I read this as an ESL teacher. I'm trying to find ways to help my students improve their vocabulary.
I think this book is PERFECT for that. Wow, this book will be such a challenge for my students to read. I'm very excited to use it with them. From a teacher perspective 5 stars. This book is awesome.
From a reader perspective....yeah. A bit less. Other reviewers have said that some of the writing is very awkward and weird, and it is. And I don't mean the "SAT word" sentences. Like, it's going to be hard to use academic vocabulary this much, you know? I expected some weirdness. But some of these sentences were just like, WEIRD. No one would talk like this, ever. Again--this isn't about using the big words. It's just.......wow these characters are unbelievable. The whole situation is pretty unbelieveable.
But I am pretty sure my ESL students won't be at the level where they are engaging with the 2-dimensional nature of the characters, so I'm not too worried about it.
So for ESL students: 5 star book. It's gonna be a *great* challenge.
For native speakers: 3 star book. It's kinda boring and unbelievable, and the words are too common to really be SAT words.