I started this only meaning to read the greats (Lewis Grassic Gibbon, Muriel Spark, J.M. Barrie, James Kelman, Alasdair Gray), but ended up finishing the whole thing. I want to read more of John Buchan and Elspeth Davie especially, but most of the stories left an impression.
Lewis Grassic Gibbon ("Smeddum") and Muriel Spark ("Bang-Bang You're Dead") are spot-on - just what short stories should be. The J.M.Barrie short is total rubbish. Alasdair Gray, self-loathing egomaniac, is just shy of brilliant. If you haven't read James Kelman's novels, "Home for a Couple of Days" sums them up nicely.
I never considered the real art that goes into curating until I read this collection. It gives a feeling of Scotland through the centuries - the social classes, the cities, the farms, the alcoholism: a land (largely) without irony.