Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Schools of Dune #2.5

Dune: Red Plague

Rate this book
New York Times bestselling authors Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson continue Frank Herbert's science fiction Dune epic with this Tor.com original story, Dune: Red Plague.

A fatal red plague is spreading among the people of Walgis, a world that has joined the anti-technology Butlerian movement, led by Manford Torondo. As the population continues to suffer and die from the disease, hope arrives in the form of vaccines transported by Venport Holdings.

But Torondo believes Venport's act of charity is actually Walgis's test of faith...

At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied.

22 pages, Kindle Edition

First published November 1, 2016

96 people are currently reading
1849 people want to read

About the author

Brian Herbert

239 books2,140 followers
Brian Patrick Herbert is an American author who lives in Washington state. He is the elder son of science fiction author Frank Patrick Herbert.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
132 (23%)
4 stars
147 (26%)
3 stars
180 (32%)
2 stars
77 (13%)
1 star
22 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
Profile Image for Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽.
1,880 reviews23.3k followers
November 8, 2016
2.5 stars. Final review, first posted on Fantasy Literature:

“Dune: Red Plague” is a brief episode in an ongoing conflict in the DUNE series universe between an anti-technology group, led by Manford Torondo, and pro-technology people, personified by Josef Venport, the selfish CEO Directeur of Venport Holdings, a huge interstellar commercial empire with a large fleet of spaceships. Manford lost his legs in a bombing that killed his inspiration and mentor, Rayna Butler, and he views himself as responsible for leading humanity away from the temptations of technology. Venport, who cruelly calls Manford a “legless freak” and the “barbarian half-Manford”, considers the Butlerian group a bunch of zealots who want to “reduce humanity to a primitive agrarian culture scattered across the galaxy.” Venport has blockaded the planets that have taken the Butlerian pledge.

However, the anti-tech people on one planet, Walgis, are dying of the terrible Red Plague. Dr. Rohan Zim, an altruistic Suk doctor, convinces Venport ― with a fair amount of difficulty ― to loan one of the Venport spaceships to him to bring a life-saving vaccine to the people of Walgis, arguing that maybe it will change their minds about the benefits of technology and will make Venport look humane.

It’s a rather confusing and opaque world if you’re not already familiar with the DUNE universe and how it’s developed under the authorship of Brian Herbert (Frank Herbert’s son) and Kevin J. Anderson. Words and concepts like Mentat, Suk doctor and Butlerian creed play a significant role but often get little or no explanation. I dimly remember these things from reading Dune years ago, but I think a reader would have to know this universe and the later entries in this series a lot better to make this story work for you, and even then, it’s a thin, rather predictable tale, and isn’t a complete story in itself. “Dune: Red Plague” probably won’t be of much interest to anyone except fans of the ongoing DUNE series.

Free online here at Tor.com.
Profile Image for Lyn.
2,009 reviews17.6k followers
November 6, 2016
Disclaimer!!! This review is written by an unapologetic and wholly illogical Dune fan who hopes one day to be considered a Dune aficionado.

Brian and Kevin’s latest excellent adventure expanding Frank’s genius vision is a short story published in November 2016 by Tor.com.

Disclaimer!!! This review is written by a rabid Tor.com fan who thinks this site is the coolest thing since the Falcon made the Kessel run in less than 12 parsecs.

Written some time after the Butlerian Jihad, this concerns an attempt by an evil thinking machines proponent to provide assistance to a disease-ravaged planet on the side of the Butlerians.

I’ve read Frank’s original six and then the next two by Brian / Kevin so I can follow along with the terminology and am for the most part picking up what the collaborators are throwing down. This makes me want to further explore their expansion on Frank’s awesomeness.

