What do you think?
Rate this book
Runemarks #1
Runemarks
It's been five hundred years since the end of the world and society has rebuilt itself anew. The old Norse gods are no longer revered. Their tales have been banned. Magic is outlawed, and a new religion - the Order - has taken its place.
In a remote valley in the north, fourteen-year-old Maddy Smith is shunned for the ruinmark on her hand - a sign associated with the Bad Old Days. But what the villagers don't know is that Maddy has skills. According to One-Eye, the secretive Outlander who is Maddy's only real friend, her ruinmark - or runemark, as he calls it - is a sign of Chaos blood, magical powers and gods know what else...
Now, as the Order moves further north, threatening all the Worlds with conquest and Cleansing, Maddy must finally learn the truth to some unanswered questions about herself, her parentage, and her powers.
From the bestselling author of CHOCOLAT and THE GOSPEL OF LOKI comes a fantastical tale of magic, adventure and Norse mythology.
528 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2007
294 people are currently reading
9725 people want to read
About the author
Joanne Harris
124 books6,304 followersJoanne Harris is also known as Joanne M. Harris
Joanne Harris is an Anglo-French author, whose books include fourteen novels, two cookbooks and many short stories. Her work is extremely diverse, covering aspects of magic realism, suspense, historical fiction, mythology and fantasy. She has also written a DR WHO novella for the BBC, has scripted guest episodes for the game ZOMBIES, RUN!, and is currently engaged in a number of musical theatre projects as well as developing an original drama for television.
In 2000, her 1999 novel CHOCOLAT was adapted to the screen, starring Juliette Binoche and Johnny Depp. She is an honorary Fellow of St Catharine's College, Cambridge, and in 2022 was awarded an OBE by the Queen.
Her hobbies are listed in Who's Who as 'mooching, lounging, strutting, strumming, priest-baiting and quiet subversion'. She also spends too much time on Twitter; plays flute and bass guitar in a band first formed when she was 16; and works from a shed in her garden at her home in Yorkshire.
Joanne Harris is an Anglo-French author, whose books include fourteen novels, two cookbooks and many short stories. Her work is extremely diverse, covering aspects of magic realism, suspense, historical fiction, mythology and fantasy. She has also written a DR WHO novella for the BBC, has scripted guest episodes for the game ZOMBIES, RUN!, and is currently engaged in a number of musical theatre projects as well as developing an original drama for television.
In 2000, her 1999 novel CHOCOLAT was adapted to the screen, starring Juliette Binoche and Johnny Depp. She is an honorary Fellow of St Catharine's College, Cambridge, and in 2022 was awarded an OBE by the Queen.
Her hobbies are listed in Who's Who as 'mooching, lounging, strutting, strumming, priest-baiting and quiet subversion'. She also spends too much time on Twitter; plays flute and bass guitar in a band first formed when she was 16; and works from a shed in her garden at her home in Yorkshire.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,018 reviews
December 11, 2016
This is a dense and sprawling satire that draws on Norse mythology and folklore on which the author has certainly done her research. She re-imagines the Norse gods and on occasion subverts them. Maddy Smith is the young heroine shunned by family and community. She was born with a new runemark on her hand denoting the gods. In her world, magic is perceived to be dangerous and banned. But here's the thing, Maddy likes doing magic.....particularly when it comes to some troublesome goblins!
Maddy's only friend is Old One-Eye (Odin) and she finds herself being tutored on magic by him. A worried Old One-Eye wants Maddy to go on a quest to locate the Whisperer in the World Below. Upon entry, Maddy comes face to face with a familiar goblin. We go on to encounter shapeshifters, enchanted apples, magical creatures, a prophecy and the wonders and joys of Lucky (Loki), a smart, comic and infinitely complex god. Maddy has to stop the Nine Worlds from falling into chaos, and there is, of course, a battle.
Harris has created an enchanting world. It is well written, although not always coherent, although this did not spoil my enjoyment of the book. There is a wonderful wide ranging cast of characters in an intricate and complex narrative. An entrancing, magical and entertaining read. It may not be the best of Joanne Harris but this is still great storytelling. Thanks to Orion for an ARC.
Maddy's only friend is Old One-Eye (Odin) and she finds herself being tutored on magic by him. A worried Old One-Eye wants Maddy to go on a quest to locate the Whisperer in the World Below. Upon entry, Maddy comes face to face with a familiar goblin. We go on to encounter shapeshifters, enchanted apples, magical creatures, a prophecy and the wonders and joys of Lucky (Loki), a smart, comic and infinitely complex god. Maddy has to stop the Nine Worlds from falling into chaos, and there is, of course, a battle.
Harris has created an enchanting world. It is well written, although not always coherent, although this did not spoil my enjoyment of the book. There is a wonderful wide ranging cast of characters in an intricate and complex narrative. An entrancing, magical and entertaining read. It may not be the best of Joanne Harris but this is still great storytelling. Thanks to Orion for an ARC.
February 6, 2017
Looking for something lighthearted to clear your head between longer and more complex series? Why not Zoidberg Runemarks?
Rating could have been lowered but this was fast and fun read and it was perfect counterweight to complex Malazan series that was reading along side it. so i'm going to give it 4 stars. It's YA fantasy but it's more inspired by older heroic fantasy with than modern YA genre. Distinctive writing style that flows easily and setting heavily inspired by Norse mythology contribute to high rating.
Rating could have been lowered but this was fast and fun read and it was perfect counterweight to complex Malazan series that was reading along side it. so i'm going to give it 4 stars. It's YA fantasy but it's more inspired by older heroic fantasy with than modern YA genre. Distinctive writing style that flows easily and setting heavily inspired by Norse mythology contribute to high rating.
February 11, 2017
Final rating: 4.25/5 stars
Final rating - for the whole series: 3.5/5 stars
I have read this book first in 2011. Back then I did not even theorize this could get a sequel. But it has. And I am glad for it. This book can be seen as stand-alone book but there were some loose ends for which I didn't give this book five stars. Neither will I this time, but in any case, it deserves to be 4.25. And, damn I forgot how much this book was fun and enjoyable to read.
I usually don't change the date read to the newer one, but this time I did because I read it from the beginning to the end, without ever skipping.
This is a high fantasy / unlike our world this has many worlds, although we see only a couple of them. Norse Gods are the main point here - but the Norse mythology is not quite going by Norse myths, so don't be surprised to not hear anything of Jötunheimr, except that there exists order of Chaos, and Loki is a child of that Chaos who has, along with Odin, swore to be brothers in blood - sworn to each other. Okay, let's be realistic - Loki will always play pranks and tricks and do stupid things, but he is honestly quite, quite smart, but also sometimes foolish and falls on tricks himself.
Æsir and Vanir categories of gods are one of the main points (Æsir - Odin, Frigg, Thor, Sif, Tyr, Balder, Loki & Vanir - Skadi, Bragi, Idun, Freyja, Frey(r), Heimdall, Njord...), and author stick with them as well - with putting the right gods in each category. Also, she included most of the myth facts (like serpent (guess who?) above Loki's head when he was captured and tortured until he escaped. ) Even if they were just a little changed. And so on... But never mind that, I am not expert on Norse mythology, although I guess i will go into a bookstore and buy a huge myths book but they are so damn expensive >_<.
Anyway, some facts held, some didn't - but it was well executed. To be honest, this whole setting seemed like an alternative universe. Despite humans settling in the Middle World, it didn't seem to be anything like the Earth - I didn't imagine it as Earth at all (I think that was the point)?
I am ranting, but the conclusion is: not all things related to the myths are the same, some are inverted or outright changed. If you don't mind that, then read this book because it's fun and worth it.
This is not a story of gods only - this is a story of Maddy Smith, and her involvement with the Gods, the world, and destiny.
This is a different, and kind of unique story where things do not go as planned, gods are not always who they are, which goes for people too and many things happen. It's a fast paced book and well done in general. When it comes to the facts on the gods, do pay attention, especially hostages situation as that is one of the most important facts one may overlook (like me, first time).
Out of all characters, I have undying love toward Loki - I will always love the Trickster god, no matter what **** he pulls. And, I am very happy to see there is this book - The Gospel of Loki - and it's about THIS Loki - which is why some people were confused why Loki was actually somewhat demon and of Chaos, instead of being Jötunn.
But here it works. There is Order, then is Chaos, and there are Æsir and Vanir and humans. And it was so well executed.
Also - ONE THING - for those looking for romance - ya - fanatasy book - you will probably only get fantasy out of the three. There is no love interest, there IS NO ROMANCE, and it's not really young-adultish. Maybe only at the beginning. AND THERE DOESN'T NEED TO BE ROMANTIC INTEREST, BECAUSE THIS BOOK IS NOT ABOUT ROMANCE, BUT ABOUT THE END OF THE WORLD.
In the universe of nine Worlds, Ragnarok happened 500 years ago and gods disappeared and the world just restarted. In the Middle Worlds, magic is now banned and considered work of demons by the new religion - the Order and their people - who worship their own God called The Nameless. It means that stories of supernatural creatures are now banned, stories of gods, goblins, and everything else related to magic.
Maddy, a 14 year old girl, was born in the village called Malbry, into the family of Smiths. Her father, Jed, and her sister, Mae, never really wanted her. In fact, she was an outsider - and that was all they needed to shut her out from their lives. Why did this happen? Maddy was born with a rune on her hand... except she didn't know what it really was, what it did, except that it was only the mark which branded her as a witch and possible spawn of the demons. Maddy tries really hard to fit in with the rest of the village, but the only person she found herself comfortable with is none other but One-Eye, a mysterious old man who knows more than he wants to tell Maddy.
In fact, One-Eye is concerned. Something serious is happening, and this Outlander One-Eye, wants Maddy to find an ancient relic of gods called the Whisperer by opening the Red Horse Hill and descending into World Below - where someone has been living for 500 years and guarding the relic. She comes across a strange little goblin whom she encountered before in the cellar of the place she worked in. Having no other choice, goblin helps her... but is afraid of that his Captain of the goblins will find them...
And then there is the Prophecy...
There is not much to talk about the characters or who they are - you will see by reading the book, in rather fun way like (for example, also key players):
And so on and on. As you can see - everyone hates Loki. I really pitty him. (Sometimes don't, but I do love him the most).
Out of everyone, I really, really loved Loki. I had so many feelings about him and (interestingly, I was always on his side). It's not easy being Loki, especially when he did many things that cannot be irreversible - and the Gods knew what they invited when they "adopted" Loki. Odin knew at least but still has a lot of feelings about Loki he cannot discard.
Maddy is really good and interesting heroine. She is not boring and she is lovely. She is not annoying and she is rather capable (although it sometimes takes time to understand everything for her).
I also really, really, loved Sugar-and-Sack, a goblin from the World Below. He is actually really, really cute.
If I tell anything else about the characters, it would be too many spoilers.
