you gasp; and even parts that will make you mad. It is quite clear that the author took her time in researching this time period, and way the Indians and English interacted with each other, and even some of the legends from this time period. I really felt as if I had climbed aboard a time machine and woke up in the 1700’s. It was certainly scary, and I found myself thankful to be living here and now.
Although the book blurb points to Betsy’s story, I really felt it was a story about Tessa. She had a lot of growing up to do, and her love for Hans seemed to affect her more than I would have liked. However, I can certainly understand how a young woman can be overcome with emotion for a boy that does not return the feelings. I would have liked to see more discussion about her friendship with Martin. Perhaps that is for another installment.
Betsy’s story however, really captured my heart. Although facing a scary situation, and not knowing if she would live or die, Betsy seemed so brave and determined to make it. There is one scene in particular that gave me goosebumps. I won’t give away any spoilers, except to say that she was being mocked by an Indian who was holding something quite grotesque in his hand. I’m glad there wasn’t great detail provided about it, but at that very moment I didn’t just see Betsy’s pain. I saw something change in her character and it was so intriguing that I kept turning the pages to see how she’d make out.
There is an underlying love story here that doesn’t get confirmation until near the end. But if you look for clues you will probably discover it about half way through. I am glad that Suzanne chose to include this in the story. It was something different, something a little unexpected, and something that left possibilities for the future. I do hope to see something happen for this couple in the next installment!
Overall this is a wonderful read that will appease historic and amish fiction fans. I felt right at home reading about these characters and their surroundings. Now if only there wasn’t so much time in between book releases 😉 I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
August 7, 2017
In The Return, author Fisher’s third in her extraordinary series Amish Beginnings, we are once again reunited with Bairn and Anna and their family. Felix and Hans have both grown up as some years have passed, and Bairn is now the minister. This story focused on Anna and Bairn’s daughter, Tessa and newly arrived from Germany, Betsy. We are treated to Anna’s and Felix’s voices as well as the story is told from their viewpoints.
As the story goes, we start with a bit of a tangled love mess. Tessa is in love with Hans and Hans is in love with Betsy. However, Betsy is taken captive during an Indian raid on her home and Hans has become a man driven by grief and determination to get her back. In the meantime, he and Tessa grow closer together.
We the reader are taken with Betsy on her journey through captivity and the author writes vividly the emotions and feelings that young Betsy is experiencing. The ruthlessness of the massacre to the trading to any Indian family of sisters where she is made to feel at home and even loved. In her captivity Betsy meets Caleb, a half breed and a captive slave and forms a bond of friendship that changes her view of life.
This story vividly portrayed how different and how difficult it was for the Amish, Mennonite, other settlers, and the Indian tribes to get along. The difficulty to reconcile their differences and live in peace when they viewed religion, rights, and land so differently. This was a read full of angst, grit, and determination as these young ladies tried to live in a harsh and difficult world that many times went against their beliefs. I appreciated the author’s notes on how much of this story was true and again I stand amazed at all the pioneers and what they endured in the wilderness of America.
I received an e-copy of this book for free. I did purchase a paperback for my keeper shelf. I was not required to post a positive review and the views and opinions expressed are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
As the story goes, we start with a bit of a tangled love mess. Tessa is in love with Hans and Hans is in love with Betsy. However, Betsy is taken captive during an Indian raid on her home and Hans has become a man driven by grief and determination to get her back. In the meantime, he and Tessa grow closer together.
We the reader are taken with Betsy on her journey through captivity and the author writes vividly the emotions and feelings that young Betsy is experiencing. The ruthlessness of the massacre to the trading to any Indian family of sisters where she is made to feel at home and even loved. In her captivity Betsy meets Caleb, a half breed and a captive slave and forms a bond of friendship that changes her view of life.
This story vividly portrayed how different and how difficult it was for the Amish, Mennonite, other settlers, and the Indian tribes to get along. The difficulty to reconcile their differences and live in peace when they viewed religion, rights, and land so differently. This was a read full of angst, grit, and determination as these young ladies tried to live in a harsh and difficult world that many times went against their beliefs. I appreciated the author’s notes on how much of this story was true and again I stand amazed at all the pioneers and what they endured in the wilderness of America.