For fans.

description
Profile Image for Joe Pranaitis.
Author 23 books87 followers
January 31, 2017
The Red Plague is a followup short story to the Schools of Dune trilogy which ended with Navigators of Dune. As the story opens we find that Josf Venport is being asked to help out a colony planet that had turned its back on technology, we also learn that the leader of the opposing force that has blockaded that planet has gone to join his fleet. I won't give away the ending but this story makes me want more Dune and I'm still looking forward to the two Leto II books that are supposed to bridge Children of Dune to God Emperor of Dune. Pick this story up you won't be disappointed.  
Profile Image for Mark.
1,654 reviews237 followers
March 9, 2018
This is a brief story in which the conflict between the Butlerian school of anti technology and the pro-technology camp come into conflict when one planet surfers the consequences of the Red Plague, from the title.
One camp has the technology and the cure for the disease and the other camp is blindly fanatic in following the anti-technology course. This of course in the aftermath of centuries of oppression by technology driven dictatorship.
This is not a story with a moral but a window on the depth of the conflict between two believe systems.
A nice addition to the Dune lore.

Too bad that any new publications by Brian & keven J Anderson written in the Duneverse have not yet been presented. As this trilogy of the Schools of Dune was actually more than decent.
107 reviews
December 30, 2016
Backpage

As usual, the writing was awesome. I am so glad that Herbert's son is in charge of revealing the back story to the Dune books. No one else would be right as far as I am concerned. Love everything that has come out of the Herbert and Anderson writings.
Profile Image for Michael.
652 reviews8 followers
November 4, 2016
A minor story in the Dune universe which adds very little to the canon.
Profile Image for Scott.
353 reviews5 followers
December 23, 2019
Always an enjoyable chance to sink back into the world of DUNE.
67 reviews
September 28, 2020
Just a little short story within the “Schools of Dune” trilogy. Highlights the divide between Josef Venport and Manford Torondo. A very quick read that won’t make sense to anyone that isn’t vested in the overall Dune series, or more specifically the trio of novels Sisterhood Of Dune, Mentats Of Dune, and Navigators Of Dune.
Profile Image for Cathy Hunter.
351 reviews1 follower
September 24, 2020
These short stories often give you little snippets of information about the next book. In this one is it no surprise to learn the Butlerian leader would rather let his followers die horribly from the Red Plague than let doctors in league with the now fugitive Josef Venport administer the vaccine.

A small window in to how the 2 extremes think and a great appetiser to the final book in this 3 book series The Schools of Dune
Profile Image for Rocky Sunico.
2,277 reviews25 followers
November 2, 2024
A bit of a non-story - more like a moment from the larger narrative but it doesn't really have an impact on anything.
Profile Image for Kieran McAndrew.
3,065 reviews20 followers
June 23, 2021
Humanity's technological withdrawal continues apace, but when a plague affects a colony world, Venport is asked to ferry medical supplies to them.

There is a sense of a war and some idea that technology is the cause of it. There is also references to a non partisan Suk school of medicine and Navigator enabled spaceships, but there is no explanation as to what these actually are. Even though this short story forms part of a very detailed wider universe, it should be able to be understandable (and enjoyable) on its own.

This short story fails to engage at all, feeling more like a "cut scene" from a larger novel. Without any context or characterisation, how can readers care what happens?
Profile Image for Joe.
1,333 reviews23 followers
December 13, 2016
I can see this short story will be unpopular among many, owing to its affiliation with the Dune concept, but I for one really enjoyed it - it reminded me, for the five minutes it took to read, how rewarding good sci-fi can be.
Profile Image for Will.
2 reviews
March 18, 2018
Short but sweet

Effectively just another chapter of the Navigators of Dune full length novel.
I have seen it said it is a prequel to that book, but I think it sits better as a chapter inside that novel, as I believe Venport would act slightly differently to the Butlerians earlier on in Navigators based on these events.
Good read.
Profile Image for Christopher.
1,589 reviews44 followers
November 6, 2025
https://magicandmeteors.wordpress.com...

Dune: Red Plague by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson is a short story set within the Dune expanded universe, positioned during the early years after the defeat of the thinking machines and the rise of the Butlerian movement. The tale unfolds on the planet Walgis, one of the many worlds that has allied itself with Manford Torondo’s fanatical anti-technology crusade. Walgis is a relatively minor planet, not of the political weight of Arrakis or Salusa Secundus, but it serves as a useful backdrop for the ideological struggle of this period. The society there is shaped by a blend of religious zeal and fear, both of technology and of the power wielded by external groups such as Venport Holdings.