It was fun, it was angsty, it was interesting and captivating. I reread this book (and wrote a review of it right now), because I wanted to continue on the second book, which was thankfully translated by my publisher and I have it sitting on the shelf for a year or two. It's about time I finish with this story (and move on on the The Gospel of Loki). In other words: I don't think you will regret reading it, unless you are the type who cannot stand changes when it comes to Myths and Legends of the Norse Mythology in general.
OTHER IMPORTANT INFO:
⚠ Standalone: Yes. But also, part of a series. Recommended to read the sequel as it covers the loose ends.
⚠ Point of View: Third POV, multiply characters.
⚠ Cliffhanger: No.
⚠ Triggers:
⚠ Love triangle: NO, ACTUALLY, THERE IS NO ROMANCE HERE AT ALL.
⚠ Angst: Yes.
⚠ Supernatural: Yeeeeeeeeeees.
⚠ Explicit content: No.
⚠ Ending type:
⚠ Recommended: Yes
⚠ Note: if possible, read the second book too :D
◈ Runemarks (Runemarks, #1)
◈ Runelight (Runemarks #2)
Final rating - for the whole series: 3.5/5 stars
I have read this book first in 2011. Back then I did not even theorize this could get a sequel. But it has. And I am glad for it. This book can be seen as stand-alone book but there were some loose ends for which I didn't give this book five stars. Neither will I this time, but in any case, it deserves to be 4.25. And, damn I forgot how much this book was fun and enjoyable to read.
I usually don't change the date read to the newer one, but this time I did because I read it from the beginning to the end, without ever skipping.
This is a high fantasy / unlike our world this has many worlds, although we see only a couple of them. Norse Gods are the main point here - but the Norse mythology is not quite going by Norse myths, so don't be surprised to not hear anything of Jötunheimr, except that there exists order of Chaos, and Loki is a child of that Chaos who has, along with Odin, swore to be brothers in blood - sworn to each other. Okay, let's be realistic - Loki will always play pranks and tricks and do stupid things, but he is honestly quite, quite smart, but also sometimes foolish and falls on tricks himself.
Æsir and Vanir categories of gods are one of the main points (Æsir - Odin, Frigg, Thor, Sif, Tyr, Balder, Loki & Vanir - Skadi, Bragi, Idun, Freyja, Frey(r), Heimdall, Njord...), and author stick with them as well - with putting the right gods in each category. Also, she included most of the myth facts (like serpent (guess who?) above Loki's head when he was captured and tortured until he escaped. ) Even if they were just a little changed. And so on... But never mind that, I am not expert on Norse mythology, although I guess i will go into a bookstore and buy a huge myths book but they are so damn expensive >_<.
Anyway, some facts held, some didn't - but it was well executed. To be honest, this whole setting seemed like an alternative universe. Despite humans settling in the Middle World, it didn't seem to be anything like the Earth - I didn't imagine it as Earth at all (I think that was the point)?
I am ranting, but the conclusion is: not all things related to the myths are the same, some are inverted or outright changed. If you don't mind that, then read this book because it's fun and worth it.
This is not a story of gods only - this is a story of Maddy Smith, and her involvement with the Gods, the world, and destiny.
This is a different, and kind of unique story where things do not go as planned, gods are not always who they are, which goes for people too and many things happen. It's a fast paced book and well done in general. When it comes to the facts on the gods, do pay attention, especially hostages situation as that is one of the most important facts one may overlook (like me, first time).
Out of all characters, I have undying love toward Loki - I will always love the Trickster god, no matter what **** he pulls. And, I am very happy to see there is this book - The Gospel of Loki - and it's about THIS Loki - which is why some people were confused why Loki was actually somewhat demon and of Chaos, instead of being Jötunn.
But here it works. There is Order, then is Chaos, and there are Æsir and Vanir and humans. And it was so well executed.
Also - ONE THING - for those looking for romance - ya - fanatasy book - you will probably only get fantasy out of the three. There is no love interest, there IS NO ROMANCE, and it's not really young-adultish. Maybe only at the beginning. AND THERE DOESN'T NEED TO BE ROMANTIC INTEREST, BECAUSE THIS BOOK IS NOT ABOUT ROMANCE, BUT ABOUT THE END OF THE WORLD.
► STORY:
In the universe of nine Worlds, Ragnarok happened 500 years ago and gods disappeared and the world just restarted. In the Middle Worlds, magic is now banned and considered work of demons by the new religion - the Order and their people - who worship their own God called The Nameless. It means that stories of supernatural creatures are now banned, stories of gods, goblins, and everything else related to magic.
Maddy, a 14 year old girl, was born in the village called Malbry, into the family of Smiths. Her father, Jed, and her sister, Mae, never really wanted her. In fact, she was an outsider - and that was all they needed to shut her out from their lives. Why did this happen? Maddy was born with a rune on her hand... except she didn't know what it really was, what it did, except that it was only the mark which branded her as a witch and possible spawn of the demons. Maddy tries really hard to fit in with the rest of the village, but the only person she found herself comfortable with is none other but One-Eye, a mysterious old man who knows more than he wants to tell Maddy.
In fact, One-Eye is concerned. Something serious is happening, and this Outlander One-Eye, wants Maddy to find an ancient relic of gods called the Whisperer by opening the Red Horse Hill and descending into World Below - where someone has been living for 500 years and guarding the relic. She comes across a strange little goblin whom she encountered before in the cellar of the place she worked in. Having no other choice, goblin helps her... but is afraid of that his Captain of the goblins will find them...
And then there is the Prophecy...
► CHARACTERS:
There is not much to talk about the characters or who they are - you will see by reading the book, in rather fun way like (for example, also key players):
Maddy Smith, a village witch
Adam Scattergood, a bully
Nat Parson, a parson
Ethelberta Parson, his wife
Examiner Number 4421974, Examiner of the Order
GODS (VANIR)
Skadi, of the Ice People, bride of Njörd, the Huntress; goddess of destruction; principal enemy of Loki
Bragi, god of poetry and song; has no reason to love Loki
Idun, his wife, goddess of youth and plenty; was once abducted by Loki and handed over to the Ice People
Freyja, goddess of desire; once mortally insulted by Loki
Frey, the Reaper, her brother; no friend to Loki
Heimdall, golden-toothed sentinel of the gods; hates Loki
Njörd, sea god, once married to Skadi but now separated due to irreconcilable differences; agrees with her on a single subject—dislike of Loki
GODS (ÆSIR—SEER-FOLK)
Odin, chief of the Æsir, blood brother of—and ultimately betrayed by—Loki
Frigg, his wife; lost her son because of Loki
Thor, the Thunderer, son of Odin; has more than one bone to pick with Loki
Sif, his wife; once went bald because of Loki
Týr, god of war; lost his hand because of Loki
Balder, son of Frigg; died because of Loki
Loki
OTHERS
Sugar-and-Sack, a goblin
And so on and on. As you can see - everyone hates Loki. I really pitty him. (Sometimes don't, but I do love him the most).
Out of everyone, I really, really loved Loki. I had so many feelings about him and (interestingly, I was always on his side). It's not easy being Loki, especially when he did many things that cannot be irreversible - and the Gods knew what they invited when they "adopted" Loki. Odin knew at least but still has a lot of feelings about Loki he cannot discard.
Maddy is really good and interesting heroine. She is not boring and she is lovely. She is not annoying and she is rather capable (although it sometimes takes time to understand everything for her).
I also really, really, loved Sugar-and-Sack, a goblin from the World Below. He is actually really, really cute.
If I tell anything else about the characters, it would be too many spoilers.
► OVERALL:
It was fun, it was angsty, it was interesting and captivating. I reread this book (and wrote a review of it right now), because I wanted to continue on the second book, which was thankfully translated by my publisher and I have it sitting on the shelf for a year or two. It's about time I finish with this story (and move on on the The Gospel of Loki). In other words: I don't think you will regret reading it, unless you are the type who cannot stand changes when it comes to Myths and Legends of the Norse Mythology in general.
OTHER IMPORTANT INFO:
⚠ Standalone: Yes. But also, part of a series. Recommended to read the sequel as it covers the loose ends.
⚠ Point of View: Third POV, multiply characters.
⚠ Cliffhanger: No.
⚠ Triggers:
⚠ Love triangle: NO, ACTUALLY, THERE IS NO ROMANCE HERE AT ALL.
⚠ Angst: Yes.
⚠ Supernatural: Yeeeeeeeeeees.
⚠ Explicit content: No.
⚠ Ending type:
⚠ Recommended: Yes
⚠ Note: if possible, read the second book too :D
► REVIEW(S) RELATED TO THIS BOOK:
◈ Runemarks (Runemarks, #1)
◈ Runelight (Runemarks #2)
May 6, 2022
Novela de fantasía de la serie Runemarks, a la que pertenece también El evangelio de Loki.
Aunque la anterior fue escrita después, es cronológicamente anterior. Runas tiene la misma temática de mitología nórdica, pero se considera juvenil sobre todo por tener como protagonista a una chica de 14 años.
La trama es ágil y ligera, con una buena ambientación y unos personajes muy bien caracterizados.
Muy entretenida.
Aunque la anterior fue escrita después, es cronológicamente anterior. Runas tiene la misma temática de mitología nórdica, pero se considera juvenil sobre todo por tener como protagonista a una chica de 14 años.
La trama es ágil y ligera, con una buena ambientación y unos personajes muy bien caracterizados.
Muy entretenida.
November 15, 2016
3.5 stars
The Nordic mythical foundations of this book were well utilised, conforming to known stories in parts and freely reimagined in others. The initial part of the book was especially well done; though it begins with the usual young protagonist coming into their powers, the runemarks and character of Maddy Smith gave it a real freshness and appeal.
However, the book felt stretched, pushed well past the moment when all the reader's attention is firmly focused. By the time of the big battle conclusion, I was there merely to see how it all ended rather than being invested in the outcome. Joanne Harris usually has a much tighter plot than this and I was surprised by feeling this way about one of her books, especially as I thought this was for more of a teen audience. Perhaps i'm doing them a disservice in thinking that they have even less patience and attention than me... In any case, i'm not sure i'll be reading the next one in the series.
Kindle copy received from Netgalley.
The Nordic mythical foundations of this book were well utilised, conforming to known stories in parts and freely reimagined in others. The initial part of the book was especially well done; though it begins with the usual young protagonist coming into their powers, the runemarks and character of Maddy Smith gave it a real freshness and appeal.
However, the book felt stretched, pushed well past the moment when all the reader's attention is firmly focused. By the time of the big battle conclusion, I was there merely to see how it all ended rather than being invested in the outcome. Joanne Harris usually has a much tighter plot than this and I was surprised by feeling this way about one of her books, especially as I thought this was for more of a teen audience. Perhaps i'm doing them a disservice in thinking that they have even less patience and attention than me... In any case, i'm not sure i'll be reading the next one in the series.
Kindle copy received from Netgalley.
