I am a big fan of historical romances, and have heard great things about Heather Snow and her debut, so I was excited about receiving a copy as a gift from a friend. The premise was quite interesting, so I dove right in.
I really enjoyed the book, particularly the chemistry between Geoffrey and Lilliana. Battle of the sexes stories are some of my favorites and this book had it in spades. The scenes when the two of them spar and bicker was great fun, and reminded me of Kate and Anthony in JQ’s The Viscount Who Loved Me. The first quarter of the book was almost like a sparring/chess match between them, the two of them circling each other, trying to get in each other’s heads and out strategize each other
After the death of her father, Lilliana Claremont has focused on chemistry experiments to try to discover and isolate the medicinal property of certain plants. It is her passion, and a way for her to remain connected to the memory of her parents. However, her focus on chemistry leaves her little time and interest to find an eligible husband and marry, much to her Aunt Eliza’s chagrin. She chafes at the societal restrictions that tells her to give up her pursuits to be a wife and mother, and won’t allow her to be a full participating member of the Royal Society, even though she has the requisite knowledge and experience. But when she gets accosted by a burglar at her cottage, it leads to the discovery that her father had not been killed by a random street thug has they had assumed, but had been betrayed and lured to his death. It appears the Earl of Stratford and/or his father may have been responsible, and she is determined to find and gather whatever evidence is necessary to bring her father’s killer to justice. Lilliana is predisposed to dislike anyone connected to the family, so she is confused and disconcerted when she feels an immediate attraction to Geoffrey, despite her initial suspicions about him. As she gets to know and understand Geoffrey, sees how honorable and kind-hearted and generous he is, she falls for him. But as their love deepens, her guilt at keeping the truth from him grows, which only heightens as he opens up and confides in her and gives her his hard earned trust. Despite her conflicting feelings, her desire for justice propels her forward. Throughout the course of her novel, she discovers not only the truth, but that since her father’s death, she’s led a shell of an existence because she has been too afraid to trust and be vulnerable for fear of getting hurt again. She eventually learns that her love for Geoffrey is worth the risk and lets down those barriers. I ended up liking Lilliana quite a bit, though I didn’t always agree with her actions, even if I understood her motives. I like heroines who are smart and intelligent like her, and I think it was interesting to have her be an accomplished chemist in an era where women in the sciences were unheard of. I think Heather does a great job of letting the reader inside her head, and I liked that Lilliana took responsibility for her actions and accepted Geoffrey’s anger has her due, instead of playing victim and saying “woe is me, if he really loved me, he would have understood why I had to do what I did.”
Geoffrey Wentworth is a war hero who is determined to use his new elevated status to help fellow veterans who have been abandoned once they came home. He is determined to wrangle the votes and support for the Poor Employment Act by any means necessary. His mother is equally determined to see him married to an eligible heiress and produce an heir. She traps him into hosting a house party by inviting influential members of Parliament. At the beginning, he is weary of Lilliana, thinking she is just another empty headed scheming debutante determined to land a lord after an unfortunate first meeting in the library when he catches Lilliana alone in the library. She’s trying to find evidence; he thinks she’s trying to spring a trap. But he is drawn to her, despite himself, coming to see and admire her scientific acumen, intelligence, and bravery. As the story develops, and his feelings for Lilliana grow, he is faced with a dilemma. Should he be with Lilliana, the woman his every instinct tells him is the one, who ignites his passions, understands him like no one else, or marry a more suitable woman who will bring the necessary money, connections, and social graces to be a political hostess and help his career and goal of helping war veterans? This struggle is not an easy one, because he takes the cause of helping veterans seriously, but he also can’t deny his heart. Eventually he comes to see that despite the example of his parents' unhappy marriage (mostly due to the actions of his manipulative shallow self-centered status conscious mother), a marraige based on mutual love, passion, trust, and respect is possible, and he wants it with Lilliana.When he discovers the truth, it is a horrible betrayal, though part of him understands why Lilliana did what she did, especially when they discover that the death of both their fathers was related. Geoffrey was a great hero, one readers will instantly fall in love with.
I felt the mystery surrounding the death of Lilliana and Geoffrey’s fathers was woven in well, and didn’t detract from the love story. I was guessing the whole time as to who the bad guy was, and what the possible connection was between their fathers.The solution, and the way Heatherexplains and ties everything together was quite clever. The conflict that arises between Geoffrey and Lilliana because of it was realistic, andshedoes a good job of ratcheting up the tension and stakes. In particular, Lilliana’s deceit was a constant dark cloud that threatened to ruin things between them at any moment. While you sympathized with Lilliana’s motives, Heather also sets up a great question of whether the ends justified the means. Was it worth it to find out what happened to her father, if it could cost Lilliana her life, reputation, and Geoffrey’s love? But I loved the subtle ways that Heather showed how much better and stronger both of them were when they worked together, and gave each other trust, love, and understanding (as in their collaboration to find out who killed their fathers) instead of giving in to mistrust and misunderstandings.
Heather's debut is very well written, with well-crafted characters that draw you in immediately. I would definitely recommend this book and am looking forward to what comes next from her.