I received an e-copy of this book for free. I did purchase a paperback for my keeper shelf. I was not required to post a positive review and the views and opinions expressed are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
August 28, 2017
The last novel in Suzanne Woods Fisher's "Amish Beginnings" series was one of the most emotionally stirring novels that I have read this year. Fisher absolutely succeeded at immersing me into historical Pennsylvania, capturing the challenging nuances of 1763, especially the ever growing tension that existed between the settlers and the Native American people groups. From the moment that Betsy was taken into captivity, I felt torn between wanting to put the book down to get away from the trauma she experienced, but still wanting to see how things resolved. Fisher does an amazing job at counterbalancing some of the more difficult scenes with some truly light-hearted and funny moments. "The Return" is chock-full of drama of the best kind, with tense scenes and unexpected twists that had me racing through the pages. The characters have been developed with care, and some I grew to love, while others I grew to really dislike, especially those giving into a profoundly disturbing racism and prejudice. In a political climate that seems ever more torn by clashing cultures and values, "The Return" offers a timely story that reminds us that God has made all peoples in his image, and all have equal worth. The characters in this story learn some very difficult lessons as a result of their experiences, and I encourage people to pick up this story and be reminded of the things that truly matter in life - our faith in God and trusting in his sovereignty. Humans may make the same mistakes over and over throughout history, but his good plan will prevail!
"The Return" is a stirring, emotionally satisfying novel that truly honours the real events it is based on. Readers could easily read this novel on its own, but I encourage anyone who loves well-written historical fiction to pick up all three books of this series. Fisher has truly out done herself! I award this novel a full 5 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
"The Return" is a stirring, emotionally satisfying novel that truly honours the real events it is based on. Readers could easily read this novel on its own, but I encourage anyone who loves well-written historical fiction to pick up all three books of this series. Fisher has truly out done herself! I award this novel a full 5 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
August 15, 2017
Tuesday, August 15, 2017
The Return by Suzanne Woods Fisher, © 2017
Amish Beginnings series, Book 3
My Review:
I enjoyed this novel very much because it was true to historical events we might not be aware of in detail. So well written, the days opened and closed awaiting the next day. The story surrounds three brothers and their families continuing from the first two books. This may be read as a standalone, but you will enjoy the background in Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anna's Crossing, of Amish coming to the New World, and settling in Penn's Woods in The Newcomer.
The beginnings of Stoney Ridge. I especially liked how each character's skill fit into the daily life of the whole. Community. Revolving around each other and fulfilled, because they did not stand alone. They were aided by Indian families nearby when they came; learning about the Three Sisters ~ beans, corn, and squash and the merging of their qualities.
The beans fed the soil for the corn, and the squash vines provided shade for the roots of the corn.
The Return, 241
I think of corn as a main staple for its many uses. All three interwoven to protect and nourish the whole.
Very synonymous with our lives. We need each other. Not separate, merging skills and prayers.
(1762-1764.) This story begins twenty-five years later than the last book in the series. There is encroaching into the Indians' hunting lands set aside by treaty early in the 1700s designating borders for settler lands.
With the ensuing dangers brought on by both sides, threatened existence caused changed lives. Though taken as an exchange, Betsy Zook finds she is cared for in place of another. Revolts continued as those ensuring peace come against agitators proclaiming warring forces.
***Thank you to Revell Reads for sending a print copy of Suzanne Woods Fisher's The Return. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
The Return by Suzanne Woods Fisher, © 2017
Amish Beginnings series, Book 3
My Review:
I enjoyed this novel very much because it was true to historical events we might not be aware of in detail. So well written, the days opened and closed awaiting the next day. The story surrounds three brothers and their families continuing from the first two books. This may be read as a standalone, but you will enjoy the background in Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anna's Crossing, of Amish coming to the New World, and settling in Penn's Woods in The Newcomer.
The beginnings of Stoney Ridge. I especially liked how each character's skill fit into the daily life of the whole. Community. Revolving around each other and fulfilled, because they did not stand alone. They were aided by Indian families nearby when they came; learning about the Three Sisters ~ beans, corn, and squash and the merging of their qualities.
The beans fed the soil for the corn, and the squash vines provided shade for the roots of the corn.
The Return, 241
I think of corn as a main staple for its many uses. All three interwoven to protect and nourish the whole.
Very synonymous with our lives. We need each other. Not separate, merging skills and prayers.
(1762-1764.) This story begins twenty-five years later than the last book in the series. There is encroaching into the Indians' hunting lands set aside by treaty early in the 1700s designating borders for settler lands.
With the ensuing dangers brought on by both sides, threatened existence caused changed lives. Though taken as an exchange, Betsy Zook finds she is cared for in place of another. Revolts continued as those ensuring peace come against agitators proclaiming warring forces.