May 28, 2008
I loved the movie Chocolat and I read a bit of Jigs and Reels, but nothing has hooked me on Joanne Harris as much as this! She started it as a story for her daughter, years later it is a fantastic tale of magic and adventure for all ages. The mythology is Norse, a nice break from the Greek gods if you've been devouring Rick Riordan's Olympians. So soon after reading Michael Scott's The Alchemyst, it's neat to come across more references to Yggdrasil, the World Tree. And if, like me, you love keeping track of a seemingly ever-expanding cavalcade of major and minor characters, and the minutiae of their lives and credos, then this is the book of the summer for you. Haven't run across this many characters since The Glass Books of the Dream Eaters. -+- After: Even better than I ever expected, and I had pretty high expectations. I hope she writes a dozen more of these! I think I've finally found someone to meet and exceed my Pottermania.
February 26, 2025
"Mom, can we have Percy Jackson ?
"We have Percy Jackson at home."
Percy Jackson at home:
"We have Percy Jackson at home."
Percy Jackson at home:
August 25, 2016
My main complaint about Runemarks was the complexity. The narrative was far too extensive and unfocused. I don’t know much about Norse mythology, so I found myself frequently frustrated with the intricate and complicated Norse histories. I usually prefer being eased into a new world where I’m given time to absorb the characters’ personalities and different politics, etc. It wasn’t my taste.
YABC May 2008
YABC May 2008
July 27, 2013
This was a really fun way to spend some reading hours. It's YA Fantasy, which I wouldn't normally read, but Harris's style proved too seductive for me. She laid out a trail of breadcrumbs from the first paragraph and before I knew it I was deep inside the mountain, and the story. Caught, and mesmerized, there was no way out, but through it.
I will admit to one or two brain spasms along the way as I tried to make sense of the complex Norse mythology, with which Harris deviates from the conventional storyline. But, given that it is all mythological who is to say after all, which is the better tale that's told? Harris's telling is beguiling.
Maddy proves to be an enchanting young heroine -- all the more glamorous because she lacks glamour and instead moves with integrity, innocence and honour. What comfort to YA readers to know that one of their "own" is incorruptible, straightforward and strong!
While a few other readers have commented that "nothing happens" and that Maddy is purposeless, I would beg to differ and suggest a closer re-reading: sometimes it's the journey that counts, and not the destination.
Even from my more mature wisdom, this was an enjoyable read. When I put myself back in my 12-year-old body, under the apple tree, this book was positively delicious!
I will admit to one or two brain spasms along the way as I tried to make sense of the complex Norse mythology, with which Harris deviates from the conventional storyline. But, given that it is all mythological who is to say after all, which is the better tale that's told? Harris's telling is beguiling.
Maddy proves to be an enchanting young heroine -- all the more glamorous because she lacks glamour and instead moves with integrity, innocence and honour. What comfort to YA readers to know that one of their "own" is incorruptible, straightforward and strong!
While a few other readers have commented that "nothing happens" and that Maddy is purposeless, I would beg to differ and suggest a closer re-reading: sometimes it's the journey that counts, and not the destination.
Even from my more mature wisdom, this was an enjoyable read. When I put myself back in my 12-year-old body, under the apple tree, this book was positively delicious!
April 8, 2024
Отказвам се - сериозно ми доскуча, както почти всяка YA история, която съм пробвал до сега.
Започна добре, но не може и да стъпи на малкия пръст на приключенията на Локи от предната епоха, сполучливо предадени в "Евангелието на Локи", години след написването на тази книга.
От един момент нататък клишетата, повторенията и слабо изградените герои просто ми дотегнаха и нямам никакво желание да науча, какво очаква главната героиня.
P.S. Даже и гоблините не струват...
Започна добре, но не може и да стъпи на малкия пръст на приключенията на Локи от предната епоха, сполучливо предадени в "Евангелието на Локи", години след написването на тази книга.
От един момент нататък клишетата, повторенията и слабо изградените герои просто ми дотегнаха и нямам никакво желание да науча, какво очаква главната героиня.
P.S. Даже и гоблините не струват...
November 16, 2012
I made one big pause while reading, so my thoughts are not 100% coherent; I also don't have time for a detailed review right now. I'll just say what made me decide on five rather than four.
-YA WITH FEMALE PROTAGONIST BUT NO ROMANCE. (No, no potential love interests introduced either.)
-Despite target audience, it is much less Bleached Underpants than many other interpretations of Norse Mythology. Also, no Black&White here.
-The recommendation mentioned "shenanigans", but it's not as much about shenanigans as deception. Layers upon layers of it. It is clear enough not to cause a headache or blink-or-miss-it, but the hints drop just before the reveal so you don't have to spend pages rolling your eyes and wishing the character would get it already.
-Also, it featured one my favourite kind of plot twist which I cannot name because it is a major spoiler and I really don't want to spoil anything here.
-YA WITH FEMALE PROTAGONIST BUT NO ROMANCE. (No, no potential love interests introduced either.)
-Despite target audience, it is much less Bleached Underpants than many other interpretations of Norse Mythology. Also, no Black&White here.
-The recommendation mentioned "shenanigans", but it's not as much about shenanigans as deception. Layers upon layers of it. It is clear enough not to cause a headache or blink-or-miss-it, but the hints drop just before the reveal so you don't have to spend pages rolling your eyes and wishing the character would get it already.
-Also, it featured one my favourite kind of plot twist which I cannot name because it is a major spoiler and I really don't want to spoil anything here.
March 26, 2018
HOW HAVE I NOT READ THIS BEFORE??? I mean, I know why, because in my opinion the summary for this book doesn't really do it justice. Or maybe it does, but it doesn't necessarily highlight the parts of the book that make it most appealing to me personally.
First of all, I feel like the summary/cover makes this seem more like a middle grade book, but it is definitely YA. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind middle grade books, but with the complexity of the story here I'm glad it was aimed at a slightly older audience. Also this is YA WITH A FEMALE PROTAGONIST WITH ABSOLUTELY NO ROMANCE OR LOVE INTERESTS [POTENTIAL OR OTHERWISE] WHATSOEVER. What a breath of fresh air!
Secondly, to me the summary reads like the book is going to feature Norse mythology but not feature the gods heavily I guess? I didn't know that Harris' The Gospel of Loki was also technically a part of this series or I would have realized my mistake earlier, but anyway the gods are VERY present in this. Pretty much all the major players make an appearance at some point but Odin and Loki are the main ones, and if you know me then you know how much I absolutely adore anything with Loki in it! In the end I thought there was a nice balance between the gods and the human characters and I really liked how all of their plots came together at the end.
Also, I've seen some reviews from people saying they aren't very familiar with Norse mythology and that they find this book confusing. I can't really speak from that standpoint because I am apparently so over-familiar with Norse mythology that Neil Gaiman's new book last year literally bored me by it bringing nothing new to the table. However, this doesn't necessarily draw on that many of the actual Norse myths - it taking place AFTER Ragnarok and all - and mostly focuses on the characters so I would think a quick wiki list of Norse gods or something would give you most of the background you need. There is a character list at the beginning but it's basically 'all the gods and what Loki did to piss them off' so, while funny, it's not the most informative.
First of all, I feel like the summary/cover makes this seem more like a middle grade book, but it is definitely YA. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind middle grade books, but with the complexity of the story here I'm glad it was aimed at a slightly older audience. Also this is YA WITH A FEMALE PROTAGONIST WITH ABSOLUTELY NO ROMANCE OR LOVE INTERESTS [POTENTIAL OR OTHERWISE] WHATSOEVER. What a breath of fresh air!
Secondly, to me the summary reads like the book is going to feature Norse mythology but not feature the gods heavily I guess? I didn't know that Harris' The Gospel of Loki was also technically a part of this series or I would have realized my mistake earlier, but anyway the gods are VERY present in this. Pretty much all the major players make an appearance at some point but Odin and Loki are the main ones, and if you know me then you know how much I absolutely adore anything with Loki in it! In the end I thought there was a nice balance between the gods and the human characters and I really liked how all of their plots came together at the end.
Also, I've seen some reviews from people saying they aren't very familiar with Norse mythology and that they find this book confusing. I can't really speak from that standpoint because I am apparently so over-familiar with Norse mythology that Neil Gaiman's new book last year literally bored me by it bringing nothing new to the table. However, this doesn't necessarily draw on that many of the actual Norse myths - it taking place AFTER Ragnarok and all - and mostly focuses on the characters so I would think a quick wiki list of Norse gods or something would give you most of the background you need. There is a character list at the beginning but it's basically 'all the gods and what Loki did to piss them off' so, while funny, it's not the most informative.
October 7, 2017
Έχω διαβάσει αυτό το βιβλίο μπορεί ίσα με 10 φορές (στην κυριολεξία).
Θυμάμαι την πρώτη φορά που το διάβασα πήγαινα γυμνάσιο και ντρέπομαι που το λέω αλλά δεν είχα ιδέα έστω ότι υπάρχει κάτι που λέγεται σκανδιναβική μυθολογία.
Το είχα πάρει από τη Δανειστική Βιβλιοθήκη με μισή καρδιά γιατί ούτε το εξώφυλλο με τρέλαινε, ούτε ο τίτλος και η περίληψη στο οπισθόφυλλο μου φαινόταν τελείως κλισέ.
Και πραγματικά πιστεύω πως τόσο πολύ έξω δεν έχω πέσει ποτέ με άλλο βιβλίο! Δεν μπορούσα να το πιστέψω! Με κάθε σελίδα που διάβαζα κολλούσα όλο και πιο πολύ.
Έχω την εντύπωση πως αυτό που με ενθουσίασε περισσότερο, εκτός από τους χαρακτήρες που ήταν όλοι ένας προς ένας, ήταν το γεγονός πως δεν ήξερα που θα καταλήξει το όλο πράγμα. Θέλω να πω στα περισσότερα βιβλία, φαντασίας, αστυνομικά, αισθηματικά, ξέρεις λίγο πολύ πως θα τελειώσουν: αυτό που ψάχνουν στο τέλος θα το βρουν, θα τον σώσουν αυτόν που κινδυνεύει, θα τον πιάσουν το δολοφόνο, μετά από όλες τις αντιξοότητες και τα εμπόδια θα καταλήξουν μαζί ευτυχισμένοι. Στην προκειμένη περίπτωση, διάβαζα, διάβαζα, περνούσαν οι σελίδες, συνέβαιναν του κόσμου όλου τα γεγονότα και οι αποκαλύψεις και δεν μπορούσα να μαντέψω τι θα συνέβαινε στο τέλος.
Βέβαια έφταιγε και λίγο το γεγονός ότι από σκανδιναβική μυθολογία δεν είχα ιδέα. Πιστεύω πως αν γνώριζα και 5 πράγματα κάποιες από τις εξελίξεις ίσως και να τις είχα προβλέψει. Και εννοείται πως αφού το τελείωσα, καθόμουνα και έψαχνα στο ίντερνετ ότι υπήρχε και δεν υπήρχε για τους θεούς, μύθους και ιστορίες.
