I was initially drawn to this book because of the John Wilkes Booth connection. I thought it was such an interesting concept to examine the mind and motivations of a presidential assassin. As so many other reviewers have said, I did not get exactly what I had expected with this book.
On starting reading I found our protagonist to be... well, a bit of a dick. I wasn't sure if I was going to enjoy the read, because who wants to read about someone they don't even like? But, I have to say, Pellegrini's strength seems to be in the characterization, and the more I read about the life of Joseph Bateman, the more I liked him, despite his MANY serious flaws. Reading about his childhood, you can't help but feel bad for this kid. Just when you think things can't get any worse, Pellegrini throws more shit at Bateman. The absolute low point of his childhood is BRUTAL, and when we reach the point where Bateman finally feels regret for his actions as an adult, we've been on a tough journey with him, and it's an emotional moment where I felt genuine sadness for him. I LOVED this part of the book, and honestly could have read a full story just about Joseph Bateman, and given it a five star review.
So then to the part of the book I had been waiting for: Joseph Bateman has been executed and travelled back in time to prevent John Wilkes Booth from assassinating Abraham Lincoln. This is the bit I had been looking forward to, but actually I found this to be the weakest part of the story. The strong characterization that I saw in the first part of the book was all but gone, and I don't think we got to see any of Booth's personality or character. His motivations were briefly touched upon, giving us the obvious explanation of Lincoln abolishing slavery and the end of the civil war, but it would have been good to see some inner turmoil in this section between Bateman and Booth; to let more of Booth's character and motivations come through. I'm not suggesting that the book should give justification for slavery, bigotry, and racism, but it almost felt like we were rushing through this part of the story to get to Bateman's ultimate salvation, and I would have liked it to breathe more. Let Booth have more of a voice and create some conflict within Bateman, or see more of Bateman planning what to do to prevent Booth assassinating Lincoln. When Bateman initially wakes up in 1865, a mysterious character warns him that Booth would try to stray Bateman from his path (of stopping Booth from assassinating the president), but frequently Booth is just described as a feeling of anger, with it seems, no real ability to overpower Bateman or take back control. And on the subject of the mysterious character, we are never told outright who he is, but it is heavily implied. Even the initial J, that he goes by, helps to cement in our heads who this guy is; but honestly, it didn't seem right to me, and kind of pulled me out of the story every time he was called by the name J. I guess that's a personal thing, and depends on your beliefs maybe. I just couldn't understand why that particular character had been put in a story about Lincoln's assassination.
Ultimately, this was always going to be a story of two parts, but the first part of the book really came to life for me, whereas the second part fell a little flat. However, it was still very readable and Pellegrini's writing keeps the story moving forward at a good pace. I just wish the second half had been as compelling as the first.
Still, this was an excellent read, and I will definitely be reading more Pellegrini in the future.