One thing SAME TIME NEXT SUMMER does extremely well is the way it explores love. Not just romantic love, but the love between family, whether or not that includes blood relation, and the love between friends. It shows love in its different stages, budding into something more than a friendship, or realizing that it is better off as one. The different types of love are ever-shifting and changing, and extremely complex. All of the relationships between characters have something difficult, something real about them, that shows how love and family are not always so easy. Even the same types of relationships, like the mother-daughter bond between Caro and Emma compared to Caro and her own mother, are varied and unique, but each have their own highs and lows. The love between Caro and Emma is extremely heartwarming and delicate and keeps readers invested in the story. Caro's stubbornness toward her daughter's recovery not only makes her a much more compelling character that's all-too-easy to root for but really shows how the bond they have is different from the relationship with everyone else.
That being said, the emphasis on this does not take away from the romance of the book. The relationship between Caro and Stephan is sweet and has such a natural build to it. In some ways, it seems long overdue, as they have been friends for so long, but at the same time, it does seem to happen quickly. However, it isn't the kind of insta-love that people always bemoan. It feels entirely natural and realistic. People can fall in love extremely fast, and when they do, they tend to have realistic reactions as they did in this book--wondering if they should take it slower, not really wanting to, having others say they are crazy. The type of relationship they develop is reminiscent for anyone who has had a kind of whirlwind romance because they knew the person was the one, or who has met the right person at perhaps the wrong time, and is conflicted on how to deal with that. Even the aspects of doing a long-distance relationship were so fresh and true-to-life, with the importance of the end-of-day phone calls. The love that builds between the two characters creates a satisfaction that is contagious.
Part of this is accomplished through the use of flashback, and a flexible timeline. It's all too easy to mess up timelines like that or use them as a way to get away with lazy plotting and exposition, but SAME TIME NEXT SUMMER does neither of those. It is very effective in showing the stories of the characters up to the point in current time, allowing the reader to fully build a relationship with them and gain empathy. It makes the ending all the more satisfying because we've seen what it took to get there. It also creates a mood that is as nostalgic and wistful as childhood summers.
My one gripe with the story isn't even so much of a gripe, but as someone who was born and raised in Cleveland, it would have been nice to see a little more Cleveland in the story. While the name of the city was mentioned, that was pretty much the extent of it. And as it may be apparent by my including this in the review, us Clevelanders tend to have a lot of pride for our city, even when we leave it. It would be rare for someone to not mention places by name, or take note of the world-renowned hospitals and Children's hospitals we have given the nature of the story. Again, something that would not affect the story at all if you're not from Cleveland and looking for some actual representation of the city. The effective nostalgia of everything else just had me ready for it.
I was a little turned off by a problem that occurred toward the end of the book, but it is also something personal and not a real issue. I just am not a fan of women being pressured to have children by their partners, and it seemed a bit out of character. However, it was resolved in the end and didn't take away from the overall reading experience. I also was not a fan of Caro's ex-husband, who was manipulative and awful, but still a well-developed character, and extremely effective in keeping the story engaging and my emotions invested.
SAME TIME NEXT SUMMER does a great job of balancing the horrors and pain of life and love with a strong feeling of hope and happiness. It is a great read for a time like now, when things are bleak, and readers may need a reminder of what is important--the people they love and a hope for a better tomorrow. Overall, it is an emotional and beautiful read that will be difficult not to finish in one sitting.