Και τη 2η φορά που το διάβασα ήταν ακόμη καλύτερο. Θες λίγο που ήξερα και 2 πράγματα για τους σκανδιναβούς θεούς, θες λίγο που δεν είχα τόση αγωνία για το τι θα γίνει στο τέλος και επικεντρωνόμουν στις λεπτομέρειες; Δεν ξέρω σίγουρα.
Και το ξαναδιάβασα…και ξανά…και ξανά…και ακόμη δεν το έχω βαρεθεί να πω την αλήθεια.
Από τα πιο ωραία βιβλία φαντασίας που έχω (ξανα)διαβάσει. Πολύ κρίμα που δεν μεταφράστηκε και η συνέχεια (η οποία είναι επίσης εξαιρετική).
Και εδώ στο τέλος θα ήθελα να μου επιτραπεί να σχολιάσω το πόσο άκυρος είναι ο ελληνικός τίτλος (στα αγγλικά είναι Runemarks) και πως μόνο τη 2η φορά που το διάβασα κατάλαβα πού αναφέρεται.
Θυμάμαι την πρώτη φορά που το διάβασα πήγαινα γυμνάσιο και ντρέπομαι που το λέω αλλά δεν είχα ιδέα έστω ότι υπάρχει κάτι που λέγεται σκανδιναβική μυθολογία.
Το είχα πάρει από τη Δανειστική Βιβλιοθήκη με μισή καρδιά γιατί ούτε το εξώφυλλο με τρέλαινε, ούτε ο τίτλος και η περίληψη στο οπισθόφυλλο μου φαινόταν τελείως κλισέ.
Και πραγματικά πιστεύω πως τόσο πολύ έξω δεν έχω πέσει ποτέ με άλλο βιβλίο! Δεν μπορούσα να το πιστέψω! Με κάθε σελίδα που διάβαζα κολλούσα όλο και πιο πολύ.
Έχω την εντύπωση πως αυτό που με ενθουσίασε περισσότερο, εκτός από τους χαρακτήρες που ήταν όλοι ένας προς ένας, ήταν το γεγονός πως δεν ήξερα που θα καταλήξει το όλο πράγμα. Θέλω να πω στα περισσότερα βιβλία, φαντασίας, αστυνομικά, αισθηματικά, ξέρεις λίγο πολύ πως θα τελειώσουν: αυτό που ψάχνουν στο τέλος θα το βρουν, θα τον σώσουν αυτόν που κινδυνεύει, θα τον πιάσουν το δολοφόνο, μετά από όλες τις αντιξοότητες και τα εμπόδια θα καταλήξουν μαζί ευτυχισμένοι. Στην προκειμένη περίπτωση, διάβαζα, διάβαζα, περνούσαν οι σελίδες, συνέβαιναν του κόσμου όλου τα γεγονότα και οι αποκαλύψεις και δεν μπορούσα να μαντέψω τι θα συνέβαινε στο τέλος.
Βέβαια έφταιγε και λίγο το γεγονός ότι από σκανδιναβική μυθολογία δεν είχα ιδέα. Πιστεύω πως αν γνώριζα και 5 πράγματα κάποιες από τις εξελίξεις ίσως και να τις είχα προβλέψει. Και εννοείται πως αφού το τελείωσα, καθόμουνα και έψαχνα στο ίντερνετ ότι υπήρχε και δεν υπήρχε για τους θεούς, μύθους και ιστορίες.
Και τη 2η φορά που το διάβασα ήταν ακόμη καλύτερο. Θες λίγο που ήξερα και 2 πράγματα για τους σκανδιναβούς θεούς, θες λίγο που δεν είχα τόση αγωνία για το τι θα γίνει στο τέλος και επικεντρωνόμουν στις λεπτομέρειες; Δεν ξέρω σίγουρα.
Και το ξαναδιάβασα…και ξανά…και ξανά…και ακόμη δεν το έχω βαρεθεί να πω την αλήθεια.
Από τα πιο ωραία βιβλία φαντασίας που έχω (ξανα)διαβάσει. Πολύ κρίμα που δεν μεταφράστηκε και η συνέχεια (η οποία είναι επίσης εξαιρετική).
Και εδώ στο τέλος θα ήθελα να μου επιτραπεί να σχολιάσω το πόσο άκυρος είναι ο ελληνικός τίτλος (στα αγγλικά είναι Runemarks) και πως μόνο τη 2η φορά που το διάβασα κατάλαβα πού αναφέρεται.
August 29, 2015
Characters: MADDY is an excellent heroine. She's not too perfect, but well-meaning, brave, daring, and affectionate without mush. She's not fluffy or weepy and she doesn't have an attitude. If in the one part she's momentarily whiny it's understandable and she stops very soon. And can she throw a mind bolt!
ONE-EYE, Odin, is a puzzle to Maddy. Her friend, mentor; but is he only utilizing her?
LOKI--unpredictable. Charming; scarred; a rogue; snarky to the limit, with a dark past. If you asked him if he cared about any one, or regretted anything, he'd deny it with a grin, and be lying. I defy you not to be hoping he stays on the light side, or glad every time he shows a bit of goodness.
And the rest of the very large, very complicated cast. It would be spoilers to mention some of them. Let's just say that the author knows her myths, and there's a pot-bellied pig too.
Plot: Read the book description for basics. The plot is epic. It goes on and on, picking up characters, places, themes. I can't say much without spoilers.
Writing: Once in a while a character (especially Loki) speaks in a too-modern fashion. Apart from that, the writing is gorgeous, dark and funny, magnificent, gentle sometimes. It's not Rosemary Sutcliff, but it's very good.
Content: Here are the problems. 4 S-words of one sort or another. I don't like vulgarity, and most books I read do not have it. If I buy this one I will use the black pen on it. Other words were p*** and d***, which don't bother me quite as much. Nothing sexual to speak of, some violence. Also the antagonistic Order seems to be a representation of Christianity, and the gods seem at times to be identified with demons. However, by the end, the Order's god is revealed, and is nothing like God; and gods and demons seem to be separate things. I loved the story and characters so much that I followed my friend Hazel's example and gave bonus points so it still is five stars.
And finally, brethren: Suitable for perhaps 16+, or younger if language doesn't bother you or you have an obliging person to mark out the baddies; girls or boys. Recommended for Norse mythology fans, epic fans, Loki fans, adventure fans, and fans of dark humor.
ONE-EYE, Odin, is a puzzle to Maddy. Her friend, mentor; but is he only utilizing her?
LOKI--unpredictable. Charming; scarred; a rogue; snarky to the limit, with a dark past. If you asked him if he cared about any one, or regretted anything, he'd deny it with a grin, and be lying. I defy you not to be hoping he stays on the light side, or glad every time he shows a bit of goodness.
And the rest of the very large, very complicated cast. It would be spoilers to mention some of them. Let's just say that the author knows her myths, and there's a pot-bellied pig too.
Plot: Read the book description for basics. The plot is epic. It goes on and on, picking up characters, places, themes. I can't say much without spoilers.
Writing: Once in a while a character (especially Loki) speaks in a too-modern fashion. Apart from that, the writing is gorgeous, dark and funny, magnificent, gentle sometimes. It's not Rosemary Sutcliff, but it's very good.
Content: Here are the problems. 4 S-words of one sort or another. I don't like vulgarity, and most books I read do not have it. If I buy this one I will use the black pen on it. Other words were p*** and d***, which don't bother me quite as much. Nothing sexual to speak of, some violence. Also the antagonistic Order seems to be a representation of Christianity, and the gods seem at times to be identified with demons. However, by the end, the Order's god is revealed, and is nothing like God; and gods and demons seem to be separate things. I loved the story and characters so much that I followed my friend Hazel's example and gave bonus points so it still is five stars.
And finally, brethren: Suitable for perhaps 16+, or younger if language doesn't bother you or you have an obliging person to mark out the baddies; girls or boys. Recommended for Norse mythology fans, epic fans, Loki fans, adventure fans, and fans of dark humor.
January 18, 2019
Firstly, this cover looks stunning in person with its gold accents and that combined with the synopsis made me instantly buy it because who doesn't love a little bit of mythology?! Well, this was absolutely filled to the brim with Norse mythology, which was super exciting because I love mythology, but it didn't make for a nice reading experience since you were just constantly overloaded with information about each of the gods and the Nine Worlds. Due to this, the pace just kept getting interrupted because you'd have to stop and take in all the information, and then the next page or chapter, you'd be reading from another perspective or within a different storyline.
That was another thing that irked me, there was the story with Maddy and the gods, and then another which crossed over with theirs involving those from the village.... Let me tell you, that storyline was very uninteresting and made me quite sad when I had to go from the gods and Maddy using runemarks to dealing with the villagers.
I believe this title is targeted at a YA audience, which typically is anywhere from 12 and up (who knows these days though), but I can't see many younger readers being interested in this...?
As always, this is my own opinion and perhaps this just didn't end up being a title for me and others may love it instead! However, it could have been an exciting book if perhaps it was stripped back a little since it's only the first book. That being said, there's only one other in the series and that was published a whole four years later.
Also, bonus points for the inclusion of two maps, a break down of all the characters, and images of the runemarks with their explanations!
That was another thing that irked me, there was the story with Maddy and the gods, and then another which crossed over with theirs involving those from the village.... Let me tell you, that storyline was very uninteresting and made me quite sad when I had to go from the gods and Maddy using runemarks to dealing with the villagers.
I believe this title is targeted at a YA audience, which typically is anywhere from 12 and up (who knows these days though), but I can't see many younger readers being interested in this...?
As always, this is my own opinion and perhaps this just didn't end up being a title for me and others may love it instead! However, it could have been an exciting book if perhaps it was stripped back a little since it's only the first book. That being said, there's only one other in the series and that was published a whole four years later.
Also, bonus points for the inclusion of two maps, a break down of all the characters, and images of the runemarks with their explanations!
August 3, 2013
I have mixed feelings about this book. I guess I'll start with the positive things about it. First off, it's well-written, the Norse mythology is accurate and it has quite an imaginative adventure.
But...
There were so many things happening all at once that I failed to get a firm grip on the story and digest it thoroughly. It felt like too much information for a single book- it could have easily been two books. Therefore, I did not feel I got to know the characters and process the story in a deeper level. I don't know about you guys, but I think that one of the most important things about a story is how well you get to know a character. In this book, I feel that the author merely skimmed the surface of her characters. Secondly, I feel that the story did not offer a full explanation of Norse mythology- its almost like you are expected to know about it already.
Finally, and this is just my opinion, it stirred nothing inside me. Yes, it was a fun and entertaining read but that's about it. I don't know about you guys, but I like books that make me feel intense emotions- like empathizing with the characters. This book, did not do that for me specially because the characters, in my opinion, lack depth.
It's good but I can live without it. :)
But...