***Thank you to Revell Reads for sending a print copy of Suzanne Woods Fisher's The Return. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
August 11, 2017
The Return by Suzanne Wood Fisher is the third book in the Amish Beginning series. Currently, this is considered to be the conclusion to the series. When I asked the author, she did say a continuation is possible; if enough interest is expressed. So, let’s hope that happens because this series is amazing!
In The Return, we are once again immersed in the lives of the first Amish settlers. Frontier life is never easy and even harder for the Amish pacifists.
The natives distrust the Amish and the Amish distrust the natives. Good relations between the two groups crumbles as racial intolerance finds a foothold. Innocent people, both the natives and Amish alike suffer the consequences.
This book picks up fifteen years after The Newcomer ends. Bairn’s father has passed away and Bairn has taken over as bishop of the fledgling community. He and Anna have one child together, Tessa. They also and act as mentors to Bairn’s adopted brother, Hans.
Every single character in this book is so well-developed. I appreciated that Suzanne didn’t make the “Indians” out to be the monsters of the story. She showed that evil can exist in all cultures as well as good.
I couldn’t put this book down and I would love to know more about Tessa, Caleb, Martin, and Betsy. I would like to see this series continued as I’m invested in the lives of the early settlers.
This book has humor, the horrors of humanity and the unfailing love of God within its pages. Suzanne brings to life the struggles of the early Anabaptist settlers. Though she explores topics of racism and uses the word “Indian,” she does so in a historically accurate way. I had great respect that she did not demonize the Native Americans.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Celebrate Lit. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. All opinions are my own.
This review was originally posted on A Simply Enchanted Life
August 17, 2017
First sentence: As Betsy climbed up from the creek carrying two buckets of water, she heard the sound of her brothers' laughter, and then a man's deeper laugh.
The Return is the third book in the Amish Beginnings series by Suzanne Woods Fisher. The first two in the series are Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer. Several decades have passed and this novel mainly focuses on the next generation. One of the heroines, for example, is Tessa Bauer the daughter of Bairn and Anna. The other heroine is Betsy Zook.
Tensions are HIGH between the white settlers and the Native Americans. While many of the Amish are happy to be at peace--stay at peace--there are a few men in the community that are hotheaded and lack common sense and decency. John Elder, for example, is one advocating the philosophy that the only good Indian is a dead Indian. Anna and Bairn think differently, as do most of the characters in the novel. But HANS (the foster brother of Felix and Bairn) goes a bit nuts when Betsy Zook, the supposed love of his life is kidnapped. Tessa sees Betsy's kidnapping by Indians as an opportunity to win Hans affection and attention.
The narrative shifts between Betsy and Tessa--mostly. Betsy meets Caleb, a "half-breed" with a Mennonite mother and an Indian father. The two become super-super close. And if I'm honest Caleb is without a doubt my favorite character in the book. In fact I HATED Hans. (I probably shouldn't say that.)
I definitely liked the book. I loved some characters; I liked some characters; and then there was Hans!
The Return is the third book in the Amish Beginnings series by Suzanne Woods Fisher. The first two in the series are Anna's Crossing and The Newcomer. Several decades have passed and this novel mainly focuses on the next generation. One of the heroines, for example, is Tessa Bauer the daughter of Bairn and Anna. The other heroine is Betsy Zook.
Tensions are HIGH between the white settlers and the Native Americans. While many of the Amish are happy to be at peace--stay at peace--there are a few men in the community that are hotheaded and lack common sense and decency. John Elder, for example, is one advocating the philosophy that the only good Indian is a dead Indian. Anna and Bairn think differently, as do most of the characters in the novel. But HANS (the foster brother of Felix and Bairn) goes a bit nuts when Betsy Zook, the supposed love of his life is kidnapped. Tessa sees Betsy's kidnapping by Indians as an opportunity to win Hans affection and attention.
The narrative shifts between Betsy and Tessa--mostly. Betsy meets Caleb, a "half-breed" with a Mennonite mother and an Indian father. The two become super-super close. And if I'm honest Caleb is without a doubt my favorite character in the book. In fact I HATED Hans. (I probably shouldn't say that.)
I definitely liked the book. I loved some characters; I liked some characters; and then there was Hans!
August 19, 2017
Amish and Savages and More, Oh My!
It was with great delight and sadness that I received my copy of Suzanne Woods Fisher’s newest release, The Return... Delight because I knew I would love another Fisher novel – I’ve been waiting for this one! Sadness because this meant the end of her Amish Beginnings series! I guarantee you’ll love this one!
