Ed Norton, who Spike Lee works with in the underrated 25th Hour, predicts something that I think will come to light in the future: "In the same way that Taxi Driver was for that post-Vietnam generation, Do the Right Thing and these movies are for us. Spike is not going to get his full due until the generation that was most impacted by his movies becomes the mainstream adult generation."
Granted, that generation is now -- or is passing the baton off to the millennial/Gen Z. Personally, it took me a while to get around to it, but as Lee is still rolling out movies that are still part of the public conscience, we should talk about how his greats are really fucking great. She's Gotta Have It and Bamboozled are still my favorites, but because Lee's experiments are littered across his filmography, I'm afraid that people will see Lee's attempts to try something new as box office duds or "bad" movies. There might be a movie that I don't connect with, but I know a Spike Lee movie once I watch it.
That's My Story follows Lee's career from his days at Morehouse up until She Hate Me, which may be disappointing for those who wanted the inside scoop for his later stuff, like Inside Man and BlackKKlansman. Lee, as well as many of his collaborators (from cinematographer-turned-director Ernest Dickerson, costume designer Ruth Carter, producer Lisa Jones, all the way down to frequent cast members John Turturro and Samuel L. Jackson), provide conversations for writer Kaleem Aftab. It doesn't feel trite; dissent in Lee's work ethic and ideas are shared by his peers in addition to the criticism spoken against his films. Lee is known as a controversial talking head, which makes the dissent believable.
The book will get into the technical BTS of certain movies, which I enjoyed as a film lover. Producing and financing is a huge topic, as Lee will sometimes find funders for certain movies that studios won't back (even with the surmounting success of black-led movies, some Lee movies just didn't carry a promised ROI). Each chapter holds place for one or two movies, so it's fun to see some love for Crooklyn and 4 Little Girls (I didn't know Lee did a documentary!).
The most surprising and unsurprising thing about Lee is that he doesn't seem to be a communicative person, even when his public image suggests otherwise. He is a director who observes on set, but actors may not receive direction from him. Instead, improvisation and one-takes are done. Old-school actors like Harvey Keitel were not a fan. I also was surprised at the specific thoughts shared by the women that he's worked with. I don't expect all male screenwriters to nail a woman's experience, but I had always felt that Lee's female characters were flawed and real. Instead, stories shared by Rosie Perez and Annabella Sciorra leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I get the impression that Lee is somewhat reserved about dictating how actors should act, but that leaves less protection for graphic scenes that I think would have benefitted the first-time actresses that he sought after.
Because the book stops before Spike Lee's current presence in the later '00s and '10s, his successes and troubles just feel like a sliver of his life. Despite his fallbacks, I think there is still so much to cover that I'd hope Aftab will be interested in a Part Two. Hopefully, as a Lee fan, that won't be in the near future.