There were so many things happening all at once that I failed to get a firm grip on the story and digest it thoroughly. It felt like too much information for a single book- it could have easily been two books. Therefore, I did not feel I got to know the characters and process the story in a deeper level. I don't know about you guys, but I think that one of the most important things about a story is how well you get to know a character. In this book, I feel that the author merely skimmed the surface of her characters. Secondly, I feel that the story did not offer a full explanation of Norse mythology- its almost like you are expected to know about it already.
Finally, and this is just my opinion, it stirred nothing inside me. Yes, it was a fun and entertaining read but that's about it. I don't know about you guys, but I like books that make me feel intense emotions- like empathizing with the characters. This book, did not do that for me specially because the characters, in my opinion, lack depth.
It's good but I can live without it. :)
December 16, 2023
I need Joanne Harris to write more fantasy books. She really is my favorite author, the one who got me back into reading, the one who makes me feel the magic through words and stories. I love her way of telling stories. She really is magical and warms your heart. Thank you for writing these books, you are truly a blessing o me.
About this book, I think it was a great way of introducing me to norse mythology. I really know nothing about it, except for what I've watched on Marvel movies. I went on searching for the gods a few times and loved to see that some characteristics were included here, namely Lokis' stitched scars. There was humor, there were sad moments, happy ones, a bit of everything. I think I found a new favorite.
About this book, I think it was a great way of introducing me to norse mythology. I really know nothing about it, except for what I've watched on Marvel movies. I went on searching for the gods a few times and loved to see that some characteristics were included here, namely Lokis' stitched scars. There was humor, there were sad moments, happy ones, a bit of everything. I think I found a new favorite.
February 24, 2017
Joanne Harris has written a fast-moving story with a young heroine, 14 at the time of the dramatic action, set 500 years after Ragnorok in a world that derives from Norse myth.
I've read dozens of books of myth and folktale over the years, as well as books that draw inspiration from the originals, and Harris's creation is fresh and satisfying.
I've read dozens of books of myth and folktale over the years, as well as books that draw inspiration from the originals, and Harris's creation is fresh and satisfying.
January 20, 2009
Imagine that Ragnarok happened, Asgard fell, and in the aftermath the survivors stumbled blindly forward to build a new world on the ashes of the old. Imagine, also, that the ancient runes have power for those that are born marked with them. Five hundred years after the end, much of the world is dominated by the Order, which has done its best to eradicate rune-magic and magical creatures of all kinds - with a thoroughness comparable to the Inquisition at its worst. But on the far side of the mountains from the Order's center of power, Maddy Smith has been allowed to grow up with an unbroken runemark on her palm - a mark that is not one of the old runes, but a new one. With Odin, Loki, and the prophet known as the Whisperer all pursuing their own goals, Maddy has to work out what her goals are - and hope that pursuing them does not condemn the world to another round of destruction This was quite a book, though I found myself a bit distracted by wondering how much was drawn from actual Norse myth and how much from Zelazny's Amber (or is it, how much did Zelazny draw on Norse myth?). But it's a fun book, aside from the occasional anachronism in the description or dialogue, with a thorough ending that's still open enough to allow for a sequel. Recommended.
December 6, 2017
Onvan : Runemarks (Runemarks, #1) - Nevisande : Joanne Harris - ISBN : 385611307 - ISBN13 : 9780385611305 - Dar 528 Safhe - Saal e Chap : 2007
May 30, 2024
Er zijn van die boeken die je meesleuren vanaf de eerste pagina, maar er zijn er ook die daar wat meer moeite voor moeten doen. Het boek Vuurvolk van Joanne Harris moest echt zijn best doen om mij in het verhaal te gaan betrekken.
Maar wie is nu Joanne Harris?
Dit is mijn eerste boek van deze schrijfster dus voor mij was ze onbekend. Maar even zien wat we kunnen vinden over deze dame.
Joanne Michèle Sylvie Harris werd geboren op 3juli 1964. ( Het jaar dat Malta onafhankelijk werd en de Rolling Stones hun eerste concert gaven in Nederland.) Harris werd geboren in Yorkshire en is het kind van een Franse moeder en een Engelse vader. De beleefde de droom van elk kind want haar grootouders hadden een snoepwinkel. Oma stond ook gekend als heks en genezer, want dan weer een rol speelt in haar verdere leven als romanschrijfster. Harris haar eerste boek zag het printerlicht in ’89 en kende maar een matig succes. In ’99 werd ze nr1 bestseller van de London Sunday Times.
Het boek dat ik las, Vuurvolk, zag het levenslicht in 2007 als Runemarks en is haar eerste boek voor jeugd / YA.
Wat is het verhaal van Vuurvolk?
Het verhaal volgt Malin die op de middenwerelden woont waar de orde heerst. Chaos, magie of bijgeloof zijn taboe. Niet alles is verdwenen aangezien Malin een runenteken op haar hand heeft waar de rest van het dorp dan weer naar kijkt en een teken van hekserij herkent. Malin raakt bevriend met eenoog die ook een runenteken heeft en haar leert haar magische krachten te gaan gebruiken. Krachten die ze zal moeten beheersen wanneer orde en chaos opnieuw in oorlog met elkaar komen.
Mijn gedacht
Mijn gedacht zat in begin niet zo goed. Er waren momenten waarin het idee naar boven kwam om het boek terug te zetten en één van die andere titels te gaan lezen die al jarenlang stof staan te happen in mijn kast. Waarom zou je hem toedoen hoor ik jullie denken?
Het verhaal sprak me niet aan. Het verhaal spatte nu niet van de pagina’s. Na een tijd kwam ik terug op het zoveelste verhaal rond Loki en de voltrokken Ragnarok. Maar dan begon er toch wat meer spanning in het verhaal te komen. Waar het in het begin echt wel soms kinderlijk overkwam begon er wat meer volwassenheid in te komen. De schrijfstijl werd wat vlotter en de gebeurtenissen kregen meer volume.
Malin die het hoofdpersonage is van het verhaal groeit naarmate het verhaal vordert van een onzeker dame tot een jonge vrouw die haar weg zoekt tussen verloren goden, orakels en andere vijanden.
Loki krijgt zijn rol als onbedoelde/bedoelde onruststoker en Eenoog blijkt de enige echte Odin te zijn, terwijl Thor een klein rolletje krijgt samen met de dame Hel. Er is zelfs plaats voor een zwijn om sporen te zoeken naar de onderwereld.
Al de personages dragen wel ergens bij aan het verhaal alhoewel het me niet altijd even duidelijk overkwam.
Het einde kwam nu niet als een verrassing maar sluit wel mooi het boek af. Er zit een goeie dosis spanning in maar had nu graag eens een grote twist gezien willen hebben maar die kreeg ik jammer genoeg niet.
Een boek dat me niet meesleurde ga ik nu ook niet als een slecht boek neerzetten. Ik heb al veel betere jeugd of YA boeken gelezen dan deze. Na die matige start kon ik mij er wel toe zetten om het boek volledig te gaan uitlezen. Dit is Harris haar eerste jeugdboek wat dan ook een ander publiek is dan waarvoor ze eerder haar boeken schreef. Ze zal hier ook wel nog in moeten te groeien hebben. Voor mij kwam het over als een gewoon boek. Niet slecht maar ook niet zo goed. Ik ga het dit weekend in de ruilkast plaatsen in de hoop dat een ander er meer plezier zal aan beleven dan ik. Op naar het volgende boek.
Maar wie is nu Joanne Harris?
Dit is mijn eerste boek van deze schrijfster dus voor mij was ze onbekend. Maar even zien wat we kunnen vinden over deze dame.
Joanne Michèle Sylvie Harris werd geboren op 3juli 1964. ( Het jaar dat Malta onafhankelijk werd en de Rolling Stones hun eerste concert gaven in Nederland.) Harris werd geboren in Yorkshire en is het kind van een Franse moeder en een Engelse vader. De beleefde de droom van elk kind want haar grootouders hadden een snoepwinkel. Oma stond ook gekend als heks en genezer, want dan weer een rol speelt in haar verdere leven als romanschrijfster. Harris haar eerste boek zag het printerlicht in ’89 en kende maar een matig succes. In ’99 werd ze nr1 bestseller van de London Sunday Times.
Het boek dat ik las, Vuurvolk, zag het levenslicht in 2007 als Runemarks en is haar eerste boek voor jeugd / YA.
Wat is het verhaal van Vuurvolk?
Het verhaal volgt Malin die op de middenwerelden woont waar de orde heerst. Chaos, magie of bijgeloof zijn taboe. Niet alles is verdwenen aangezien Malin een runenteken op haar hand heeft waar de rest van het dorp dan weer naar kijkt en een teken van hekserij herkent. Malin raakt bevriend met eenoog die ook een runenteken heeft en haar leert haar magische krachten te gaan gebruiken. Krachten die ze zal moeten beheersen wanneer orde en chaos opnieuw in oorlog met elkaar komen.
Mijn gedacht
Mijn gedacht zat in begin niet zo goed. Er waren momenten waarin het idee naar boven kwam om het boek terug te zetten en één van die andere titels te gaan lezen die al jarenlang stof staan te happen in mijn kast. Waarom zou je hem toedoen hoor ik jullie denken?
Het verhaal sprak me niet aan. Het verhaal spatte nu niet van de pagina’s. Na een tijd kwam ik terug op het zoveelste verhaal rond Loki en de voltrokken Ragnarok. Maar dan begon er toch wat meer spanning in het verhaal te komen. Waar het in het begin echt wel soms kinderlijk overkwam begon er wat meer volwassenheid in te komen. De schrijfstijl werd wat vlotter en de gebeurtenissen kregen meer volume.
Malin die het hoofdpersonage is van het verhaal groeit naarmate het verhaal vordert van een onzeker dame tot een jonge vrouw die haar weg zoekt tussen verloren goden, orakels en andere vijanden.
Loki krijgt zijn rol als onbedoelde/bedoelde onruststoker en Eenoog blijkt de enige echte Odin te zijn, terwijl Thor een klein rolletje krijgt samen met de dame Hel. Er is zelfs plaats voor een zwijn om sporen te zoeken naar de onderwereld.
Al de personages dragen wel ergens bij aan het verhaal alhoewel het me niet altijd even duidelijk overkwam.
Het einde kwam nu niet als een verrassing maar sluit wel mooi het boek af. Er zit een goeie dosis spanning in maar had nu graag eens een grote twist gezien willen hebben maar die kreeg ik jammer genoeg niet.
Een boek dat me niet meesleurde ga ik nu ook niet als een slecht boek neerzetten. Ik heb al veel betere jeugd of YA boeken gelezen dan deze. Na die matige start kon ik mij er wel toe zetten om het boek volledig te gaan uitlezen. Dit is Harris haar eerste jeugdboek wat dan ook een ander publiek is dan waarvoor ze eerder haar boeken schreef. Ze zal hier ook wel nog in moeten te groeien hebben. Voor mij kwam het over als een gewoon boek. Niet slecht maar ook niet zo goed. Ik ga het dit weekend in de ruilkast plaatsen in de hoop dat een ander er meer plezier zal aan beleven dan ik. Op naar het volgende boek.