The Return is set 25 years since the last in the series, The Newcomer, and it’s full of suspense and good old fashioned adventure. What a cast of characters! Of course Bairn, Anna, and Felix and the gang are all back. But there’s also beautiful Betsy, taken captive after an Indian raid on her Amish farm. Little Hans has grown up to be handsome Hans who adores Betsy, but not Indians. And don’t overlook troubled Tessa who has an adventurous spirit…and loves Hans. How will this all resolve? I bet you can’t figure out the ending…read and find out!
I was given The Return in exchange for my honest review. While it can be read as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading the series in chronological order. No only will the storylines flow better, but the series is THAT good. The characters are engaging and enjoyable. Fisher does a tremendous job of pulling readers in and transporting them to 1760s Pennsylvania. What a wonderful ending to a phenomenal series! Five stars, hands down!
It was with great delight and sadness that I received my copy of Suzanne Woods Fisher’s newest release, The Return... Delight because I knew I would love another Fisher novel – I’ve been waiting for this one! Sadness because this meant the end of her Amish Beginnings series! I guarantee you’ll love this one!
The Return is set 25 years since the last in the series, The Newcomer, and it’s full of suspense and good old fashioned adventure. What a cast of characters! Of course Bairn, Anna, and Felix and the gang are all back. But there’s also beautiful Betsy, taken captive after an Indian raid on her Amish farm. Little Hans has grown up to be handsome Hans who adores Betsy, but not Indians. And don’t overlook troubled Tessa who has an adventurous spirit…and loves Hans. How will this all resolve? I bet you can’t figure out the ending…read and find out!
I was given The Return in exchange for my honest review. While it can be read as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading the series in chronological order. No only will the storylines flow better, but the series is THAT good. The characters are engaging and enjoyable. Fisher does a tremendous job of pulling readers in and transporting them to 1760s Pennsylvania. What a wonderful ending to a phenomenal series! Five stars, hands down!
April 5, 2020
This novel is feisty and sassy! I like how the authoress was able to interwoven the feelings and actions of wild-at-heart teenager into the creuel realities of the colonisation of the West.
This one is a third part of the Amish Beginnings series - the main characters from the previous installments, Anna and and Bairn, are parents of a rebellious Tessa, whose character plays the main role here. Tessa is in love with Hans, but Hans has his eyes set on Betsy Zook, who is everything that Tessa is not - namely beautiful. But then Betsy got kidnapped and Tessa might get her way to Hans´s heart, only if she did not see the yearning in his eyes!
Betsy´s life in the captivity is easied with the help of Caleb, half-Indian and Christian.
But what will become of them in the times of return?
Very interesting take on the beginnings of the Amish community! One gets very curious about how such a peaceful people could survive in such hard times of Indian raids and not less cruel (maybe even more) colonists´s killings and oppression of the Native people. My favourite ingredient of the story is Tessa´s teenage sassiness and frankness, which is very fresh. I also like how Anna and Bairn generally are very mature people, yet they stay real and relatable.
While I do think that Betsy´s captivity went very easily as she is a girl of child-bearing age, I appreciate the condemnation of the abusive behavior of colonizers towards natives.
Good read!
This one is a third part of the Amish Beginnings series - the main characters from the previous installments, Anna and and Bairn, are parents of a rebellious Tessa, whose character plays the main role here. Tessa is in love with Hans, but Hans has his eyes set on Betsy Zook, who is everything that Tessa is not - namely beautiful. But then Betsy got kidnapped and Tessa might get her way to Hans´s heart, only if she did not see the yearning in his eyes!
Betsy´s life in the captivity is easied with the help of Caleb, half-Indian and Christian.
But what will become of them in the times of return?
Very interesting take on the beginnings of the Amish community! One gets very curious about how such a peaceful people could survive in such hard times of Indian raids and not less cruel (maybe even more) colonists´s killings and oppression of the Native people. My favourite ingredient of the story is Tessa´s teenage sassiness and frankness, which is very fresh. I also like how Anna and Bairn generally are very mature people, yet they stay real and relatable.
While I do think that Betsy´s captivity went very easily as she is a girl of child-bearing age, I appreciate the condemnation of the abusive behavior of colonizers towards natives.
Good read!
August 1, 2017
Suzanne Woods Fisher’s newest book, The Return, centers around the Amish in Beacon Hollow, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, in 1763 and is inspired by real events.
Betsy Zook and her little brother Johnny are captured by Indians and forced to march on a long, arduous journey, only to be separated at the end.
