Well, I have been a huge Anya Seton fan for about fifty of my sixty years. I have read all of her books...except, until just now, "Foxfire".
In the 1980s, I owned a used copy of the 1970s Fawcett Crest paperback. But I just skimmed parts of it. I knew it took place in a small backwards mining town in Arizona and I knew it took place in the early 1930s and knew it was about a New York society girl marrying a one quarter Apache mining engineer and that she had trouble coping and I knew it had something to do with them trying to find a lost gold mine, but that's all.
I was put off by the time setting. I don't like novels that take place in modern times, and although by the 1980s the early 1930s were over fifty years in the past rather than just seventeen years in the past as they were when the novel was published in 1950, that was still too modern for me. In fact, it still is, even now when the early 1930s are ninety years in the past. Telephones, cars, movies, The New Yorker and Vanity Fair magazines, small airplanes, make-up, blonde hair helped by peroxide, Hershey bars, no thanks, I'm out.
Usually. But I decided that in order to be a true Anya Seton fan I needed to overlook all that and give this one a real go so, the 1970s Fawcett Crest paperback long since having been lost, I ordered a new copy and did just that.
Well, I know that Anya Seton had a real love for the Desert Southwest because her father owned a ranch there or some such, but it turned out that she was not the one person in the world who can convince me that the Desert Southwest is beautiful. I don't like it and never have. So this is the only novel of hers the setting of which I didn't like. (I'm overlooking the New Mexico Territory setting of the beginning of "The Turquoise" because only about the first quarter of the novel is set there.)
Anyway, yes, the first half is slow but you need to have patience so you can get the payoff in the second half.
I started to really enjoy the second half of the book despite its modern setting. I liked the theme of two people falling in love yet not knowing how to bend and compromise, and was interested to see how they would work this out, UNTIL....
The unrealistic, contrived ending in which everything falls into place so beautifully. Most of Seton's books have happy endings but none so contrived as this. It really pushed the ending over the edge from simply happy into excessively sappy. I would rather have seen Dart and Amanda mend their relationship and then just go forth into hard times, knowing they had the strength together to weather them, rather than have God move all of the right chess pieces into all of the right squares just to make things perfect for Dart and Amanda.
So one star docked for disliked setting and time and another docked for the ending. Three stars.