May 3, 2023
2.75⭐
June 22, 2009
AWESOME! I AM OBSESSED WITH THIS BOOK, DO YOU HEAR ME? AWESOME! "Runemarks" is based on Norse Mythology, and the witty and surprisingly colorful cast of characters includes many Norse Gods (including Loki the Trickster, Odin the All-Father, and Thor the Thunderer), several hilarious goblins (my favorite of which was named Sugar-&-Sacke), and quite a few persnickety, clever, and downright serendipitous humans (including Nat Parson, his wife Ethelberta who is not all she seems, and the uptight Mrs. Scattergood).
But of course, no one can forget the book's main character, the clever and brave Maddy Smith, a fourteen-year-old with a "ruinmark" (runemark) on the palm of her hand, an ancient and mysterious symbol that signifies the Seer-folk blood she is scorned for and the magic that she is able to preform.
Read this book and you are in for a wild adventure without even leaving your room!
But of course, no one can forget the book's main character, the clever and brave Maddy Smith, a fourteen-year-old with a "ruinmark" (runemark) on the palm of her hand, an ancient and mysterious symbol that signifies the Seer-folk blood she is scorned for and the magic that she is able to preform.
Read this book and you are in for a wild adventure without even leaving your room!
September 8, 2017
supermooie cover en leuk verhaal (een dosis Loki kan nooit kwaad ;-))
April 10, 2013
Opinião do blogue Chaise Longue: http://girlinchaiselongue.blogspot.pt...
Nos primeiros dez anos da sua vida, Joanne refugiou-se na leitura, nos dez anos seguintes escreveu histórias a imitar as dos seus autores preferidos e depois, finalmente, começou a escrever as suas próprias histórias mas houve uma história, escrita durante os seus dezanove anos que a autora acabou por recuperar, uma história inspirada pelo seu amor à mitologia nórdica, originalmente chamada Witchlight e que foi recusada pelos editores devido ao seu tamanho, complexidade e obscuridade. Esta história um dia saiu da gaveta e tornou-se uma história de mãe para filha, uma história que Joanne lia e adaptava para a sua filha Anouchka, uma história divertida e privada até a filha de Harris a convencer a publicá-la e assim nasceu A Marca das Runas.
Publicado em 2007, e reeditado agora pela ASA, editora da autora em Portugal, este é o primeiro volume da duologia de fantasia da autora de Chocolate, uma série juvenil que não deixa de apresentar a profundidade sombria de Joanne mas que contém diversão, mitologia e aventura e, mais uma vez, o combate entre magia e religião.
Maddy nunca foi uma menina como as outras. Renegada desde a nascença por causa da marca que apresenta na pele, Maddy é uma estranha na sua própria casa, olhada de lado pelos que a viram crescer, diferente em todos os aspectos, ela sonha com outro mundo, onde não seja uma estranha, um símbolo de algo que é temido e há muito esquecido… mal Maddy sabe que algo está mudar, que o que está adormecido voltará, que a magia está mais entranhada nela do que alguma vez ela pode supor e que está na hora de ela cumprir a sua parte nos desígnios do destino. Encarregada de uma missão, ela parte para o desconhecido e descobre que as fábulas que o seu mentor lhe contava são mais reais e perigosas, que existe um inimigo que está prestes a torná-las nada até ao esquecimento absoluto, que ela própria é muito mais do que aparenta. Numa guerra onde o Caos e a Ordem se enfrentam mais uma vez, inimigos tornam-se amigos, aliados mudam de lado e uma Nova Era pode morrer antes de puder crescer.
Autora que brilha em livros esotéricos de alguma estranheza e muita complexidade, Joanne dá-nos este A Marca das Runas, um livro juvenil de fantasia, muito diferente do seu estilo habitual mas que não deixa de surpreender, nem que seja pelo lado refrescante e divertido, jovem e espirituoso, uma faceta desconhecida da autora, cujos livros pontuam, por regra, pela densidade e obscuridade. Numa linha mais simples mas com a mesma escrita envolvente que perde o seu lado tentador pra um mais ingénuo e satírico, a autora de Chocolate mostra que quando se nasce com um dom se pode escrever qualquer coisa, até uma fábula de aventuras, demandas e objectos mágicos.
Mas desenganem-se se pensam que este livro é uma leitura básica e banal, muito pelo contrário, está repleta de segredos, profecias e ligações obscuras que se unem numa narrativa de acção rápida e momentos únicos que nos levam a ler a toda a velocidade. Onde as gargalhadas são sempre bem-vindas, o inesperado acontece nos momentos menos propícios e o coração se aperta quando só queremos que tudo acabe bem, a mitologia nórdica ganha outra graça e dimensão, uma versão mais colorida, trapaceira e trapalhona que nos faz voltar à idade em que acreditávamos em tudo e em que o entusiasmo era quase infantil e extravagante. Mesmo assim, como sempre, a autora não nos deixa de espantar com a forma como o Bem e o Mal são uma única e só moeda, como ambos os conceitos se entrelaçam e desmontam dependendo da perspectiva de cada lado, mostrando que por baixo da cor e risada há uma mensagem mais profunda do que transparece a um primeiro olhar.
Também este livro é marcado pelos temas habituais. O conflito entre a religião e a magia, a fábula e a realidade, a ordem e o caos, pautam toda a narrativa, onde as coisas não são tão lineares quanto aparentam e que são apresentadas de uma forma tão imaginativa pela autora, que cada descrição nos faz viver os acontecimentos, deixando a nossa mente voar mais longe pelas páginas ao encontro das milésimas tarefas que Maddy e companhia cumprem ao longo da sua jornada. Em cada momento nota-se que este é um livro feito por diversão, um livro para extravasar ideias, para fazer rir e abrir os olhos mas com a certeza que respiraremos de alívio no fim, pelo menos até ao próximo livro.
As próprias personagens são tal como a narrativa em que se inserem. Ingénuas, rezingonas, irónicas e divertidas, um grupo para nos animar e enternecer que colocarão até ao fim da leitura a visão Marvel longe das nossas mentes. Desde os deuses aos habitantes da aldeia, cada um apresenta um conjunto de características que nos impedem de odiar profundamente e apelam ao perdão e isto, sendo um factor que algumas personagens de Joanne chegam a apresentar em outros livros, acaba por ter a sua certa ironia porque estas personagens são tão menos pesadas e intricadas que apelam desde logo ao nosso lado bom.
Sem deixar de ter aquela marca inimitável de Joanne, A Marca das Runas é um conto para a família, um livro em que podemos voltar atrás no tempo, sozinhos ou acompanhados mesmo dos mais novos. Sem a complexidade e mistério mais envolvente típicos, este livro é para se desfrutar, para descansar a mente das coisas tristes, para ler sempre com um sorriso. Uma leitura pitoresca e colorida que mesmo não atingindo a soberba dos outros romances de Joanne traz, sem dúvida, uma inocência e doçura que se deve recuperar, mesmo de vez em quando.
Nos primeiros dez anos da sua vida, Joanne refugiou-se na leitura, nos dez anos seguintes escreveu histórias a imitar as dos seus autores preferidos e depois, finalmente, começou a escrever as suas próprias histórias mas houve uma história, escrita durante os seus dezanove anos que a autora acabou por recuperar, uma história inspirada pelo seu amor à mitologia nórdica, originalmente chamada Witchlight e que foi recusada pelos editores devido ao seu tamanho, complexidade e obscuridade. Esta história um dia saiu da gaveta e tornou-se uma história de mãe para filha, uma história que Joanne lia e adaptava para a sua filha Anouchka, uma história divertida e privada até a filha de Harris a convencer a publicá-la e assim nasceu A Marca das Runas.
Publicado em 2007, e reeditado agora pela ASA, editora da autora em Portugal, este é o primeiro volume da duologia de fantasia da autora de Chocolate, uma série juvenil que não deixa de apresentar a profundidade sombria de Joanne mas que contém diversão, mitologia e aventura e, mais uma vez, o combate entre magia e religião.
Maddy nunca foi uma menina como as outras. Renegada desde a nascença por causa da marca que apresenta na pele, Maddy é uma estranha na sua própria casa, olhada de lado pelos que a viram crescer, diferente em todos os aspectos, ela sonha com outro mundo, onde não seja uma estranha, um símbolo de algo que é temido e há muito esquecido… mal Maddy sabe que algo está mudar, que o que está adormecido voltará, que a magia está mais entranhada nela do que alguma vez ela pode supor e que está na hora de ela cumprir a sua parte nos desígnios do destino. Encarregada de uma missão, ela parte para o desconhecido e descobre que as fábulas que o seu mentor lhe contava são mais reais e perigosas, que existe um inimigo que está prestes a torná-las nada até ao esquecimento absoluto, que ela própria é muito mais do que aparenta. Numa guerra onde o Caos e a Ordem se enfrentam mais uma vez, inimigos tornam-se amigos, aliados mudam de lado e uma Nova Era pode morrer antes de puder crescer.
Autora que brilha em livros esotéricos de alguma estranheza e muita complexidade, Joanne dá-nos este A Marca das Runas, um livro juvenil de fantasia, muito diferente do seu estilo habitual mas que não deixa de surpreender, nem que seja pelo lado refrescante e divertido, jovem e espirituoso, uma faceta desconhecida da autora, cujos livros pontuam, por regra, pela densidade e obscuridade. Numa linha mais simples mas com a mesma escrita envolvente que perde o seu lado tentador pra um mais ingénuo e satírico, a autora de Chocolate mostra que quando se nasce com um dom se pode escrever qualquer coisa, até uma fábula de aventuras, demandas e objectos mágicos.
Mas desenganem-se se pensam que este livro é uma leitura básica e banal, muito pelo contrário, está repleta de segredos, profecias e ligações obscuras que se unem numa narrativa de acção rápida e momentos únicos que nos levam a ler a toda a velocidade. Onde as gargalhadas são sempre bem-vindas, o inesperado acontece nos momentos menos propícios e o coração se aperta quando só queremos que tudo acabe bem, a mitologia nórdica ganha outra graça e dimensão, uma versão mais colorida, trapaceira e trapalhona que nos faz voltar à idade em que acreditávamos em tudo e em que o entusiasmo era quase infantil e extravagante. Mesmo assim, como sempre, a autora não nos deixa de espantar com a forma como o Bem e o Mal são uma única e só moeda, como ambos os conceitos se entrelaçam e desmontam dependendo da perspectiva de cada lado, mostrando que por baixo da cor e risada há uma mensagem mais profunda do que transparece a um primeiro olhar.