The story begins with the outbreak of a deadly disease known as the red plague, a fast-spreading and devastating infection that threatens to wipe out the population of Walgis. In this universe, even after the Butlerian Jihad, interstellar travel, trade, and communication still rely on a delicate balance of human skill and limited, regulated technology. Venport Holdings, led by Josef Venport, is one of the great commercial powers that has survived the machine wars. Venport’s organisation controls space travel and the vital trade routes that link human worlds. It represents the pragmatic, pro-technology side of the emerging Imperium, opposed in almost every way to the fanatical Butlerians who see all machines as a enemy of all humanity.

When the red plague strikes, Venport Holdings offers a vaccine that could stop the disease entirely. For any rational society, this would seem a gift and a lifeline. Yet for Manford Torondo’s followers, the offer is something far more sinister. In their eyes, accepting technological help—even if it comes in the form of medicine—amounts to a betrayal of their faith. Torondo believes that humanity must remain pure and reject all remnants of machine thinking. The offer of a vaccine thus becomes a moral and theological test, not a scientific solution. This conflict between the followers of Torondo and those who believe in technological progress forms the heart of the story.

The main people involved reflect this ideological divide. Josef Venport, a descendant of Norma Cenva and connected to the origins of the Spacing Guild, embodies the belief that controlled and ethical technology can coexist with human freedom. His motivations are not purely altruistic—Venport is a businessman as much as a scientist—but his perspective is rooted in practicality and reason. Manford Torondo, by contrast, is the charismatic and uncompromising leader of the Butlerians. He is a man of fierce conviction, who lost his legs in an accident and now uses that suffering to inspire devotion, preaching that humanity must never again rely on machines. Supporting him is Mother Superior Raquella Berto-Anirul, the early figure of what will become the Bene Gesserit Sisterhood, who walks a delicate line between faith and intellect. Although she respects Torondo’s zeal, she also understands that absolute rejection of knowledge can destroy civilisation.

The people of Walgis find themselves caught between these two powers. On one side, there is the promise of survival through science; on the other, the demand for spiritual purity through suffering. The result is a moral tragedy, typical of the Dune universe. Herbert and Anderson use the planet’s plight as a microcosm of a much larger argument that runs throughout the saga: whether humanity’s advancement lies in embracing knowledge or in restraining it. The red plague becomes a metaphor for ignorance as much as for disease. By refusing help, Torondo’s followers show how fanaticism can be as deadly as any biological infection.

Technologically, the story offers glimpses into the transitional age between the destruction of the thinking machines and the later, more stable Imperium of Dune. Space travel still depends on Venport’s Navigators, who use the early form of prescience to fold space. Medical science exists but is treated with suspicion by the Butlerians. The vaccine itself, though never fully described, represents the kind of careful biological engineering that would later underpin the genetic programmes of the Bene Gesserit and the Suk Doctors. This tension over scientific ethics echoes through all of Dune’s future history.

Stylistically, the writing is clean and direct, though not as dense or layered as Frank Herbert’s original novels. The story’s brevity—only about thirty pages—means the characters serve mostly as representatives of ideas rather than as deeply developed individuals. Still, the moral conflict is sharply drawn. The authors succeed in showing how easily ideology can twist good intentions, and how both sides—faith and technology—risk becoming inhuman when pushed to extremes. Venport’s pragmatism verges on arrogance, while Torondo’s piety curdles into cruelty. The narrative’s final consequences, which I won’t spoil, underline the cost of choosing belief over compassion.

As an entry in the Schools of Dune era, Dune: Red Plague expands the universe’s history in a meaningful way. It gives a sense of how the Butlerian purges spread across human worlds and how fear of technology shaped early Imperial society. It also provides insight into the roots of several later institutions: the Bene Gesserit, with their emphasis on discipline and selective knowledge; the Mentats, born out of the rejection of computers; and the Spacing Guild, which represents the compromise between human intuition and the need for technological function. These threads tie the story directly to the grander arc of Dune’s philosophical evolution.

