This is a whole-series review.
TL;DR: Cool story, slightly shallow in some parts, but gives a satisfying HEA. It would be a decently good read except it's plagued by technical issues that are front-and-center levels of distracting. I finished the series because I wanted to know how Nick and Bane turned out, but I won't read this author again for a long while due to the issues.
The longer version...
Alright, so this is probably the most polarizing series I've ever read. There are things about it that I loved and things that I fucking despised.
Is it a sweet, intriguing story with a unique background? Yes. I especially loved the portrayal of the tiger spirit, very adorable. It was definitely a different take on "shifters" and one that kept me turning pages.
I also liked the pacing for the most part, as well as the interweaving of the back history. Some parts, particularly in book 2, seemed to drag a bit, but it wasn't anything crazy. The resolution of family and "endgame" stuff near the end of the third book felt a bit rushed. I would have to limit my rating to a 4 for that reason, but still a good read...
And if those were my only thoughts, I would have indeed rated this an overall 4. But so far I've just covered the things I liked. Now let's talk about the fucking problems.
Let me first say these next things are basically technical issues. I normally don't care about that too much. Seriously, mistakes happen, no biggie. I rarely knock ratings for technical issues unless they are egregious, and even then it's usually just a minor half-star bump or so. What I'm about to list off, though, yeah I'm giving that rating a FULL 2-STAR DROP. It's that fucking bad.
HOLY REPETITIVE PHRASES, BATMAN! The epithets are out of fucking control. Do you know how many times the author says "the billionaire" or "the billionaire's" to refer to Bane or something of his? 107 times. That's an average of once every 5-6 pages. Yes, I counted with a search. "The billionaire" this and "the billionaire" that. Jesus, he's Bezos, we fucking got it the first 5 times (i.e. in chapter 1). It's even more stupid when you realize that not much of the story has to do with how rich Bane (or anyone else) is... why the fuck does it matter if he's a billionaire?
Another insanely repetitive phrase is used nearly as many times, describing Bane's "Siberian blue eyes". I'm not kidding people. It is used verbatim over and over and over just like that. It is so fucking cringe after the first few times.
And the icing on the cake for repetitive phrases, while also doubling as some of the most passively racist shit I've ever read in a novel... I present you the phrase "the Indian man," aka Omar! I think he's referred to as "the Indian man" just as many times as he's called by name. You are NEVER allowed to forget he's Indian. Ever. He's a cool character (though a tad bland), but holy fuck, author. Do a find/replace in your text editor for these phrases. The books will be instantly better. Did I mention Omar is an Indian man?
Finally, I save the most infuriating thing for last: the fucking use of italics. So normally, as basically everyone knows, authors use italicized words to convey emphasis. Well, if that's the case here, then this author really wants to emphasize the fuck out of EVERYTHING. Italicized words are used a MINIMUM of 5 times per page. PER PAGE. PER FUCKING PAGE. I'm not kidding, not exaggerating. At all. It was so distracting that I nearly DNF'd this series a handful of times despite really liking the story. Oh, and there was an Indian man, too, Omar I think is his name.
I eventually trained myself to completely ignore the italicized words and then it wasn't quite as painful. But it still fucking sucked. Whenever some dialogue rolled around that actually called for emphasis, I spent several moments re-reading and deciding whether to mentally inject emphasis and where. It was exhausting, and that was in between reading about the billionaire and his Siberian blue eyes.
I once again remind you that I do not usually care much for technical issues. So for me to bitch about this... yeah I will not be reading any other of this author's work for quite some time. Which is sad because they are clearly talented at creating interesting stories and characters. But damn does it need an editor. Or even just a single beta reader, fuck. Hopefully their future work will not have these problems and I can revisit later.
There's an Indian man in this story, by the way. Can't remember his name anymore, but he's definitely Indian, and a man. He's the billionaire's servant, you know the billionaire with the Siberian blue eyes.
Fucking eye roll.
Broken (#1): 3.5 stars, rounded to 4 because cuteness, dropped to 2 for technical issues
Bound (#2): 3 stars, dropped to 1 for technical issues
Beloved (#3): 4 stars, dropped to 2 for technical issues