Simone, by Angel Berry, is set in a context that is historically as well as geographically charged: the year is 1930, and the place is Louisiana. As the book description underlines, the conflicts are not clearly racial, but rather based on a peculiar dynamic between race and class.
The novel is constructed around a simple, yet well executed scenario: what if, the novel seems to ask its readers, you're in love with someone you can't have? Although the premise doesn't sound too original (and it isn't), this isn't anything to worry about in terms of engagement. The narrative succeeds in offering a thrilling progression of events, with a good tempo and very few slow points. Although things progress in a more-or-less predictable way, this isn't at all problematic, as Berry's language and personal style more than adequately make up for what lacks in terms of originality. Personally, I'd much rather read a well-written unoriginal story, rather than a badly written larger-than-life one. After all, although this book is marketed as an African-American novel, it is first and foremost a literary fiction one, involving sociocultural commentary, personal struggle, and reflection. It is in this context, however, that there is some room for improvement.
Although the characters are generally well-written, realistic, I think they could have a bit more depth and richer inner worlds that would truly allow something greater than themselves to peer through. As it stands, the characters come off as slightly too unidimensional, concerned only with their main aim (as provided by the story), and they appear a bit too disconnected from their - arguably very important - sociocultural setting. It isn't detrimental to the reading enjoyment of the book, but it feels a bit like a lost opportunity to provide something even better. Partly, I think this is also a consequence of a sharp division that occurs about half-way in the novel - the shift in time/space as well as character focalization has a thinning effect.
Still, to counter the criticism above, this novel remains a text that is clearly superior compared to so many others out there. Its story is intense, engaging, and accessible whether one is interested in African-American literature or not (to put it this way, I see absolutely no reason why international audiences wouldn't find this book interesting). After all, its story could be a story that has occurred anywhere, at any time, and I think managing to portray this might be one of the novel's greatest achievements