My review originally posted on Romancing-the-Book.com is shown below:
Once again Amy Lillard does not disappoint! I've loved all the books in both her Clover Ridge Series as well as her Wells Landing Series of which Titus Returns is the fifth book. Next up is Marrying Jonah which is Sarah and Jonah's story and I for one can't wait.
The people of Wells Landing feel like family. I've met them and seen their stories come to life as they mingle with others in the Amish community or outside of it in the Englisch world. The Bishop is fair but definitely knows what he wants of his church members. He's a great resource to those in the community as they come to grips with where life is taking them.
This is Abbie and Titus' story and it was heartbreaking, heartwarming, comforting and real. When Titus returns home after being in prison for five years he doesn't know if he really belongs in Wells Landing anymore. Abbie, whose twin died in the accident that Titus went to jail for, is not forgiving even if it's against the beliefs of the Amish. As they get closer due to Titus' remorsefulness and help he gives freely on her family's decrepit farm, she starts to forgive him. But does she really? His ex-girlfriend, Mandy, who married another while he was imprisoned now is sniffing around and believes they should be together which also goes against the Amish belief that you marry for life. Titus is always caught in the middle and reflects on his life, where he's going and whether to ask for forgiveness and rejoin the Church or leave and start his life elsewhere.
There were many emotions involved as I read. Laughter, tears, anger, sadness, hurt, fear, love, friendship, forgiveness and letting go. There were family and friends, the Amish businesses, the farm, the animals, partnerships, services, prayers, accidents, buggies and tractors, food, clothing and get togethers. Titus' family tried to be there for him even when he pushed them away over and over again. Their bond though was strong enough to withstand everything he dished out even when he didn't want it to be or did he? Watching Abbie and Titus take two steps forward and one back was disheartening especially since they formed a special bond when working together on the farm. There was wonderful closure and loose ends mainly tied up. There was a happily ever after in the offing and things seem to be right in Titus and Abbie's world. I closed the book with tears in my eyes looking forward to reuniting once again with the neighbors in Wells Landing.