Ms. Fisher draws you into the story and doesn’t let you go. Even after the story is over, you relive the events.
I greatly enjoyed this story. The extensive research was very evident, and the story heart-rending and spellbinding. However, there were a few scenes (due to PTSD) that were deeply disturbing. Nonetheless, they were authentic to the circumstances. This is not your typical Amish tale. Intrigue, heartache, betrayal and revenge factor into the account along with redemption, forgiveness, love and hope.
The Return is book three of the Amish Beginnings by Suzanne Woods Fisher. However, I have not read the other two books, and I seriously doubt I would love Betsy or enjoy the book more had I read the other two stories first.
If you are looking for a fascinating story of early America with Amish as the protagonists, you need look no further.
I received this book from LibraryThing. However, I was under no obligation to post a review.
Betsy Zook and her little brother Johnny are captured by Indians and forced to march on a long, arduous journey, only to be separated at the end.
Ms. Fisher draws you into the story and doesn’t let you go. Even after the story is over, you relive the events.
I greatly enjoyed this story. The extensive research was very evident, and the story heart-rending and spellbinding. However, there were a few scenes (due to PTSD) that were deeply disturbing. Nonetheless, they were authentic to the circumstances. This is not your typical Amish tale. Intrigue, heartache, betrayal and revenge factor into the account along with redemption, forgiveness, love and hope.
The Return is book three of the Amish Beginnings by Suzanne Woods Fisher. However, I have not read the other two books, and I seriously doubt I would love Betsy or enjoy the book more had I read the other two stories first.
If you are looking for a fascinating story of early America with Amish as the protagonists, you need look no further.
I received this book from LibraryThing. However, I was under no obligation to post a review.
August 19, 2017
The Return is a book that really grabbed my attention once I started reading it. It is part of the Amish Beginnings series, however, it is set quite a while after books one and two. I have read the first two books, so I knew the original characters. However, I think I could have picked this book up and enjoyed it even without having read the other two books.
I really enjoyed that there were two main storylines. One was set in the Amish community and was viewed from Tessa and her mother, Anna’s, perspectives. The other storyline followed Betsy, and what she went through while she was a captive of Indians.
The author did a great job of making me feel that I was back in the time and place of these characters. I also felt very connected to some characters and it was hard to find that the novel was coming to an end. I’d love to read more about these people. I was left wanting a bit more to this story when the final page was turned.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I really enjoyed that there were two main storylines. One was set in the Amish community and was viewed from Tessa and her mother, Anna’s, perspectives. The other storyline followed Betsy, and what she went through while she was a captive of Indians.
The author did a great job of making me feel that I was back in the time and place of these characters. I also felt very connected to some characters and it was hard to find that the novel was coming to an end. I’d love to read more about these people. I was left wanting a bit more to this story when the final page was turned.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
July 19, 2017
Amish settlers are trying to start a new life in Pennsylvania, but there are Indian attacks and kidnappings because of the land they are taking over.
The Zook family had arrived and set up their home on property that is in Indian land. They are attacked and after the parents are killed, their daughter and one son is taken captive . The other son hid when he saw what was happening, what has happened to him ?
Suzanne Woods Fisher’s descriptive writing will have your mind’s eye see and feel what Betsy Zook and her brother Johnny go through after being taken captive.
Though there is tragedy, loss and jealousy, faith, love and forgiveness are there too. Betsy’s fiancé Hans is angry at all Indians and wants revenge, he can’t understand that a miracle could still happen. He sees nothing nice about Indians, even those that have been friends all along.
I received a copy of The Return from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review. I enjoyed this book very much. This is book 3 of the Amish Beginnings Series, you will see many of the characters from the first 2 books. They will still make you smile ...
The Zook family had arrived and set up their home on property that is in Indian land. They are attacked and after the parents are killed, their daughter and one son is taken captive . The other son hid when he saw what was happening, what has happened to him ?
Suzanne Woods Fisher’s descriptive writing will have your mind’s eye see and feel what Betsy Zook and her brother Johnny go through after being taken captive.
Though there is tragedy, loss and jealousy, faith, love and forgiveness are there too. Betsy’s fiancé Hans is angry at all Indians and wants revenge, he can’t understand that a miracle could still happen. He sees nothing nice about Indians, even those that have been friends all along.
I received a copy of The Return from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review. I enjoyed this book very much. This is book 3 of the Amish Beginnings Series, you will see many of the characters from the first 2 books. They will still make you smile ...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews