“James is dating Amanda or outsourcing his job? The jury is out.” 😬
Just finished Mistletoe, Moonlight, and Murder by Carolyn Dean and I’m sitting at a solid ⭐️⭐️⭐️½ (3.5 stars). I’m still enjoying this series and I’m clearly invested enough to keep going… but this one definitely didn’t hit the way I wanted it to.
First of all… if you’re going to set a book at Christmas, I need you to COMMIT. 🎄
Where are the messy holiday parties? The town drama? The secret affairs under the mistletoe? The passive-aggressive gift exchanges? The scandal in the snow?? This felt like a regular day murder that just happened to have a Christmas tree in the background. I wanted more holiday chaos and got… vibes. Mild vibes.
And then there’s James and Amanda… 😬
Their “budding romance” is already starting to feel stale to me.
It’s giving: James: “Here is all the sensitive information about an active investigation.”
Amanda: does all the actual work
Me: 🤨
At this point I’m like… sir, are you dating her because you like her… or because she’s basically solving your cases for you and keeping your career afloat? Is this romance or is this a strategic professional partnership? Because the lines are BLURRY. 😅
I don’t hate them, but I’m definitely not swooning. I need more tension, more spark, more something. Right now it’s just… there.
All that said, I’m still invested, still like the town, still like the overall series, and yes… I will be continuing. 🙃 Because once I’m in, I’m in.
I just need future books to either: • bring the holiday drama when it’s a holiday book
• or shake up James and Amanda’s dynamic before I start a formal petition.
Cozy mystery, but make it spicier. Festive, but make it messier. And James… sir… I am watching you. 👀📚