This is a long book at 799 pages and requires a commitment to read. It’s a story about a dysfunctional family: a mother, father, grown son, and grown daughter. (There is another son with Down Syndrome.) The four main characters alternate chapters. Each of them has their own issues, personal and with each other. The writing is beautifully descriptive as each of their situations become more dire and you’re drawn in. But there are a few criticisms. I couldn’t understand why it felt jarring when a new chapter began with a different character’s perspective. It finally hit me that two of the characters, the mother and father, are told in third person, while the daughter’s and son’s are told in first person. There is also some inconsistency with past and present tense, and sometimes it was difficult to tell who was speaking in conversations. We spend the least amount of time with the mother and most with the father, who I found the least interesting of the four. Some of the tangential stories that a few of the characters tell are unnecessarily verbose. Most people wouldn’t speak so poetically and descriptively and at such length. The character of Cait also seemed too convenient, especially as much as she helped the son. What would he have done without her? Possibly learned to save himself, which was essential to his growth. The characters do grow and there’s a nice summary at the end. But also an unanswered question: why is the character in the first chapter in a coma? Otherwise, an involving, interesting beautifully written story with characters you care about, that, although long, is engrossing and enjoyable.