Just as it is meant to, this book made me feel vividly as if I was there. It has a lovely sense of wilderness and freedom, and comfort, and love. Every time I read it, these emotions are evoked again. The re-readability is off the charts.
I’m not sure what it is - the compelling, beautiful setting, the wonderful description, the delightfully real characters, but this book is so good and if I could give it more than five stars I would.
Alice Mistlethwaite is an eleven-year-old girl living in England who loves to write stories and is still reeling from her mother’s death four years prior. She lives with her absentee father Barney whom she worships and her aunt Patience who just wants what’s best for Alice. Patience sells their family home and ships Alice off to an eccentric boarding school in Scotland.
Now, Alice isn’t the only main character. Introduced second is Jesse Okuyo, my personal favourite character. He’s a lonely, shy, sensitive boy who feels overshadowed by his family of overachievers with a talent for running (a talent he finds useless and hates). Then there’s Fergus Mackenzie, a genius and a prankster whose parents are divorced, and because of this he views parents in general as rubbish. They all go to a boarding school called Stormy Loch, famous for its Great Orienteering Challenge. The three fall into a complicated and tumultuous friendship, and when the Great Orienteering Challenge comes they are placed in a team together. Alice sees this as her chance to run away across the Scottish highlands to find an island and find her father, if only she can convince her teammates to follow her. And a mysterious package may get in the way...
This book is so beautiful. The school of Stormy Loch is an amazing example of a storybook boarding school. The description is magical -
“Three seals swam into the bay as they were eating, three sleek black heads bobbing in the quiet waves just offshore, with silvery whiskers and bright, curious eyes. They put on a show as the children watched, diving and bobbing back up, turning lazily in the water then disappeared as suddenly as they came into the waves turned indigo and gold by the endlessly setting summer sun.”
“He was probably by some quay right now, getting into a boat, sailing surrounded by seals across a star-strewn sea towards the purple islands to wait for her.”
I love this description so much. Star-strewn sea? Waves turned indigo and gold? The Children of Castle Rock is a middle grade novel, and it takes a special skill to write prose so evocative and poetic but still comprehensible to young readers.
But that’s not the best part of this book. The characters are so realistic that it wouldn’t be hard to believe that the author copied real children’s behaviour and dialogue word-for-word. Their friendship is astoundingly real. The kids are petty, they’re deep, they’re shallow, they’re jealous, they’re angry, they’re happy, they have desires and wishes and fears and motives. They’re complex, like people are. They’re different and each have their own diverse personalities.
I can't pick a favourite aspect of this book because the plot, the description, the setting, the theme, the prose, and the characters and their interpersonal dynamics all come together wonderfully to make it the excellent example of middle grade that it is.