As a piece of writing, Dune: Red Plague is more thought-provoking than emotionally driven. While its emotional depth may be limited, the intellectual themes are strong. It explores the ongoing Dune idea that progress and ideology often come into conflict. Some readers might find its moral stance too simplistic—highlighting the contrast between technology and its challenges—while others will appreciate its deeper message: that any ideology, whether focused on progress or tradition, can become harmful if it neglects the value of human life.

In sum, Dune: Red Plague is a concise and effective exploration of the early Dune universe. It works best for readers already familiar with the Butlerian movement and the politics of Venport Holdings, as the story assumes that background knowledge. For newcomers, it might feel like a glimpse of a larger conflict without full context. Nevertheless, it succeeds in portraying the human cost of fanaticism and the perilous balance between faith and reason that defines the Dune saga. It is not among the most profound works in the canon, but it enriches the lore and reminds readers that in Dune, advancement and destruction often come from the same human impulse—to believe absolutely or take a stand.
Profile Image for Katherine.
1,383 reviews17 followers
April 15, 2021
This was only ok, based on context. When I am reading a short story, I like to have some establishing explanation. A good example are the previous short stories I just read by A.M. Dellamonica. Those were set in a world that she's written other books in, but she inserted enough worldbuilding so that they stood on their own.

There's none of that with this story. Not even having read the original Dune books was any help here. I had no idea who these characters were, and what was really going on. This felt more like a deleted scene than anything else, and it was a pretty heavy handed metaphor. This seems like it's really only for people who have read the particular Dune series this is attached to.
Profile Image for Jemini Willis.
153 reviews2 followers
digital
February 6, 2023

New York Times bestselling authors Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson continue Frank Herbert's science fiction Dune epic with this Tor.com original story, Dune: Red Plague.


A fatal red plague is spreading among the people of Walgis, a world that has joined the anti-technology Butlerian movement, led by Manford Torondo. As the population continues to suffer and die from the disease, hope arrives in the form of vaccines transported by Venport Holdings.


But Torondo believes Venport's act of charity is actually Walgis's test of faith...


At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied.

Profile Image for Elwin Kline.
Author 1 book11 followers
December 5, 2020
This was super weak.

Honestly... I don't even know why this was written/published, or having someone even take the time to illustrate a cover for it.

This is basically a single chapter within the Butlerian Jihad story line of Dune.

I guess I would rate it a 1.5, giving it an additional half a point for only being ~30 pages and being able to knock it out in a single reading session very quickly.

Again, even as a big Dune fan this offers little to no value and isn't even worth the very short time investment it takes to get through this.
Profile Image for Rafael Sousa.
5 reviews1 follower
October 14, 2017
As a short story, it's nothing special. It highlights the ongoing technology feud that's present in the Schools of Dune trilogy.

Something to briefly keep you up to date on the story before starting Navigators of Dune.
Profile Image for Christopher M..
Author 2 books5 followers
April 28, 2022
An entertaining enough story which acts as a refresher on some character relationships between the publication of novels, rendered redundant in my chronological reading marathon as I hadn't forgotten them!
Profile Image for Stephen Masters.
64 reviews
May 4, 2025
Short story taking place between the Mentats of Dune and the Navigators of Dune.

The execution of this story was perfect.

Plague infected planet has to choose between Manford Torondo, and the faith or the Venport and his technology.

Perfect build up for the Navigators of Dune.

Profile Image for Paca Sad.
273 reviews
January 8, 2019
Probably deserving of three stars but I'm torn as its such a short book that should have been an appendix or chapter of either Mentats or Navigator book and it really is irrelevant on its own
Profile Image for Zach.
122 reviews1 follower
May 6, 2019
Snooozzzzeeeeee
Profile Image for Brandon Smith- Scolaro.
114 reviews1 follower
March 15, 2020
A pretty solid little short story that takes place between Mentats and Navigators of Dune. I've got to say, I really hate Manford Torondo.
Profile Image for Claudio.
28 reviews
December 29, 2023
One more dispute between Technologists and Butlerians. Let's see if this tale has any implications in future books.
Profile Image for Mary.
245 reviews2 followers
January 1, 2024
A very short story. As always Dune is a interesting universe.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.