I got a copy of Presenting Data Effectively to see if it might be helpful in any of my undergrad or master's classes. I'm mostly interested in better-looking Powerpoints; reports and other documents aren't so urgent for what I teach right now. The book is a very helpful primer in basic issues of visual design. I don't know that I'll use the whole book verbatim in any class, but I will use chapters from it, or at least knowledge and tips I gained from it.
For me, the most interesting chapters were the ones about typefaces and colors. In addition to the helpful, entry-level information, Stephanie Evergreen has also included links to some great websites that I wasn't familiar with.
Less interesting to me was the chapter called "Arrangement," which seemed like the "Miscellaneous" box when I'm moving. And that's really one of the book's primary difficulties. If it were only about Powerpoint design, that would be focused and great, or only about report documents, or only about graphs and charts. But Evergreen covers a little of this and a little of that, and so it feels just a little scattered.
My other criticism of the book is Evergreen's tone. I've never seen a textbook where the author is so obsessed with herself, using a very informal, almost flippant, writing style. I don't mind if a textbook isn't as cold and sterile as the standard once required, but my goodness, reading this book often feels like listening to the caffeine-hyped monologue of a college student. I don't need a textbook to tell me I'm a "Rock Star"; I just want information, clearly presented. If this were a normal book in the $20 range, all of this would be fine, and Evergreen could do what she wants. But since it's classified as "textbook," students are paying quite a lot for it—currently $52.13 on Amazon.com. And with that price, I expect a tone that is more respectful toward the reader. I recommend that Sage assign Evergreen a co-author in future editions, to try to temper the voice in the book.
A good thing about the textbook is that the $52.13 gets you full-color pages, which is completely necessary for this topic. I can't believe the first edition of this book wasn't in color! It's a real gift to be able to enjoy the accompanying illustrations to the fullest.
Criticisms aside, Presenting Data Effectively was very helpful for me, and I recommend it to teachers at any level.