I really wanted to love this book, and although it was a good story overall, I was a bit disappointed.
What I liked: Reed. What a great character. Bookstore owner, hot cousin of Cam, what's not to love? I thought his character was awesome and we got to see a lot of sides of him which was really nice. I also, as always, love the small town vibe throughout the book, and how all the characters interweave through this series. It was really cool to get to know Cecily, since she was just a side character in the first book that I didn't really think I would see surface again. Their chemistry was written well and it was fun reading about how they're pulled to each other.
What I didn't like: First, I didn't really know the back story of how they met. It was alluded to, but the whole scene never unfolded. Was there a meet cute of their story that I missed? I felt like that was missing from this book. Next, there were a lot of similarities between this book and Wishful #1 of Norah and Cam, which wasn't a bad thing, and the characters even noted how similar their story was to their friends' story, but it made the book a bit predictable. There were also some big misunderstandings that could have been easily cleared up with good communication, which I've found happens in many of these books, as well as many movies and series, but that kind of bugs me because I feel it's been done so many times, and why aren't any of these adults mature enough to speak to their partner when something goes wrong?