Também este livro é marcado pelos temas habituais. O conflito entre a religião e a magia, a fábula e a realidade, a ordem e o caos, pautam toda a narrativa, onde as coisas não são tão lineares quanto aparentam e que são apresentadas de uma forma tão imaginativa pela autora, que cada descrição nos faz viver os acontecimentos, deixando a nossa mente voar mais longe pelas páginas ao encontro das milésimas tarefas que Maddy e companhia cumprem ao longo da sua jornada. Em cada momento nota-se que este é um livro feito por diversão, um livro para extravasar ideias, para fazer rir e abrir os olhos mas com a certeza que respiraremos de alívio no fim, pelo menos até ao próximo livro.
As próprias personagens são tal como a narrativa em que se inserem. Ingénuas, rezingonas, irónicas e divertidas, um grupo para nos animar e enternecer que colocarão até ao fim da leitura a visão Marvel longe das nossas mentes. Desde os deuses aos habitantes da aldeia, cada um apresenta um conjunto de características que nos impedem de odiar profundamente e apelam ao perdão e isto, sendo um factor que algumas personagens de Joanne chegam a apresentar em outros livros, acaba por ter a sua certa ironia porque estas personagens são tão menos pesadas e intricadas que apelam desde logo ao nosso lado bom.
Sem deixar de ter aquela marca inimitável de Joanne, A Marca das Runas é um conto para a família, um livro em que podemos voltar atrás no tempo, sozinhos ou acompanhados mesmo dos mais novos. Sem a complexidade e mistério mais envolvente típicos, este livro é para se desfrutar, para descansar a mente das coisas tristes, para ler sempre com um sorriso. Uma leitura pitoresca e colorida que mesmo não atingindo a soberba dos outros romances de Joanne traz, sem dúvida, uma inocência e doçura que se deve recuperar, mesmo de vez em quando.
October 24, 2014
Sarò sincera: se non avessi saputo che nel libro sarebbero comparse le divinità nordiche non l'avrei letto: trovo la quarta di copertina veramente brutta e poco interessante. Nessun motivo in particolare, proprio prima impressione a pelle.
E un'altra cosa: nonostante abbia letto ben due recensioni, ero convintissima che si trattasse di un urban fantasy... quindi ho passato un certo numero di pagine a chiedermi dove e quando fossimo.
La risposta è abbastanza semplice: sul quando, siamo qualche secolo dopo Ragnarok. Sul dove... siamo in un mondo fantasy generico, che mi ha ricordato un po' Mondo Disco (sempre per il motivo che al mio cervello piace fare connessioni completamente random) tranne che la magia è IL MALE: in seguito alla fine del mondo il mondo non è finito, si è "solo" riassestato. Le antiche divinità sono morte o divenute ombre di sé stesse; tutto ciò che è legato al vecchio è una minaccia per la nuova magia, ma il nuovo ordine è pericoloso perchè vuole essere unico e totalitario, e pertanto mira ad infrangere l'equilibrio.
Che dopo aver letto tre fantasy sai già che è una pessima idea anche se non ti spiegano nel dettaglio perchè.
La cosa interessante è che ad infrangere la situazione di stallo venutasi a creare nel corso dei secoli non sono i cattivi ma la protagonista: Maddy, 14 anni e reietta nel proprio paese per via di una troppo spiccata propensione a usare la magia, è destinata ad essere l'ago della bilancia nella lotta tra vecchio e nuovo, e per esserlo deve dare il via ad una sequenza di avvenimenti così folli che nessuno sano di mente lo farebbe volontariamente (e diciamocelo, se hai un piano a cui persino Loki dice di no perchè non ha senso, hai un bel problema tra le mani).
Maddy è una protagonista che ho amato un sacco: tanto per cominciare è una ragazzina che si comporta da ragazzina, è matura come possono esserlo i bambini. Ossia prendendo un sacco di decisioni sbagliate.
Rimane quella con l'atteggiamento più normale ma questo perchè le divinità hanno un'età media mentale che va dai 3 ai 5 anni: alla fine mi aspettavo che Maddy avesse una crisi di nervi e facesse presente che, nel mucchio, la bambina era lei. Ho trovato ben gestiti i suoi poteri, nel senso che li ha, sono grandi ma non li sa usare: per tutto il libro la si vede generalmente lanciare in avanti la sua malia contando sul fatto che è essenzialmente l'unica a cui funziona ancora del tutto (i vantaggi di essere nati dopo Ragnarok... ), ma per il resto personaggi con più esperienza sono in grado di farla a pezzettini piccoli piccoli.
Ad affiancare Maddy nelle sue avventure c'è Loki, che vuol dire che io ero contenta e Maddy non tanto perchè cosa c'è di meglio che affrontare La Fine del Mondo 2.0 in compagnia di un trickster dio del caos, che incidentalmente ha causato La Fine del Mondo 1.0?
Loki l'ho amato: un demone adottato da Odino come fratello, portato ad Asgard e lì disprezzato da tutti perchè... beh, perchè si comportava da demone. Ad ogni modo questo Loki non è un grande incompreso: sì, gli Æsir non sono stati molto carini con lui, ma lui è stato insopportabile nel migliore dei casi.
Apprezzo un sacco gli autori in grado di scrivere i caotici neutrali in modo credibile, e questo Loki, pur non essendo l'esempio migliore, si piazza molto bene in classifica. In più, il suo rapporto con Odino mi ha un pochino incrinato il cuore.
Ci sono un sacco di comprimari, e un difetto può essere il loro numero: a parte Loki ed Odino (più Thor), che più o meno si sa chi sono, c'è tutto il pantheon norreno che francamente non ho mai sentito nominare salvo qualche eccezzione (tipo Hel, e il cielo sa quanto ho fangirlato per Hel) che è trattato in modo molto macchiesttistico. Beh, non proprio. Diciamo che se fosse un film, loro sarebbero i personaggi da affidare a caratteristi bravi.
Ed è un peccato, perchè la Harris è brava a coinvolgere il lettore, per cui almeno io ho trovato fastidiosa la fretta con cui molti personaggi sono stati trattati perchè sono certa che sarebbero stati bellissimi. Per esempio avrei pagato per saperne di più della famiglia di Maddy, di come vivono la caccia alle streghe scatenatasi contro di lei.
Il ritmo del libro è strano: è lungo, ma mentre vai avanti con la lettura sembra che le pagine siano troppo poche per risolvere tutto ciò che è stato messo in moto, che la storia proceda troppo lentamente per poter avere un degno finale. E in effetti un po' è così: se la Harris riesce a trovare il modo di integrare il cattivo finale senza farlo sembrare un boss sbucato fuori dal nulla di un videogame, il modo in cui questo viene affrontato è poco convincente e troppo veloce. Per contro, tutto accade nel mondo di Hel, che è una location così figa che fa passare in secondo piano tutto o quasi. L'alternarsi dei punti di vista, poi, permette di seguire in modo completo la trama e la piacevole sorpresa è che c'è anche il pov del cattivo. Saranno pure personaggi sgradevoli, ma mi piace vedere come corre il criceto nella loro testolina... ma i cambi sono abbastanza bruschi, e sinceramente all'inizio mi hanno lasciata un po' perplessa.
In sostanza, si è trattato di una lettura estremamente piacevole, che ho amato nonostante i difetti e di cui non vedo l'ora di leggere il seguito.
E un'altra cosa: nonostante abbia letto ben due recensioni, ero convintissima che si trattasse di un urban fantasy... quindi ho passato un certo numero di pagine a chiedermi dove e quando fossimo.
La risposta è abbastanza semplice: sul quando, siamo qualche secolo dopo Ragnarok. Sul dove... siamo in un mondo fantasy generico, che mi ha ricordato un po' Mondo Disco (sempre per il motivo che al mio cervello piace fare connessioni completamente random) tranne che la magia è IL MALE: in seguito alla fine del mondo il mondo non è finito, si è "solo" riassestato. Le antiche divinità sono morte o divenute ombre di sé stesse; tutto ciò che è legato al vecchio è una minaccia per la nuova magia, ma il nuovo ordine è pericoloso perchè vuole essere unico e totalitario, e pertanto mira ad infrangere l'equilibrio.
Che dopo aver letto tre fantasy sai già che è una pessima idea anche se non ti spiegano nel dettaglio perchè.
La cosa interessante è che ad infrangere la situazione di stallo venutasi a creare nel corso dei secoli non sono i cattivi ma la protagonista: Maddy, 14 anni e reietta nel proprio paese per via di una troppo spiccata propensione a usare la magia, è destinata ad essere l'ago della bilancia nella lotta tra vecchio e nuovo, e per esserlo deve dare il via ad una sequenza di avvenimenti così folli che nessuno sano di mente lo farebbe volontariamente (e diciamocelo, se hai un piano a cui persino Loki dice di no perchè non ha senso, hai un bel problema tra le mani).
Maddy è una protagonista che ho amato un sacco: tanto per cominciare è una ragazzina che si comporta da ragazzina, è matura come possono esserlo i bambini. Ossia prendendo un sacco di decisioni sbagliate.
Rimane quella con l'atteggiamento più normale ma questo perchè le divinità hanno un'età media mentale che va dai 3 ai 5 anni: alla fine mi aspettavo che Maddy avesse una crisi di nervi e facesse presente che, nel mucchio, la bambina era lei. Ho trovato ben gestiti i suoi poteri, nel senso che li ha, sono grandi ma non li sa usare: per tutto il libro la si vede generalmente lanciare in avanti la sua malia contando sul fatto che è essenzialmente l'unica a cui funziona ancora del tutto (i vantaggi di essere nati dopo Ragnarok... ), ma per il resto personaggi con più esperienza sono in grado di farla a pezzettini piccoli piccoli.
Ad affiancare Maddy nelle sue avventure c'è Loki, che vuol dire che io ero contenta e Maddy non tanto perchè cosa c'è di meglio che affrontare La Fine del Mondo 2.0 in compagnia di un trickster dio del caos, che incidentalmente ha causato La Fine del Mondo 1.0?
Loki l'ho amato: un demone adottato da Odino come fratello, portato ad Asgard e lì disprezzato da tutti perchè... beh, perchè si comportava da demone. Ad ogni modo questo Loki non è un grande incompreso: sì, gli Æsir non sono stati molto carini con lui, ma lui è stato insopportabile nel migliore dei casi.
Apprezzo un sacco gli autori in grado di scrivere i caotici neutrali in modo credibile, e questo Loki, pur non essendo l'esempio migliore, si piazza molto bene in classifica. In più, il suo rapporto con Odino mi ha un pochino incrinato il cuore.
Ci sono un sacco di comprimari, e un difetto può essere il loro numero: a parte Loki ed Odino (più Thor), che più o meno si sa chi sono, c'è tutto il pantheon norreno che francamente non ho mai sentito nominare salvo qualche eccezzione (tipo Hel, e il cielo sa quanto ho fangirlato per Hel) che è trattato in modo molto macchiesttistico. Beh, non proprio. Diciamo che se fosse un film, loro sarebbero i personaggi da affidare a caratteristi bravi.
Ed è un peccato, perchè la Harris è brava a coinvolgere il lettore, per cui almeno io ho trovato fastidiosa la fretta con cui molti personaggi sono stati trattati perchè sono certa che sarebbero stati bellissimi. Per esempio avrei pagato per saperne di più della famiglia di Maddy, di come vivono la caccia alle streghe scatenatasi contro di lei.
Il ritmo del libro è strano: è lungo, ma mentre vai avanti con la lettura sembra che le pagine siano troppo poche per risolvere tutto ciò che è stato messo in moto, che la storia proceda troppo lentamente per poter avere un degno finale. E in effetti un po' è così: se la Harris riesce a trovare il modo di integrare il cattivo finale senza farlo sembrare un boss sbucato fuori dal nulla di un videogame, il modo in cui questo viene affrontato è poco convincente e troppo veloce. Per contro, tutto accade nel mondo di Hel, che è una location così figa che fa passare in secondo piano tutto o quasi. L'alternarsi dei punti di vista, poi, permette di seguire in modo completo la trama e la piacevole sorpresa è che c'è anche il pov del cattivo. Saranno pure personaggi sgradevoli, ma mi piace vedere come corre il criceto nella loro testolina... ma i cambi sono abbastanza bruschi, e sinceramente all'inizio mi hanno lasciata un po' perplessa.
In sostanza, si è trattato di una lettura estremamente piacevole, che ho amato nonostante i difetti e di cui non vedo l'ora di leggere il seguito.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 15, 2017
This was a pretty good book. Not amazing, but not half bad either--the kind of rollicking adventure, with themes of self-esteem and rebellion against intolerant, controlling leadership, that seems to have taken the world of young adult literature by storm. I had already fallen in love with the subtle overtones of fairy-tale in 'Chocolat,' so when I discovered this, Joanne Harris' first excursion into YA fantasy lit, I picked it up and devoured it eagerly.
To say that I was disappointed with the book would be an unfair exaggeration--but there's no denying it didn't hook me quite as much as Chocolat. Perhaps this is partly due to my utter lack of familiarity with the Norse myths that are the basis of the the story; but Runemarks' plot seemed loose and wandering, with new characters and plot twists introduced with such frequency, and so little explanation, that their significance was often lost on me.
That said, Harris' characterizations are delightful. The Trickster Loki in particular is a deliciously cheeky, wickedly mischievous, roguish, irreverent, and impertinent scoundrel who, in true Joanne Harris style, single-handedly redeems the book from any plot pitfalls and keeps readers, like his cohorts, simultaneously laughing at him and wanting to strangle him, and unsure whether he is set to save the world or bring it crashing down into Chaos (which, despite Loki's family connections there, is NOT at all a nice place).
What is missing, ironically, is that mysterious spark or zing--that flirting with the supernatural--that indescribable, but tangibly present, whiff of otherworldliness that brought 'Chocolat' tantalizingly close to the borders of Faery. Spells and cantrips--not to mention the eponymous runes of power--are as thick as fog in all nine worlds of the World tree, and gods and goblins run amok; but that magical quality in the former sense is markedly lacking. What made Chocolat so memorable was the way it infused everyday life with a mythical sense of wonder.
Runemarks, on the other hand, brings the legendary down into the realm of the everyday. “God’s just a word,” Loki says, dismissing with a single gesture a world of awe and mystery. “Anyone can be a god if they have enough worshippers… Just words people use for things they don’t understand.” Within the story, where the gods may turn out to be the enemy, this idea may be reassuring; but once that awe of the divine has been diminished, the world does seem a colder and less colorful place.
To say that I was disappointed with the book would be an unfair exaggeration--but there's no denying it didn't hook me quite as much as Chocolat. Perhaps this is partly due to my utter lack of familiarity with the Norse myths that are the basis of the the story; but Runemarks' plot seemed loose and wandering, with new characters and plot twists introduced with such frequency, and so little explanation, that their significance was often lost on me.
That said, Harris' characterizations are delightful. The Trickster Loki in particular is a deliciously cheeky, wickedly mischievous, roguish, irreverent, and impertinent scoundrel who, in true Joanne Harris style, single-handedly redeems the book from any plot pitfalls and keeps readers, like his cohorts, simultaneously laughing at him and wanting to strangle him, and unsure whether he is set to save the world or bring it crashing down into Chaos (which, despite Loki's family connections there, is NOT at all a nice place).
What is missing, ironically, is that mysterious spark or zing--that flirting with the supernatural--that indescribable, but tangibly present, whiff of otherworldliness that brought 'Chocolat' tantalizingly close to the borders of Faery. Spells and cantrips--not to mention the eponymous runes of power--are as thick as fog in all nine worlds of the World tree, and gods and goblins run amok; but that magical quality in the former sense is markedly lacking. What made Chocolat so memorable was the way it infused everyday life with a mythical sense of wonder.
Runemarks, on the other hand, brings the legendary down into the realm of the everyday. “God’s just a word,” Loki says, dismissing with a single gesture a world of awe and mystery. “Anyone can be a god if they have enough worshippers… Just words people use for things they don’t understand.” Within the story, where the gods may turn out to be the enemy, this idea may be reassuring; but once that awe of the divine has been diminished, the world does seem a colder and less colorful place.
February 5, 2017
Joanne Harris... well, it was a love at first word with her and has been so ever since. I have NEVER read a book by her and felt disappointment, regret or mixed feelings. She is a unique human being that has been blessed with the magic of writing and brings joy to the world with ther storytelling.
This is Joanne Harris's first novel for young adults. Its the story of maddy Smith a fourteen year old girl who lives in the distant future in a world entirely different to ours. Maddie is born with a mysterious rune mark on her hand which in her world is considered a very bad omen.
The novel which is quite long for a childrens novel relates Maddie's adventures as she crosses over into the different worlds. On her journey she encounters many colourful characters including norse gods. No-one is quite who they appear to be and who actually can Maddie really trust! There are lots of twists along the way. Joanne Harris in this book demonstates her ability as a storyteller. Although I did feel that she did not explore the character of Maddy strongly enough that said a very readable story. I also would have wished for Loki's character to be a bit more... Well, Nordic... Ever since I read Lachlan's Wolfsangel I have been spoiled by the way he portrays Loki, and so far every other portrayal falls flat for me. I just cannot live with the idea of another Loki, who is to be different to that, which is of course absolute non-sense, for Loki is a shapeshifter above all. But alas, I am a humble human.
On the bright side Joanne Harris' writing style is as strong as ever and it is easy to get involved in the magical world she creates. It is all very tongue-in-cheek with humour that owes a lot to the influence of Douglas Adams and Terry Pratchett. It is easy to read and enjoyable as ever. But I find it a bit less influencial than her other works. Nothing can beat the Five Quaters of the Orange or Chocolate for me. It is still very good, although a tiny bit inferior the rest of her novels.
It is again a crossover book that any age group with a penchant for fantasy and magic will thoroughly enjoy. This is a re-release of the original book which was published in 2007 but this version has an epic, artistic and mythology based landscape on the cover which is absolutely stunning (it is also hardback which is a bonus). I am a huge fan of Joanne Harris so thank you to Gollancz for providing me a copy of the book to devour almost immediately.
This is Joanne Harris's first novel for young adults. Its the story of maddy Smith a fourteen year old girl who lives in the distant future in a world entirely different to ours. Maddie is born with a mysterious rune mark on her hand which in her world is considered a very bad omen.
The novel which is quite long for a childrens novel relates Maddie's adventures as she crosses over into the different worlds. On her journey she encounters many colourful characters including norse gods. No-one is quite who they appear to be and who actually can Maddie really trust! There are lots of twists along the way. Joanne Harris in this book demonstates her ability as a storyteller. Although I did feel that she did not explore the character of Maddy strongly enough that said a very readable story. I also would have wished for Loki's character to be a bit more... Well, Nordic... Ever since I read Lachlan's Wolfsangel I have been spoiled by the way he portrays Loki, and so far every other portrayal falls flat for me. I just cannot live with the idea of another Loki, who is to be different to that, which is of course absolute non-sense, for Loki is a shapeshifter above all. But alas, I am a humble human.
On the bright side Joanne Harris' writing style is as strong as ever and it is easy to get involved in the magical world she creates. It is all very tongue-in-cheek with humour that owes a lot to the influence of Douglas Adams and Terry Pratchett. It is easy to read and enjoyable as ever. But I find it a bit less influencial than her other works. Nothing can beat the Five Quaters of the Orange or Chocolate for me. It is still very good, although a tiny bit inferior the rest of her novels.
It is again a crossover book that any age group with a penchant for fantasy and magic will thoroughly enjoy. This is a re-release of the original book which was published in 2007 but this version has an epic, artistic and mythology based landscape on the cover which is absolutely stunning (it is also hardback which is a bonus). I am a huge fan of Joanne Harris so thank you to Gollancz for providing me a copy of the book to devour almost immediately.
July 17, 2011
We're all familiar with the author who lives in denial of their genre writing ("It doesn't have spaceships in, so it can't be science fiction!"). Joanne Harris is somewhat the opposite; for years she's been slyly slipping fantastic elements into her otherwise resolutely mainstream fiction and getting away with it. Here she goes for all-out fantasy, and it's a sad reflection on the publishing world today that in order to do so she's had to have it marketed as YA. This is a lovely book: a joyous, irreverent romp through Norse legend, full of verve, humour, action, adventure, and the most dangerously charming Loki you're ever likely to meet. At almost 500 pages it initially looks daunting, but Ms Harris's timing is impeccable: the action is divided into bite-sized chunks, and every section ends with a punch that makes you want to keep on reading.[return][return]My one criticism is that the young female protagonist, Maddy, who is initially the novel's main POV character, finds herself more and more squeezed out as more and more characters are introduced in particular Loki, against whom nobody stands a chance and appears rather colourless compared to the Norse pantheon. But then, I suppose & anyone would.[return][return]Highly recommended.
March 22, 2013
Reread this really quickly to refresh my memory on the plot before I read Runelight. Still enjoyable, although it's kinda lacking in Joanne Harris' usual precise plotting -- this time through, I felt like she made it a bit too convoluted, a bit too... I don't know. I wasn't so impressed by the plotting in The Lollipop Shoes and Peaches for Monsieur le Curé, likewise with this on a second read.
Still fun, though, like I said, and even if you know your Norse myth and think you know how it's going to turn out, it can still surprise you.
A little apprehensive about Runelight; wish I'd had it to read straight after I read Runemarks, way back whenever. I was learning Old English or Old Norse then, too, and was just... deep into everything Norse. I think that would've added a layer of enjoyment.
Still fun, though, like I said, and even if you know your Norse myth and think you know how it's going to turn out, it can still surprise you.
A little apprehensive about Runelight; wish I'd had it to read straight after I read Runemarks, way back whenever. I was learning Old English or Old Norse then, too, and was just... deep into everything Norse. I think that would've added a layer of enjoyment.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,018 reviews